Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think you've missed the point - the tax would be on the value of the insurance premiums, not the payouts.
I pay half my premium every other week, thanks. Why would the company's contribution be subject to taxation while mine isn't?

If such a situation were to occur, the most significant result would be to discourage paying for insurance, either on the part of companies, individuals, or both. It would be a *********** screw job, and don't we already get enough of that from Republicans in Congress?
 
I pay half my premium every other week, thanks. Why would the company's contribution be subject to taxation while mine isn't?
Because the company's contribution is the equivalent of income to you, but is not taxed as income. The payment you are making is from your own income, on which you have already paid taxes.

If such a situation were to occur, the most significant result would be to discourage paying for insurance, either on the part of companies, individuals, or both. It would be a *********** screw job, and don't we already get enough of that from Republicans in Congress?

Employees generally expect -- or at least hope for -- certain benefits from their employers. The impact of taxing the employee for the value of his insurance wouldn't affect the employer at all; the outlay would be the same as if the employer just gave the employee the equivalent amount of cash.

The issue is that people who get insurance from their employer -- which has a value of several thousand dollars a year or more -- have a tax advantage over people who have to buy insurance for themselves out of their after-tax income. If two people make the same salary and pay the same taxes, but one gets $10,000 worth of untaxed health insurance that the other doesn't get, is that fair?

U.S. employer-provided health insurance goes back, as I understand it, to the era of WWII price controls, when employers couldn't offer employees more money but could give them more benefits. In other countries that don't have a National Health-style system, employers aren't in the insurance business, and people contract directly with insurance companies for their coverage. Could that work here?
 
Because the company's contribution is the equivalent of income to you, but is not taxed as income. The payment you are making is from your own income, on which you have already paid taxes.
Wrong. My health insurance premium is taken before assessing income tax. This advantage is equally available to anyone who pays for their own insurance on a completely independent basis because health insurance premiums are tax deductible*.

Again, making premiums taxable will only screw individuals. Increasing taxes on things people pay for does not reduce costs...ever. Now, that doesn't mean that I consider all taxes bad, but this particular tax would be screwing people on something that everyone needs to live a decent life, either now or in the future, because everyone ends up with medical issues.

As far as some people getting more benefits from their employers than others, well, that's the nature of the free market, for better and worse.

Personally, I'd be happier in a single-payer system where health insurance companies would service only those who want to pay premium prices for private health care. In the absence of that, increasing taxes isn't going to increase fairness, it's just going to increase costs and make it harder for more people to pay for their health care. It's a solution to nothing.

*ETA: Apparently, upon reading more on the issue, there are limitations on health insurance premium tax deductions. So, the answer to the unfairness would be to remove/reduce those limitations, not screw over everyone who gets employer contributions to their premiums.
 
Last edited:
Remember when Hillary was criticized for holding health care reform meetings in secret?

Ending Its Secrecy, White House Lists Health-Care Panel
WASHINGTON, March 26— After much criticism of the secrecy surrounding the work of his health policy team, President Clinton today abandoned his effort to conceal the names of more than 500 people who are developing his proposal to guarantee health insurance coverage for all Americans....

Before today, Health Care Reform Week, published by the United Communications Group, and Health Care Policy Report, published weekly by the Bureau of National Affairs, had listed the names of many people working for the task force, which is headed by Hillary Rodham Clinton.
 
As mentioned above, I fail to understand how taxing health insurance benefits can do anything other than screw the employees.

I understand the illusions that free-market people like to pretend are true- the lack of taxes distort the market because consumers currently obtain these health benefits "free" , and if the employee had to pay more directly for their health insurance they would, in the resulting free market, insist on higher quality and lower priced plans.

First- most people obtain health insurance through their jobs. It is the employer who does the negotiating and decides on the insurance plan (or choice of plans) based on the employer's needs (typically the employer seeks to constrain their own costs while still providing some form of health insurance that will not result in an active revolt by the employees). I have a good employer but I have absolutely no choice in terms of what health insurance plans they offer to me. They have more than once completely dropped plans with which I was very happy simply because the negotiated price to them became too high. I had no choice but to switch to one of the plans that they did support, whether I liked it or not. If suddenly I would now have to pay taxes on these benefits, I would still have no influence on which plans were offered to me. The deal between employer and employee in terms of health insurance is pretty much "take it or leave it." And the employees recognize that many employers do not offer any health insurance, or only dreadful health insurance, so they really don't have a super-strong position from which to negotiate. Taxing the benefits wouldn't change this.

As noted above there is already pressure from the employers on the insurance companies to offer plans that are as low cost to the employer as possible, yet good enough to avoid open revolt by the employees. Isn't this what the free-marketers think requires taxes to achieve?

Both employers and employees recognize that the premiums paid by the employers are diverted from money that could have paid salaries, so it is not as if the costs of health insurance premiums by the employer are viewed as invisible; the employees recognize this.

Finally the tax structure is heavily engineered to achieve certain social goals at all levels. It is important to society to encourage people to have health insurance (until we go to a single government-run health care system). Not taxing these benefits is a way to encourage people to buy into health insurance. Just as the US government encourages pre-tax retirement investment (and if you were to ask the free-market financiers how they view implementing taxes on income diverted to 401Ks, you will find that they are not such free-market advocates after all).
 
As mentioned above, I fail to understand how taxing health insurance benefits can do anything other than screw the employees.

I understand the illusions that free-market people like to pretend are true- the lack of taxes distort the market because consumers currently obtain these health benefits "free" , and if the employee had to pay more directly for their health insurance they would, in the resulting free market, insist on higher quality and lower priced plans.

First- most people obtain health insurance through their jobs. It is the employer who does the negotiating and decides on the insurance plan (or choice of plans) based on the employer's needs (typically the employer seeks to constrain their own costs while still providing some form of health insurance that will not result in an active revolt by the employees). I have a good employer but I have absolutely no choice in terms of what health insurance plans they offer to me. They have more than once completely dropped plans with which I was very happy simply because the negotiated price to them became too high. I had no choice but to switch to one of the plans that they did support, whether I liked it or not. If suddenly I would now have to pay taxes on these benefits, I would still have no influence on which plans were offered to me. The deal between employer and employee in terms of health insurance is pretty much "take it or leave it." And the employees recognize that many employers do not offer any health insurance, or only dreadful health insurance, so they really don't have a super-strong position from which to negotiate. Taxing the benefits wouldn't change this.

As noted above there is already pressure from the employers on the insurance companies to offer plans that are as low cost to the employer as possible, yet good enough to avoid open revolt by the employees. Isn't this what the free-marketers think requires taxes to achieve?

Both employers and employees recognize that the premiums paid by the employers are diverted from money that could have paid salaries, so it is not as if the costs of health insurance premiums by the employer are viewed as invisible; the employees recognize this.

Finally the tax structure is heavily engineered to achieve certain social goals at all levels. It is important to society to encourage people to have health insurance (until we go to a single government-run health care system). Not taxing these benefits is a way to encourage people to buy into health insurance. Just as the US government encourages pre-tax retirement investment (and if you were to ask the free-market financiers how they view implementing taxes on income diverted to 401Ks, you will find that they are not such free-market advocates after all).
I don't know but my impression was the tax was only on very high end insurance policies and essentially put a limit on the insurance deduction, that's all.

Your employer pays your health insurance with untaxed wages.
 
I don't know but my impression was the tax was only on very high end insurance policies and essentially put a limit on the insurance deduction, that's all.

Your employer pays your health insurance with untaxed wages.

A lot of ideas have been proposed but let's just focus on proposals to specifically tax contributions to the high end plans. Okay- why should high end plans be discouraged? This is not a free market theory for me but quite personal and real. It is because I paid extra for decades to get the high end plan from among the choices offered by my employer that I alive today without backrupting my family!

The treatments for my neoplasia over the past 5 years probably total well over $500,000. If not for my high end plan, the drugs and copay's would have greatly drained my savings and taken away from the financial security that my family will have when I do die. Wasn't it the smart thing for me to do to get this better plan rather than the cheaper plans with which my costs now would be much greater? Probably so much greater that I would have had to choose between my family's financial security and the treatments I could afford! And would it have made more sense if the government discouraged me from doing so by making it even more expensive for me to pay the extra premiums?

We are not discussing spending huge sums just to keep an unconscious person alive a few more weeks. My access to very expensive but very effective drugs and treatments have kept me very functional with a great quality of life for 5 years. And with luck, for years more. And my access depended on having a very good health insurance plan. High end plans are not luxuries- they are crucial if one is unlucky enough to have a very serious illness or accident. But of course better still would be everyone having this kind of access- not just people like me with a good employer and enough salary to pay the extra remiums.

Better insurance should be encouraged; not discouraged.
 
Last edited:
A lot of ideas have been proposed but let's just focus on proposals to specifically tax contributions to the high end plans. Okay- why should high end plans be discouraged? This is not a free market theory for me but quite personal and real. It is because I paid extra for decades to get the high end plan from among the choices offered by my employer that I alive today without backrupting my family!

The treatments for my neoplasia over the past 5 years probably total well over $500,000. If not for my high end plan, the drugs and copay's would have greatly drained my savings and taken away from the financial security that my family will have when I do die. Wasn't it the smart thing for me to do to get this better plan rather than the cheaper plans with which my costs now would be much greater? Probably so much greater that I would have had to choose between my family's financial security and the treatments I could afford! And would it have made more sense if the government discouraged me from doing so by making it even more expensive for me to pay the extra premiums?

We are not discussing spending huge sums just to keep an unconscious person alive a few more weeks. My access to very expensive but very effective drugs and treatments have kept me very functional with a great quality of life for 5 years. And with luck, for years more. And my access depended on having a very good health insurance plan. High end plans are not luxuries- they are crucial if one is unlucky enough to have a very serious illness or accident. But of course better still would be everyone having this kind of access- not just people like me with a good employer and enough salary to pay the extra remiums.

Better insurance should be encouraged; not discouraged.
You missed my only point and addressed a whole bunch of stuff my point had nothing to do with.

Of course high end plans are a luxury. I know some medical practices that cater to such clients with personal on-call physicians that make house calls among other things.

But even if they weren't, putting a limit on a tax deduction is the only point. If you make millions, why do you need a bigger tax break on your health insurance premiums than the little guy?

I don't get to deduct my actual medical costs, I only get to deduct the premiums no matter the proportion that is copays and deductibles. Give me a tax break on those medical expenses and you might have a point.


BTW, the ACA was supposed to address that issue of very expensive care so I'm not sure why you fall into a high-end policy. Not to mention ending lifetime caps, why do you not have a plan with a maximum out of pocket expense?
 
Last edited:
Employees generally expect -- or at least hope for -- certain benefits from their employers.
That is less and less the case, or at least it seems that way to me. The "gig economy" involves many younger people willing to work with no benefits, but the model also applies somewhat to underemployed boomers such as myself.

My insurance is not cheap but at least it's portable. Thanks, Obama.

If Obama had presented the Affordable Health Care Act to Congress in 2009, would Republicans have voted for it?
 
That is less and less the case, or at least it seems that way to me. The "gig economy" involves many younger people willing to work with no benefits, but the model also applies somewhat to underemployed boomers such as myself.

My insurance is not cheap but at least it's portable. Thanks, Obama.

If Obama had presented the Affordable Health Care Act to Congress in 2009, would Republicans have voted for it?


Republicans were not going to vote for anything Obama presented. From the day he was elected. No matter what it was. They said as much.

Not even if they liked it.

Not even if it was their idea.

Not even if it would save the country.

Obama couldn't be allowed to get anything done.

And if it was something good or useful that just made it worse in their view.
 
You missed my only point and addressed a whole bunch of stuff my point had nothing to do with.

Of course high end plans are a luxury. I know some medical practices that cater to such clients with personal on-call physicians that make house calls among other things.

But even if they weren't, putting a limit on a tax deduction is the only point. If you make millions, why do you need a bigger tax break on your health insurance premiums than the little guy?

I don't get to deduct my actual medical costs, I only get to deduct the premiums no matter the proportion that is copays and deductibles. Give me a tax break on those medical expenses and you might have a point.


BTW, the ACA was supposed to address that issue of very expensive care so I'm not sure why you fall into a high-end policy. Not to mention ending lifetime caps, why do you not have a plan with a maximum out of pocket expense?

High end plans should not be a luxury. Cosmetic plans should be a luxury. Plans that offer more hospital rooms with more features should be a luxury. Something that avoids bankruptcy in the case of life-saving medical treatment should not be considered a luxury.
 
A lot of ideas have been proposed but let's just focus on proposals to specifically tax contributions to the high end plans. Okay- why should high end plans be discouraged?

I'm not sure the "high end plan" that you describe would even trigger the tax provisions. I know my plan doesn't, and if I happened to have a condition that cost $100,000 per year to treat, I would pay my premium plus a $6,000 out of pocket family maximum for all my family's health care. It wouldn't bankrupt me. That out of pocket cost would be very inconvenient, but nothing more.

If my company offered a plan with a lower deductible and a lower out of pocket maximum, it still wouldn't trigger the tax provisions for "high end" plans.

As I understand it, and someone can correct me if I'm wrong, the real problem with the "Cadillac" plans that are the targets of the law is that they are putting in lots of things that don't really qualify as medically necessary aspects of treatment, or maybe not even as "health care" at all (e.g. gym memberships), but doing it with tax deductible dollars. It's a way of providing employees, usually executives and other highly paid employees, some additional compensation but doing it in a way the government will pick up part of the tab.

I don't have an opinion on whether that's a good idea or a bad idea, honestly. I haven't studied it enough to know. However, the basic concept fo the tax makes sense to me. I just don't know whether the specific implementations actually achieve the goal.

My real opinion on the subject is that employers should have absolutely nothing at all to do with health care, but that's too entrenched in America to get rid of it.
 
Last edited:
You missed my only point and addressed a whole bunch of stuff my point had nothing to do with.

Of course high end plans are a luxury. I know some medical practices that cater to such clients with personal on-call physicians that make house calls among other things.

But even if they weren't, putting a limit on a tax deduction is the only point. If you make millions, why do you need a bigger tax break on your health insurance premiums than the little guy?

I don't get to deduct my actual medical costs, I only get to deduct the premiums no matter the proportion that is copays and deductibles. Give me a tax break on those medical expenses and you might have a point.


BTW, the ACA was supposed to address that issue of very expensive care so I'm not sure why you fall into a high-end policy. Not to mention ending lifetime caps, why do you not have a plan with a maximum out of pocket expense?

We appear to be missing each other's point.

My point was that "high end health care plans" are not necessarily, or even typically, luxury plans. My own "high end" plan (with the extra premiums paid by me, although per tax) pays enough benefits to allow me access to treatments that I could not have afforded if I had enrolled in a cheaper plan. No massages. No on call physicians. No spa-like hospital rooms. But it did pay most of the cost of a bone marrow transplant, and most of the cost of some of the very expensive drugs I've been taking. Whereas my costs would have been much higher, most likely impossibly higher, had I a cheaper plan.

I don't view being kept alive without financially damaging my family as luxury. If you specifically wish to target for taxation the "true" luxury plans (I haven't seen one but I'll accept you have) that are over the top spa-like hospital suites and personal doctors, okay then let's be more specific than lumping all "high end" plans into one category. I do not see how one is easily going to be able to make the distinction when drafting the rules, but let's assume we can. But I do have some dismal news for you: mortgage paid on a 1 million dollar home is just as deductible as mortgage paid on a 50 thousand dollar home, so if your argument is that the rich should not have their over-the-top life style subsidized by tax deductions beyond that available to. the poor or middle class- I agree with you, but you have a lot of tax code to revisit.

Some other parts of your response confuse me. You argue that if "you" make millions why do "you" need a bigger tax break on "your" health insurance than the little guy? I was discussing not my income per se (which is far short of millions) but what I (and my employer) pay extra for my better health care plan. Isn't that what we are discussing taxing? And if I was wealthy wouldn't it be easier for me to pay the extra tax, versus someone middle class such as myself who had to struggle just to pay the extra premiums without the proposed extra taxes to get the plan that is keeping me alive? The proposal we are discussing is to tax health insurance benefits and this appears to me to be an inherently retrogressive tax- the extra cost of enrolling in the same better ("high end") plan is the same for the poor or rich, but will this extra cost (and being taxed on it) will impact the overall finances of the poor much more than the wealthy (I don't think the different tax brackets would make a big difference here- plus remember how many wealthy have very low adjusted incomes).

I was also confused by your statement you cannot deduct medical costs. In the USA anyone can deduct medical costs over 7.5 to 10% (depends on the year) of their salary. This has the added benefit of putting a higher burden on the wealthy versus the poor. Are you just suggesting that the threshold should be set lower?

Finally- I do have a plan with maximum out of pocket expenses- which are at a level that has helped in certain years. Less high-end plans generally have a much greater max. And shall we discuss the many low-end plans that had a maximum life-time cap on pay out before Obamacare? "Sorry, I know you desperately need this treatment but you've maxed out your benefits. Tough luck." Do we know what the Republican/Trumpcare plan proposes as to that? From what I can gather, given the secrecy, by leaving issues like that to the States, it is quite likely that year and life-time payouts caps will be re-imposed by insurers, at least in certain States. Sounds great for someone like me- "We are done with you- you are just too expensive to keep alive""
 
Last edited:
High end plans should not be a luxury. Cosmetic plans should be a luxury. Plans that offer more hospital rooms with more features should be a luxury. Something that avoids bankruptcy in the case of life-saving medical treatment should not be considered a luxury.

This^
 
I'm not sure the "high end plan" that you describe would even trigger the tax provisions. I know my plan doesn't, and if I happened to have a condition that cost $100,000 per year to treat, I would pay my premium plus a $6,000 out of pocket family maximum for all my family's health care. It wouldn't bankrupt me. That out of pocket cost would be very inconvenient, but nothing more.

If my company offered a plan with a lower deductible and a lower out of pocket maximum, it still wouldn't trigger the tax provisions for "high end" plans.

As I understand it, and someone can correct me if I'm wrong, the real problem with the "Cadillac" plans that are the targets of the law is that they are putting in lots of things that don't really qualify as medically necessary aspects of treatment, or maybe not even as "health care" at all (e.g. gym memberships), but doing it with tax deductible dollars. It's a way of providing employees, usually executives and other highly paid employees, some additional compensation but doing it in a way the government will pick up part of the tab.

I don't have an opinion on whether that's a good idea or a bad idea, honestly. I haven't studied it enough to know. However, the basic concept fo the tax makes sense to me. I just don't know whether the specific implementations actually achieve the goal.

My real opinion on the subject is that employers should have absolutely nothing at all to do with health care, but that's too entrenched in America to get rid of it.

I don't disagree. I think the issue is what exactly are we discussing when we allude to taxing "luxury" health insurance plans. And in my discussions with Skeptic Ginger it still remains unclear to me. I do not have a problem with the current rules. It was my impression that we were discussing changing the rules to consider all health benefits as taxable income, as has been proposed by the free-market conservatives.
 
Last edited:

Neither should income I use on health care outside of premiums be taxed but they are.

Cadillac Insurance Plan
As most Cadillac plans are sponsored by employers, economists generally believe that the widespread availability of these plans is at least partially attributable to the tax-advantaged status that employer-sponsored health plans currently have. Employer-sponsored health insurance is considered part of the employees' compensation package, but is not taxed as wages. This is thought to be essentially a government subsidy that encourages employers to offer, and employees to enroll in, more expensive plans that cover more of the cost of medical care, and then the employees use that subsidized medical care excessively because they are insulated from its full cost, according to some commenters.[5]
There are other views in the link.

This is the point of the tax (which BTW doesn't kick in until 2020):
The tax is intended to do three things: help finance the PPACA; reduce overall health care costs; and address the unequal tax benefit of excluding employer-based health insurance coverage from taxes.[9]

I see no reason the planned tax (which insurers pay) cannot be further evaluated and the problems addressed by 2020, that is if the GOP doesn't gut the ACA in order to cut federal payments to Medicaid so that millionaires can have additional tax cuts.


This is a more important issue:

Was Medicaid real target of Trumpcare?
The law would limit federal spending on Medicaid — the program that provides health insurance to the poor — to an index of inflation in medical prices. Since the program’s costs are increasing more rapidly than that index, over time, the government would spend hundreds of billions of less on Medicaid than it would under the current system. It would be up to states to decide how to make up the difference.

And the collateral damage: A Little-Noticed Target in the House Health Bill: Special Education
With all the sweeping changes the Republican bill would impose, little attention has been paid to its potential impact on education. School districts rely on Medicaid, the federal health care program for the poor, to provide costly services to millions of students with disabilities across the country. For nearly 30 years, Medicaid has helped school systems cover costs for special education services and equipment, from physical therapists to feeding tubes. The money is also used to provide preventive care, such as vision and hearing screenings, for other Medicaid-eligible children.

The Republican health-care bill threatens Trump's voters
The House bill would also produce major reductions in spending on Medicaid, the expansion of which generated a large proportion of Obamacare's gains in insurance coverage. ...

Medicaid has long been a target of Republican budget cutters, both because the party favors smaller government and because it provides health care to poor Americans who tend to support Democrats. Nationally, most Medicaid enrollees are nonwhite.
 
Wrong. My health insurance premium is taken before assessing income tax. This advantage is equally available to anyone who pays for their own insurance on a completely independent basis because health insurance premiums are tax deductible*.
.....

*ETA: Apparently, upon reading more on the issue, there are limitations on health insurance premium tax deductions. So, the answer to the unfairness would be to remove/reduce those limitations, not screw over everyone who gets employer contributions to their premiums.

As you note, health insurance premiums are deductible only to specific degrees in specific circumstances. More important, the large majority of taxpayers take the standard deduction, so they don't benefit at all now and wouldn't be likely to benefit from any changes in deductions. And a deduction is only worth your tax rate; in other words, if you take a $10,000 deduction and you are in the 25% tax bracket, your taxes are reduced by $2500. But you actually spent the whole $10,000 out-of-pocket. That's different from getting a $10,000 benefit that you pay no taxes on.
http://www.healthedeals.com/articles/are-health-insurance-premiums-deductible

The broader question is whether something of value given to you by your employer should be taxed as income. In general, you pay taxes on things like free rent or a company car; why should health insurance be treated differently? To what degree does it distort both the insurance and employment markets? It's a fair subject for discussion.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom