Interesting Ian said:The neurophysiological evidence could not possibly be a compelling logical reason. It could only possibly aspire to a compelling empirical reason.
As far as I am aware the neurophysiological evidence merely consists in correlations between brain states and mental states.
It does not logically compel one to conclude that the brain is the genesis of consciousness. It merely provides evidence.
How can evidence possibly be irrelevant? Furthermore how is it possible to misunderstand me so much as to suppose that I think evidence is irrelevant.
Incredible.
Interesting Ian said:I suspect you really wouldn't be interested in what I consider to be evidence.
I'm perfectly satisfied with the fact that people have been having certain experiences of a certain character throughout history and across all cultures. That makes it prima facie likely that the paranormal occurs.
Completely and totally irrelevant. If someone pretends to have psychic powers, and they are unable to demonstrate such powers, this gives no evidence whatsoever against the existence of the paranormal or indeed the alleged talent in question.
If you think it's biased then your brain must be seriously damaged.
So Ian, I will repeat. What about extra terrestrial abductions? what about the malign satan? heck, what about santa? a fairly big percentage of humanity believes in him, I guess that points to santa being real.
Clearly biased:
"nothing more than biological machines"
"the apparent tight correlation between our states of consciousness"
"in saying that human beings are essentially nothing more than biological machines"
Besides... you say nothing new, your arguments have been used by so many people so many times that now its boring to read them again.
To me, a point where the faith aspect of science enters is that a materialist should believe *you* (or *i*) can be replaced by a Turing machine (i.e. a digital computer) and some reasonably sophisticated I/O.
Although I don't discount the possibility of physics-based life rather than chemical-based, that isn't what I was driving at.I suspect a turing machine would need to start as a more primative life form--and evolve.
Such is the neo-Darwinists faith ....It took humans eons to evolve from very simple life forms.
Any computer can in theory replicate brain function at the needed level of detail which indeed may involve QM effects at neurotransmitter level.Also, a computer runs via data and electricity--Although there are electrical components in a brain (and thus consciousness...as brain stimulation studies show), the mechanisms of action are primarily chemical ....
The possibility of whether a Turing machine can be created is not really an argument for consciousness outside the brain.
Given my comment above, why not? Soon, if not today. Unfortunately, I can't tell if you have "consciousness", either. I choose to believe both I, and You are "conscious".Certainly, we can invent a turing machine at a more basic level--say the level of a mouse...we can probably create a turing machine that acts almost identical to a mouse. We can't tell if it has "consciousness" nor can we tell if a mouse has "consciousness".
Er, that's what the I/O systems supply; again to whatever level of detail is needed, probably photon by photon, electron by electron, etc.We can presume that brains that have structures for fear, memory, pain receptors, sex drive, etc. have "feelings" and "experiences" that the turing machine doesn't have.
'But this is irrelevent to the fact that you need a brain to generate consciousness.
The created conciousness we are 'loading' onto the computer exists, today, presumably in each of us. Can we use yours for the test?You are confusing the issue with a non-useful hypothetical. If humans are to create consciousness, they would use the same materials that evolution used--DNA. And we already do that.
Subjects of merit, but not in this thread, imo.--so I suspect that anything that evolved would be different because it conained different building blocks. Currently, we can take DNA from egg and sperm and make a whole new consciouss human. We can clone many animals and generate new life forms from genetic modification. Natural selection for the survival of genes in DNA would not be the same selection used by computer data (viruses, software, etc.). It took an infintestimal number of fortuitous events to evolve the life forms we see on our planet today--without the same building blocks, it is extremely unlikely that we can imitate that same duplication.
The article basically says that consciousness appears to be generated in the brain but that he's going to challenge that assumption with an argument that he'll provide at some later time, doesn't it? I don't think he's providing the evidence yet...Lots of words--not much said.
People who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones!
![]()
Well I was concerned it was a bit short. But I feel it gets the point across without droning on about it.
Do you like what I've written or don't you?? I will be expanding upon the notion of electronic chips replacing neurons when I discuss the possibility of computers becoming conscious.
If people have any constructive comments on this section of my forthcoming website I've quoted, I'd be very pleased to hear about it. I keep changing it and making it better all the time.
Although I don't discount the possibility of physics-based life rather than chemical-based, that isn't what I was driving at.
Such is the neo-Darwinists faith
Any computer can in theory replicate brain function at the needed level of detail which indeed may involve QM effects at neurotransmitter level.
Note that you accept that as a proven fact. I and a few others here are less certain. We could I suppose discuss consciousness; brains certainly are involved in "animal consciousness" perceptions.
What you believe its irrelevant for the argument, if thats clear lets continue, why on earth such a mental experiment is important for you? First of all, the copy would have its own consciousness, and it will be someone with an identical body and identical memories. Whats the big deal about this?
Originally Posted by Ian :
From the materialist perspective a person is defined in terms of their psychological constitution. If this psychological constitution changes then the person literally changes. Compare what you are like now as to when you were a child. From a materialist perspective in what sense can you be said to be the same person? Your intelligence has changed, your interests have changed, your personality has totally changed. Your psychological constitution has completely and totally changed, and therefore you cannot literally be the same person. Indeed many other children are more similar to what you were like as a child than what you are now.
Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
Well, you didn't use scare quotes, but you did use scare italics. I am the same person because I have some of the same physical body and the same memories.
In what sense are you the same person from moment to moment in your metaphysic? Please select something that you can actually point to, as opposed to some concept whose sole purpose is to be the thing that is supposedly consistent.
I used the dupicator experiment to prove that for anyone who subscribes to materialism or supposes that the brain generates consciousness and conscious states are dictated by physical states of the brain, you have to believe that a continuous self is an illusion. This is staggeringly counter-intuitive.
We cannot point to consciousness since it is non-physical, and we cannot point to the self since it is non-physical.
Thanks. I'm reasonably conversant with the current thinking and eveidence used to support evolution.Actually, there is a compendium of evidence in support of evolution. It's called DNA. Darwin didn't even know about DNA--much less how beautifully it details many of the finer points of his theory. This evidence is growing everyday. Don't take my word for it...read a bit and learn for yourself. Although "Intelligent Designers" like to use terms like "darwinist" to make science seem like faith it's dishonest. Faith is belief without evidence. Evolution is as much of fact in the Biological world as a spherical earth is in the physical sciences. The evidence is getting increasingly evident and growing by leaps and bounds--in fact, we've mapped the whole human genome.
What is a soul? Burn your strawmen as suits you.I have seen my own chromosomes. Contrast that evidence to evidence for the soul-- a concept that seems true (just as the earth seems flat), but a concept for which eons of belief have produced no evidence.
You have a point somewhere in that common knowledge dump?Big words--bad thinking. Humans are very good at fooling themselves. They already apply this level of thinking to anthromoporphize all sorts of things included forces, weather, gods, etc. In fact, I suspect that there are word generators advanced enough to posit answers like yours at forums and convince people that they are "conscious". Certainly there are games such as chess being played online where there is one player does not know that the other player is a computer.
A Turing Machine, and the Turing Test are not the same thing. Cherished beliefs plague all of us sfaik.The Turing test just keeps you from defining what consciousness is or what it does so that you can keep it free from scientific inquiry...and keep your cherished beliefs in tact.
Darned if I know.And what happens to animal consciousness when the brain dies.
I don't.Why would someone presume that humans (who are in fact animals) would be different.
Er, yup. Some form of non-interactive dualism could be postulated to allow human memory stored 'elsewhere'. I make no such proposal.Humans are special to humans...but long after humans no longer exist, there may never be any entity that finds humans special at all...or even cares one bit about them. But there will be other life. Some will no doubt be animal life with a brain. What are you positing? How is death of a human different that blowing out a flame? What do you think is left? Certainly not memory. Because we can destroy all new memory formation by removing a hippocampus; therefore, we conclude that you need a hippocampus to make memory.
Again, so what? I wasn't discussing the Turing Test -- which makes no comment whatsoever on the question of consciousness, human or otherwise.John Edwards channels "entities" that pass the turing test. People have sacrificed to sun gods that pass the Turing test. Just because people apply meaning that is not there, doesn't mean that the conclusion is true. The computer generated psychologist ELISA passes the turing test at least some of the time.
Quite a diatribe. Again, not related to the topic of this thread I'm attempting to discuss.You are displaying your "intelligent design" promoter hand in your arguments. It's hard to take them seriously because no scientist considers them scientific. Moreover, they are dishonest and purposefully ignorant.
Frankly, I think computers learn at a much faster rate than you. You need to believe in the "soul" and your "intelligent designer" and you are not even open to examining much less understanding ANY paradigm whose notions don't conform with that belief.
Well, it's a good start...I just don't know what the evidence is yet. You say that consciousness can't be "perceptually perceived"--so I'm wondering how it is you DO perceive it. The invisible pink unicorns can't be perceived either--how is your definition of "consciousness" different?
I can make any claim I want about things not proven to exist (like invisible pink unicorns, souls, etc.) because there is nothing to test--but that doesn't make their existence more likely. How is perceiving oneself as "having" a soul less of an illusion than perceiving that the world is "flat".
It's hard to take what you are saying seriously without having these differences clarified. But the masses might find it fabulously interesting--they might "take" to it right away. So if your goal is to convince others or yourself--it is probably working.
If your goal is to take a skeptical approach so as not to fool yourself, it helps if you responds to questions rather than preach and assume.
Think about the questions without trying to make them fit into your predetermined conclusion that consciousness can exist outside the body--there is truly no good evidence for such a claim.
Religions are guilty of trying to make facts fit conclusions...but science follows the evidence to make their conclusions-- whether its the conclusion hoped for or not. Because humans are so very good at fooling themselves. To learn useful truths...it's important to minimize confirmation bias as much as possible. This is what a double blind test aims to do.
Are you interested in what IS true or what "feels" true? You can believe the moon is made of cheese all you want--it doesn't change the actual composition of the moon one bit. You can invent all sorts of tests which seem to confirm your predetermined conclusion about the moon--it still doesn't change the actual composition of the moon. You can willingly ignore and brush aside all evidence to the contrary--and still the moon remains unchanges. You can kill people in an effort to make the moon gods happy and make the moon more cheesy--and still the moon doesn't change.