Quote:
Who do you think created that problem in the first place?
The Bush Administration and their deregulation philosophy.
LOL! Yeah, blame it all on Bush.
Never mind the Community Reinvestment Act (CRA), started by a democrat (Jimmy Carter), which eventually allowed ACORN and *community-minded* democrats like Obama to delay and halt the efforts of banks to merge or expand until they had agreed to lower their credit standards … to provide mortgages to people who couldn't really afford them.
Never mind the role of the Clinton Administration in expanding the CRA's powers in 1995 … giving ACORN and those *community organizers* even more leverage to force banks to ignore long established and sound financial traditions and make unsound loans … especially unsound if there were any downturn in the economy.
Never mind the role of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, two institutions controlled by democrats that grew to control most of the mortage business in the US and eventually were responsible for a large portion of the bad loans. Never mind that the socialists/democrats at ACORN played a key role in enmeshing Fannie and Freddie in those unwise policies.
Never mind all the warnings that began to appear in the late 90's about the situation. Warnings like this (from
Insight on the News back in 1999 ,
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1571/is_41_15/ai_57748148/ ):
The easy flow of credit during the 1990s has helped to fuel a nationwide housing boom and spending spree that has kept the economy humming. But analysts say banks have lowered their lending standards, particularly to tap into the fast-growing minority markets, and have been under strong political pressure to do so despite studies showing minorities are more likely to default than whites. The result of this largess may be soaring levels of bankruptcy and default during the next recession.
Never mind that at the same time democrats kept assuring us that all was well. And getting big campaign contributions from Fannie and Freddie. And doing things to make matters even worse. For example, here's an excerpt from a 2000 article cited in the above link:
Fannie Mae, the nation's largest source for financing home mortgages, plans to invest at least $700 billion through 2009 to provide financing to 4.6 million minority households. … snip … "Through this agreement," said Raines, "we hope to extend the benefits of the housing finance system to more Americans in underserved communities and boost minority home ownership rates closer to the national rate of 60 percent."
Never mind that in 2004, after a tip from a whistleblower, the Office of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversight issued a report finding that Fannie Mae (under Raines) had engaged in Enron-like accounting machinations that allowed Fannie to overstate its earnings and underestimate the risk the company faced.
Never mind the role of democrats (like Waters, Franks and Dodd, etc) in fighting republican attempts to oust Raines and to reform Fannie and Freddie in the early-mid 2000's, when there might have still been time to prevent the impending collapse.
Never mind that despite all the bad that Raines had done, Obama then sought his advice on mortgage and housing policy matters.
Learn some history, TKN.
Stop blaming everything on Bush.
That excuse has grown old.
Learn some history. You might start here:
http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=ZjRjYzE0YmQxNzU4MDJjYWE5MjIzMTMxMmNhZWQ1MTA= .
The primary cause of the Great Recession was the run on largely unregulated investment banks.
No, that was merely a symptom … an event … not the fundamental cause. For that you have to go back to the 90's and see what democrats were doing.
Quote:
Who do you think obstinately refused to do anything about that problem when republicans tried to do something in the years before it burst? Take a guess.
What did the Republicans try to do? How did the Democrats block this?
For starters, in 2003, President Bush warned that Fannie and Freddie where facing a crisis and proposed a new agency to oversee regulatory reforms of them. Here:
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpa...2575AC0A9659C8B63&sec=&spon=&pagewanted=print . The new agency would have had the authority, that still rests with Congress today, to set one of the two capital reserve requirements for the companies. And it would have determined whether the two were adequately managing the risks of their portfolios. But guess who was against it? Democrats, of course.
And in 2005, Republicans introduced a bill that McCain co-sponsored which would have set up an agency like Bush proposed ... the "Federal Housing Enterprise Regulatory Reform Act of 2005". Had it passed (it didn't because democrats opposed it), it would have (
http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bill.xpd?bill=s109-190&tab=summary ) amended "the Federal Housing Enterprises Financial Safety and Soundness Act of 1992 to establish: (1) in lieu of the Office of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversight of the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), an independent Federal Housing Enterprise Regulatory Agency which" would "have authority over the Federal Home Loan Bank Finance Corporation, the Federal Home Loan Banks, the Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae), and the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac); and (2) the Federal Housing Enterprise Board." It would have set "forth operating, administrative, and regulatory provisions of the Agency, including provisions respecting: (1) assessment authority; (2) authority to limit nonmission-related assets; (3) minimum and critical capital levels; (4) risk-based capital test; (5) capital classifications and undercapitalized enterprises; (6) enforcement actions and penalties; (7) golden parachutes; and (8) reporting." Read that, and you'll see it would have directly addressed the problem that led to the mortgage crisis.
And McCain issued a warning. He made a speech to the Senate in 2006 in support of the above bill in which he warned "If Congress does not act, American taxpayers will continue to be exposed to the enormous risk that Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac pose to the housing market, the overall financial system, and the economy as a whole." What prescience he had.
But again, democrats prevented that bill from passing. Democrat after democrat got up and spoke, claiming no reform was needed and that all was well. Here are their words. Representative Barney Frank said "These two entities -- Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac -- are not facing any kind of financial crisis, the more people exaggerate these problems, the more pressure there is on these companies, the less we will see in terms of affordable housing." Representative Mel Watt said "I don't see much other than a shell game going on here, moving something from one agency to another and in the process weakening the bargaining power of poorer families and their ability to get affordable housing." Senator Charles Schumer said "I think Fannie and Freddie over the years have done an incredibly good job ... snip ... if you look over the last 20 or whatever years, they've done a very, very good job." And many other democrats joined them in denial of the warnings.
And guess what? In 2007, this bill was reintroduced. And what happened? Again, nothing. The now democrat led banking committee chaired by Chris Dodd (who was a big recipient of Fannie and Freddie campaign contributions) never reviewed it. The problem was identified but again democrats prevented any solution.
See how little you actually know?
Quote:
That being the case, why do you assume that democrats weren't still an obstacle to effectively addressing the problem in 2007?
The Republicans controlled the White House and Congress for 6 years, but it was the Democrats who were causing the problem.
Unlike democrats, republicans didn't have complete "control" of Congress. Democrats had the means to keep bills from coming out of committee. And that's what they did, over and over.
Exactly what did the Democrats do in 2007 that prevented the problem from being addressed?
By then it was probably too late. The collapse was already under way. Perhaps we could have bought a little time by doing something to stimulate the economy … like say a tax cut, but the end was pretty much inevitable by then. And besides, from 2007 on democrats controlled Congress so nothing Bush could have suggested to solve the problem was remotely possible. Because democrats were still busy defending ACORN, Fannie and Freddie, and all the mortgage policies that were at the root of the collapse.
Quote:
Would you admit that part of the reason deficits increased at that time is that we entered a recession that contrary to democrat claims started at the end of Clinton's term. And that 9/11 occurred which also negatively impacted the economy? That naturally impacted GDP which naturally impacted the revenue side of the equation. Which caused larger deficits.
Yep. And the Bush tax cuts also added to the deficits.
To fight several wars that we didn't start. To rebuild a military and intelligence apparatus that fell into decay during Clinton's two terms. What would you have had Bush do … ignore those problems?
Or are you suggesting he should have increased taxes to try and pay for those things immediately ... in the year the money's were spent? If so, you haven't been listening.
No matter what he did, we were unlikely to see revenues as a percent of GDP go above 18 or 19 percent, which they did anyway. That's what 65 years of history tells us. All that increasing taxes at that point would have done is LOWER GDP, so even if he'd managed with higher taxes to get revenue as a percent of GDP to climb to the historic average (unlikely), the net take would have been LOWER. A bigger deficit than what we had. This isn't rocket science or anything but 3rd grade math and basic logic. I don't see why this is so difficult for leftists to understand?
And the Bush tax cuts were phased in over a 9-year period, so they obviously were not intended to be a short-term stimulus to address any economic downturn, even though they might have provided some stimulus.
Handwaving. Why don't you address my previous point instead.
However, any intelligent stimulus plan has to phase out so that large budget deficits don't persist into growth periods.
But the deficit as a percent of GDP (what matters) was closing towards the end of Bush's term … until the mortgage crisis exploded. So why was removal of the tax cuts needed? And you do realize that however you want to spin it, after 6 years in place, removal of the tax cuts would be tantamount to a tax increase … which would have had a negative affect on GDP and LOWERED revenues … as historical data proves over and over.
Quote:
What would your alternative have been? Not fight the WOT? Or are you foolish enough to think that raising taxes would have solved the revenue problem? Don't you imagine that might have had a negative impact on GDP and been self-defeating? Because history suggests raising taxes in times of economic stress is self defeating, as I've proven over and over in threads at JREF in the last week. Just the opposite was needed. A lowering of taxes. And that's what Bush did. And the economy responded favorably. GDP growth increased into the 2-3% range for quarter after quarter.
I recall saying that I agreed with you that deficit spending is a good way to combat recessions.
LIAR. I told you that I don't agree with that claim. I'm not a Keynesian socialist. And you are ignoring my question. Would you not have fought the WOT? Where do you stand on the invasion of Iraq, for instance? Hmmmmm?
However, as anyone with a cursory understanding of economics knows, increased spending is a more efficient way of creating a stimulus than is cutting taxes
LOL! I thinks it's clear who has LESS than a cursory understanding of economics here. If what you claim is true, why didn't Obama's Stimulus work? It was predicated on the belief that a dollar in stimulus spending would create more than a dollar in GDP. It hasn't happened. Didn't even come close. Don't you socialists EVER learn from history … even the history you make?
Bush's 2-3% GDP growth is not impressive by historical standards
I told you socialists earlier (
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7453800&postcount=366 ) why 2-3.5% growth during the 2000's was actually quite good. And you basically ignored that response. So let me repeat what I said.
The 80's and 90's were periods when the US was still pre-eminent in many high-growth technologies (medical devices, electronics and then software). You heard of the internet boom, right? That might have something to do with why the average Real GDP growth during those periods was somewhat higher than in the 2000's, when the rest of the world had caught up in those technological areas. And as I noted, the problem is that we didn't move on to the next technology and dominate it … perhaps because democrat controlled schools have been pumping out community organizers, *actresses*, defense lawyers, and political science majors, rather than more conservative scientists and engineers … the folks who actually fueled the GDP growth of the 80's and 90's. Furthermore, the 90's had less events to impede GDP growth. No 9/11. And in the second half of the 90s when growth rates were a percent or two higher than under Bush, not even a recession.
Furthermore, let me add that there is a natural reduction (with occasional exceptions) in GDP growth as economies grow and mature. It's not unusual for small economies to sustain double digit GDP growth for many years. But as an economy grows, growth rates start to drop. The US has the largest economy in the world. So why would you expect GDP to climb much above 3% unless we come up with some new technology the rest of the world needs? Perhaps your expection shows you don't have a "cursory understanding of economics"? So let me help you. Here is a chart (from
http://www.house.gov/jec/growth/govtsize/govtsize.htm ) that you might find interesting … if you bother to study it carefully:
http://www.house.gov/jec/growth/govtsize/fig-2.gif
It shows how 10 year GDP growth has fallen in the US since 1799. You can see that when we were a young, immature nation, we saw 10 year growth rates of 70% (an average of 7% a year). And as our country has aged and our economy grown that percentage has quite steadily dropped. By 1900 the average rate was down to about 5% a year. By the 1980s and 1990s, it was down to about 3% a year. So did you really expect Bush to beat that by much? Seriously? LEARN FROM HISTORY.
Quote:
And guess what? As this chart (
http://poisonyourmind.files.wordpres...ge-of-gdp1.png ) shows, revenues as a percent of GDP responded positively, moving back to the historical average and even a little above.
And guess what? Your chart contains nothing that proves that the tax cuts were the cause of the increased tax revenues. Normal post-downturn growth in corporate profits coupled with a major shift of income from people in lower tax brackets to people in high tax brackets can also explain the revenue increase.
Sigh. As to your first point, don't you understand that the backbone of our economy are the small businesses which employ the vast majority of workers. And their taxes are primarily paid for as individuals and as payroll taxes. Revenue from corporations is only a small part of total revenues. They account for only 9% of total federal revenues (
http://www.heritage.org/budgetchartbook/federal-revenue-sources and
http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2009/10/20/business/economy/revenues.jpg ). And many of those corporations are tiny (with just a few or no employees) … effectively small businesses who will be hurt if government increases taxes.
As to your second point, read what I noted earlier in this post. You really didn't say anything significant or relevant to the issue at hand. But then little that you've said is.
You might not have noticed, but tax revenues as a percentage of GDP are currently lower than they were before the Bush tax cuts were enacted, without a major change in the tax code.
Well, gee … do you suppose that might have something to do with how business UNFRIENDLY a climate Obama and democrats have been creating? Do you suppose that might also have to do with the fact that if GDP drops or slows (because of that business unfriendly environment), and the wealthy pay most of the taxes, and they pay them at marginal rates higher than maximum historical percentage for revenues over GDP, then revenues as a percentage of GDP might naturally drop. Without a change in tax code. It's simple math and clear logic. Think about it.
Quote:
No. That is not what I'm saying at all. Re-read the above a second time. You encourage the economy by getting out of the lives of people and business.
Which leads to results like the Savings and Loan Crisis and the collapse of the "shadow" banking system, both of which did significant long-term damage to the economy (the latter led to the worst recession since 1929).
LOL! And here I thought you socialists were insisting that the current bank crisis was much, much worse than the S&L debacle … which Reagan dealt with without a massive bailout and stimulus.
So if I understand you, you socialists want to control our lives for our own good. Because we are all too stupid to do it ourselves. I see.
Quote:
If liberals should have learned ANYTHING from the trillion dollar Stimulus fiasco, it's that GDP increases less than the amount of Stimulus … especially the sort of stimulus that democrats have pushed and pushed and pushed.
So were Bush's tax cuts a stimulus or were they not a stimulus?
Non-sequitur noted. I guess you don't want to directly respond to my challenge. Instead you want to try a red herring. Well fine … to answer your question, yes, but not in the same way that handing out unemployment checks and spending a $250,000 to *create or save * a single job is a *stimulus*. One approach has historically been shown over and over to create more GDP than it's cost. To work. The other has not. Just the opposite.
For example, the Bush tax cuts didn't actually cost us anything. Federal Tax revenues climbed back to historical levels as a percentage of GDP and remained there until democrats took over Congress. And GDP increased markedly for quarter after quarter after quarter after those tax cuts.
In constrast, Obama's stimulus accomplished next to nothing. GDP growth has remained less than lackluster … far less than even Bush achieved . And the stimulus will cost us trillions of dollars to finance. And revenues as a percent of GDP have NOT returned to the historic average.
Does that adequately address you attempted red herring?
And did that September 1982 tax increase derail the recovery?
I addressed that issue in the next paragraph? Read on.
Quote:
There's an interesting table here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reaganomics , which sums up the effect of the various tax measures during the Reagan years, and shows that indeed, all told (even accounting for increases in Social Security), the tax burden was reduced by Reagan, contrary to what you are now trying to make people believe.
I was trying to make people believe that Reagan actually increased the tax burden?
Non sequitur. And yes, I think you did try to suggest that Reagan increased the tax burden. That's why you never mentioned that he started the recession with a massive tax cut. That's why you only mentioned his later tax increase and made it sound like it occurred early in the recession.
Quote:
The economy didn't fall back into recession (as it is now doing under Obama) because it was already booming (not like now), and $214 billion over the next five years was small potatoes in an economy that would grow over $1.65 TRILLION in that 5 year period.
Unless you believe that the tax reduction-induced deficits were a factor in creating the 1991 recession.
Another non-sequitur. I notice you are having a bit of trouble actually addressing my arguments.
And if that's going to be your logic, why blame the current troubles on Bush … go back to the source and blame it on the most hated conservative of all … Reagan. Maybe HIS tax cut/increase is the reason Obama and democrats are creating a trillion dollar a year deficit now?
And wasn't there a downturn in the stock market in 1987?
Non-sequitur red herring. And what has that to do with anything?
Yep, I'm a socialist, just like Obama.
Figured as much.