To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

We cant point to radio waves. They are physical.

So is gravity, electromagnetism, mental illness, sound waves, wind, atoms, relativity--etc. All things that exist appear to measurable in some way--either as a force, process, matter or a combination therein. Immeasurable things like souls fall into the same category as fairies, dragons, satan, gods, psychic power, and ghosts.
 
Love, anger, orgasms, pains, I would bet hope, happiness and certainly despair are measurable. Stop being obtuse.
 
I don't ever want to hear Ian talk about orgasms again. :boxedin:

Must... get... images... out... of... my... head...

Please, pretty please - some people should not make home movies.

Oh, Ian - I almost forgot - You're nearly completely wrong, as usual.
 
And love, anger, orgasms, pains, hope, happiness, despair.

Indeed everything we ever experience. In other words all things.

Wrong, but nice try. All of these we can see in the brain...in fact we can stimulate the brain with electrodes to stimulate some of these emotions--all of these things can be effected by drugs--we have no data which indicates these experiences occur absent a brain. They are measurable also in that people (with brains) can describe them as they occur.

In the 70's people were afraid that that test tube babies wouldn't have a soul. Guess what, it turns out that test tube babies are just like everyone else. And humans can make these babies in a petri dish--lots of people on this planet began that same way.

Which of the feelings listed above (love, anger, orgasms, etc.) do you imagine a soul has? Why?
 
Ian,
Aren't arguing for the idea that consciousness can exist outside the brain. The other people on this thread seem to conclude that consciousness is a product of a brain--like walking is a process of legs. Without legs, there is no walking. If consciousness of any sort can exist outside of a brain--what attributes do you think such a consciousness can have--what "is" this consciousness? A force? Matter? A process? What characteristics do you ascribe to it? What are your reasons or evidence that such a thing exists?

You and Hammy argue against materialism but offer nothing in return as far as I can tell for what you mean by consciousness much less what attributes it has. To me, it seems like you dismiss what other people say, avoid questions, and fail to participate in a dialogue. We understand that you lean towards dualism, but how can we even examine it when you avoid defining it. You refer to "something" that has no discernible properties and get defensive when others call this "something" an illusion. If it's NOT an illusion, why isn't it? What makes it so very possible to you?--you know that intuitiveness is not a good argument, don't you? I mean it's a good way to convince yourself, but it's not a good way to get others to take your claims seriously.

And if you don't want to examine it critically, then maybe a skeptic website isn't the place to proffer your insights.

As to the topic of whether science=faith, I would have to say clearly not. Science provides definitions, measurable claims, evidence, and replicability. Faith has obfuscation, unproveable notions, and claims that "seem" true. Faith is about untestable conclusions. If your version of consciousness defies all measurement, then I suspect it falls under a faith based claim. Materialism is a science based claim. There is a very big difference indeed.

I think most scientists have believed in dualism through the eons, but now more seem to be materialists; it does appear that dualism is an illusion, but this does not mean that we don't understand the concept (or that you can avoid the topic by pretending we are not talking about souls or gods, etc.)--I think we'd be glad to find some sort of evidence for the existence of consciousness as other than a brain process, but the extreme lack of evidence and pussyfooting of believers seems only to make materialism more obvious. It's not faith that lead me to this conclusion, but the absolute lack good evidence for the more "intuitive" view. Do you have ANY?? Wanting something to be so doesn't make it so.

As for you Hammy, what exactly is it you are trying to discuss? I appear to have missed it completely.
 
Last edited:
To me, a point where the faith aspect of science enters is that a materialist should believe *you* (or *i*) can be replaced by a Turing machine (i.e. a digital computer) and some reasonably sophisticated I/O.

Maybe it will help if you say why it is a materialist "should" believe *you* or *i* could be replaced by a Turing machine, because I find it irrelevent and a digression. Replaced in what way? And what does this have to do with whether consciousness is a brain process? If we want to replicate life, we can easily do so in a test tube using the basic ingredience of life--sperm and egg. Why should I expect something composed of different type of matter could "replace" me?

I think humans will be able to clone themselves, but a clone is just an identical twin born at a different time--they would have their own consciousness. Memory resides in the brain of the individual--it's brain dependent--hippocampus dependent to be more specific.
 
Originally Posted by Interesting Ian :
And love, anger, orgasms, pains, hope, happiness, despair.

Indeed everything we ever experience. In other words all things.

articulett
Wrong, but nice try. All of these we can see in the brain

What does hope look like?



...in fact we can stimulate the brain with electrodes to stimulate some of these emotions--all of these things can be effected by drugs--we have no data which indicates these experiences occur absent a brain.

Irrelevant.

They are measurable also in that people (with brains) can describe them as they occur.

Even if you're right here, a description is not a measurement. A measurement is quantifying by a specific number of appropriate units.

Anyway, get it through your head that I do not regard physical processes as being literally one and the same thing as mental processes. Otherwise all things would be measurable rather than nothing being so.

In the 70's people were afraid that that test tube babies wouldn't have a soul. Guess what, it turns out that test tube babies are just like everyone else. And humans can make these babies in a petri dish--lots of people on this planet began that same way.

I already told you that I define a soul as a self which survives the destruction of the body it is "housed" in.

I have no idea what these people mean by a soul who deny that test tube babies, clones/twins have a soul. What is this additional thing called a "soul"? What would it mean to lack this additional thing?? You say in the 70's. Are you saying these people have now changed their mind? If so then why have they?

Which of the feelings listed above (love, anger, orgasms, etc.) do you imagine a soul has? Why?

My definition of soul? All of them. Something which is not a self and therefore is not conscious eg a boulder, cannot have feelings.
 
Ian,
Aren't arguing for the idea that consciousness can exist outside the brain.

What? You miss a word out here?

The other people on this thread seem to conclude that consciousness is a product of a brain--like walking is a process of legs. Without legs, there is no walking.

You should be more careful here. Walking is not a product of legs. You say yourself it is a process of legs. In other words walking is literally movements of legs. The analogy then says consciousness is just literally physical processes in the brain.

But consciousness is not a product of the brain just as walking is not a product of legs. At least that's the reductive materialist's premise*.

Excellent analogy by the way! Did you think of it yourself? I must use it in my website if you don't mind.

(I'll address the rest of your post in a separate post since this is such an important point)


*Although it seems the vast majority of so called reductive materialists on here don't understand their own alleged position. Otherwise I wouldn't have to explain it!
 
Ian,
Aren't arguing for the idea that consciousness can exist outside the brain. The other people on this thread seem to conclude that consciousness is a product of a brain--like walking is a process of legs. Without legs, there is no walking. If consciousness of any sort can exist outside of a brain--what attributes do you think such a consciousness can have--what "is" this consciousness? A force? Matter? A process? What characteristics do you ascribe to it? What are your reasons or evidence that such a thing exists?

You and Hammy argue against materialism but offer nothing in return as far as I can tell for what you mean by consciousness much less what attributes it has. To me, it seems like you dismiss what other people say, avoid questions, and fail to participate in a dialogue. We understand that you lean towards dualism, but how can we even examine it when you avoid defining it. You refer to "something" that has no discernible properties and get defensive when others call this "something" an illusion. If it's NOT an illusion, why isn't it? What makes it so very possible to you?--you know that intuitiveness is not a good argument, don't you? I mean it's a good way to convince yourself, but it's not a good way to get others to take your claims seriously.

*snip*

Here is the crux of the issue. You've worded it all nicely, BTW, however you will not get a response that will suit any easy definition. Non-materialists always fall back into the same traps;

The universe has laws dictating how phenomena persist. Check.
These laws are consistent from moment to moment. Check.

The issue occurs when it's pointed out that this is the material. They prefer to create a field of non-definition, an elusive descriptor of the universe that fails to suit any laws (in spite of agreeing with the above).

As for you Hammy, what exactly is it you are trying to discuss? I appear to have missed it completely.

Forget it. Try squeezing orange juice from an earthworm. You'd have better luck. Hammy is a solipsist of the most extreme kind; another one who pretends to be arguing science without knowing what it is exactly, who denies the existance of everything without knowing it.


Athon
 
If consciousness of any sort can exist outside of a brain--what attributes do you think such a consciousness can have--what "is" this consciousness? A force? Matter? A process? What characteristics do you ascribe to it? What are your reasons or evidence that such a thing exists?

Consciousness is never outside or inside the brain. If you think it's inside the brain then where is it located?? Consciousness is not a force, not matter, not a process. All those "things" are physical. Consciousness has exactly the same characteristics whether "inside" the brain or "outside" the brain -- it's just not being limited by being "filtered" through the brain (although it should be understood that my position certainly need not entail that consciousness can exist independently from the brain. I certainly believe in "life after death", but the notion that consciousness is an emergent phenomenon is certainly a very reasonable one if we ignore all the evidence suggesting survival).

You and Hammy argue against materialism but offer nothing in return as far as I can tell for what you mean by consciousness much less what attributes it has. To me, it seems like you dismiss what other people say, avoid questions, and fail to participate in a dialogue.

Well I'm not interested in a dialogue. I can learn nothing from you guys. I am trying to educate you and others. And I can say nothing about consciousness that you don't already understand since (presumably) you yourself are conscious.

We understand that you lean towards dualism, but how can we even examine it when you avoid defining it. You refer to "something" that has no discernible properties and get defensive when others call this "something" an illusion. If it's NOT an illusion, why isn't it? What makes it so very possible to you?--you know that intuitiveness is not a good argument, don't you? I mean it's a good way to convince yourself, but it's not a good way to get others to take your claims seriously.

What are you talking about here, consciousness or a self? Consciousness cannot be an illusion. There can be no distinction between an illusionary consciousness and "real consciousness". Agreed? So I assume you're talking about a self.

As for whether we truly are selves I've already hinted at an argument earlier in this thread. To remind you I said:

"I am well aware what it means to deny the existence of a self. I would argue that materialists, or any position which holds that conscious states follow and are completely depend upon brain states, must also deny the existence of the self.

The first thing to note is this absolutely is not denying the existence of consciousness. For example there could be a raw sensation of a toothache, the raw sensation of the taste of jelly, the feeling of terror etc. Now what absolutely cannot be denied is that there really is the taste of jelly, a toothache, the feeling of terror etc. So consciousness most definitely exists.


However it has been argued that experiences e.g the raw sensation of a toothache, the raw sensation of the taste of jelly, the feeling of terror, and more generally any experience whatsoever are not literally had by an experiencer (i.e a self), but rather exist in isolation. That is to say experiences exist, but without an experiencer. Thus pains etc exist, but no-one is the subject of that pain. The notion that *I* am the author of all these experiences is an illusion in other words.

Now apart from such a notion being staggeringly counter-intuitive (which doesn't seem to bother anyone on here one iota), we have the problem of why experiences are grouped into families so that "I" appear to have some set of experiences, and "you" appear to have another set of experiences. But there is no "I" or "you".

Moreover it's all very well asserting a pain can exist all by itself without experiencer experiencing that pain, but what about intentions to behave in a given manner? Maybe you have the intention to cancel a cheque say. Now this intention of yours implies a network of other beliefs on your part -- the existence of a currency system, of banks, of the concept of promising, that failing to cancel the cheque will have undesirable consequences etc. It is incredibly difficult to suppose that all this is possible when there really is no self!"

As to the topic of whether science=faith, I would have to say clearly not. Science provides definitions, measurable claims, evidence, and replicability. Faith has obfuscation, unproveable notions, and claims that "seem" true. Faith is about untestable conclusions.

Doesn't seem to me there's any contradiction here between "faith" and science. The inductive principle for example has already been discussed. If the Universe can dissolve into chaos in the very next second then what does all this measurable claims, evidence, and replicability amount to?

If your version of consciousness defies all measurement, then I suspect it falls under a faith based claim. Materialism is a science based claim. There is a very big difference indeed.

Umm . .no. Materialism is a philosophical position. It is no more "science based" than my own subjective idealism (not dualism). Indeed I would argue that my own position is somewhat more consistent with science (but obviously I won't bother arguing for that here).

I think most scientists have believed in dualism through the eons, but now more seem to be materialists; it does appear that dualism is an illusion,

Dualism is a position in the mind/body problem. It cannot be an illusion.

but this does not mean that we don't understand the concept (or that you can avoid the topic by pretending we are not talking about souls or gods, etc.)--I think we'd be glad to find some sort of evidence for the existence of consciousness as other than a brain process, but the extreme lack of evidence and pussyfooting of believers seems only to make materialism more obvious. It's not faith that lead me to this conclusion, but the absolute lack good evidence for the more "intuitive" view. Do you have ANY?? Wanting something to be so doesn't make it so.

The problem here is that I have no idea what you want evidence for. You seem here to be asking for evidence for a "life after death". But I'm completely uninterested in providing such evidence. What I'm interested in is arguing against reductive materialists (and to a certain extent non-reductive materialists too). I really have no deep quarrel against people who think that consciousness and indeed even selves are emergent phenomena generated by the brain -- so long as the self interacts with the brain in turn. A person who rejects materialism but still thinks that consciousness is an emergent phenomenon of the brain ought to be vastly more sympathetic to the possibility of a "life after death". Do you understand this? Ummm . . .does anyone understand this?
 
Ian said:
I used the dupicator experiment to prove that for anyone who subscribes to materialism or supposes that the brain generates consciousness and conscious states are dictated by physical states of the brain, you have to believe that a continuous self is an illusion. This is staggeringly counter-intuitive.
No, it's not, not even when you use the word staggeringly.

Ian said:
What on earth are "scare" quotes? I use quotes where they are necessary. I use italics to emphasise.
And in this case you emphasized literally to scare me into saying to myself "Ooh, well, I couldn't literally be changing from moment to moment."

You say you are the same person. But you are not literally. Memories cannot establish identity. Sometimes people "remember" what someone else actually did. And false memories could be implanted into you. And you do not have the same physical body in the sense you are composed of the very same atoms. And that's irrelevant anyway. Of course your body can be continuously traced through space and time but that's also insufficient to establish identity.

It seems to me that only a continuous self is sufficient to make you the very same person from second to second.
Groovy. Then I am not literally the very same actual identical person from second to second. Why am I supposed to wring my hands over this?

I am the same person by virtue of the fact that my self is enduring. I can't point to the self obviously. We cannot point to consciousness since it is non-physical, and we cannot point to the self since it is non-physical.
So you invent the "self" to be the enduring aspect of yourself. Again, why is it so important to do so?

~~ Paul
 
Well I'm not interested in a dialogue. I can learn nothing from you guys. I am trying to educate you and others.

Want to hear it straight? You have zero chances to "educate" no one. Go away, we like to learn from each other, to be presented with intriguing new arguments, we like to talk with people who is open to debate in order to advance general knowledge.

You have been unable to provide anything interesting, everything you say and believe have been said before. What is worst, you are obtuse and arrogant!

Ohh, please stop! you make me laugh!
 
Last edited:
Interesting Ian said:
Why are we discussing anything then? Why do we get up in the morning? Why??? if we're not conscious! :eek:

What ? So animals don't get up in the morning because they're not conscious ?

You all seem to be completely screwed up as far as I can ascertain. Have none of you ever tried to think for yourselves?? Study some philosophy of science for Christ sake.

Just because people don't agree with you doesn't mean they haven't given any thought to it.

Interesting Ian said:
And love, anger, orgasms, pains, hope, happiness, despair.

Those things are measurable. You don't get any points, here.
 
And love, anger, orgasms, pains, hope, happiness, despair.

Indeed everything we ever experience. In other words all things.


This is important, sorry if this disturbes your ego Ian (do you have a hint now in why I deliverately used "ego" instead of "self" when talking to you about this subjects??????)

YOU ARE WRONG, you have proved it yourself by this tiny example!! How amusing is that??!! :D
 
Last edited:
Interesting Ian said:
No, nothing that actually exists is measurable. Ultimately measurements only systematically relate our perceptual qualia.

You're very well versed in wording things in ways that make only YOUR interpretations possible.

Interesting Ian said:
What does hope look like?

Obtuse statement of the year.

Interesting Ian said:
(although it should be understood that my position certainly need not entail that consciousness can exist independently from the brain. I certainly believe in "life after death", but the notion that consciousness is an emergent phenomenon is certainly a very reasonable one if we ignore all the evidence suggesting survival).

Anecdotal evidence. Evidence of the weakest kind.

Well I'm not interested in a dialogue. I can learn nothing from you guys. I am trying to educate you and others.

So you want US to learn from you but you refuse to learn from US ? Do you see a problem, here ?

Now apart from such a notion being staggeringly counter-intuitive (which doesn't seem to bother anyone on here one iota),

You seem to have, as usual, ignored what people have said about OTHER counter-intuitive things that have turned out to be true.

Moreover it's all very well asserting a pain can exist all by itself without experiencer experiencing that pain, but what about intentions to behave in a given manner?

What about single-celled organisms that shy away from certain chemicals ? Are they "conscious" of those chemicals ? If not, why can they still react ? At which point do you consider something "conscious" ?

But I'm completely uninterested in providing such evidence. What I'm interested in is arguing against reductive materialists (and to a certain extent non-reductive materialists too).

So, you're just trolling ?
 
Funny thing is that anyone can see how easy we can account for every one of your "arguments", yet you are here to "educate us".

What can be more laughable?

Ian, I beg you. Impress us, give us something (anything) coherent and innovative, and we will analyze it with delight.
 
At least Ian seems sincere. Hammy reeks of creationist agenda. He uses the term "neo-darwinist faith" which is a dishonest creationst tactic to try and put ID and evolution on the same footing. By Hammy's definiton, all who believe the earth is spherical are neo-Aristotlists and math is a faith practiced by neo-Pythagoreists

Morever, he pretends people are talking nonsense or misunderstanding him or clueless when people point this out. Perhaps for Darwin evolution was a "theory"--the compendium of evidence in DNA (which Darwin never knew about) makes evolution a FACT to well over 99% percent of Biologists working in their field.

Hammy is a "neo-scopesian" (scopes monkey trials) and a "neo-ignoramus" and a "neo-creationist" per his own blighted analogy. All the hubris and hope in the world doesn't change the facts, Hammy. You are the modern day equivalent of a flat earthist.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom