Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
The entire purpose of having a "deliberative" body such as our Congress, and the way it was intended, is to deliberate upon the merits of a proposed law. To allow the representatives of the various constituencies to evaluate the bill, consider how it will affect the people they are there to represent, and if needed to propose changes.

Then to decide if they believe that law is in the best interests of the public.

Openly. In full view of the public. So that the actions and behavior of those elected representatives can be judged by their constituencies, And if found wanting those representatives can be held to account at the next election.

That is what the two chambers of Congress are for.

Bypassing the deliberative process, writing bills in secret with only a relative handful having any idea what is in them, intentionally withholding all knowledge of the bill's specific content and wording from everyone else, including those responsible for enacting the law, until the very last possible minute before calling for a vote;

That is the antithesis of the process.

It is more than a "valid complaint".

On the plus side... maybe these ridiculous shenanigans will get a lot of these idiots out of congress. That would be refreshing. Still pretty pyrrhic though :(
 
...I'm totally unfamiliar with the US system - does that sound like a valid complaint or is it just people nitpicking the process?

Senate bills being developed in "secret" used to be common and just how things were done...

According to Donald Ritchie that's not how things were done. Who is Donald Ritchie?
The level of secrecy in crafting the Senate's health care bill has not been seen since before World War I, according to esteemed Senate historian emeritus Donald Ritchie. Ritchie, who worked in the Senate Historical Office for nearly four decades, told the Los Angeles Times that the upper chamber has not drafted such a major piece of legislation behind closed doors since a tariff reform effort during the presidency of Woodrow Wilson.

He added that Senate Democrats tried the move again during the Great Depression, but they were derailed when rank-and-file senators were unwilling to go along with the maneuver. Link to Time magazine article
 
It's really getting scary.
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has said there is nothing out of the ordinary about the way Republicans are working on the bill to repeal the Affordable Care Act. “Nobody’s hiding the ball here,” he said recently. “You’re free to ask anybody anything.” Link

Not exactly.
The Senate is restricting journalists’ ability to question Republicans about their secret health care bill. Reporters at the U.S. Capitol were shocked to learn on [June 13th] that they’re not allowed to film interviews with senators in the halls of the U.S. Capitol, as they have done for years. Hallway interviews are allowed only if reporters get permission—not only from the senator, but from the Senate Rules Committee as well. Link


 
McConnell is an obscenity in vaguely human form: a smirking, hypocritical, treasonous, and thoroughly corrupt avatar for everything that is wrong with American democracy today; a toxic parasite who should be expelled from the body politic directly into Hell.

Sadly, I catch myself sometimes hoping that he gets his way and that many of the people who keep voting him into office suffer, badly, as a result. That's a terrible thing to wish for.
 
Well the Senate version is out.

On the scale of party in the rose garden to being mean, mean, mean, what do people think Trumps reaction will be?
 
Trump does realize there are tapes of him promising to cover everyone, cut deductibles, and lower premiums? Because this bill doesn't do that. On the other hand if you're making $200,000 a year and can't afford a 3.8% tax on investment income, 14 million people are losing Medicaid to help you.
 
Local news is showing Trump lying again - first about medical and next about the Big Fail Wall. Needs a good enema - will wash the insides out (well, he is completely and clearly full of ****) so he can safely be folded up and hidden with other bad ideas in American History!!!!!!
 
Cruz is holding forth about how he wants insurers to be able to offer "catastrophic" health insurance policies. How is a "catastrophic" policy different from a "high-deductible" policy? Would a catastrophic policy only cover specified maladies (cancer, heart disease, massive trauma)? Or would it cover all medical treatment above a dollar value ($10,000, $25,000, pick a number)?If the insured had to pay before insurance kicked in, presumably he would be charged at the insurance company's negotiated rates, right? Or would he get stuck for the full retail cost?
 
If both the employer and the employee tax benefits were removed, it's possible that some employees would turn down their employer coverage and shop on their own... but again it depends a lot on the size of the employer. Most mid and large employers contribute substantially more toward premium on behalf of their employees that the tax would be. In general, it might be more feasible the smaller the employer, and less feasible the larger the employer.
Are there any, like, actuaries advising Congress? That they pay attention to? You post on this forum, clarify issues in a few paragraphs. IMO it would be helpful for lawmakers to read similar thumbnail overviews. Unless they are not interested, and prefer soundbites to feed their constituents.
 
Are there any, like, actuaries advising Congress? That they pay attention to? You post on this forum, clarify issues in a few paragraphs. IMO it would be helpful for lawmakers to read similar thumbnail overviews. Unless they are not interested, and prefer soundbites to feed their constituents.

