UK establishment child abuse cover-up inquiry

I am dismayed to find this thread here as I was just about to start one on a peculiar phenomenon I have noticed about legal systems in different countries. Still, I have made the point before I guess. We Brits cannot deal with class or matters too close to The Establishment. OTOH we have no problem with celebrity at all, unlike the yanks who are paralysed by it. Indeed, our judges being vastly superior (socially) to the divers players, jesters and minstrels who distract the populace from their labour, have no qualm about locking them up and chucking away the key. And a jolly good thing too. Ho ho.

But if a bishop takes a choir boy up the backside behind the cross benches in the House of Lords then ranks close to protect two of our great institutions (the Church and the Lords). After yesterday's resignation of Baroness Butler-Sloss (she that already had to pull out of the Dianagate inquest after getting flustered by all the pesky appeals against her rulings) there is now no longer anybody left to conduct the enquiry into illicit rumpy-pumpy within the legislature: no lords, no judges etc So who?

Daily Mail said:
The Government's inquiry into historic child sex abuse was thrown into disarray today after the ex-judge chosen to lead a wide-ranging inquiry dramatically quit - leaving the Home Secretary Theresa May facing questions over her judgement.
Baroness Butler-Sloss said she had not 'sufficiently considered' concerns that her brother Michael Havers sat in the Cabinet during the 1980s - the period on which claims of a cover-up are focussed.
Mrs May this afternoon admitted to MPs that she was not aware that the late Conservative Attorney General had allegedly attempted to stop an MP airing paedophile allegations in Parliament.

There is a simple answer: these cases should be decided/reviewed by American judges in a judge/swap programme in which we will send our guys over to sort out the Michael Jacksons, OJs etc while the yanks get to nail our delinquent toffs and upper class twits, provided they have the stomach for all that public school fagging and rodgering.

All in favour say 'Aye'.
 
There is a simple answer: these cases should be decided/reviewed by American judges in a judge/swap programme in which we will send our guys over to sort out the Michael Jacksons, OJs etc while the yanks get to nail our delinquent toffs and upper class twits, provided they have the stomach for all that public school fagging and rodgering.

All in favour say 'Aye'.

I've heard this brought up elsewhere today.
Apparently some countries will pull in foreign judges to investigate problems with those in charge.

Now that would be interesting...:)
 
It's a splendid idea
Thank you. We could also borrow the yanks for prosecuting financial crime - although some on their side of the pond may emit a sardonic guffaw at that they really should check out our useless pack of ineffectual weeds, hopelessly outclassed by the big boys in The City.
 
It's a marvellous idea, anglolawyer, though I can foresee a problem:

what if there were any (gasp) royals involved? We might be incapable of disciplining our own establishment, but the Americans love the Windsors even more than we* do.








*well not me, I'm a republican, but you know what I mean.
 
It's a marvellous idea, anglolawyer, though I can foresee a problem:

what if there were any (gasp) royals involved? We might be incapable of disciplining our own establishment, but the Americans love the Windsors even more than we* do.








*well not me, I'm a republican, but you know what I mean.
Surely we turn to the French in this instance.
 
:D

Hmm, Denmark has royalty too. They might be prejudiced.


I thought you English had a nearly 150 year headstart on the French in this regard? :)

For the rest, it sounds like an excellent idea to have foreign investigators.

We were faint hearted. We chopped off Charlie's head but re-instated his heir within a generation. Hence, we are disqualified.
 
I suggest Camila Batmanghelidj (hope I spelled that right? AFAIK it's pronounced Batmanjelly) to head the inquiry. Not only does she have a cool name, and fantastic dress sense, but she has an impeccable reputation, especially for children's issues.
 
Me too. I never heard of this Batman person but, whoever she is, I vote for her just because of the name. If there is a Supermantrifle out there, he can act as counsel to the enquiry.

You'd probably know her if you saw her. Always wears very bright clothing and turbans. Seen her as a talking head on TV quite often, Question Time etc.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camila_Batmanghelidjh
 
Last edited:
Elizabeth Butler-Sloss is 80. I mean, what were they thinking of? I'm not saying she's geriatric in the colloquial sense of the word, but she certainly is in the strict sense. Even if she's as sharp as a tack, is it fair to be asking an old lady to take on that amount of work in her declining years? And is it reasonable to employ someone of that age when the risk of a breakdown in health (either mental or physical) is obviously greater than in a younger person?

Rolfe.
 
Elizabeth Butler-Sloss is 80. I mean, what were they thinking of? I'm not saying she's geriatric in the colloquial sense of the word, but she certainly is in the strict sense. Even if she's as sharp as a tack, is it fair to be asking an old lady to take on that amount of work in her declining years? And is it reasonable to employ someone of that age when the risk of a breakdown in health (either mental or physical) is obviously greater than in a younger person?

Rolfe.

It was a very strange choice for that reason among others. As I said upthread, they also picked her for the super-sensitive Diana inquest which, it turned out, she wasn't up to. She kept making pro-cover-upestablishment decisions which kept getting successfully appealed (auto correct just tried to me make me spell that 'sucessfully' :boggled:) until she threw all her papers in the air and flounced out (speaking figuratively). 80 is way past it for a lawyer. Judges are forced to retire before that age in case they end up gibbering like Denning.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom