What?
You're seriously claiming that consciousness doesn't exist? That it has the same existential status as "invisible pink unicorns"??
Why are we discussing anything then? Why do we get up in the morning? Why
??? if we're not conscious!
Oh no, Ian. Consciousness exists--in the brain. There is no more evidence for consciousness outside the brain then there is for the proverbial invisible unicorns. If there is, you sure haven't illuminated it in any way except in your own head.
Why are you talking about souls?? Why are you trying to run before you walk?
Wow, you mixed middle eastern mumbo jumbo in with your deception. Disembodied consciousness is generally referred to as souls...even if you are trying to convince yourself that the two invisible "entities" are different.
Well that's useful. So the fact that sometimes things are not quite what they seem means that absolutely nothing is . . .oh apart from the set of beliefs comprising the "skeptical" worldview.
So let's just believe in anything should we?
Actually, the fact that things are not as they seem goes to the core of science. We know very well that humans are good at fooling themselves--so we do everything possible to reduce false conclusions. If you want to roll your eyes at that, I sincerely think you are at the wrong forum. In regards to "let's just believe in anything"--I think it's very clear that this is far more applicable to your credulous self then to the majority of posters on this forum. But I find your sanctimonious dance of smoke and mirrors interesting.
It gives me insight as to how people convince themselves that things are true--like the 9-11 hijackers. To me it's a scam--kill for your god and you will get 72 virgins in a happy eternity. I am in awe that people could be intelligent enought to fly airplanes but so gullible when it came to their faith.
(Then again, Heavens Gate had members gifted enough to design websites, but gullible enough to believe that a spaceship was coming for them.) Would you die for your beliefs? Why not, if you don't believe that you really die?
Let's believe that we are not selves.
Let's believe that no-one has ever even been conscious . . . umm . . no . . .leave me out of this last one. It's possible that other people may not be conscious, but one thing that absolutely cannot be doubted by myself, and that is that I am conscious!
What? You say I have no scientific proof that I am conscious?? Let me tell you I don't give a damn about your scientific proof. Is there any so-called skeptic on here who has a smidgen of sanity?
Do you realize you derive false (and rather schizophrenic) interpretations from what people say? It reminds me of the fundies...how they must fit all their interpretations into the "truth" that the bible is the "inerrant word of god".
I'm not trying to convince anyone of anything. My intention is simply to educate people.
Well, you are doing that very well. You are a shining example of people hell bent on believing their cherished delusion.
Did you know that the 9-11 hijackers were trying to educate Americans so they wouldn't continue their "immoral" ways? What is it exactly you think we need educating about? Why don't you ever conclude that it's yourself that needs educating.
Eh? Where have I preached and assumed in that extract??
Well, your long winded diatribe suggesting that I said selves don't exist.
I was more than clear in saying that selves (consciousnes) etc. exist--IN THE BRAIN.
You really are completely clueless.
You may be the only person in the world who thinks that. However, many people on this forum have concluded exactly that about you.
QUOTE=I think you should try to convince others with your insane ravings. I think peoples' brains have been completely f***** up on here by selective "education" with this notion of a hypothetical "scientific method" and the notion that only that which has been scientifically "proved" should be accepted as existing. You all seem to be completely screwed up as far as I can ascertain. Have none of you ever tried to think for yourselves?? Study some philosophy of science for Christ sake.
Philosophy? like Dennet? He's an atheist philospher and I bet his education and I.Q. vastly outmeasure your own. That being said, philosphy isn't really about truth. It's math and science that bases conclusions on axioms and logic. The above rant sounds like the pouting christians that proselytize here.
Do you actually think there is going to be some evidence to prove god or disembodied consciousness will ever manifest? Have none of us tried to think for ourselves??!? I used to think kind of like you BEFORE I started thinking for myself...and before I got a science degree. I was naive.
I can feel the spittle from here.
It might be coming from you; you sound like someone who could have drooling problems.