UK establishment child abuse cover-up inquiry

Do you need a lawyer to lead an enquiry?
I don't think it's a actual rule but it seems to be usual. Perhaps a Royal Commission with a groups of commissioners would be a better idea?

Utterly OT but since seeing a few pics of Ms. Batmanghelidj(h) I now have the person for the Sixth Doctor in the alternate Female Doctor Who project...

It was a very strange choice for that reason among others. As I said upthread, they also picked her for the super-sensitive Diana inquest which, it turned out, she wasn't up to. She kept making pro-cover-upestablishment decisions which kept getting successfully appealed (auto correct just tried to me make me spell that 'sucessfully' :boggled:) until she threw all her papers in the air and flounced out (speaking figuratively). 80 is way past it for a lawyer. Judges are forced to retire before that age in case they end up gibbering like Denning.
Wasn't he gibbering long before he was retired?
 
I think that's kind of Anglolawyer's point.

Chairing an inquiry of that nature is hard, time-consuming, demanding work. Why would anyone think it was an appropriate job for an old lady? From any point of view?

Rolfe.
 
I suggest Camila Batmanghelidj (hope I spelled that right? AFAIK it's pronounced Batmanjelly) to head the inquiry. Not only does she have a cool name, and fantastic dress sense, but she has an impeccable reputation, especially for children's issues.

I dunno - never liked her since I saw her being interviewed and effectively saying that they only solution to some problem or other was to give £X million to her charity to sort it out.
 
Last edited:
Seems like they thought no harder than saying, "Who was it that did the Cleveland abuse inquiry and are they still alive?".

Call me cynical but I fancy it was more like 'who can we get who will authoritatively and reliably kick this into the long grass?' I have been meaning to take Jihad Jane to task about the name of this thread - it should be:

UK establishment child abuse cover-up cover-up.
 
If a person were to be found reasonably responsible of something which was at the time a crime but is at the present legal (such as any male homosexual intercourse or gay sex with someone younger than 21/18 years old) would it be possible that they would be found guilty and sentenced for said crime?
 
If a person were to be found reasonably responsible of something which was at the time a crime but is at the present legal (such as any male homosexual intercourse or gay sex with someone younger than 21/18 years old) would it be possible that they would be found guilty and sentenced for said crime?
Aged 16-20 in this context. Even if it were legally possible, it would be hard to justify.
 
If a person were to be found reasonably responsible of something which was at the time a crime but is at the present legal (such as any male homosexual intercourse or gay sex with someone younger than 21/18 years old) would it be possible that they would be found guilty and sentenced for said crime?

Depends whether the amendment to the law was expressed to have retrospective effect. If not, then they could still be prosecuted but the public interest test applied by the prosecutor's office would probably weigh against it, almost certainly for the kinds of offence you mention,.
 
I'm currently seeing an interesting conspiracy theory that the child abuse networks were in fact run by the security services in order to tempt known pederast MPs into the net so that they could be manipulated. Not sure if it really flies.

Rolfe.
 
I'm currently seeing an interesting conspiracy theory that the child abuse networks were in fact run by the security services in order to tempt known pederast MPs into the net so that they could be manipulated. Not sure if it really flies.

Rolfe.

The problem again is the cold war context. If you can blackmail them so can the Soviets. Its easy to get less damaging dirt on MPs that can still be used for a degree of control but can be revealed for less damage.

The other problem is that with the likely exception of GCHQ the security services of the time were quite impressively incompetent.
 
The problem again is the cold war context. If you can blackmail them so can the Soviets. Its easy to get less damaging dirt on MPs that can still be used for a degree of control but can be revealed for less damage.

The other problem is that with the likely exception of GCHQ the security services of the time were quite impressively incompetent.

As I said before, the Soviets would have loved something like this (the KGB would have been posting the allegations directly to the white house for supreme damage to the special relationship)
 
Aged 16-20 in this context. Even if it were legally possible, it would be hard to justify.
Depends whether the amendment to the law was expressed to have retrospective effect. If not, then they could still be prosecuted but the public interest test applied by the prosecutor's office would probably weigh against it, almost certainly for the kinds of offence you mention,.

So in a sense it's not unimaginable that at least some of the supposed crimes that were supposedly covered up were of the sort that are now perfectly legal? If that's the case i wouldn't be surprised if the scale of the "child sexual abuse" is being inflated by including crimes such as consensual sodomy with youths aged 16 and up.
 
It's not unimaginable however there is no evidence that anyone is facing any kind of prosecution or charges in regards to consensual sex with a male who was under 21 but over 16. Just as an aside if this was the case there would be some males who were between 16 and 21 at the time also being prosecuted today.
 
It's not unimaginable however there is no evidence that anyone is facing any kind of prosecution or charges in regards to consensual sex with a male who was under 21 but over 16. Just as an aside if this was the case there would be some males who were between 16 and 21 at the time also being prosecuted today.

Considering we are talking about elected politicans, nobles and such people I'm sure the mere possibility of them being branded as criminals and worse, "sex-criminals", would be bad enough.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom