To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

Can you delineate what sort of qualia (feelings/ notions, etc.) are strictly brain processes, which are soul processess, and which are part of both.

He can't, in fact, something like this was one of my first questions to Ian when I came to the forum.
 
A quale of colour is not an emotion.

Sure, but without cones (color visual perceptors connected to the eye and brain) you don't see color. You can still use a spectometer to assess color--or ask a non-color blind person...or take a digital picture and let your computer tell you what colors the picture contains.

If people assume that it is and more generally that mental states are literally physical states, then this is nothing but the reductivist materialist position.

This is peoples' argument.

1) Reductive materialism correctly characterises reality

2) Therefore only the physical exists.

3) All that which is physical is potentially measurable.

4) Therefore nothing exists that is not measurable.

5) selves/consciousness/souls are not physical.

6) Therefore souls/consciousness/selves do not exist.

There's just one very slight problem with this otherwise flawless superb argument . . . .

I deny reductive materialism!
(Indeed I have produced a refutation of this metaphysic many times on this board).

Sure, but without cones (color visual perceptors connected to the eye and brain) you don't see color. You can still use a spectometer to assess color--or ask a non-color blind person...or take a digital picture and let your computer tell you what colors the picture contains.

As to number one I'd say reductive materialism explains reality better than any other theory. There is no good evidence for dualism of any kind althougth we feel like we have a "soul"--it's an illusion...just like we "feel" like the world is flat and we feel like "solids" are solid (and not composed of vibrating atoms that are mostly empty space.) We feel separate from our parents--as though we "created ourselves", but we are, indeed, made by our parents. We perceive things as purple that upon close examination are really red and blue dots.

And no one is saying that consiousness doesn't exist--we are just stating that conciousness seems to require a brain. I'm sure we'd all be eager to believe otherwise if there were proof. You can define things however you want, but the bottom line is there is no proof for a disembodied consciousness of any kind--god, souls, satan, demons, succubi, invisible aliens, etc. There is lots of proof that humans are great at deluding themselves. Don't make it more complicated then it is. Don't invent arguments and claims that aren't there. They just make you seem a little desparate and even more deluded.

As to your denial of reductive materialism--so what. People denied the earth was flat too--it doesn't change the truth. Your denial seems to be a statement that you refuse to consider the notion--we understand. Go preach to the choir; they might actually welcome your insights.
 
Last edited:
And, in regards to whatever it is you are trying to teach us Ian--
Why should I believe your "truth" over the Jehovah Witness or Mormon that comes to my door to share the "good news"? Can I send them over to your home so that you can learn that which they know to be true? Why would you expect anyone to take your claims more seriously than theirs?
 
Last edited:
He can't, in fact, something like this was one of my first questions to Ian when I came to the forum.

I know...I've "interacted" with him before. But he does amuse me. I love hubris complicated by ignorance--the decompensation is always fun to observe. I am just amazed that he chooses a skeptic forum to battle for his cherished "truths".
 
Here are some more questions for Ian to ignore.

1. Why aren't presents under the Christmas tree every Christmas reason enough to conclude that Santa is real?

2. Why aren't mysterious and unexplainable crop circles proof that aliens visit our planet?

3. Why isn't the fact that people don't fall off of our earth and that oceans don't spill out proof that the earth is flat?

4. Why isn't the divine nature of the Koran (or bible) proof that Allah (or God) exists?

5. Why isn't the stunning success, fame, and riches of John Travolta and Tom Cruise proof that Scientology is true?

6. Why aren't documented miracles, assorted stigmata, and a sainted Mother Theresa proof that Catholicism is true?

7. Why aren't the things that Charlie Manson believes so completely proof that he's divinely (or demonically) inspired?

8. Why isn't a rain dance followed by rain proof of rain gods? Why isn't proof that rain dances cause rain?

9. Why isn't an absent of Jesus' bones proof that he existed and rose bodily from the dead?

10. Why isn't the fact that things look "designed" proof of an intelligent designer?

11. Why is your staggering intuition about external consciousness more likely to be true than the above notions?

--If you answer these questions you may begin to understand why science and logic are utilized to uncover "truths" and why they are important tools for weeding out fact from fiction.

It's hard to accomplish your mission of "educating" us when you seem so very ignorant of basic logic skills and the many ways people fool themselves.

Nevertheless, thanks for the amusement.
 
Oh, no! What will happen to our education???

Dont tell us Ian that you cant answer the objections. I bet your impecable, flawless logic will show us a way out. I want to believe that you can illustrate us, being that intelligent. Cant you?

Oh, and if you cant, please go away, for a long time, from the forum. It will be interesting to discuss your ideas someday, when you abandon your immense ego.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps you ARE a turing machine!
Could be, but as I assign 100% probability to Thought exists, almost as high a probablility to believing *i* think, deny I'm The Solipsist (should such be The Answer), and choose (free-will, donchaknow?) to believe *you* are as real as *i* am, the chance is remote.

.... Evolution has quite and abundance of evidence that continues to amass.
No doubt that mutations occur, and the best suited to the encountered envoironment do better than those lesser suited, that Mendelian genetics are correct, and current rna/dna studies are allowing mapping back to specific alleles.

Has there been a demonstrated case of (damn language) change from 1 'kind' to another? You see the evidence as 100% yes; I don't find it that compelling.

Your discussion aims to discredit one notion without providing any explanation of an alternative--no matter what fancy words you want to use or how wise you view yourself or how superior to "noobs" you think you are. GIGO
I don't consider myself superior to anyone, a priori. I prefer to learn rather than teach, and tire quickly of stale lessons of the type you offer to date.


Can you delineate what sort of qualia (feelings/ notions, etc.) are strictly brain processes, which are soul processess, and which are part of both.
Your lack of understanding of the discussion is typified by that silly and meaningless question. Or are you an illogical interactive dualist?
 
hammegk

what is the alternative to evolution? so far, I thought you were an "objective idealist" but I didnt know that you also suscribe to some form of creationism??
 
I propose no alternative. The questions and doubts that plague me are in the minutiae of details that are needed for one species to be altered sufficiently at dna level to be genotypically and phenotypically 'new, different, and viable over the longer term'. Those changes that have allowed the ancestors of green alga (or whatever) to reach human brain complexity in the sequence of lurches demonstrated in the fossil record are obviously a fait accompli.

As to being a creationist, I am not one that we could ever reach agreement on a definition of.
 
I propose no alternative. The questions and doubts that plague me are in the minutiae of details that are needed for one species to be altered sufficiently at dna level to be genotypically and phenotypically 'new, different, and viable over the longer term'. Those changes that have allowed the ancestors of green alga (or whatever) to reach human brain complexity in the sequence of lurches demonstrated in the fossil record are obviously a fait accompli.

As to being a creationist, I am not one that we could ever reach agreement on a definition of.

If by "species" you mean the usual biological definition, i.e., a population of organisms capable of successfully reproducing but incapable of reproducing with organisms outside the population, don't ring species-- e.g., herring gulls around the northern hemisphere and salamanders around the Salinas Valley-- pretty well establish that the accumulation of mutations in a population can eventually give rise to new species?
 
hammegk

Have you considered that the changes you are looking for does not exist? suppose that changuing from a photoelectric receptor to an eye takes millions of years.

So, you are a creationist after all... now, would you propose, as justgeoff, that this "creator" is a personal being? if I understand you correctly, this is not what you would think. Maybe in some form of "abstract creative directionality" of some sort?
 
If by "species" you mean the usual biological definition,
Therein is good part of the problem I have -- and we here have been around and around this issue dozens of times, with talkorigins / you name it thrown in.

In essence, the various definitions of "species" are all moveable goalposts, most of them post hoc. :)


B.D.Z. said:
Maybe in some form of "abstract creative directionality" of some sort?
'What-is' characterized by a universal, say, Bergsonian-like 'elan vital' is a way to express the flavor of any creationism you would care to assign to me.

Atman=Brahman is another expression I'm comfortable with.
 
I think we agree then, but I also believe that we might differ in our use of the word "creationism". It doesnt exist in my worldview, because it is related to Christian's god.

Atman=Brahman is a more elegant way to put it. ;)
 
I propose no alternative. The questions and doubts that plague me are in the minutiae of details that are needed for one species to be altered sufficiently at dna level to be genotypically and phenotypically 'new, different, and viable over the longer term'. Those changes that have allowed the ancestors of green alga (or whatever) to reach human brain complexity in the sequence of lurches demonstrated in the fossil record are obviously a fait accompli.

As to being a creationist, I am not one that we could ever reach agreement on a definition of.

You use the term "neo darwinist"--that's creationist talk--so is referring to science as "faith". I think you know this, and it's dishonest. In Darwin's time evolution was a very good theory--now it is considered fact among biolgists.

As for speciation--We can see when species begin to diverge--they can mate, but their offspring are not fertile. Tigers and lions can make tigons and ligers (differences in cubs are based on whether the mother is the lion or tiger)--Horses and donkeys mate and produce mules which are sterile. Donkeys and Zebras can mate--I'm not sure if the offspring is sterile. Currently dogs and wolves are the same species--they can mate with eachother and produce fertile offspring--even wolves and chihuahuas. But if they are not mated on occasions, we can expect dogs and wolves to become divergent species. Speciation takes time in large organisms--insects and plants speciate quicker. Traveling kept humans from speciating. When you look at Chimpanzee DNA and Human DNA you can pretty much SEE how the DNA diverged--what the common ancestors DNA was likely to be--and how it mutated. Neanderthals are a separate species of hominid--although we may share genes with them from our common ancestor, humans do not have Neanderthal mitochondrial DNA nor do they have Neanderthal Y chromosomes.
If humans and Neanderthal mated, the offspring would likely have been sterile. Cells, bacteria, and viruses mutate all the time and become different organisms--hence chemo resistance, antibiotic resistance, and new flu strains.

It isn't really amazing when you grasp the amount of time and the number of sperm, eggs, and replication going on. Even if only 1 in a billion mutations or duplications or translocations are beneficial--that is still more than enough to give rise to every organism on this planet many times over. I think that you fail to grasp the utter scope of replication. Each human male ejaculation has 230,000,000 sperm! A 3 month old female human fetus has well over 50,000 eggs. Do you have any idea how many seeds there are in one dandilion puff? or in one sunflower? There is such an abundance of potential life all over this planet. Evolution is a ruthless, sometimes sloppy, often cruel, process filled with so much potential life that never gets to exist--but it only takes one fortuitous mutation to change the future hugely. Just the number of DNA fragments in the ocean is amazing. Life is an exponential process with a slow but ever accelerating start. The internet is very complex...the start was slow...now it's huge and growing huger--

Humans actually share some of the same genes as fruit flies--hox genes are the genes that give 3D directionality to an organism--head, tail, front, back, sides (arms, leggs, appendages). If you were to study DNA you can actually estimate how far back the common ancestor between you and any given life form existed...Moreover, the DNA shows that all Humans have a common male ancestor (human) which exists nearer in time to us than our common female ancestor (also human)--and every step of the evolutionary path backwards from that female is exactly the same for all humans...It's very very interesting and very very compelling and utterly profound.

Don't let your belief that science is a "faith" keep you from exploring the facts. You don't have to believe it--you can weigh the evidence for yourself. Really. A point mutation can make a huge phenotypic change. The doubts that plague you have answers--real ones--that you can see--but you can't learn genetics in a forum. And if you have a need to believe in an intelligent designer it might make you resistant to understanding--just as someone who believed that the bible was the "inerrant word of god" had trouble accepting that the earth was spherical and not the center of the universe.
 
Perhaps you think I'm not aware of, and have not considered all that, and even more. I have. And in many more areas of science too.

My distaste for evolutionary theory is part and parcel of my worldview which is objective idealism.

I try to keep abreast of (layman's) science; what do you think of, say, delayed choice quantum eraser double slit results? Fit that into your worldview. I keep testing mine against 'reality' as best I understand it.

Peace.
 
I try to keep abreast of (layman's) science; what do you think of, say, delayed choice quantum eraser double slit results? Fit that into your worldview. I keep testing mine against 'reality' as best I understand it.

Why would this fit "better" with objective idealism that with plain old physicalism?
 
I don't suggest it does. If one specific example were sufficient, we'd all agree. The totality of one's knowledge base as understood shades all answers. :)
 
We are "cursed" to understand throughout ourselfs? Yep, this is why is fascinating to try to learn beyond us.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom