Firstly, I admittedly have a bias. I am biased toward having some doubt that human consciousness is capable of being 'computed' within the constraints of what we call 'our physical reality'. I'm not just biased against the ability of neural networks, I am biased against the inertial/information-processing constraints of this universe. For analogy: remember the days of the "math co-processor chip" we used to have on our PC386s? The math chip could perform calculations in parallel with other processes, thereby speeding up the process of a program. While I may have said before, in another thread, that I doubt 'mechanism', I suppose I think of consciousness having to be supported by some sort of super-mechanism that may be impossible within what we normally consider our physical reality. So call it 'gut feel' that I believe the best mechanism that can work within the substrate of our physical reality, is insufficient to support consciousness, it seems to me there can be a sort of "co-processor" that can help here. I interpret what is coming out of "loop quantum gravity" as indicating that there can indeed be room for a process that runs 'outside' of our reality 'screen'. Admittedly, the premise for "loop quantum gravity" is that it relies on "nothing outside the universe". My tiny understanding of what I read, though, sees this as a semantical game because this very Bekensteinian related phenomenon appears to me to contradict the premise of "nothing outside". Be that as it may, to answer your question now: how does all/some of that assist me? It assists me in concluding that dualism is plausible since, I am biased toward needing to find a mechanism that is "outside" but is linked to our universe. Semantics again: some have already responded to me to say that it isn't outside if it relates to this universe. You even called it "interactive" which I think you were using to imply it would have to be a two-way porting. So since I need to find such a porting or linking, I see that leading edge quantum gravity theory may be postulating, albeit for their own and much different reasons, such a worldview. You ask "logical"? ...I say "plausible". Pretty vague? Yes, but ... no one else knows what they are talking about either when it comes to dualism/monism so I am with familiar company.I see. And how does any or all of that assist you in concluding some form of interactive dualism is logical?![]()
Perhaps you think I'm not aware of, and have not considered all that, and even more. I have. And in many more areas of science too.
My distaste for evolutionary theory is part and parcel of my worldview which is objective idealism.
I try to keep abreast of (layman's) science; what do you think of, say, delayed choice quantum eraser double slit results? Fit that into your worldview. I keep testing mine against 'reality' as best I understand it.
Peace.
We are "cursed" to understand throughout ourselfs? Yep, this is why is fascinating to try to learn beyond us.
Therein is good part of the problem I have -- and we here have been around and around this issue dozens of times, with talkorigins / you name it thrown in.
In essence, the various definitions of "species" are all moveable goalposts, most of them post hoc.![]()
Is it? I thought that "neo-darwinism" referred to the theory of evolution subsequent to the synthesis of Darwin's theory with Mendelian genetics? I'm pretty sure I've heard Dawkins use the term in that sense.You use the term "neo darwinist"--that's creationist talk--so is referring to science as "faith".
Doesn't this suggest a false qualitative dichotomy between "theory" and "fact"? The theory of evolution certainly is supported by a much greater weight of evidence, and can therefore be regarded as much more probable, than it was in Darwin's time, but if you're using "fact" to mean "an assertion verified to absolute certainty," is there such a thing?In Darwin's time evolution was a very good theory--now it is considered fact among biolgists.
You are not the only one on this forum who does this, but you are a good example of it: IMO you have such a nice clean and tidy certitude of what you believe that you think anyone who is a skeptic, is disingenuous. You accused here that Hammegk "pretend(s) (to) have questions that (he) (doesn't) really have." More than once, I've seen you mention me, along with your wrong interpretations of who I am and what I think, to others.You aren't fooling anyone here from what I can tell, except maybe yourself. You have a pet "theory" and you can only "interpret" and "understand" evidence which promotes that theory. You just plug in non-sequitars here and there and pretend you have questions that you don't really have.
If I have any gift for you at all, it is that I tell you that you should get outside your box and go read Lee Smolin's "Quantum Gravity". He says he tries to apply natural selection to a cosmological level, which is moot, because it helps not at all toward his theorization about quantum gravity. That is not why I think you should read it. The reason I think you should read it is because you pondered here "what the heck (I) believe in." If you start with Quantum Gravity, you might get a glimpse of my worldview.They both pretend that everyone else on these threads are beneath them--just like Ian--but they never seem to offer up anything useful or fact based for anyone to consider. Does anyone understand what the heck they believe in? ...
Is it? I thought that "neo-darwinism" referred to the theory of evolution subsequent to the synthesis of Darwin's theory with Mendelian genetics? I'm pretty sure I've heard Dawkins use the term in that sense.
Doesn't this suggest a false qualitative dichotomy between "theory" and "fact"? The theory of evolution certainly is supported by a much greater weight of evidence, and can therefore be regarded as much more probable, than it was in Darwin's time, but if you're using "fact" to mean "an assertion verified to absolute certainty," is there such a thing?
I hope someone else, somewhere, shares your high opinion of your abilities to understand other posters. However, as a mind-reader, you suck.....Hammy ... alleges that there are problems with a theory because he doesn't understand it, but he willingly ignores all attempts at understanding by claiming to know everything already and refusing to detail his "doubts".
Even though it apparently bothers you, that's not a requirement for discussions, here, or anywhere else.Moreover, he never offers anything else to flesh out another theory.
You obviously think a lot a things. Perhaps some future thought will be correct, so keep trying.I think it's smarmy to pretend to be part of a dialogue or be curious about something, when, in fact, your intent is to muddy the topic and push your own unsupported agenda.
Why would any of us care about your worldview?If I have any gift for you at all, it is that I tell you that you should get outside your box and go read Lee Smolin's "Quantum Gravity". He says he tries to apply natural selection to a cosmological level, which is moot, because it helps not at all toward his theorization about quantum gravity. That is not why I think you should read it. The reason I think you should read it is because you pondered here "what the heck (I) believe in." If you start with Quantum Gravity, you might get a glimpse of my worldview.
Don't go on with your proclamation of what VonNeumann believes until you can begin to understand more than what you read about biology in Discover magazine - that was tacky but that's the way you come across to me.
To see how to add nothing but vituperation to a thread, many of your posts offer a good lesson.... Prate on in your pathetic attempt to prop up your self-importance. The world will pass you by.
While I may have said before, in another thread, that I doubt 'mechanism', I suppose I think of consciousness having to be supported by some sort of super-mechanism that may be impossible within what we normally consider our physical reality.
So call it 'gut feel'
Admittedly, the premise for "loop quantum gravity" is that it relies on "nothing outside the universe". My tiny understanding of what I read, though, sees this as a semantical game because this very Bekensteinian related phenomenon appears to me to contradict the premise of "nothing outside".
how does all/some of that assist me? It assists me in concluding that dualism is plausible since, I am biased toward needing to find a mechanism that is "outside" but is linked to our universe.
...goodness! ...poor fella'...Why would any of us care about your worldview?
You appear to be in love with yourself, your ideas, and your words. Those things do not interest me - you have yet to offer any reason to care about them. You are not a diamond in the rough that might warrant patience and nurturing. Instead, you are a pile steaming in a field. You have been given far too much time and attention.
Babble on if you must - we can happily ignore you. Prate on in your pathetic attempt to prop up your self-importance. The world will pass you by.
I was answering a question of Hammegk's, directed to me, from more than a week ago, Belz. Let me try to address your questions:Well, that IS a problem, isn't it ? It's an assumption, and one that's unsupported.
How could there be something outside without space ?
??? So, you believe in what you believe because you WANT to believe in it. Big surprise. Everyone does. That's why they're so resilient to evidence.
Its your free choice. Having straddled both hardware and software in my career, your comment reminds me of all the programmers who said "hardware does not matter to me, I only want to think about software."The immaterial never mattered to me one bit.
You are not plagued with my over-verbosity-disease. Good for you. But I'm trying to understand your worldview you called "objective idealism", and you may be too laconic for me to follow. But in my response to your question of a week ago, Belz asked me some questions, for which I summarized something above. I would be interested in your take on the analogy, if you are so inclined to comment.Some thoughts:
...
Matter is an epiphenomena
...
explanation: dunno how or why, but INTENT in more complex outcomes is seen in myriad things
Science works equally well under either monism; interactive dualism is logically indefensible
Finally, Thought exists, or has existed.
I'd say Von N is just pointing out that the macroworld force most obviously a Law is yet one of the least understood; higgs fields, gravitons, multiverse with gravitational connections, 11 dimensions, etc.
1. I posited that mechanism cannot support consciousness. You say that is an assumption and is one that is unsupported. This is true. What is also an assumption and is unsupported, is the opposite.
My interpretation of leading-edge physics is this: It appears that there is nothing but information and the processing of that information. What we think is 'space' appears to be merely the network of information transfer.
That is the way I see it is that 'space' is like the 'screen' and some process that is not visible to us is responsible for what is on the 'screen'.
3. We believe what we want to believe, yes, of course. From the many posts of yours I have read, Belz (and others), I understand that you feel confident that you have evidence for what you believe.
I feel that you keep lecturing me on my not having evidence for something, say for that there are processes outside of space-time, and yet you seem not to understand that we do not have evidence of necessary processes within space time.
If the process of a photon emission is fundamentally non-attainable yet effects photon-emission, then so also might our own consciousness rely directly upon the unattainable processes. The brain may be constructed to make access of and make use of the process. It may be an illusion that consciousness merely emerges from a complex neural network; it may be much more than that.
While this equation is a human construct it does not tell us how the two masses "know" how to pull on each other, the right amount. We might posit that the each mass calculates the force based upon a measured field and somehow moves accordingly - but that is absurd, right?
I ask you to inquire of your own 'worldview' what process actually invokes the change. Where is that process. What substrate does it 'run' on. Is it explainable by bunch of little particles bouncing around on a micro-scale?
Is it an intrinsic mechanism of space-time, itself? Is it a continuous function or is it discrete? Is it possible that it makes sense that space-time warps somehow without using any thing that would be construed as being a process. It just happens? What do you think, Belz?