The Congressional Budget Office is rather good at crunching numbers and predicting the impact of legislation. On matters of science they have the National Academy of Sciences. For medical issues they have the National Academy of Medicine.

The current Congressional leadership doesn't seem at all interested in getting advice from these sources.
 
Cruz is holding forth about how he wants insurers to be able to offer "catastrophic" health insurance policies. How is a "catastrophic" policy different from a "high-deductible" policy? Would a catastrophic policy only cover specified maladies (cancer, heart disease, massive trauma)? Or would it cover all medical treatment above a dollar value ($10,000, $25,000, pick a number)?If the insured had to pay before insurance kicked in, presumably he would be charged at the insurance company's negotiated rates, right? Or would he get stuck for the full retail cost?

My pre ACA insurance plan had a $5,000 deductible. As long as I used the provider network in the plan, I was charged at the negotiated rate. To give one example, a surgery center charged me $3,500 instead of the list rate of $17,500.

For most American families, the current $7,150 individual and $14,300 family maximum deductibles are basically catastrophic plans. They still include certain cost effective preventive procedures such as vaccinations and birth control at zero additional cost. But these don't add a lot to the cost of the insurance.

A small fraction of the top 1% might be interested in much higher deductibles. (The few that don't have a corporation to pay for their health insurance). But at this income level premiums for a high deductible ACA plan are essentially small change. They could just pay for the cheapest Bronze plan even if they don't intend to use the services.
 
Let's put aside whether the plan is good or not;the way that McConnell is trying to shove it down people's throats stinks on ice.
 
Are there any, like, actuaries advising Congress? That they pay attention to? You post on this forum, clarify issues in a few paragraphs. IMO it would be helpful for lawmakers to read similar thumbnail overviews. Unless they are not interested, and prefer soundbites to feed their constituents.

Prior to ACA, several actuarial organizations provided expert opinion and advice to congress. The didn't really listen very well :(
 
McConnell unveiled the secret healthcare bill yesterday to a decidedly mixed review.
Senate Republicans...unveil[ed] a bill to make deep cuts in Medicaid and end the law’s mandate that most Americans have health insurance. The 142-page bill would create a new system of federal tax credits to help people buy health insurance, while offering states the ability to drop many of the benefits required by the Affordable Care Act, like maternity care, emergency services and mental health treatment.

“We are extremely disappointed by the Senate bill released today,” the medical school association [Association of American Medical Colleges] wrote. “Despite promises to the contrary, it will leave millions of people without health coverage, and others with only bare-bones plans that will be insufficient to properly address their needs.”

Democrats and some insurers say Mr. Trump has sabotaged the Affordable Care Act, in part by threatening to withhold subsidies paid to insurers so they can reduce deductibles and other out-of-pocket costs for millions of low-income people. news link

Four major Republican senators -- Rand Paul of Kentucky, Ted Cruz of Texas, Mike Lee of Utah and Ron Johnson of Wisconsin -- immediately announced they cannot support the bill as written. Even Donnie seems uncomfortable with the billions of dollars in cuts to Medicaid, calling them "mean." Another controversial feature of the Republican program is a prohibition against using federal tax credits to buy healthcare plans that include abortion coverage.

The problem facing Republicans has not changed: How to draft a bill that is extreme enough that Tea Party members will support it, without making it so severe more moderate Republicans will not.
 
Last edited:
The so-called "moderates" who say they are "uncomfortable" with the bill are playing a cynical game. They get to put on a show of standing up for their unhappy constituents and will get some relatively trivial changes which they can say "address their concerns" so they can vote for it. A couple in the most vulnerable places may even be allowed to vote against it, but under no circumstances will more than two GOP senators vote against it, so that that Michael (spit) Pence can cast the deciding vote. The "can't supporters" on the right are don't the same thing, but from a different direction.

All the talk about how they're "concerned" is absolute BS. They don't care about how awful the bill is, they don't care about the rotten and anti-democratic the process is, and they don't care how many of their nominal constituents are going to lose healthcare as a result. The only things they care about are getting their base to vote again for them, even if they are dying of manageable chronic conditions, and giving fat tax breaks to their real constituency, the richest 1% of Americans.
 
Even Donnie seems uncomfortable with the billions of dollars in cuts to Medicaid, calling them "mean."

Meh, whatever he says about something today, he'll say the opposite in the near future. If it seems like the bill will pass then it'll be the best thing ever (as was the House bill a few short weeks ago), if not then it'll be the worst thing ever......
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom