Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
For some of them, it's probably just a way of signalling they need some pork added in order to get their nod.

Sent from my SM-J327P using Tapatalk
 
Here's what he promised even after he was elected:
"We’re going to have insurance for everybody,” Trump told The Washington Post’s Robert Costa and Amy Goldstein during an interview less than a week before his inauguration...The plan would have “lower numbers, much lower deductibles.”...What’s more, people could “expect to have great health care” that would be “in a much simplified form. Much less expensive and much better.” Link

This is Atlantic City all over again. Only now he's doing it to the whole country. :(
 
Wisconsin holdout can be lumped with Cruz abd Rand Paul. They want to deny sick people insurance:
Johnson raised his concerns about Medicaid funding levels with President Donald Trump at a White House meeting with other lawmakers last week. His other major beef is that the bill won’t do enough to reduce premiums — a chief complaint among Cruz, Lee and Paul. They would like the bill to repeal Obamacare’s requirement that insurance companies accept everyone regardless of a pre-existing condition — a political non-starter with many other Republicans. The Senate conservatives say there are other ways to protect people with medical problems, such as high-risk pools.

“The primary driver of premium increases is guaranteed issue,” Johnson said, referring to the Obamacare protection for pre-existing conditions. “We really should be talking about providing individuals the freedom to purchase the kind of health care products they want to buy not being dictated by the federal government.”

http://www.politico.com/story/2017/06/24/ron-johnson-gop-senate-health-care-bill-239922
 
Will the GOP ever understand the mistake they're making? They are taking health care away from sick people. Kind of like taking food from hungry children: It does not take a lot of explaining; the reality can be captured in one sentence. Congress seems oblivious to any connection to even their own electorate. Constituents aren't clamoring for the passage of the AHCA and I doubt many are clamoring to repeal the AHA. The anti-Obama impetus has largely run out of steam and the advantages to having everyone insured are gradually sinking in with the health care industry. Cut access to health care and you cut health-care jobs.

So who exactly is Congress hoping to please with their health-care bill? "The rich" is a facile answer and doesn't explain much. Politicians have the whole tax reform issue coming up to craft cuts. To do this in the guise of a replacement bill that is literally worse than nothing seems horribly misguided. Congressional leadership has bent over backwards to keep people from learning the bill's impact, hoping that ideally no one even reads the damn thing. Trump certainly won't, and no one in his administration seems likely to take the time or effort to brief him on this measure's toxic potential. Maybe he can feel like a big boy by vetoing it. I don't think it jibes with what he wants in his heart of hearts. He wants to be liked. How will that go down in coal country? Double whammy: The jobs aren't coming back and now your health insurance is gone. Who benefits? The rich, kind of, but that doesn't explain the House and Senate's desperate rush.

How is this even good for the insurance industry? I'm likely to be one of those appeased, an underemployed baby boomer with a pre-existing condition. I'm a captive consumer, unless I just decide to take my chances while waiting for Medicare to kick in. But how are insurers going to react to losing healthier, younger customers in droves?

Leadership has to know all of this.
 
https://www.vox.com/platform/amp/2017/6/24/15867614/senate-health-waiting-period

Apparently the GOP's reaction to criticism of the bill is to make it worse. They're now considering adding a provision that would lock customers out of the individual market for six months if they fail to maintain continuous insurance coverage.
Which may not pass the Byrd Rule. Byrd is on everybody's lips these days, I've heard. One might almost say ...

But of course I won't.

I read that piece, and followed up on the Senate Parliamentarian (who knew?), and was reminded why Democracy is such a hard sell in parts not already blessed with it. In principle it sounds great : people decide on who governs them, they govern, and if they don't do it well people replace them. Fine, people say, but how does that work in practice? Well, take the Byrd Rule for example ...
 
For clarity : are the AHA and the expansion of Medicare separate issues? I get that impression from Stacko's post

Simply repealing the ACA would be a better position. The AHCA does more which is cruel. This is a massive tax cut at the expense of Medicaid recipients.

I had assumed they were a package.
 
https://www.vox.com/platform/amp/2017/6/24/15867614/senate-health-waiting-period

Apparently the GOP's reaction to criticism of the bill is to make it worse. They're now considering adding a provision that would lock customers out of the individual market for six months if they fail to maintain continuous insurance coverage.
An interesting concept, it's not OK to fine you for not carrying health insurance, as an incentive.

But it is OK to threaten you with not being able to get insurance for 6 months as an incentive.
 
An interesting concept, it's not OK to fine you for not carrying health insurance, as an incentive.
That is an imposition on you by the state.

But it is OK to threaten you with not being able to get insurance for 6 months as an incentive.
You can still get insurance, just not under advantageous terms. That is removing an imposition by the state on insurance companies.

Very different things.
 
You can still get insurance, just not under advantageous terms. That is removing an imposition by the state on insurance companies.

Very different things.

Nope, you can't use the individual market so it's employer insurance or if you qualify Medicaid. They would be barred for six months from purchasing a plan for themselves. It's cruel solution to the problem of healthy people only buying insurance once they get sick.
 
For clarity : are the AHA and the expansion of Medicare separate issues? I get that impression from Stacko's post



I had assumed they were a package.
They came as a package but there's nothing stopping them from separating them. Well tax cuts for the rich and a desire to cut Medicaid to the bone are a reason but most first world countries view denying access to healthcare to citizens in order to enrich the top 1% as a bad thing. 'Murica!
 
That is an imposition on you by the state.

You can still get insurance, just not under advantageous terms. That is removing an imposition by the state on insurance companies.

Very different things.
So the six month wait is not imposed via the state? :rolleyes:
 
Nope, you can't use the individual market so it's employer insurance or if you qualify Medicaid. They would be barred for six months from purchasing a plan for themselves. It's cruel solution to the problem of healthy people only buying insurance once they get sick.

It's also the original method the ACA was trying to improve on. If insurers are mandated to cover pre-existing conditions, it doesn't work to let people wait to get insurance only after they need it.

I doubt a 6 month wait will meet the insurer's needs, thereby leading to a smaller pool and skyrocketing premiums as we all have to cover pre-existing conditions while the burden is not evenly shared.
 
Well, yeah, but it's not being imposed on anyone important, like the insurance companies.

That's just a fallacy. It's not the insurance companies themselves that are important, it's the richest shareholders who are important. If those people could make even more money by destroying the companies, and the entire industry, then we'd certainly see a healthcare bill to do just that.
 
That is an imposition on you by the state.

You can still get insurance, just not under advantageous terms. That is removing an imposition by the state on insurance companies.

Very different things.

Yes one punishes you when you are doing the wrong thing, the other punishes you when you start to try to do the right thing.
 
That's just a fallacy. It's not the insurance companies themselves that are important, it's the richest shareholders who are important. If those people could make even more money by destroying the companies, and the entire industry, then we'd certainly see a healthcare bill to do just that.

The belief that corporations will act in the best long term interest of the corporation is common. Reality is that corporations are controlled by insiders who are human. Science has shown us that humans value short term gains over long term gains and personal gains over the welfare of a group. In short they will make decisions that create short term personal profits even if these decisions are bad for the long term survival of a corporation. What happened to Lehman Brothers is a good example.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom