UK establishment child abuse cover-up inquiry

BBC News: Butler-Sloss cautions over victims' role in abuse inquiry

"Baroness Butler-Sloss has cautioned against giving victims too much influence over who runs the planned inquiry into historical child abuse.

The retired judge, who stepped down as head of the public inquiry, said there could be "real problems" if they were to decide who is its eventual chair."

Cue Phil Frampton whinging like a prick...
 
BBC News: Butler-Sloss cautions over victims' role in abuse inquiry

"Baroness Butler-Sloss has cautioned against giving victims too much influence over who runs the planned inquiry into historical child abuse.

The retired judge, who stepped down as head of the public inquiry, said there could be "real problems" if they were to decide who is its eventual chair."

Cue Phil Frampton whinging like a prick...

Good grief! I propose a revolution rule: all those who think, speak or have names like Butler-Sloss be summarily executed without trial. Apparently, we cannot have an enquiry into establishment cover-ups of illicit pedophile-shagging by members of the establishment which is not itself chaired by a member of the establishment.
 
Another day, another "dossier," and more figures plucked out of thin air....

BBC: John Mann MP says scale of historical child abuse claims 'too many for state'

"The number of victims claiming historical child abuse could reach the tens of thousands and is too many for the state to cope with, an MP says.

John Mann, who has given a dossier of allegations of historical abuse to Scotland Yard, told the Today programme victims wanted a national institute.

The Labour MP for Bassetlaw said the government needed victims' confidence."
 
Last edited:
Good grief! I propose a revolution rule: all those who think, speak or have names like Butler-Sloss be summarily executed without trial. Apparently, we cannot have an enquiry into establishment cover-ups of illicit pedophile-shagging by members of the establishment which is not itself chaired by a member of the establishment.

The obviouus solution has already been brought up in this thread, but not very seriously, but I've heard it advanced seriously by people with more knowledge of such matters than I have, at the time of Butler-Sloss' resignation: why not have a foreign judge?

The UK has the advantage over any other country faced with a similar situation in that it has exported a lot of its legal system(s) as well as its language to other countries. Would it really be difficult to find an experienced, respected judge or recently retired judge from New Zealand or Australia or Canada, with no ties to the British establishment, to do the job?

ETA: having heard Ms Butler-Sloss on the Today programme, I'd say her own words abundantly showed why she should never have been picked for this role. It was one of those "are people like this still around???" moments.
 
Last edited:
With reference to anglolawyer's "judge swap" programme.
I was wondering if any Egyptians were available.
 
The obviouus solution has already been brought up in this thread, but not very seriously, but I've heard it advanced seriously by people with more knowledge of such matters than I have, at the time of Butler-Sloss' resignation: why not have a foreign judge?

The UK has the advantage over any other country faced with a similar situation in that it has exported a lot of its legal system(s) as well as its language to other countries. Would it really be difficult to find an experienced, respected judge or recently retired judge from New Zealand or Australia or Canada, with no ties to the British establishment, to do the job?

ETA: having heard Ms Butler-Sloss on the Today programme, I'd say her own words abundantly showed why she should never have been picked for this role. It was one of those "are people like this still around???" moments.

Absolutely. It is utterly incredible that there is apparently no one in the entire country considered sufficiently trustworthy to whitewash the establishment competent to conduct this enquiry.
 
The obviouus solution has already been brought up in this thread, but not very seriously, but I've heard it advanced seriously by people with more knowledge of such matters than I have, at the time of Butler-Sloss' resignation: why not have a foreign judge?

The UK has the advantage over any other country faced with a similar situation in that it has exported a lot of its legal system(s) as well as its language to other countries. Would it really be difficult to find an experienced, respected judge or recently retired judge from New Zealand or Australia or Canada, with no ties to the British establishment, to do the job?

ETA: having heard Ms Butler-Sloss on the Today programme, I'd say her own words abundantly showed why she should never have been picked for this role. It was one of those "are people like this still around???" moments.
I missed that - what was the gist?


Mind you she did seem to be missing the point when I heard her several weeks ago.
 
I missed that - what was the gist?

Mind you she did seem to be missing the point when I heard her several weeks ago.

The most salient was this bit, which I quote from the Guardian (the BBC article already cited doesn't include the first sentence):

If you do not have in the past a position of authority, how are you going to be able to run the inquiry? You are going to need someone who knows how to run things and if you get someone with an obscure background with no background of establishment, they will find it very difficult and may not be able to produce the goods.

IOW, only someone who is a long-standing member of the establishment is qualified to examine the establishment. The rest of what she said on the topic boiled down to the victims better not getting above their station.

She is also a keen, impartial judge of her own capabilities, and how she sounds to other people:

I think, without sounding arrogant, that I could probably have done the job.
(my emphasis)

I think you can still listen to the whole thing in her own voice on the BBC website, it was the Today programme for December 31st. Her voice is actually part of the problem. I suppose she can't help sounding like something you'd hear on an early 1950s BBC archive recording, but it doesn't help. (Think a much older but more butch Brian Sewell.)

The BBC also adds this, just to show how much in touch with 2015 Britain she is:

In her programme, Baroness Butler-Sloss visits Gibraltar to examine what the future holds for this contested British outpost. She will also look at how the London-based media misrepresents the countryside, as well as seeing just how stressful the life of a parish priest can be.
 
Hmm... not too impressive and oart of the problem

Thanks
 
Dame Butler-Sloss said:
I think, without sounding arrogant, that I could probably have done the job.
My slightly different emphasis. She didn't last the course when presiding over the Dianagate inquest. She had a succession of rulings (all restrictive in nature) successfully appealed and quit. From wikipedia:


The inquests into the deaths of Diana and Fayed opened on 8 January 2007, with Dame Elizabeth Butler-Sloss acting as Deputy Coroner of the Queen's Household for the Diana inquest and Assistant Deputy Coroner for Surrey in relation to the Fayed inquest. Butler-Sloss originally intended to sit without a jury;[57] this decision was later overturned by the High Court,[58] as well as the jurisdiction of the Coroner of the Queen's Household. On 24 April 2007, Butler-Sloss stepped down, saying she lacked the experience required to deal with an inquest with a jury.
 
The issue is that this is the establishment that is being investigated therefore it really can't be a member of the establishment running the inquiry. Of course this poses a problem as they don't understand how to recruit someone they or their mates dont know for a job. There are hundreds of thousands of people in the UK that could run the inquiry and do a better job than a member of the establishment. Indeed I would like to see a non establishment figure running it because of the waves it would cause. We need someone who won't be satisfied with official newspeak and the typical run around.
 
The issue is that this is the establishment that is being investigated therefore it really can't be a member of the establishment running the inquiry. Of course this poses a problem as they don't understand how to recruit someone they or their mates dont know for a job. There are hundreds of thousands of people in the UK that could run the inquiry and do a better job than a member of the establishment. Indeed I would like to see a non establishment figure running it because of the waves it would cause. We need someone who won't be satisfied with official newspeak and the typical run around.

Russell Brand. No, I didn't think that through. We want a reasonably classless person of unquestioned integrity who won't take no **** from anybody. There are probably plenty of senior barristers and/or judges who would fit the bill. They aren't all Eton/Oxbridge types. A university academic of the right stripe perhaps. Experience of legal-type processes is probably an asset though.

Incidentally, we bandy the word about as though we all know what it means, but what exactly is 'the establishment'?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom