Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
The so-called "moderates" who say they are "uncomfortable" with the bill are playing a cynical game. They get to put on a show of standing up for their unhappy constituents and will get some relatively trivial changes which they can say "address their concerns" so they can vote for it. A couple in the most vulnerable places may even be allowed to vote against it, but under no circumstances will more than two GOP senators vote against it, so that that Michael (spit) Pence can cast the deciding vote. The "can't supporters" on the right are don't the same thing, but from a different direction.

All the talk about how they're "concerned" is absolute BS. They don't care about how awful the bill is, they don't care about the rotten and anti-democratic the process is, and they don't care how many of their nominal constituents are going to lose healthcare as a result. The only things they care about are getting their base to vote again for them, even if they are dying of manageable chronic conditions, and giving fat tax breaks to their real constituency, the richest 1% of Americans.

I tend to agree with this. The GOP are nothing if not well marshaled. :mad:
 
The Times has outlined the winners of the wealthcare bill.

Who benefits? It’s all about the tax cuts, almost half of which will go to people with incomes over $1 million, the great bulk to people with incomes over 200K.

So, is this bill good for you? Yes, if you meet the following criteria:

1.Your income is more than $200,000 a year
2.You have a job that comes with good health insurance
3.You can’t imagine any circumstances under which you lose that job or income
4.You don’t have any family members or friends who don’t meet those criteria
5.You have zero empathy for anyone else

I don't understand the GOP's intense desire to pass this bill since the voters they added to win in November are going to be harmed the most by it.
 
I don't understand the GOP's intense desire to pass this bill since the voters they added to win in November are going to be harmed the most by it.

Their desire to pass this is driven by their need to repeal the ACA. They have to repeal quickly because they've said time and again how bad it is and how it's going to collapse under its own weight but it's becoming more and more popular so they have to do it before it becomes un-repealable.

In order to repeal they have to offer an alternative and it seems that the current bill may be able to pass the Senate and then they may be able to crowbar it back through the House. That will be a campaign promise fulfilled.

Of course tens of millions will be worse off and millions will lose their healthcare altogether but that's fine because many (if not most) of those people who voted GOP but who will suffer under this bill:

  • Won't be hurt immediately - so the pain can be blamed on later administrations
  • Will not connect their suffering to the ACA repeal and instead it will be put down to something else
  • Will think they're better off even if they are paying more and/or have more or less worthless coverage
  • Will think it's good regardless because the GOP did it
 
Their desire to pass this is driven by their need to repeal the ACA. They have to repeal quickly because they've said time and again how bad it is and how it's going to collapse under its own weight but it's becoming more and more popular so they have to do it before it becomes un-repealable.

In order to repeal they have to offer an alternative and it seems that the current bill may be able to pass the Senate and then they may be able to crowbar it back through the House. That will be a campaign promise fulfilled.

Of course tens of millions will be worse off and millions will lose their healthcare altogether but that's fine because many (if not most) of those people who voted GOP but who will suffer under this bill:

  • Won't be hurt immediately - so the pain can be blamed on later administrations
  • Will not connect their suffering to the ACA repeal and instead it will be put down to something else
  • Will think they're better off even if they are paying more and/or have more or less worthless coverage
  • Will think it's good regardless because the GOP did it


they probably will be paying less - until they need the insurance. My understanding is that a lot of the plans that were lost under the ACA were pretty worthless
 
The Times has outlined the winners of the wealthcare bill.



I don't understand the GOP's intense desire to pass this bill since the voters they added to win in November are going to be harmed the most by it.

If I put my 'politician' hat on, I can see a roadmap that includes misrepresenting the content of the bill to constituents through expensive and sophisticated information campaigns.

Deny there are any tax cuts.
Emphasize that they've protected Americans from Death Panels.

Not working? Get maskirovka help from the Kremlin. Kushner has them on speed dial.
 
McConnell unveiled the secret healthcare bill yesterday to a decidedly mixed review.


Four major Republican senators -- Rand Paul of Kentucky, Ted Cruz of Texas, Mike Lee of Utah and Ron Johnson of Wisconsin -- immediately announced they cannot support the bill as written. Even Donnie seems uncomfortable with the billions of dollars in cuts to Medicaid, calling them "mean." Another controversial feature of the Republican program is a prohibition against using federal tax credits to buy healthcare plans that include abortion coverage.

The problem facing Republicans has not changed: How to draft a bill that is extreme enough that Tea Party members will support it, without making it so severe more moderate Republicans will not.

If you were depending on any of those four to vote no for deciding vote, you're going to be disappointed. However, in a crushing blow for the bill, Dean Heller has come out as a no. The GOP can only lose one more and pass it which is a problem with moderates Lisa Murkowski and Susan Collins already signalling they're already most likely nos.
 
If you were depending on any of those four to vote no for deciding vote, you're going to be disappointed. However, in a crushing blow for the bill, Dean Heller has come out as a no. The GOP can only lose one more and pass it which is a problem with moderates Lisa Murkowski and Susan Collins already signalling they're already most likely nos.

I've said it repeatedly, I'll believe it when I see it.

Like as not it will turn out as sts60 suggested it will in another thread:

Some minor concessions will be made, or at least be seen to be made so that some senators can loudly proclaim that they have worked hard in the interests of their constituents (and pass a bill that will screw them over) and up two GOP senators will be allowed to dissent with the Vice President breaking the tie if needs be. :mad:
 
Yep. Murkowski and Collins in particular keep repeating this bit of pretend political courage, orchestrated by one of the worst Americans ever to infest Congress, Mitch (spit) McConnell. No one should ever fall for it again, but somehow we keep seeing the same breathless stories about how certain Senators - usually including but not limited to those two - are concerned and "can't vote for the bill in its present form".
 
Yep. Murkowski and Collins in particular keep repeating this bit of pretend political courage, orchestrated by one of the worst Americans ever to infest Congress, Mitch (spit) McConnell. No one should ever fall for it again, but somehow we keep seeing the same breathless stories about how certain Senators - usually including but not limited to those two - are concerned and "can't vote for the bill in its present form".

Murkowski has stated that defunding Planned Parenthood is a nonstarter for her so that needs to come out before she'll support the bill in any form. Removing the defunding of Planned Parenthood might cause them to lose the support of Christian supremacists Lee and/or Cruz. This blindside from Heller might actually cause the bill to at least be debated in the Senate in order for the Republicans to figure out which two purple state Senators are going to get the seat saving no votes.
 
I think the above posts, most of them, are pretty realistic, and they also make a broader point. That for healthcare, as for many other programs, Republican politicians are concerned most of all with what's best for the Republican Party. The American people come in a distant second. I know the obvious (partisan) counter to this is to respond, "Yes they're just like Democrats!" but I really don't see that's true to the same extent.

There's been a number of Democratic politicians who have worked pretty hard over the past two decades to try and gain greater access to healthcare for more Americans. To try and end the situation where many people do not have a primary care doctor, and can only get health services (public) when they become too sick to turn away.
 
Passing an atrocious bill and having the main effects take place after 2020, well isn't that special. They get to pretend they replaced the ACA while making sure the negative consequences will be blamed on the Democratic administration which is sure to replace Trump if Trump runs for a second term.

Ron Paul of the libertarian four who claim the can't support the bill couldn't keep a straight face saying he would vote against the bill as is, but hint hint, give him something in return and he will. :rolleyes:

And Susan Collins, as middle of the aisle as she seems is also easily manipulated by her GOP colleagues. She doesn't sound like she has the guts to vote against the Wealthcare Act. We're doomed.
 
Murkowski has stated that defunding Planned Parenthood is a nonstarter for her so that needs to come out before she'll support the bill in any form. Removing the defunding of Planned Parenthood might cause them to lose the support of Christian supremacists Lee and/or Cruz. This blindside from Heller might actually cause the bill to at least be debated in the Senate in order for the Republicans to figure out which two purple state Senators are going to get the seat saving no votes.

Ah, but they only defunded it for one year. :boggled: Or something like that.
 
Passing an atrocious bill and having the main effects take place after 2020, well isn't that special. They get to pretend they replaced the ACA while making sure the negative consequences will be blamed on the Democratic administration which is sure to replace Trump if Trump runs for a second term.

I think that makes the wealthcare bill a central issue of the 2020 election since if you elect a Democratic congress and President those cuts could be stopped.
 
Prior to ACA, several actuarial organizations provided expert opinion and advice to congress. The didn't really listen very well :(

Can you name the groups you're referring to and what advice and/or changes they recommended that were not listened to? More importantly, who exactly wasn't listening?

This group is a 19,000 member actuary group (link) and this is from their website:
  • Although the ACA has dramatically reduced uninsured rates, enrollment in the individual market has been lower than initially expected and enrollees have been less healthy than expected.
  • The uncertain and changing regulatory environment—including legal challenges to the ACA, allowing individuals to retain pre-ACA coverage, and constraints on risk corridor payments—contributed to adverse experience among insurers. As a result of these and other factors, insurer participation and consumer plan choice declined in 2016 and is declining further in 2017.
  • In recent years, health care spending has been growing relatively slowly compared with historical averages, but there are signs that growth rates are increasing.
 
Last edited:
That for healthcare, as for many other programs, Republican politicians are concerned most of all with what's best for the Republican Party. The American people come in a distant second.
I doubt if the "American people" are that high on the priority list.

I really don't know what Republican politicians are thinking. Few people/interest groups seem to actually like this bill. In some ways I'd rather see a straight-up repeal of the ACA. At least that wouldn't foster the illusion that the GOP did something constructive.
 
Last edited:
This is from a business analysis regarding large managed care companies. Apparently they've been crying "wolf!":
“If Obamacare has been bad for the managed care stocks, why have they performed so well under it?” asked Paul Hickey, a founder of Bespoke Investment Group. “And do they really need to be rescued by Congress?” The answers are complex but boil down to this: Basically, several analysts on Wall Street and in Washington said, the underlying businesses of the big managed care companies have actually done extremely well under Obamacare. They have run into some problems but are hardly in need of a rescue. Link
 
Having picked the policy of being against the ACA to define the party they've pretty much trapped themselves.

Simply repealing the ACA would be a better position. The AHCA does more which is cruel. This is a massive tax cut at the expense of Medicaid recipients.

[IMGw=640]http://i1070.photobucket.com/albums/u492/rfstack/000000_131.jpg[/IMGw]

The Senate bill’s tax cuts for the richest 400 families are the equivalent of ending Medicaid expansion in Alaska, Arkansas, Nevada and WV.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom