UK establishment child abuse cover-up inquiry

Inherently I don't think the idea that to rise to a certain level in the judiciary one becomes part of the establishment, or at least become entwined with it, is that weird. It might sound snobbish, but there's a ring of truth to it.

I don't disagree. Far from it. Once you make High Court Judge or above you're in.

If you had to, how would you define the establishment? Not an easy question.
 
It's certainly a good question. It's probably easier to define it by who is or isn't in it, rather than coming up with a workable definition of it.

I am definitely not in it. Let's see: The Royals and upper social strata and the following elites: political, judicial, commercial, civil service, military and security and (peut etre) the quangocracy . Basically, the state's power centres.
 
Well the new one says she doesn't think any 'Survivors' should be on the inquiry board and that's ruffling feathers already.

I predict the Tabloids will go for her sooner or later and it will all collapse again
 
Well the new one says she doesn't think any 'Survivors' should be on the inquiry board and that's ruffling feathers already.

I predict the Tabloids will go for her sooner or later and it will all collapse again

Unfortunately I think the "survivors" will not STFU until they have an inquiry chair that it is 100% guanteed to toe their line.
 
Well the new one says she doesn't think any 'Survivors' should be on the inquiry board and that's ruffling feathers already.

I predict the Tabloids will go for her sooner or later and it will all collapse again

I don't know what the precedents are but I should have thought such an arrangement would undermine the weight to be given to the enquiry's conclusions. I am surprised at the suggestion and agree with the judge that it's just as inappropriate to have survivors on the board as it was to have establishment figures.
 
Just make her sheare a sheep and ring Richer McCaw. She will be back on track :o)
 
I am dismayed to find this thread here as I was just about to start one on a peculiar phenomenon I have noticed about legal systems in different countries. Still, I have made the point before I guess. We Brits cannot deal with class or matters too close to The Establishment. OTOH we have no problem with celebrity at all, unlike the yanks who are paralysed by it. Indeed, our judges being vastly superior (socially) to the divers players, jesters and minstrels who distract the populace from their labour, have no qualm about locking them up and chucking away the key. And a jolly good thing too. Ho ho.

But if a bishop takes a choir boy up the backside behind the cross benches in the House of Lords then ranks close to protect two of our great institutions (the Church and the Lords). After yesterday's resignation of Baroness Butler-Sloss (she that already had to pull out of the Dianagate inquest after getting flustered by all the pesky appeals against her rulings) there is now no longer anybody left to conduct the enquiry into illicit rumpy-pumpy within the legislature: no lords, no judges etc So who?



There is a simple answer: these cases should be decided/reviewed by American judges in a judge/swap programme in which we will send our guys over to sort out the Michael Jacksons, OJs etc while the yanks get to nail our delinquent toffs and upper class twits, provided they have the stomach for all that public school fagging and rodgering.

All in favour say 'Aye'.

I suggest Alabama Chief Justice Ray Moore. As a matter of fact, you can keep him. We don't even want him back. Despite some recent problems with his willingness to follow the law, I think he'd be pretty good for this particular case.
 
Last edited:
If she goes boys club on it she will be basically dead ended here, so trust me, she is the right person
 
If she goes boys club on it she will be basically dead ended here, so trust me, she is the right person

I think she is too. A colleague told me that she impressed him in her performance on the Today Programme.
 
I think she is too. A colleague told me that she impressed him in her performance on the Today Programme.

She is a highly respected judge in her own country, has relevant experience with child abuse work and is free of the taint of owing anything to or being part of the establishment. She is from 12,000 miles away. If that's not good enough then we must extend the search to other planets.
 
I haven't been there, but the far South was quite different.

Tuatapere stuck in the mind. "Give me a high six".
 
I can hardly imagine there's no establishment at all, in any country. But at least the NZ establishment is a different one than the British.

She seems a far better bet than the previous two, who were rather unimpressive.
Yes.

I think Butler-Sloss's unacceptability should have been anticipated,
Is it me that I every time I read that name, I get an image of someone drinking all day?

but Woolf having a passing social connection with Britten's wife much less so. It will be interesting to see after however many year's this inquiry will take whether those concerns were justified or not.
How passing was that? Wiki says:
On 21 October 2014, Woolf disclosed that she lived in the same London street as Lord Brittan and had invited the Conservative Peer and his wife, Diana Brittan (formally styled The Lady Brittan of Spennithorne DBE), to dinner on three occasions. Lord Brittan had been Home Secretary in 1984 when ministers were handed a dossier on alleged high-profile paedophiles; he has insisted that the proper procedures were followed. In total, she had dined with Lord Brittan and his family five times since 2008, and also had joined Lady Brittan for coffee on a "small number of occasions".
Within a paragraph, the number of dinners goes up from three to five. I would not be surprised if the number of coffees, when properly investigated, goes up from "a small number" to "once a week". And moreover, she had not disclosed the connection before it was dug up by the press, so that's a big no-no to begin with.
 
Within a paragraph, the number of dinners goes up from three to five. I would not be surprised if the number of coffees, when properly investigated, goes up from "a small number" to "once a week". And moreover, she had not disclosed the connection before it was dug up by the press, so that's a big no-no to begin with.

Well, I daresay that the likes of them go to/host a hell of a lot more dinner parties than most of us, so keeping track must be a tad trying!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom