Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's not true. Insurance coverage didn't magically change when ACA went into effect.
??? It wasn't magic; it was part of the law. Essential Health Benefits were required of non-grandfathered plans. I don't know how that would affect a plan that offered a $500 :eek: hospital "benefit" though.
 
A while back, my surface read of it didn't seem too bad. High level, it appeared not horrible, and if one had limited understanding of the market place, it could even have seemed like a decent approach. But then you get into the details. And yeah, it sucked. But if you don't get into the details it may not be obvious.

Everyone involved knew is was awful, that was why they couldn't let the CBO analyse it before they voted, they needed to hide just how bad it was. Trump had to realize this, he is far to much of a con man to to know the basics of how the game is played.

He just follows the political winds, his base loved the victory party when it was voted on, now they know how bad it is and he needs to down play it.

The real question is can the senates version be passed by the house fast enough to get it past the CBO with out analysis and so Trump can have the big legislative signing that he really wants. And not just make big deals of nothing memo's.
 
Whoa, Sarah Kliff is pissed.

“The extreme secrecy is a situation without precedent, at least in creating health care law” writes Julie Rovner, who has covered health care politics since 1986 and is arguably the dean of the DC health care press corps.

I don’t have quite as long of a tenure as Rovner, but I have been covering health care politics since Democrats began debating the Affordable Care Act in 2009. It’s become obvious to me, particularly this week, that Republicans plan to move more quickly and less deliberatively than Democrats did in drafting the Affordable Care Act. They intend to do this despite repeatedly and angrily criticizing the Affordable Care Act for being moved too quickly and with too little deliberation.

My biggest concern isn’t the hypocrisy; there is plenty of that in Washington. It’s that the process will lead to devastating results for millions of Americans who won’t know to speak up until the damage is done. So far, the few details that have leaked out paint a picture of a bill sure to cover millions fewer people and raise costs on those with preexisting conditions.

The plan is expected to be far-reaching, potentially bringing lifetime limits back to employer-sponsored coverage, which could mean a death sentence for some chronically ill patients who exhaust their insurance benefits.
 
There isn't going to be a transcript of a private meeting. It sounds like multiple people remembered and recounted the key word:
This is reminding me of Trump blaming the Justice Department for his own executive order. Context was included there because it was a tweet. I hope he was really clear about his AHCA comment, so people like Paul Ryan can get a little more honest with themselves about the president's basic nature. Jeff Sessions too. Maybe put just a tiny bit of air between the tip of their tongues and Trump's rectum.

It's pathetic how badly Trump wants people to like him.
 
A link I posted put the Senate timeline at Sept. 1. It was a columnist from the LA Times - a couple of pages ago depending on how fast this thread is moving. That soothed my alarm some.
 
This is actually a tough nut on the senators. They can pass a repeal now, but their entire re-election will be spent on fixes to this at their home states. Not sure how many senators are up in 2018, but those are the ones wanting to postpone the whole thing past Nov 2018. Congressmen/women are ALL stuck with this in 2018.
 
Congressmen/women are ALL stuck with this in 2018.
Which they're fine with, having gerrymandered a comfortable margin.

Of course, if they go below that margin, every district so gerrymandered will flip to blue, but please don't tell them this. Let them find out on their own.
 
Conservatives complain that the fact that employer health insurance are generally not treated as taxable income distorts the insurance market and reduces incentives to shop for a better deal. Question: Apart from the increased taxes on the recipient, what would be the likely impact of taxing health benefits? Would employers just give people the money and get out of the insurance business? Would employees really be likely to turn down the employer's group insurance to find something else? Would insurers become more competitive? Etc.
 
Conservatives complain that the fact that employer health insurance are generally not treated as taxable income distorts the insurance market and reduces incentives to shop for a better deal. Question: Apart from the increased taxes on the recipient, what would be the likely impact of taxing health benefits? Would employers just give people the money and get out of the insurance business? Would employees really be likely to turn down the employer's group insurance to find something else? Would insurers become more competitive? Etc.
If my medical insurance benefit starts being taxed, I will literally not be able to afford it. I'd obviously be able to use the money I would no longer be spending for insurance on the most basic care but I'd be bankrupted by the most basic procedure, let alone a serious illness or emergency.
 
Conservatives complain that the fact that employer health insurance are generally not treated as taxable income distorts the insurance market and reduces incentives to shop for a better deal. Question: Apart from the increased taxes
You have it backwards. It's taxes that distort the marketplace, not the lack of them. The correct way to solve this problem is remove all income tax.
 
If my medical insurance benefit starts being taxed, I will literally not be able to afford it. I'd obviously be able to use the money I would no longer be spending for insurance on the most basic care but I'd be bankrupted by the most basic procedure, let alone a serious illness or emergency.

I think you've missed the point - the tax would be on the value of the insurance premiums, not the payouts.
 
??? It wasn't magic; it was part of the law. Essential Health Benefits were required of non-grandfathered plans. I don't know how that would affect a plan that offered a $500 :eek: hospital "benefit" though.

Jumping in, I don't know the context of your conversation, exactly, but a story of a woman who was angry about losing her healthcare plan because of Obamacare comes to mind. It was really, really cheap, after all. On inspection, though, it just covered... effectively nothing at all. It was to the point that she even probably couldn't even get back the money that she put in if she needed to use it. Insurance in name only.

Aside from the 80 days that was spent debating the ACA.

[IMGw=640]http://i1070.photobucket.com/albums/u492/rfstack/000000_127.jpg[/IMGw]

That 20 hours for AHCA is now a zero.

...Wow. It gets worse and worse.

This is now worse than Garland, in terms of destroying deliberative process.

Where was that quote from, by the way, and what's the rest of it?

I'll join.

I'd be tempted, but such would depend on what's actually in the party platform.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom