USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

And yet Bush managed to keep growth in the 3% range for 3 years. What suddenly caused it to start dropping after 2006? The only thing I see are democrats controlling Congress.

Try subtracting his deficits from those figures. You should always do that if you want to see the real picture. Always. If you want to see the even scarier and realer picture (trust me you don't), use the appropriate multipliers for knock-off effects etc.
 
Last edited:
And yet Bush managed to keep growth in the 3% range for 3 years. What suddenly caused it to start dropping after 2006? The only thing I see are democrats controlling Congress.

I seem to recall that the housing bubble began to burst in 2007. However, if you can come up with actions that Congress took in 2007 that led to a slowdown in growth, feel free to post them.

Well that only occurred in late 2007 and 2008. And Bush was prevented from doing what he'd done in 2001 and 2003 to stimulate the economy ... by democrats. Instead we began to hear incessant talk of raising taxes ... in the midst of the downturn ... which only made matters worse. And once it became a trifecta with Obama in the Whitehouse, that's when things really nose-dived. And you want to blame that on Bush? :rolleyes:
And what did Bush do in 2001 and 2003? He increased the budget deficit. So you're saying that increasing budget deficits is a good way to stimulate the economy during a downturn? I'd have to agree with you on this point. Though I think that increasing spending is more efficient than lowering taxes. And you have to have an end date so that you don't keep running up deficits after the economy is healthy.

Incidentally, Reagan increased taxes in the midst of a downturn (in 1982). How did that work?
 
Last edited:
But this also affects the numbers that go into historical tables that show our debt for each year, by making it appear artificially low during the Bush years, does it not?

No. As has been pointed out over and over and over to you folks. :rolleyes:
 
Democrats win mid-terms '06,
take congressional power with Pelosi and Reid in '07,
Dems own everything 2008, lame duck Bush and Reps do nothing,
Dems own everything of power unopposable 2009 and 2010,
Mid-term decisively against Dems 2010,
Reps take some back 2011 and put up slight opposition.

Dems say blame Tea Party...

Will the people be majority as stupid as Dems want them to be?
8 years of Bush, lower taxes and deregulation lead to bank melt down, housing crash, pathetic GDP stock market growth, staggering deficit. Will people really just ignore that?
 
Did the revenue go up as much as it would have if the tax rate hadn't been lowered?

Well look at this chart:

http://poisonyourmind.files.wordpress.com/2011/04/tax-revenue-as-percentage-of-gdp1.png

As you can see, historically (for the last 65 years before Obama) revenues as a percent of GDP have averaged about 18%. You can see that in the 2000-2003 timeframe, as a result of the dot-com recession and the impact of 9/11 on the economy, revenue as a percent of GDP dipped to about 16%. The major Bush tax cut (the one that democrats want to let expire) occurred in 2003. And look what happened. Despite the tax cuts that democrats now blame for everything, revenue as a percent of GDP climbed back to over 18%, above the historical average. And might have gone higher had democrats not gained control of Congress in late 2006 and had the mostly democrat-caused mortgage/bank crisis not come to a head shortly after that.
 
you are blaming the sub-prime mortgage debacle on the democrats?
wow.
you should get a job with the tea party, revising history texts.
For partisans just asserting something makes it true. That the debacle happened during Bush's presidency and given that Republicans were the ones calling for deregulation means nothing.
 
Well look at this chart:

http://poisonyourmind.files.wordpress.com/2011/04/tax-revenue-as-percentage-of-gdp1.png

As you can see, historically (for the last 65 years before Obama) revenues as a percent of GDP have averaged about 18%. You can see that in the 2000-2003 timeframe, as a result of the dot-com recession and the impact of 9/11 on the economy, revenue as a percent of GDP dipped to about 16%. The major Bush tax cut (the one that democrats want to let expire) occurred in 2003. And look what happened. Despite the tax cuts that democrats now blame for everything, revenue as a percent of GDP climbed back to over 18%, above the historical average. And might have gone higher had democrats not gained control of Congress in late 2006 and had the mostly democrat-caused mortgage/bank crisis not come to a head shortly after that.

And the evidence that revenues would not have increased at least as much without the tax cut is?

If I try hard, I can come up with other possible explanations, which may or may not be valid. I seem to recall reading, though my memory might be faulty, that roughly 2/3 of the increase in personal income between 2001 and 2007 went to the top 1 percent of the highest paid people and that essentially all of the increase in income during that period went to the top 20 percent (in fact, in real terms the income of the lower 80 percent actually declined). This means that a greater percentage of the income went to people in the higher tax brackets, which should have increased the percentage of income that was paid in taxes.
 
Last edited:
BAC you're using the hurricane in the Atlantic as evidence that the butterfly flapped its wings in Australia. The revenue chart you linked is meaningful and important, but you're only using that mountain to support your arguments about molehills.
 
Obama wanted to reduce the deficit by $4 trillion, putting $3 trillion in cuts --including entitlements -- on the table in exchange for $1 trillion in revenue increases (most of which would have come from closing loopholes rather than raising taxes).

Nice history rewrite.

Here's another version.

Republicans had agreed to a deal that would have totaled $4 trillion with about a trillion of that coming from cuts in entitlements and other forms of mandatory spending. Boehner said he had the votes to pass that. Revenue increases (taxes) were to total $800 billion. Then hours before everything seemed settled, Obama blindsided Boehner and Cantor by demanding another $400 billion in new taxes. At that point it became obvious that Obama was just playing more of his games and Boehner walked.

Now as evidence of this version, consider the fact that leftist MSNBC via Lawrence O'Donnell reported that it "appears President Obama has backed away from the original agreement with Cantor and Boehner for an $800 BILLION increase in tax revenue”. Furthermore, Obama himself admitted during his press conference (http://www.shallownation.com/2011/0...011-press-conference-on-budget-deficit-talks/ ) that he and Boehner had agreed to an $800 billion increase in revenue. Then went on to say that he thought a 4 to 1 cut in spending wasn't "fair". So if the talks failed, they failed because Obama played games, not republicans. Obama wasn't negotiating in good faith.

And my opinion is that if the republicans had agreed to even this revised deal, as George Will put it, Obama could have "run away from his record and run as a debt-reducing centrist" … which is not true even now. He's a socialist through and through. My personal opinion is that the LAST THING this country needs is 4 more years of him sitting in the Oval Office. Then things might not be recoverable at all.
 
I seem to recall that the housing bubble began to burst in 2007.

And why do you think that bubble burst?

Who do you think created that problem in the first place?

Who do you think obstinately refused to do anything about that problem when republicans tried to do something in the years before it burst? Take a guess.

That being the case, why do you assume that democrats weren't still an obstacle to effectively addressing the problem in 2007?

However, if you can come up with actions that Congress took in 2007 that led to a slowdown in growth, feel free to post them.

Well what sort of language was coming out of Washinton at the time … when democrats controlled Congress? Spend spend? Tax tax? Change change? Hope Hope? A prelude to Obama?

IAnd what did Bush do in 2001 and 2003? He increased the budget deficit.

Would you admit that part of the reason deficits increased at that time is that we entered a recession that contrary to democrat claims started at the end of Clinton's term. And that 9/11 occurred which also negatively impacted the economy? That naturally impacted GDP which naturally impacted the revenue side of the equation. Which caused larger deficits.

What would your alternative have been? Not fight the WOT? Or are you foolish enough to think that raising taxes would have solved the revenue problem? Don't you imagine that might have had a negative impact on GDP and been self-defeating? Because history suggests raising taxes in times of economic stress is self defeating, as I've proven over and over in threads at JREF in the last week. Just the opposite was needed. A lowering of taxes. And that's what Bush did. And the economy responded favorably. GDP growth increased into the 2-3% range for quarter after quarter. And guess what? As this chart (http://poisonyourmind.files.wordpress.com/2011/04/tax-revenue-as-percentage-of-gdp1.png ) shows, revenues as a percent of GDP responded positively, moving back to the historical average and even a little above.

So you're saying that increasing budget deficits is a good way to stimulate the economy during a downturn?

No. That is not what I'm saying at all. Re-read the above a second time. You encourage the economy by getting out of the lives of people and business. If liberals should have learned ANYTHING from the trillion dollar Stimulus fiasco, it's that GDP increases less than the amount of Stimulus … especially the sort of stimulus that democrats have pushed and pushed and pushed.

Incidentally, Reagan increased taxes in the midst of a downturn (in 1982). How did that work?

Actually, as I pointed out on another thread, that recession began in July of 1981. You seem to forget that Reagan FIRST cut taxes in August 1981. It wasn't until September 1982, when the recession was almost declared over, that he raised taxes (it was called TEFRA). There's an interesting table here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reaganomics , which sums up the effect of the various tax measures during the Reagan years, and shows that indeed, all told (even accounting for increases in Social Security), the tax burden was reduced by Reagan, contrary to what you are now trying to make people believe. The economy didn't fall back into recession (as it is now doing under Obama) because it was already booming (not like now), and $214 billion over the next five years was small potatoes in an economy that would grow over $1.5 TRILLION in that 5 year period. Plus, there were a lot of other factors then led to the optimism that resulted in large GDP growth. One is that unlike Obama he inspired the small businesses which generate the bulk of jobs in our economy. He really did stand for free enterprise and free trade, as opposed to the lip service now being given those things by socialists/democrats across the board (and that I presume includes you). Another is that the US still was the world's leader in many technologies, including much electronics and software. That was the basis of the growth that even raising taxes could not significantly depress. Whereas now, what's our product going to be? Hmmmm?
 
The chance that you actually are a republican is close to zero, RF.

I'm a registered Republican and I think RandFan was exactly correct. But I will agree that I am not a hyper partisan Republican that missed the fact that George Bush was the worst president in modern times because my mind was stuffed full of Rush Limbaugh style BS. I doubt that the country will fully recover from the disaster of the Bush presidency in what remains of my life.

Unfortunately for the country, the sins of the Bush administration could not be washed away by doubling down on the Bush hyper spending which seemed to be the strategy of the Obama administration up until recently. There is no quick fix available. Probably, no politician can get elected that admits this but the country faces some deep structural problems that can't begin to be solved until after the congress and the president agree to govern the country in a sustainable way. And then the country will have a long period of readjustment as the economy adjusts itself to the reality of sustainable governance again.

The S & P action seemed to be a pretty reasonable one to me in the face of a congress that was still cynically maneuvering for political advantage while the country slides ever closer to major economic crisis.

The simple fact is that the Bush administration spent more than 5 trillion dollars the country didn't have. If the Republicans are so sure that this problem can be solved without tax increases why don't they start by explaining how what they advocate now is any different from what they did when they were in power before.
 
I wonder legitimately sometimes if America could really survive. I think it has much less to do with this credit rating than it does with the fact that America is boiling over with political rivalry and regional factionalism. It may sound ridiculous but issues from the civil war still haven't been sorted out. Furthermore, instead of taking one unified stance against issues Americans take several stances that only further separate us. I am willing to bet that America will become 4 or 5 separate regions by mid-century. I don't think this is a gross over estimation of the facts. Day by day each different region in the U.S. takes a severely different politically stance from the other ones and this will have rippling consequences for the world. Not only will our country sink into an unending depression for the next 30 years, but it will also lead to a factional split that will have global consequences. This type of foolishness and bickering is what I am sure will lead to a new dark age that will last for 2 or 3 centuries.
 
Last edited:
You are confusing revenue and tax levels. They aren't the same thing, otherwise revenues would go down every time taxes were lowered. And they haven't. In fact, often as not, revenue has gone up after lowering taxes.

I keep hearing Republicons spewing that blather, but I have yet to see proof that it works.

Sure, Ronaldus Senilus cut income taxes and revenue supposedly went up. I want to see figures to prove it.

No, don't just show me total tax collections. I want to know from what sources those collections came. I want proof that he didn't steal the difference from tax payers who could ill afford it through other taxes.

Remember, that the senile old fart also increased payroll taxes that were supposedly there to pay for Social Security, along with a few other odds and ends.

You see what we have here is a battle of economic ideologies. One that has been proven wrong over and over and over throughout history (yours) and one that has been proven right over and over (mine).
No. Your blather has not been proven right. A lot of the seeming "improvement" is just a fleecing of the weak to benefit the strong.

Kennedy's tax cuts worked because they actually increased the amount that some people paid. The rich, especially, paid more because he shut some loopholes on their greedy little fingers.

Seems to me that the Republicons, if they feel like closing loopholes, are more likely to do stupid stuff, like taking away my deduction for state sales tax.

I am not buying your unicorn poo.
 
For partisans just asserting something makes it true. That the debacle happened during Bush's presidency and given that Republicans were the ones calling for deregulation means nothing.
Mostly true, but we can't ignore the ham-handed massive financial deregulation of the Clinton administration either.
 
They would be more credible if they would man up and admit their errors.
I'd assign partial blame for the morgage derivative fiasco to the Democratic party pushing the low income loans. What amount? Who knows, maybe 30%....those WERE the problem loans in fair part.

But it was not a single cause.
 
Nice history rewrite.

Here's another version.

Republicans had agreed to a deal that would have totaled $4 trillion with about a trillion of that coming from cuts in entitlements and other forms of mandatory spending. Boehner said he had the votes to pass that. Revenue increases (taxes) were to total $800 billion. Then hours before everything seemed settled, Obama blindsided Boehner and Cantor by demanding another $400 billion in new taxes. At that point it became obvious that Obama was just playing more of his games and Boehner walked.

If it was hours before everything seemed settled, then everything wasn't settled. I'm guessing that Boehner walked out because he refused to raise any taxes, not because he thought Obama was "just playing more of his games" (whatever that means -- that seems to be something you made up).

Conjecture aside, here's what is actually known.

Obama stated that he wanted approximately $3 trillion in cuts (and was willing to include significant cuts to entitlements) and $1 trillion in revenues. Boehner agreed to $800 billion in revenues from closing tax loopholes, but was unwilling to raise taxes to get any additional amount of revenue.

It seems fairly likely that when it looked like Boehner wasn't going to get away with a deal that didn't include tax increases, he walked out. Not that surprising since that's just what Cantor did in previous negotiations. After Cantor's walkout, it was pretty clear that at some point raising taxes was going to come up, and unless the Republicans were willing to compromise there wasn't going to be a deal. They weren't and there wasn't.

-Bri
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom