You missed my only point and addressed a whole bunch of stuff my point had nothing to do with.
Of course high end plans are a luxury. I know some medical practices that cater to such clients with personal on-call physicians that make house calls among other things.
But even if they weren't, putting a limit on a tax deduction is the only point. If you make millions, why do you need a bigger tax break on your health insurance premiums than the little guy?
I don't get to deduct my actual medical costs, I only get to deduct the premiums no matter the proportion that is copays and deductibles. Give me a tax break on those medical expenses and you might have a point.
BTW, the ACA was supposed to address that issue of very expensive care so I'm not sure why you fall into a high-end policy. Not to mention ending lifetime caps, why do you not have a plan with a maximum out of pocket expense?
We appear to be missing each other's point.
My point was that "high end health care plans" are not necessarily, or even typically, luxury plans. My own "high end" plan (with the extra premiums paid by me, although per tax) pays enough benefits to allow me access to treatments that I could not have afforded if I had enrolled in a cheaper plan. No massages. No on call physicians. No spa-like hospital rooms. But it did pay most of the cost of a bone marrow transplant, and most of the cost of some of the very expensive drugs I've been taking. Whereas my costs would have been much higher, most likely impossibly higher, had I a cheaper plan.
I don't view being kept alive without financially damaging my family as luxury. If you specifically wish to target for taxation the "true" luxury plans (I haven't seen one but I'll accept you have) that are over the top spa-like hospital suites and personal doctors, okay then let's be more specific than lumping all "high end" plans into one category. I do not see how one is easily going to be able to make the distinction when drafting the rules, but let's assume we can. But I do have some dismal news for you: mortgage paid on a 1 million dollar home is just as deductible as mortgage paid on a 50 thousand dollar home, so if your argument is that the rich should not have their over-the-top life style subsidized by tax deductions beyond that available to. the poor or middle class- I agree with you, but you have a lot of tax code to revisit.
Some other parts of your response confuse me. You argue that if "you" make millions why do "you" need a bigger tax break on "your" health insurance than the little guy? I was discussing not my income per se (which is far short of millions) but what I (and my employer) pay extra for my better health care plan. Isn't that what we are discussing taxing? And if I
was wealthy wouldn't it be easier for me to pay the extra tax, versus someone middle class such as myself who had to struggle just to pay the extra premiums without the proposed extra taxes to get the plan that is keeping me alive? The proposal we are discussing is to tax health insurance benefits and this appears to me to be an inherently retrogressive tax- the extra cost of enrolling in the same better ("high end") plan is the same for the poor or rich, but will this extra cost (and being taxed on it) will impact the overall finances of the poor much more than the wealthy (I don't think the different tax brackets would make a big difference here- plus remember how many wealthy have very low adjusted incomes).
I was also confused by your statement you cannot deduct medical costs. In the USA anyone can deduct medical costs over 7.5 to 10% (depends on the year) of their salary. This has the added benefit of putting a higher burden on the wealthy versus the poor. Are you just suggesting that the threshold should be set lower?
Finally- I do have a plan with maximum out of pocket expenses- which are at a level that has helped in certain years. Less high-end plans generally have a much greater max. And shall we discuss the many low-end plans that had a maximum life-time cap on pay out before Obamacare? "Sorry, I know you desperately need this treatment but you've maxed out your benefits. Tough luck." Do we know what the Republican/Trumpcare plan proposes as to that? From what I can gather, given the secrecy, by leaving issues like that to the States, it is quite likely that year and life-time payouts caps will be re-imposed by insurers, at least in certain States. Sounds great for someone like me- "We are done with you- you are just too expensive to keep alive""