USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

The very fact that you have to try and spin the increase of debt as a percentage of GDP during a period when the Republicans held both houses of Congress and the Presidency as being the fault of the dot-com crash and the multiple conflicts of the WOT

You don't think they had something to do with it? You think that's just spin? :rolleyes:

while placing blame for the post 2006 rise solely on the Democratic control of Congress (and in 2008 the Presidency)

Well, what was different between the 2003-2005 period and the 2006-2007 period? Other than democrats controlling Congress?

and completely ignoring the both the fact that those Bush-era wars haven't ended

And yet Bush managed to keep growth in the 3% range for 3 years. What suddenly caused it to start dropping after 2006? The only thing I see are democrats controlling Congress.

ANTPogo;7455101and that there was an economic [I said:
far[/I] worse than the dot-com crash puts the lie to your partisan thesis.

Well that only occurred in late 2007 and 2008. And Bush was prevented from doing what he'd done in 2001 and 2003 to stimulate the economy ... by democrats. Instead we began to hear incessant talk of raising taxes ... in the midst of the downturn ... which only made matters worse. And once it became a trifecta with Obama in the Whitehouse, that's when things really nose-dived. And you want to blame that on Bush? :rolleyes:
 
http://www.powerlineblog.com/archives/2011/08/tea-party-downgrade-they-cant-possibly-sell-it.php

AUGUST 7, 2011

… snip …


The downgrading of U.S. debt is an extreme embarrassment for the government in general, and the Obama administration in particular. So the administration has reacted in the only way it knows: by denouncing Standard & Poors, and by blaming its political opponents, the supporters of the Tea Party, for the downgrade.

The administration’s knee-jerk responses are somewhat inconsistent: if S&P was wrong to downgrade the debt, and the downgrade was based on a mathematical error, then it is hard to see how the downgrade can also be the Tea Party’s fault. (In the legal world, this is known as pleading in the alternative … snip …

Of the administration’s alternative theories, the most ludicrous is the claim that the Tea Party, the one group dedicated to doing something about the nation’s spending and debt crisis, is somehow to blame for it.

… snip …

Put aside for a moment the fact that Obama’s willingness to compromise was entirely theoretical; never did he put such a compromise plan on the table. His FY 2012 budget proposal was anything but a compromise; it included no entitlement reform and projected massive deficits for as far as the eye could see, and therefore received not a single vote in Congress.

What is most ludicrous is the Democrats’ effort to distract attention from the fact that they controlled Congress from January 2007 until January 2011. The first Congress that had any ability to be influenced by the Tea Party movement has been in office for only six months. Do the Democrats seriously expect anyone to believe that S&P’s downgrade of U.S. debt arises out of something that Republican Congressmen have done in the last six months?

… snip … it is hard to believe that even the dimmest voters will fall for the idea that the movement that was founded in order to do something about the spending and debt crisis is somehow to blame for that crisis.

But never count out stuck-on-stupid, dim-witted democrats. :p
 

Well, let's ask Standard and Poor's why they downgraded our rating.

We lowered our long-term rating on the U.S. because we believe that the prolonged controversy over raising the statutory debt ceiling and the related fiscal policy debate indicate that further near-term progress containing the growth in public spending, especially on entitlements, or on reaching an agreement on raising revenues is less likely than we previously assumed and will remain a contentious and fitful process.

Curse those Democrats for flat-out refusing any new raising of revenue! This is all their fault!
 
Curse those Democrats for flat-out refusing any new raising of revenue! This is all their fault!
I know,

Dems: We propose cutting spending if you will raise taxes.
Repubs: We propose you sit down, shut up and agree to cut spending or we will force America into default.

Obstinate Democrats.
 
We lowered our long-term rating on the U.S. because we believe that the prolonged controversy over raising the statutory debt ceiling and the related fiscal policy debate indicate that further near-term progress containing the growth in public spending, especially on entitlements, or on reaching an agreement on raising revenues is less likely than we previously assumed and will remain a contentious and fitful process.
Like you can take them at their word.
 
Curse those Democrats for flat-out refusing any new raising of revenue!

You are confusing revenue and tax levels. They aren't the same thing, otherwise revenues would go down every time taxes were lowered. And they haven't. In fact, often as not, revenue has gone up after lowering taxes. You see what we have here is a battle of economic ideologies. One that has been proven wrong over and over and over throughout history (yours) and one that has been proven right over and over (mine).
 
The very fact that you have to try and spin the increase of debt as a percentage of GDP during a period when the Republicans held both houses of Congress and the Presidency as being the fault of the dot-com crash and the multiple conflicts of the WOT, while placing blame for the post 2006 rise solely on the Democratic control of Congress (and in 2008 the Presidency) and completely ignoring the both the fact that those Bush-era wars haven't ended and that there was an economic far worse than the dot-com crash puts the lie to your partisan thesis.

Isn't there also the matter of Bush keeping his wars off-budget, and thus out of calculations of the debt, a dishonest practice which Obama ended?

I'd also like to see a breakdown of what caused the actual growth in GDP under Bush, before Wall Street destroyed our economy and brought the GDP down, that is.
 
Isn't there also the matter of Bush keeping his wars off-budget, and thus out of calculations of the debt, a dishonest practice which Obama ended?
Obama is sneaky. His honesty makes you wonder what else the guy is being honest about.

I'd also like to see a breakdown of what caused the actual growth in GDP under Bush, before Wall Street destroyed our economy and brought the GDP down, that is.
Wall Street destroyed our economy. Wait, what?
 
Last edited:
Isn't there also the matter of Bush keeping his wars off-budget, and thus out of calculations of the debt, a dishonest practice which Obama ended?

Sort of. Obama changed the deficit projection calculation to include war spending. That calculation doesn't affect actual observed deficits or debt -- it only changes how future deficits are projected (predicted). So projections of future deficits will appear to be higher (and more accurate since they take into account war spending) than they would have under Bush's calculation.

Source: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/20/us/politics/20budget.html

-Bri
 
Sort of. Obama changed the deficit projection calculation to include war spending. That calculation doesn't affect actual observed deficits or debt -- it only changes how future deficits are projected (predicted). So projections of future deficits will appear to be higher (and more accurate since they take into account war spending) than they would have under Bush's calculation.

Source: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/20/us/politics/20budget.html

-Bri

But this also affects the numbers that go into historical tables that show our debt for each year, by making it appear artificially low during the Bush years, does it not?
 
But this also affects the numbers that go into historical tables that show our debt for each year, by making it appear artificially low during the Bush years, does it not?

No, I don't believe so. It only changes predictions of deficits into the future. Historical data includes all spending, including war spending. That's why the calculation Bush used for projections was inaccurate (future deficit projections didn't include war spending whereas actual deficits include war spending). Fudging projections in this way allows you to make a better case for, say, more tax cuts while you're at war, because it makes it look like the deficit will be smaller 10 years from now than it actually will be when you include the war spending.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
The honest impression I got through the whole debate was that for both parties the only definition of compromise was voting party-line. It's why there was no bill until the last minute, and why it came out as bad as it did. The downgrade was largely attributed to the same reason.
 
The honest impression I got through the whole debate was that for both parties the only definition of compromise was voting party-line. It's why there was no bill until the last minute, and why it came out as bad as it did. The downgrade was largely attributed to the same reason.
Perhaps I missed something. There were spending cuts right? How was that a compromise? I thought there was no bill until the last minute because the Republicans said their way or default and the Dems wanted something out of the deal.
 
You are confusing revenue and tax levels. They aren't the same thing, otherwise revenues would go down every time taxes were lowered. And they haven't. In fact, often as not, revenue has gone up after lowering taxes.

Did the revenue go up as much as it would have if the tax rate hadn't been lowered?
 
Until the GOP starts getting serious about compromising on these issues (and sticking the Tea Party ideologues into the crazy closet), there will be no progress on the matter.
So, what we need to do is ostracize and demonize the only new representatives that say new things and insist upon new principles and that were just elected overwhelmingly in the last mid-term election less than a year ago,,, them... we need to exclude them in favor of the same old regular establishment entrenched Democrats and the same old establishment entrenched Republicans. Yeah... that's what you say the American People want...
Polls show consistently that President Obama is viewed much more favorably than the GOP/Tea Party on the issue of the economy, that more people trust President Obama to help fix things, and the Tea Party poll numbers are tanking at the same time
Go ahead, keep believing the psychosis. The overwhelming election just 9 months ago, yeah, those people, things have changed so much for the better since... that they all support Obama and the Democrats now... yeah.... you go ahead and believe that....
 
The honest impression I got through the whole debate was that for both parties the only definition of compromise was voting party-line. It's why there was no bill until the last minute, and why it came out as bad as it did. The downgrade was largely attributed to the same reason.

Obama wanted to reduce the deficit by $4 trillion, putting $3 trillion in cuts --including entitlements -- on the table in exchange for $1 trillion in revenue increases (most of which would have come from closing loopholes rather than raising taxes). The GOP insisted that agreeing to raise the debt ceiling was their compromise, for which they demanded only cuts and no tax increases.

So the final deal included a fraction of the amount the S&P said would be necessary to avoid a downgrade, with no tax increases. That's what S&P attributed the downgrade to.

-Bri
 
I say let the Republican party keep going down this path, because they're only going to hang themselves with this strategy. It is already apparent that people blame the GOP/Tea Party more than anyone for this current mess, and trying to point the finger of blame at President Obama is only going to make matters worse, politically, for them.

Hopefully, the leadership in the GOP will soon get realistic about a compromise to help fix things. We'll see.

Democrats win mid-terms '06,
take congressional power with Pelosi and Reid in '07,
Dems own everything 2008, lame duck Bush and Reps do nothing,
Dems own everything of power unopposable 2009 and 2010,
Mid-term decisively against Dems 2010,
Reps take some back 2011 and put up slight opposition.

Dems say blame Tea Party...

Will the people be majority as stupid as Dems want them to be?
 
Last edited:
Obama says U.S. remains 'AAA country'

Will we ever make it to the Majors though?
picture.php
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom