USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

I don't mind a degree of satire and mockery. It comes with the territory. But at some point people need to face up to the facts. Spending will have to be cut. The Dems didn't do enough. However, it's hard to get more when your position is "sit down, shut up, and do as we tell you."

qft
 
I don't mind a degree of satire and mockery. It comes with the territory. But at some point people need to face up to the facts. Spending will have to be cut. The Dems didn't do enough. However, it's hard to get more when your position is "sit down, shut up, and do as we tell you."

I actually agree. I think President Obama's position of putting Social Security, Medicare, AND tax increases on the table was the right way to go.

Both parties in Congress messed this one up, but the GOP/Tea Party shoulders most of the blame, in my opinion.
 

As long as RandFan spams the forum with that I will respond with this:

I admire and agree with much of what Stockman has said concerning this crisis. He certainly has demolished the claims of the Obama administration that the Stimulus has helped unemployment and the economy.

I'll also agree with Stockman's assertion that Paul Ryan's solution to this crisis is too "non-radical". I'll agree that Ryan's solution would let things grow worse before they turned around and started to get better. Perhaps worse enough to become unfixable. I'll agree with Stockman that we have to find a quicker solution to reducing the debt as a percentage of the GDP. I agree with him that we have to massively cut government spending (far more than democrats have been willing to do). And I'll agree with him that this alone will not reduce the national debt as a percentage of GDP, not unless revenues significantly exceed spending or the GDP grows.

But here's where Stockman goes astray. In the past, Stockmen has said the way to force lower spending is to cut taxes. He called that tactic "starving the beast." Now Stockman is advocating an increase in taxes. He apparently thinks we can tax our way into a surplus that will significantly lower national debt as a percentage of GDP.

But that's a pipedream. He underestimates how difficult it is to get government to actually spend less than revenue. He ignores 65+ years of history. Historically, our government has almost always spent more than it took in as revenues. Here, see for yourself: http://static8.businessinsider.com/...345/us-government-spending-versus-revenue.jpg .

He also overlooks the effect of higher taxes on GDP growth. Why he is doing this now I don't know, but nevetheless he is. In any given period, what has made all the difference historically is whether there was economic growth or not. The share of the economy that has been seized by the government has gone down at times because of economic growth … not because government spent less than it took in as revenues (because they've rarely done that).

Relying on government to spend less than it takes in as revenue is a pipedream. And Stockman should know this. It's why he used to advocate "starving the beast". His new approach rarely has and rarely will work. It has certainly never done that long enough in the US to measurably shrink the deficit/debt as a percentage of GDP … which is what matters. What has reduced the deficit/debt as a percentage of GDP has been economic growth. Almost every time.

That's why I say that the ONLY way to fix the current economic mess is to cap spending so that government can't keep borrowing and thus increase the debt without bound, and then grow our way out of this by encouraging economic growth. By keeping taxes low and reducing needless government regulation of our lives. Just like the Tea Party advocates.

If we do that, we will see the size of the debt as a percentage of GDP shrink. THAT will get our economic house back in order. And a look at the period from 1995 to 2001, shows how rapidly that could occur:

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_QxBGECHec...4YsgU/s400/D.+National+Debt+as+percent+of+gdp

But it will never happen with Obama in the Whitehouse and Pelosi/Reid style democrats controlling Congress. Never. History proves that their type of economic thinking simply does not work.

So don't be deceived by RandMan's latest red herring. It's just as bogus as the "before deflator" Real GDP nonsense he posted the other day and continues to spout despite my pointing out his error. Don't be deceived by this clueless liar. :D
 
I actually agree. I think President Obama's position of putting Social Security, Medicare, AND tax increases on the table was the right way to go.

Both parties in Congress messed this one up, but the GOP/Tea Party shoulders most of the blame, in my opinion.
Agreed. Had the GOP said, look, we will give you X points in tax rate increases for everyone over $250,000 for X cuts across the board in spending we very well might not be looking at a market meltdown.
 
Last edited:
What?!

:confused:

Please back that up.

House Majority Whip Kevin McCarthy showed a clip from the Ben Affleck movie The Town in order to inspire the members of the GOP to have the same sense of unity as the characters in the movie.

This clip, in fact, in which Ben Affleck's character (who started the movie by robbing a bank and taking the bank manager hostage) tells one of his fellow thugs that he needs his help to go hurt some people, to which his friend responds "Who's car are we gonna take?". The scene after this has the two of them brutally beating up some people.

Reportedly, after watching the clip, Rep. Allan West jumped up and said "I'll drive the car!"
 
And a look at the period from 1995 to 2001, shows how rapidly that could occur:

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_QxBGECHec...4YsgU/s400/D.+National+Debt+as+percent+of+gdp

But it will never happen with Obama in the Whitehouse and Pelosi/Reid style democrats controlling Congress. Never. History proves that their type of economic thinking simply does not work.

Can you remind us who was president during that period, BAC, and what the tax rates then were as compared to now, during the period of the Bush tax cuts?
 
How do I know you're a US citizen, BAC? Just because you say so?

I don't care whether you think I'm a US citizen. All I'm posting are facts and history, and drawing logical conclusions. My conclusions aren't dependent on any claim I make about myself. Nor am I basing my conclusions on what another JREFer claims to be his *history*. Whereas you ... :D

And I gather from your reponse you have NO proof that RandFan is a republican. Other than what he claims. But he also claims that there's a "before Real GDP" deflator and an "after Real GDP" deflator and that none of the charts I linked to him were inflation adjusted. And both claims are nothing but pure nonsense. So what makes you think he wouldn't pretend to be a republican to further an agenda that apparently includes heavily taxing/redistributing not just the income but the assets of Americans? Hmmmmmm?
 
Can you remind us who was president during that period, BAC, and what the tax rates then were as compared to now, during the period of the Bush tax cuts?

Do you have cotton in your ears? A blindfold over your eyes? As I've noted repeatedly in the last few days, debt as a percent of GDP (the only parameter that really matters in this debate) ONLY started dropping after republicans gained control of both houses of Congress, forced tax cuts, reduced welfare and unleashed the power of the private sector with less government regulation. And that period has a number of advantages, economically, over Bush's tenure … not the least of which was the internet boom, no recession, no 9/11 and no WOT to wage.
 
Do you have cotton in your ears? A blindfold over your eyes? As I've noted repeatedly in the last few days, debt as a percent of GDP (the only parameter that really matters in this debate) ONLY started dropping after republicans gained control of both houses of Congress, forced tax cuts, reduced welfare and unleashed the power of the private sector with less government regulation. And that period has a number of advantages, economically, over Bush's tenure … not the least of which was the internet boom, no recession, no 9/11 and no WOT to wage.

The very fact that you have to try and spin the increase of debt as a percentage of GDP during a period when the Republicans held both houses of Congress and the Presidency as being the fault of the dot-com crash and the multiple conflicts of the WOT, while placing blame for the post 2006 rise solely on the Democratic control of Congress (and in 2008 the Presidency) and completely ignoring the both the fact that those Bush-era wars haven't ended and that there was an economic far worse than the dot-com crash puts the lie to your partisan thesis.
 
The wheels, they won't turn! Aieeeee!

Gasp! Obama is secretly behind the Brotherhood of Steel!

BoS_logo.png
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom