Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Conservatives complain that the fact that employer health insurance are generally not treated as taxable income distorts the insurance market and reduces incentives to shop for a better deal. Question: Apart from the increased taxes on the recipient, what would be the likely impact of taxing health benefits? Would employers just give people the money and get out of the insurance business? Would employees really be likely to turn down the employer's group insurance to find something else? Would insurers become more competitive? Etc.

Depends. There are two parts to the tax shelter here - the tax on the recipient (the covered life) and the tax on the employer.

If the tax on the employer is removed, it will depend on the employer. The most likely outcome would be that employers contribute less toward the premium on behalf of their employers, or that they would select leaner benefits (or of course a combination of the two). A surprising number of mid-sized to large employers are quite paternalistic when it comes to health care. Smaller employers often don't have the capital to do the same, they're much more sensitive to the cost overall.

It's possible that some employers would provide a stipend and drop coverage... although that's less feasible as long as ACA is in place. ACA imposes penalties on employers if they drop coverage for their employees. I'm not sure how big exactly, but my vague recollection is that it's substantial enough to make dropping coverage not reasonable in most cases.

If both the employer and the employee tax benefits were removed, it's possible that some employees would turn down their employer coverage and shop on their own... but again it depends a lot on the size of the employer. Most mid and large employers contribute substantially more toward premium on behalf of their employees that the tax would be. In general, it might be more feasible the smaller the employer, and less feasible the larger the employer.

The tax benefit enjoyed by employers and employees with respect to their health care is unlikely to have any material impact on the competitiveness of insurance carriers. I'm sure there are some scenarios that would have this impact, but I can't think of any that make sense.
 
Depends. There are two parts to the tax shelter here - the tax on the recipient (the covered life) and the tax on the employer.

If the tax on the employer is removed, it will depend on the employer. The most likely outcome would be that employers contribute less toward the premium on behalf of their employers, or that they would select leaner benefits (or of course a combination of the two). A surprising number of mid-sized to large employers are quite paternalistic when it comes to health care. Smaller employers often don't have the capital to do the same, they're much more sensitive to the cost overall.

It's possible that some employers would provide a stipend and drop coverage... although that's less feasible as long as ACA is in place. ACA imposes penalties on employers if they drop coverage for their employees. I'm not sure how big exactly, but my vague recollection is that it's substantial enough to make dropping coverage not reasonable in most cases.

If both the employer and the employee tax benefits were removed, it's possible that some employees would turn down their employer coverage and shop on their own... but again it depends a lot on the size of the employer. Most mid and large employers contribute substantially more toward premium on behalf of their employees that the tax would be. In general, it might be more feasible the smaller the employer, and less feasible the larger the employer.

The tax benefit enjoyed by employers and employees with respect to their health care is unlikely to have any material impact on the competitiveness of insurance carriers. I'm sure there are some scenarios that would have this impact, but I can't think of any that make sense.
Most large employers who are trying to attract top employees offer good insurance as a perk; tax incentives are just gravy.
 
It's just so American, insuring healthy work age middle class folks. Part time? Nothing. Wal Mart? A few minimal benefits. Once you get sick you go on disability for 6 months. Six months us up, you are fired. You can buy long term disability insurance. I had it through a professional organization.
 
Last edited:
It appears the Senate has decided to make the house bill worse.

The Senate health care bill, which Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has said will be released on Thursday, will contain optional state waivers of some Affordable Care Act insurance regulations, according to two senior GOP aides. But those waivers may not end up in the final bill — because they could get stripped out for violating Senate budget rules.

Here's why: The Congressional Budget Office has to give its cost estimates for the bill before Republicans can argue their case to the Senate parliamentarian that the waivers should be allowed. (The bill has to comply with Senate budget rules, and she decides whether it does.) And there's a good chance that she'll rule that the waivers, including essential health benefits, have to come out. One of the aides described the parliamentarian as "skeptical."

...

So that means Republicans may only be able to make the ACA's current state waivers more flexible. It's unclear how many members know this, but conservatives — who were pushing to waive even more of the ACA regulations than the House did, or even require states to opt into the regulations rather than out — will surely be disappointed.

If they actually pass this cruel legislation, America could end up voting for single payer in a backlash.
 
I've seen some grumbling on Facebook etc. from various posters that the Senate bill has not been consulted on, debated etc. and has basically been developed 'in secret'.

I'm totally unfamiliar with the US system - does that sound like a valid complaint or is it just people nitpicking the process?
 
I've seen some grumbling on Facebook etc. from various posters that the Senate bill has not been consulted on, debated etc. and has basically been developed 'in secret'.

I'm totally unfamiliar with the US system - does that sound like a valid complaint or is it just people nitpicking the process?

This is completely unprecedented. The ACA was debated for months and had more than a hundred republican amendments added to it.
 
I've seen some grumbling on Facebook etc. from various posters that the Senate bill has not been consulted on, debated etc. and has basically been developed 'in secret'.

I'm totally unfamiliar with the US system - does that sound like a valid complaint or is it just people nitpicking the process?

It's true.

Despite reports Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell is attempting to bring the bill for a vote before the week-long July 4 recess, there remains no public text of any proposed legislation, and therefore no Congressional Budget Office score. There have also been no public hearings on changes made to the House version of the bill.

While a core group of GOP senators is working on the bill, it appears that not all*Senate Republicans even know what could be in it.

McConnell is likely able to keep the bill under wraps until days before a final vote. By all indications that is the path the Republicans will take to try to ensure its passage.

The secretive process has drawn the ire of Democratic lawmakers and activists, who have argued that Republicans attacked Democrats for "backroom deals" on the Affordable Care Act, the law known as*Obamacare, despite that bill getting dozens of hearings and hundreds of amendments from both sides.*
 
I've seen some grumbling on Facebook etc. from various posters that the Senate bill has not been consulted on, debated etc. and has basically been developed 'in secret'.

I'm totally unfamiliar with the US system - does that sound like a valid complaint or is it just people nitpicking the process?

While it is not uncommon for bills to be done in secret, for a bill affecting so many people it is a valid complaint. Also, the Democrats had public debates on the ACA for over 100 days with 133 Republican amendments. Despite this fact, the Republicans lied and complained that it was done in secret and rammed through quickly.
 
I've seen some grumbling on Facebook etc. from various posters that the Senate bill has not been consulted on, debated etc. and has basically been developed 'in secret'.

I'm totally unfamiliar with the US system - does that sound like a valid complaint or is it just people nitpicking the process?

While a lot of what goes on in congress occurs behind "closed doors," the biggest complaint about this process is that the exact same people who are negotiating this one in secret and refusing to have any public hearings were among those who howled the loudest about the "secrecy" of the ACA, despite the fact that it was far, far, FAR more transparent and public than this is.

We have their statements from 2010 complaining. Now they are doing exactly what they complained about, and to an even greater extreme.

Moreover, they have been clear about why. They know if they details of the plan got out, it would be ripped to shreds and lots and lots and lots of people would complain. McConnell's statement about it is, "We aren't stupid."
 
Moreover, they have been clear about why. They know if they details of the plan got out, it would be ripped to shreds and lots and lots and lots of people would complain. McConnell's statement about it is, "We aren't stupid."

IIRC, the statement was from a GOP staffer not McConnell.
 
I've seen some grumbling on Facebook etc. from various posters that the Senate bill has not been consulted on, debated etc. and has basically been developed 'in secret'.

I'm totally unfamiliar with the US system - does that sound like a valid complaint or is it just people nitpicking the process?


The entire purpose of having a "deliberative" body such as our Congress, and the way it was intended, is to deliberate upon the merits of a proposed law. To allow the representatives of the various constituencies to evaluate the bill, consider how it will affect the people they are there to represent, and if needed to propose changes.

Then to decide if they believe that law is in the best interests of the public.

Openly. In full view of the public. So that the actions and behavior of those elected representatives can be judged by their constituencies, And if found wanting those representatives can be held to account at the next election.

That is what the two chambers of Congress are for.

Bypassing the deliberative process, writing bills in secret with only a relative handful having any idea what is in them, intentionally withholding all knowledge of the bill's specific content and wording from everyone else, including those responsible for enacting the law, until the very last possible minute before calling for a vote;

That is the antithesis of the process.

It is more than a "valid complaint".
 
IIRC, the statement was from a GOP staffer not McConnell.


Right.

McConnell's own statements are worse. He says that since it's been talked about for a long time, everybody should already know what's in this bill.

“Look, we’ve been dealing with this issue for seven years,” McConnell tells the New York Times. “It’s not a new thing.” McConnell adds that there have been “gazillions of hearings on this subject” over the years.
Yeah, he thinks the American public is that stupid.

Sadly, all indications are that he might be right about enough of them.
 
I'm totally unfamiliar with the US system - does that sound like a valid complaint or is it just people nitpicking the process?
Senate bills being developed in "secret" used to be common and just how things were done, but it pretty much always involved both sides of the aisle. The argument being that it allowed senators from both sides of the aisle work without having to deal with short term backlash and could make better compromises. That sort of thing ended around the 70s with a push for more transparency.

So this is uncommon for modern times and is also uncommon to exclude the other party entirely.
 
Last edited:
the biggest complaint about this process is that the exact same people who are negotiating this one in secret and refusing to have any public hearings were among those who howled the loudest about the "secrecy" of the ACA,
There is no hypocrisy here. The ACA was created by Democrats, so any complaints were justified.
 
Senate bills being developed in "secret" used to be common and just how things were done, but it pretty much always involved both sides of the aisle. The argument being that it allowed senators from both sides of the aisle work without having to deal with short term backlash and could make better compromises. That sort of thing ended around the 70s with a push for more transparency.

So this is uncommon for modern times and is also uncommon to exclude the other party entirely.


Even then the the final bill itself was not held in secret from the general body of Congresscritters up to almost the very moment of the vote, as is being done here.

They haven't been hiding it just from public comment, they have been hiding it from nearly all the Senators who are supposed to be able to vote on it knowledgeably.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom