UK establishment child abuse cover-up inquiry

The issue is that this is the establishment that is being investigated therefore it really can't be a member of the establishment running the inquiry. Of course this poses a problem as they don't understand how to recruit someone they or their mates dont know for a job. There are hundreds of thousands of people in the UK that could run the inquiry and do a better job than a member of the establishment. Indeed I would like to see a non establishment figure running it because of the waves it would cause. We need someone who won't be satisfied with official newspeak and the typical run around.

Geoffrey Robertson? Or is he part of "The Establishment" these days?
 
Geoffrey Robertson? Or is he part of "The Establishment" these days?

I thought of him too. He is a bloody good lawyer of considerable integrity and not afraid to take up unpopular positions. I bet there are a couple of hundred like him.
 
Russell Brand. No, I didn't think that through. We want a reasonably classless person of unquestioned integrity who won't take no **** from anybody. There are probably plenty of senior barristers and/or judges who would fit the bill. They aren't all Eton/Oxbridge types. A university academic of the right stripe perhaps. Experience of legal-type processes is probably an asset though.

Incidentally, we bandy the word about as though we all know what it means, but what exactly is 'the establishment'?
If the Sun can find enough of a link between them and anybody who was in the media, cabinet, police, judiciary, or child protection in the past half century to print a story about it they are too establishment. What you want is somebody with talent, knowledge of the law, and natural authority who has somehow never risen to any kind of officially sanctioned prominence. Maybe somebody in organised crime would fit the bill?
 
Russell Brand. No, I didn't think that through. We want a reasonably classless person of unquestioned integrity who won't take no **** from anybody. There are probably plenty of senior barristers and/or judges who would fit the bill. They aren't all Eton/Oxbridge types. A university academic of the right stripe perhaps. Experience of legal-type processes is probably an asset though.

Incidentally, we bandy the word about as though we all know what it means, but what exactly is 'the establishment'?

I think that having family and friends in senior positions in more than one area of law, arts, media or politics probably helps. Especially if they were not crass enough to go to a minor public school.
 
Martin McGuiness.
A politician with no love of the British establishment.

Or (slightly more seriously) any sufficiently senior lawyer from Ireland who would be unlikely to have anyone in London to protect.
 
There are plenty of candidates.

On a wider note, if B-S (apt) is saying the Establishment will only accept policing by the Establishment then that is... erm....

I may have to return to this when sober
 
There are plenty of candidates.

On a wider note, if B-S (apt) is saying the Establishment will only accept policing by the Establishment then that is... erm....

I may have to return to this when sober

No, I get it. I thought the same. 'Either let us do it (on our terms) or it won't get done at all.' It's *********** outrageous.
 
Martin McGuiness.
A politician with no love of the British establishment.

Or (slightly more seriously) any sufficiently senior lawyer from Ireland who would be unlikely to have anyone in London to protect.

I saw you did the 'slightly more seriously' thing but - Martin McGuiness??? I would be personally happy to be on his firing squad. Would you trust such fellows to find the truth with respect to these allegations?
 
I saw you did the 'slightly more seriously' thing but - Martin McGuiness??? I would be personally happy to be on his firing squad. Would you trust such fellows to find the truth with respect to these allegations?


Someone with more experience of two faced, duplicitous lying would be hard to find....
 
BBC News: New Zealand judge Lowell Goddard to lead abuse inquiry

Obviously the net was cast further than even we suspected...

I'm just glad to see they took my advice. I posted here on Jan. 1st (post #66):

The UK has the advantage over any other country faced with a similar situation in that it has exported a lot of its legal system(s) as well as its language to other countries. Would it really be difficult to find an experienced, respected judge or recently retired judge from New Zealand or Australia or Canada, with no ties to the British establishment, to do the job?

See how I even subtly put New Zealand first in that list?
 

She seems a far better bet than the previous two, who were rather unimpressive.

An earlier article about her:

http://www.stuff.co.nz/world/europe/65832339/justice-lowell-goddard-latest-career-move



Goddard, 66, who was last year made Dame Companion of the New Zealand Order of Merit, has led this country's judiciary in many ways. In 1992, she became deputy solicitor-general, overseeing prosecution of serious crime.

Of Ngati Kahungunu ancestry, she was the first person of Maori descent to sit in the High Court, joining the bench in 1995. She later become the first woman appointed to a division of the Court of Appeal.

During her five-year tenure she oversaw the [ Independent Police Conduct Authority (IPCA)] authority's transformation from a reviewing agency to one that focused on active investigations of serious complaints against police.
In 2002, she gave what was then a record jail sentence – with no hope of parole for 28 years – to Bruce Howse, who murdered his two young step-daughters in their Masterton sleep-out.

She would later admit: "There have been very few people throughout my career that I have not been able to relate to in any way. These were the paedophiles and the psychopaths. Usually I could relate in a professional way to anyone, no matter what they'd done."

Goddard is married to fellow barrister and judge Chris Hodson QC. She has three stepchildren and a daughter from her first marriage, Rebecca Scott, who is also a barrister. As well as the law, the family share a passion for horses. Hodson is president of Equestrian Sports New Zealand, and Scott was an equestrian rival of Catriona Williams, who became a tetraplegic after a 2002 riding accident.

Goddard is a significant supporter of the CatWalk Spinal Cord Injury Trust, founded by Williams.

In her latest role, which will see her lead an investigation into child sex abuse cases from as far back as 1945, Goddard will be able to draw on her work for the IPCA where she led an inquiry into police handling of more than 100 cases of child abuse.
 
She seems a far better bet than the previous two, who were rather unimpressive.
I think Butler-Sloss's unacceptability should have been anticipated, but Woolf having a passing social connection with Britten's wife much less so. It will be interesting to see after however many year's this inquiry will take whether those concerns were justified or not.

Of course, there's an interesting subtext to the only choices being female....
 
I think Butler-Sloss's unacceptability should have been anticipated, but Woolf having a passing social connection with Britten's wife much less so. It will be interesting to see after however many year's this inquiry will take whether those concerns were justified or not.

Of course, there's an interesting subtext to the only choices being female....

Well, aside from having zero experience with child abuse cases and being a member of the establishment (what was Lady Butler-Sloss's phrase 'you must have establishment' or something weird like that?) she was just perfect! :)
 
Well, aside from having zero experience with child abuse cases and being a member of the establishment (what was Lady Butler-Sloss's phrase 'you must have establishment' or something weird like that?) she was just perfect! :)
Inherently I don't think the idea that to rise to a certain level in the judiciary one becomes part of the establishment, or at least become entwined with it, is that weird. It might sound snobbish, but there's a ring of truth to it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom