To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

Input, output, and with luck, processing can change one's understandings as well as one's knowledge base. :)
 
I see. And how does any or all of that assist you in concluding some form of interactive dualism is logical? :)
Firstly, I admittedly have a bias. I am biased toward having some doubt that human consciousness is capable of being 'computed' within the constraints of what we call 'our physical reality'. I'm not just biased against the ability of neural networks, I am biased against the inertial/information-processing constraints of this universe. For analogy: remember the days of the "math co-processor chip" we used to have on our PC386s? The math chip could perform calculations in parallel with other processes, thereby speeding up the process of a program. While I may have said before, in another thread, that I doubt 'mechanism', I suppose I think of consciousness having to be supported by some sort of super-mechanism that may be impossible within what we normally consider our physical reality. So call it 'gut feel' that I believe the best mechanism that can work within the substrate of our physical reality, is insufficient to support consciousness, it seems to me there can be a sort of "co-processor" that can help here. I interpret what is coming out of "loop quantum gravity" as indicating that there can indeed be room for a process that runs 'outside' of our reality 'screen'. Admittedly, the premise for "loop quantum gravity" is that it relies on "nothing outside the universe". My tiny understanding of what I read, though, sees this as a semantical game because this very Bekensteinian related phenomenon appears to me to contradict the premise of "nothing outside". Be that as it may, to answer your question now: how does all/some of that assist me? It assists me in concluding that dualism is plausible since, I am biased toward needing to find a mechanism that is "outside" but is linked to our universe. Semantics again: some have already responded to me to say that it isn't outside if it relates to this universe. You even called it "interactive" which I think you were using to imply it would have to be a two-way porting. So since I need to find such a porting or linking, I see that leading edge quantum gravity theory may be postulating, albeit for their own and much different reasons, such a worldview. You ask "logical"? ...I say "plausible". Pretty vague? Yes, but ... no one else knows what they are talking about either when it comes to dualism/monism so I am with familiar company.:)
 
Perhaps you think I'm not aware of, and have not considered all that, and even more. I have. And in many more areas of science too.

My distaste for evolutionary theory is part and parcel of my worldview which is objective idealism.

I try to keep abreast of (layman's) science; what do you think of, say, delayed choice quantum eraser double slit results? Fit that into your worldview. I keep testing mine against 'reality' as best I understand it.

Peace.

I was responding to the following that you wrote:

"I propose no alternative. The questions and doubts that plague me are in the minutiae of details that are needed for one species to be altered sufficiently at dna level to be genotypically and phenotypically 'new, different, and viable over the longer term'. Those changes that have allowed the ancestors of green alga (or whatever) to reach human brain complexity in the sequence of lurches demonstrated in the fossil record are obviously a fait accompli.

As to being a creationist, I am not one that we could ever reach agreement on a definition of."

You seemed to have problems with the details of speciation, not "objective idealism" as you now claim.--I gave you some info.--you tell me you know it already as though my answer was a non-sequitar. I think almost everything you write is a non-sequitar. How do you twists the "details of species alteration" to really mean something about objective idealism? And what does that have to do with the topic. And if you don't offer any theory or explanation in return, why shoud people take anything you say seriously?

you said you don't agree that you are a creationist; I think it's more than clear you are. In fact, I think the above illustrates that you are making up arguments so you DON'T have to understand things. I realize, now, I wasted my time in thinking you wanted some illumination. I actually do have some experience and have seen the DNA that "plague you with doubts". I don't believe that you really know what problems you have with evolution--you're just a dishonest creationist who NEEDS to have problems with creationism, so you invent them and then keep changing them and throw in assorted terms to try and sound like you are being logical and thinking critically.

You aren't fooling anyone here from what I can tell, except maybe yourself. You have a pet "theory" and you can only "interpret" and "understand" evidence which promotes that theory. You just plug in non-sequitars here and there and pretend you have questions that you don't really have.
 
We are "cursed" to understand throughout ourselfs? Yep, this is why is fascinating to try to learn beyond us.

Just when we got rid of Ian, more woos.

Ah well...I'll leave and let Hammegk and Von Neumman have a little supportive love fest for their "intelligent designer"and their theory of dualism, etc. If you see Ian, tell him his audience is here.

They both pretend that everyone else on these threads are beneath them--just like Ian--but they never seem to offer up anything useful or fact based for anyone to consider. Does anyone understand what the heck they believe in? Can they understand eachother? I guess it takes one to know one...
 
Therein is good part of the problem I have -- and we here have been around and around this issue dozens of times, with talkorigins / you name it thrown in.

In essence, the various definitions of "species" are all moveable goalposts, most of them post hoc. :)

Ok, but doesn't the very fact that we have such a difficult time figuring out how to define a "species" lend some credibility to the theory of evolution-- i.e., that all organisms are linked in a single genetic and phenotypic spectrum and, therefore, that trying to divide them into discrete categories requires a degree of arbitrary judgment?

What definition of "species" did you have in mind when you argued that it is implausible that the process of mutation could create a new species from an old one? And, again, if we're using "species" in its generally accepted sense of a population capable of interbreeding within itself but not outside itself, doesn't the existence of ring species illustrate that it is possible for accumulated mutations to create new species?

You use the term "neo darwinist"--that's creationist talk--so is referring to science as "faith".
Is it? I thought that "neo-darwinism" referred to the theory of evolution subsequent to the synthesis of Darwin's theory with Mendelian genetics? I'm pretty sure I've heard Dawkins use the term in that sense.

In Darwin's time evolution was a very good theory--now it is considered fact among biolgists.
Doesn't this suggest a false qualitative dichotomy between "theory" and "fact"? The theory of evolution certainly is supported by a much greater weight of evidence, and can therefore be regarded as much more probable, than it was in Darwin's time, but if you're using "fact" to mean "an assertion verified to absolute certainty," is there such a thing?
 
Some thoughts:

Monism=materialism, non-life operating under immutable Physical Laws

Life from non-life operating under PL and random mutations meeting random environmental stress has resulted in the human brain:

explanation, emergent property


Theism (usually dualist .. say, mind/body) non-life operating under sientient god's laws

Life from or in non-life: explanation, goddidit

Xians
YECs: it was created 6000 yrs ago to look exactly as it does and provide the results science sees: goddidit

OECs: it was created in billions of years with methods seen by science: goddidit


Monism=objective idealism, life operating under immutable Laws

Matter is an epiphenomena


explanation: dunno how or why, but intent in more complex outcomes is seen in myriad things


Science works equally well under either monism; interactive dualism is logically indefensible

Finally, Thought exists, or has existed.


I'd say Von N is just pointing out that the macroworld force most obviously a Law is yet one of the least understood; higgs fields, gravitons, multiverse with gravitational connections, 11 dimensions, etc.
 
You aren't fooling anyone here from what I can tell, except maybe yourself. You have a pet "theory" and you can only "interpret" and "understand" evidence which promotes that theory. You just plug in non-sequitars here and there and pretend you have questions that you don't really have.
You are not the only one on this forum who does this, but you are a good example of it: IMO you have such a nice clean and tidy certitude of what you believe that you think anyone who is a skeptic, is disingenuous. You accused here that Hammegk "pretend(s) (to) have questions that (he) (doesn't) really have." More than once, I've seen you mention me, along with your wrong interpretations of who I am and what I think, to others.

You can assume i am ignorant, or that I am unintelligent, or i am deluded with religion. that seems to me the opinion you exhibit. I notice that you have pointed out that other people think themselves so intelligent. Whatever bothers you about other people when they tell you what they think, is not really whether they think of themselves as so intelligent, I don't believe. I think you do not like it when people who are obviously intelligent, have opinions different than yours. You think you need to go "teach" them.:)

If I were a government school teacher, I'd bet I'd give you an A+ because you can regurge the stuff so well. But your knowledge base is limited in scope. That is not a put down. You mentioned 'love fest'. Aren't you the one that is aligned so well with establishment thinking that you should have no trouble finding a love-fest partner with someone of like mind? Just because I'm not a Hatfield does not mean I'm a McCoy - it is not that simple.
 
They both pretend that everyone else on these threads are beneath them--just like Ian--but they never seem to offer up anything useful or fact based for anyone to consider. Does anyone understand what the heck they believe in? ...
If I have any gift for you at all, it is that I tell you that you should get outside your box and go read Lee Smolin's "Quantum Gravity". He says he tries to apply natural selection to a cosmological level, which is moot, because it helps not at all toward his theorization about quantum gravity. That is not why I think you should read it. The reason I think you should read it is because you pondered here "what the heck (I) believe in." If you start with Quantum Gravity, you might get a glimpse of my worldview.

Don't go on with your proclamation of what VonNeumann believes until you can begin to understand more than what you read about biology in Discover magazine - that was tacky but that's the way you come across to me.
 
Is it? I thought that "neo-darwinism" referred to the theory of evolution subsequent to the synthesis of Darwin's theory with Mendelian genetics? I'm pretty sure I've heard Dawkins use the term in that sense.

I've heard the term used by creationists and, like Hammy, those who wish to equate science with faith (as if they are on the same footing).

Doesn't this suggest a false qualitative dichotomy between "theory" and "fact"? The theory of evolution certainly is supported by a much greater weight of evidence, and can therefore be regarded as much more probable, than it was in Darwin's time, but if you're using "fact" to mean "an assertion verified to absolute certainty," is there such a thing?

Dawkins is the one who suggested that we start using it as fact so that creationists don't confuse it with the philosophical meaning of theory in their attempts to assert that Intelligent Design is also a theory (it isn't per scientific definition). I believe Dawkins even wrote as much in this months Skeptic. But, in the world of Biology and Genetics, we don't refer to it as a theory anymore that we'd say that gravity is a theory... Scientific and math theories like Pythagoreums theorem are not on the same footing as hypothesizing that the world was designed by a higher intelligence.

There's just this dishonesty among Intelligent Design believers that obfuscate the issue as Hammy is doing. He alleges that there are problems with a theory because he doesn't understand it, but he willingly ignores all attempts at understanding by claiming to know everything already and refusing to detail his "doubts". Moreover, he never offers anything else to flesh out another theory. I think it's smarmy to pretend to be part of a dialogue or be curious about something, when, in fact, your intent is to muddy the topic and push your own unsupported agenda.
 
....Hammy ... alleges that there are problems with a theory because he doesn't understand it, but he willingly ignores all attempts at understanding by claiming to know everything already and refusing to detail his "doubts".
I hope someone else, somewhere, shares your high opinion of your abilities to understand other posters. However, as a mind-reader, you suck.

Moreover, he never offers anything else to flesh out another theory.
Even though it apparently bothers you, that's not a requirement for discussions, here, or anywhere else.

I think it's smarmy to pretend to be part of a dialogue or be curious about something, when, in fact, your intent is to muddy the topic and push your own unsupported agenda.
You obviously think a lot a things. Perhaps some future thought will be correct, so keep trying.
 
If I have any gift for you at all, it is that I tell you that you should get outside your box and go read Lee Smolin's "Quantum Gravity". He says he tries to apply natural selection to a cosmological level, which is moot, because it helps not at all toward his theorization about quantum gravity. That is not why I think you should read it. The reason I think you should read it is because you pondered here "what the heck (I) believe in." If you start with Quantum Gravity, you might get a glimpse of my worldview.

Don't go on with your proclamation of what VonNeumann believes until you can begin to understand more than what you read about biology in Discover magazine - that was tacky but that's the way you come across to me.
Why would any of us care about your worldview?

You appear to be in love with yourself, your ideas, and your words. Those things do not interest me - you have yet to offer any reason to care about them. You are not a diamond in the rough that might warrant patience and nurturing. Instead, you are a pile steaming in a field. You have been given far too much time and attention.

Babble on if you must - we can happily ignore you. Prate on in your pathetic attempt to prop up your self-importance. The world will pass you by.
 
... Prate on in your pathetic attempt to prop up your self-importance. The world will pass you by.
To see how to add nothing but vituperation to a thread, many of your posts offer a good lesson.

That's unfortunate; the few times you actually added something positive in a thread demonstrate you are capable of doing so more often. :confused:
 
While I may have said before, in another thread, that I doubt 'mechanism', I suppose I think of consciousness having to be supported by some sort of super-mechanism that may be impossible within what we normally consider our physical reality.

Well, that IS a problem, isn't it ? It's an assumption, and one that's unsupported.

So call it 'gut feel'

I will.

Admittedly, the premise for "loop quantum gravity" is that it relies on "nothing outside the universe". My tiny understanding of what I read, though, sees this as a semantical game because this very Bekensteinian related phenomenon appears to me to contradict the premise of "nothing outside".

How could there be something outside without space ?

how does all/some of that assist me? It assists me in concluding that dualism is plausible since, I am biased toward needing to find a mechanism that is "outside" but is linked to our universe.

??? So, you believe in what you believe because you WANT to believe in it. Big surprise. Everyone does. That's why they're so resilient to evidence.
 
Why would any of us care about your worldview?

You appear to be in love with yourself, your ideas, and your words. Those things do not interest me - you have yet to offer any reason to care about them. You are not a diamond in the rough that might warrant patience and nurturing. Instead, you are a pile steaming in a field. You have been given far too much time and attention.

Babble on if you must - we can happily ignore you. Prate on in your pathetic attempt to prop up your self-importance. The world will pass you by.
...goodness! ...poor fella'... :)
 
But I thought this was the room for intelligent discourse.
As far as I can see, there's the material world out there banging Bishop Berkley in the goolies every time he tries to kick the rock. The immaterial never mattered to me one bit.
 
Well, that IS a problem, isn't it ? It's an assumption, and one that's unsupported.

How could there be something outside without space ?

??? So, you believe in what you believe because you WANT to believe in it. Big surprise. Everyone does. That's why they're so resilient to evidence.
I was answering a question of Hammegk's, directed to me, from more than a week ago, Belz. Let me try to address your questions:
1. I posited that mechanism cannot support consciousness. You say that is an assumption and is one that is unsupported. This is true. What is also an assumption and is unsupported, is the opposite.
2. That there can be something that exists outside of space, you ask how that can be? My interpretation of leading-edge physics is this: It appears that there is nothing but information and the processing of that information. What we think is 'space' appears to be merely the network of information transfer. That's all we get to 'see', the rest must, if anything, be deduced. There is no evidence of what actually performs the processing except that we must deduce that something does. Imagine how you could write a computer program, using the full extent of the machine's instruction set, in order to find out physical things about the machine. You may find out what I/O ports you have, how much memory you have, how many registers there are in the ALU etc. But you will not be able to find out anything at all about the logic that decodes each instruction. You will not be able to see the flip-flops, much less the transistors. You can determine what each instruction does, but you can only assume there is something that performs the process. Use that analogy to see what I mean when I say that there exists mechanism that performs the process that does not exist where we can poke at it, yet we know it must exist. That is the way I see it is that 'space' is like the 'screen' and some process that is not visible to us is responsible for what is on the 'screen'.
3. We believe what we want to believe, yes, of course. From the many posts of yours I have read, Belz (and others), I understand that you feel confident that you have evidence for what you believe. All is well. But there are things for which none of us have evidence. I feel that you keep lecturing me on my not having evidence for something, say for that there are processes outside of space-time, and yet you seem not to understand that we do not have evidence of necessary processes within space time. Do you just presume that some specialist somewhere has evidence to the contrary of what I posit?
---
I will conclude this by summarizing that, since we have no evidence of fundamental processes within space-time, I deduce that they may be unattainable. Further, if such fundamental processes are unattainable, yet influence what happens here (like the flip-flops that hold hexadecimal 0x30 in this "0" are unattainable but the "0" is quite visible - please, this is an analogy, only), then it is not logically inconsistent that other processes are unattainable. Of course, I am back to consciousness. If the process of a photon emission is fundamentally non-attainable yet effects photon-emission, then so also might our own consciousness rely directly upon the unattainable processes. The brain may be constructed to make access of and make use of the process. It may be an illusion that consciousness merely emerges from a complex neural network; it may be much more than that.

I have a question for you now, Belz. Since you have had undergrad physics, let us use something classical and simple: F=Gm1m2/r^2 the gravitational law . We know that this equation is a model that can approximate the force between two masses, if we know G, m1, m2 and r. While this equation is a human construct it does not tell us how the two masses "know" how to pull on each other, the right amount. We might posit that the each mass calculates the force based upon a measured field and somehow moves accordingly - but that is absurd, right? We could say that the masses do not have a choice because space-time is warped by the presence of the masses - and maybe that is closer to what really happens. So if there is some sort of change in space-time due to the masses, I ask you to inquire of your own 'worldview' what process actually invokes the change. Where is that process. What substrate does it 'run' on. Is it explainable by bunch of little particles bouncing around on a micro-scale? Is it an intrinsic mechanism of space-time, itself? Is it a continuous function or is it discrete? Is it possible that it makes sense that space-time warps somehow without using any thing that would be construed as being a process. It just happens? What do you think, Belz?
 
Last edited:
The immaterial never mattered to me one bit.
Its your free choice. Having straddled both hardware and software in my career, your comment reminds me of all the programmers who said "hardware does not matter to me, I only want to think about software." :)

If that does not make sense, see my previous post for intended context.
 
Some thoughts:
...
Matter is an epiphenomena
...
explanation: dunno how or why, but INTENT in more complex outcomes is seen in myriad things

Science works equally well under either monism; interactive dualism is logically indefensible

Finally, Thought exists, or has existed.

I'd say Von N is just pointing out that the macroworld force most obviously a Law is yet one of the least understood; higgs fields, gravitons, multiverse with gravitational connections, 11 dimensions, etc.
You are not plagued with my over-verbosity-disease. Good for you. But I'm trying to understand your worldview you called "objective idealism", and you may be too laconic for me to follow. But in my response to your question of a week ago, Belz asked me some questions, for which I summarized something above. I would be interested in your take on the analogy, if you are so inclined to comment.

I see you think that matter is an epiphenomenon, for which I found this definition: Any occurrence that is accidental, accessory, or incidental to a cause-and-effect relationship. I am trying to see if I concur... It seems to me that whatever matter is, it is necessary for our perception of what we think is reality. Being necessary, it has a purpose and is not merely incidental. Could you elaborate on what you mean by this equation?

In quoting you above i emphasized "intent": was that the key word? If so, to what extent do you favor having a teleological viewpoint?

You said that interactive dualism is logically indefensible. In my post to Belz, I posited that whatever mechanisms that are responsible for fundamental processes, they are no more attainable for our analysis than are the fundamental logic circuits by the software that relies upon same. If my position has truth, then there is a sort of dualism that exists in the fundamental structure of everything we think is 'reality'. If you stop me right here and disagree, then I understand why you make the statement of dualism being logically indefensible. If you concur there is a fundamental dualism, is your point of diversion pivoting upon the question of whether it is 'interactive'?

Yes, thought exists - at least mine does, and my thinking tells me it is logically symmetrical that what I observe of people is that they have it, too. No disagreement there, anywise:) .

...and finally, you said "I'd say Von N is just pointing out that the macroworld force most obviously a Law is yet one of the least understood; higgs fields, gravitons, multiverse with gravitational connections, 11 dimensions, etc." Yeh, OK in general I am saying: because there are hundreds of specialists groping at the leading edge of physics, and some argue whether we are 10 years or whether we are 200 years from modeling a unified theory, that leaves plenty room for admitting we do not have sufficient knowledge to dismiss as much as I see being dismissed here on this forum.

But I am saying something much more specific than that. I am saying that I think the BEST model we have, that we can humanly relate to, for what lies just beneath the fundamental layer of "physical" existence, is a model that is analagous in many ways to the artifact we call the digital computer. So, there is my clarification on what you said "... Von N is pointing out..".
 
Last edited:
1. I posited that mechanism cannot support consciousness. You say that is an assumption and is one that is unsupported. This is true. What is also an assumption and is unsupported, is the opposite.

That is incorrect. If you'd bother to do some research into mind-brain dependency and neurological disorders, you'd understand. Every bit of evidence we have points to mechanism beign the source of consciousness.

My interpretation of leading-edge physics is this: It appears that there is nothing but information and the processing of that information. What we think is 'space' appears to be merely the network of information transfer.

You shouldn't forget that this is an analogy that you've created. So far I don't see how it relates to reality.

That is the way I see it is that 'space' is like the 'screen' and some process that is not visible to us is responsible for what is on the 'screen'.

Words. The universe is in the anus of a chicken. Disprove THAT!

3. We believe what we want to believe, yes, of course. From the many posts of yours I have read, Belz (and others), I understand that you feel confident that you have evidence for what you believe.

I'll add that the evidence does not suit me, because the universe as it stands does not seem satisfactory to me. So that's far from beign what I WANT to believe in.

I feel that you keep lecturing me on my not having evidence for something, say for that there are processes outside of space-time, and yet you seem not to understand that we do not have evidence of necessary processes within space time.

Would you care to rephrase that ? If you claim that such processes exist, provide your evidence.

If the process of a photon emission is fundamentally non-attainable yet effects photon-emission, then so also might our own consciousness rely directly upon the unattainable processes. The brain may be constructed to make access of and make use of the process. It may be an illusion that consciousness merely emerges from a complex neural network; it may be much more than that.

But that WOULD go against the evidence.

Imagine someone who believes in flying pink unicorns (FPU). The fact that not only have NO FPUs have ever been found but also that the laws of physics as we know them preclude their existence, does not deter this person from believing in FPUs because "we haven't looked everywhere" or "we haven't understood the whole of physics." How would you call that person ? I call him deluded.

While this equation is a human construct it does not tell us how the two masses "know" how to pull on each other, the right amount. We might posit that the each mass calculates the force based upon a measured field and somehow moves accordingly - but that is absurd, right?

Yes it is, because it would be Iacchan physics.

I ask you to inquire of your own 'worldview' what process actually invokes the change. Where is that process. What substrate does it 'run' on. Is it explainable by bunch of little particles bouncing around on a micro-scale?

Or is the curvature of space-time actually the ORIGIN of the particles ?

Is it an intrinsic mechanism of space-time, itself? Is it a continuous function or is it discrete? Is it possible that it makes sense that space-time warps somehow without using any thing that would be construed as being a process. It just happens? What do you think, Belz?

Ask Hawkings.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom