To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

What does hope look like?
Sorry, couldn’t find hope, but here are a few other emotions for you.

Pain looks like this:
mri_pain_side.jpg


Love:
mri_love_side.jpg
mri_love_top.jpg


Fear:
mri_fear_side.jpg
mri_fear_top.jpg


Joy:
mri_joy_top.jpg


Smell:
mri_smell_front.jpg
mri_smell_top.jpg


Here is an PET scan of happiness:
5b59.jpg


and one of sadness:
5b510.jpg


http://www.nlm.nih.gov/hmd/emotions/frontiers.html
http://www.insidestory.iop.org/mri.html

I could probably find a few more, but I didn’t feel like digging to much on this one. A simple google search should turn up quite a few for you.
 
Last edited:
By Hammy's definiton, all who believe the earth is spherical are neo-Aristotlists

Neo-Ptolomists. Then you add the argument that if you believe the Earth is spherical, you must agree with the geocentric universe.
 
Sorry, couldn’t find hope, but here are a few other emotions for you.

Pain looks like this:
[qimg] http://www.insidestory.iop.org/images/mri_pain_side.jpg[/qimg]

Love:
[qimg]http://www.insidestory.iop.org/images/mri_love_side.jpg[/qimg][qimg]http://www.insidestory.iop.org/images/mri_love_top.jpg[/qimg]

Fear:
[qimg] http://www.insidestory.iop.org/images/mri_fear_side.jpg[/qimg][qimg]http://www.insidestory.iop.org/images/mri_fear_top.jpg[/qimg]

Joy:
[qimg] http://www.insidestory.iop.org/images/mri_joy_top.jpg[/qimg]

Smell:
[qimg]http://www.insidestory.iop.org/images/mri_smell_front.jpg[/qimg][qimg] http://www.insidestory.iop.org/images/mri_smell_top.jpg[/qimg]

Here is an PET scan of happiness:
[qimg] http://www.nlm.nih.gov/hmd/emotions/images/5b59.jpg[/qimg]

and one of sadness:
[qimg] http://www.nlm.nih.gov/hmd/emotions/images/5b510.jpg[/qimg]

http://www.nlm.nih.gov/hmd/emotions/frontiers.html
http://www.insidestory.iop.org/mri.html

I could probably find a few more, but I didn’t feel like digging to much on this one. A simple google search should turn up quite a few for you.


Beautiful...
But it still won't make a dent.

I wonder how we could scan hope...give people lottery tickets and scan them as the numbers are read?

Do you think Hammy could be a Turing Machine?--a veritible creationist word generator with a malfunctioning learning algorhythm?
 
Re the interesting pictures, something must be wrong with me; I felt none of the emotions portrayed. ;)


As to nooby's who think they know me, my discussion drives at the ontology underlying epistemology.

As to the current theory of evolution, yes, I do agree that some teleological aspects are not addressed, currently. Nor, imo, will they ever be by scientific methodology. The 'god-of-the-gaps' will always exist (or, as materialists prefer to address what otherwise is magic -- emergent properties). :)
 
A quale of colour is not an emotion.

If people assume that it is and more generally that mental states are literally physical states, then this is nothing but the reductivist materialist position.

This is peoples' argument.

1) Reductive materialism correctly characterises reality

2) Therefore only the physical exists.

3) All that which is physical is potentially measurable.

4) Therefore nothing exists that is not measurable.

5) selves/consciousness/souls are not physical.

6) Therefore souls/consciousness/selves do not exist.

There's just one very slight problem with this otherwise flawless superb argument . . . .


I deny reductive materialism!
(Indeed I have produced a refutation of this metaphysic many times on this board).
 
Ian said:
1) Reductive materialism correctly characterises reality

2) Therefore only the physical exists.

3) All that which is physical is potentially measurable.

4) Therefore nothing exists that is not measurable.

5) selves/consciousness/souls are not physical.

6) Therefore souls/consciousness/selves do not exist.
Isn't step 5 supposed to be:

5) selves/consciousness/souls are not measurable.

I can't address (5) unless we agree on good definitions of selves/consciousness/souls.

~~ Paul
 
Ian said:
It's precisely the same meaning. To say something is physical is to say it is measurable.
If you're going to leave (5) as is, then you don't need (3) or (4).

~~ Paul
 
Last edited:
1) Reductive materialism correctly characterises reality
2) Therefore only the physical exists.
3) All that which is physical is potentially measurable.
4) Therefore nothing exists that is not measurable.
5) selves/consciousness/souls are not physical.
6) Therefore souls/consciousness/selves do not exist.

Wrong wrong wrong wrong. Yes. Wrong. Your reasonement is plagued with your bias. Next time try to do it better.

The fact that reductive physicalism works towards describing (and defining) what we call "reality" suggest that physical things exist beyond us. Point to their ontological independence of us. Nothing more.

The proposition about that if something exists then its measurable is a working hypothesis, not a conclusion.

Science cannot say nothing about what is not measurable, and this is correct methodology, not a conclusion from the previous hypothesis

(doG how you like to complicate things, no wonder why you are so deeply confused)

Selves and souls are ideas, not ontological entities, consciousness is a process, and so far everything we have found indicates that it is clearly related to physical stuff. This certainly points towards consciousness as being part of the physical world, even if we cant yet understand it fully. Heck, we still cant even DEFINE it properly.

So, we have ZERO reasons to believe that selves and souls even exist in the first place (no Ian, subjective reports does not represent evidence), how can we think in discuss their ontological status??? For crying out loud, read some Voltaire.
 
Last edited:
Oh yes, Ian, and you are incorrectly (again) assuming that consciousness is not measurable... even when concrete examples have been given to you!

Amazing.
 
A quale of colour is not an emotion.

Question: how would "consciousness", apart from the brain, interact with it ?

1) Reductive materialism correctly characterises reality
2) Therefore only the physical exists.
3) All that which is physical is potentially measurable.
4) Therefore nothing exists that is not measurable.
5) selves/consciousness/souls are not physical.
6) Therefore souls/consciousness/selves do not exist.

Wrong. You got numbers 1, 4 and 6 wrong. Try again.

I deny reductive materialism!
(Indeed I have produced a refutation of this metaphysic many times on this board).

Merely saying you disagree does not constitute a refutation.
 
No, nothing that actually exists is measurable. Ultimately measurements only systematically relate our perceptual qualia.

Those photos are measurable evidence Ian. Asking people what they feel is evidence. Stimulating the brain and provoking those feelings or using drugs to stimulate those feelings or illuminating what parts of the brain are active (processing more sugars) are evidence. Facial expression and galvanic skin responses are evidence of qualia experiences or interpreted in the brain. All things that are proven to exist are measurable. Consciousness outside of a body is not measurable in any of the above ways--therefore, until evidence shows otherwise, it's safe to presume that consciousness does not exist outside of a brain. The brain is the object we use to describe our world, interpret sensory information, formulate memory, solve problems, draw analogies...
 
What?
You're seriously claiming that consciousness doesn't exist? That it has the same existential status as "invisible pink unicorns"??
Why are we discussing anything then? Why do we get up in the morning? Why??? if we're not conscious! :eek:

Oh no, Ian. Consciousness exists--in the brain. There is no more evidence for consciousness outside the brain then there is for the proverbial invisible unicorns. If there is, you sure haven't illuminated it in any way except in your own head.

Why are you talking about souls?? Why are you trying to run before you walk?

Wow, you mixed middle eastern mumbo jumbo in with your deception. Disembodied consciousness is generally referred to as souls...even if you are trying to convince yourself that the two invisible "entities" are different.

Well that's useful. So the fact that sometimes things are not quite what they seem means that absolutely nothing is . . .oh apart from the set of beliefs comprising the "skeptical" worldview. :rolleyes:

So let's just believe in anything should we?

Actually, the fact that things are not as they seem goes to the core of science. We know very well that humans are good at fooling themselves--so we do everything possible to reduce false conclusions. If you want to roll your eyes at that, I sincerely think you are at the wrong forum. In regards to "let's just believe in anything"--I think it's very clear that this is far more applicable to your credulous self then to the majority of posters on this forum. But I find your sanctimonious dance of smoke and mirrors interesting.
It gives me insight as to how people convince themselves that things are true--like the 9-11 hijackers. To me it's a scam--kill for your god and you will get 72 virgins in a happy eternity. I am in awe that people could be intelligent enought to fly airplanes but so gullible when it came to their faith.
(Then again, Heavens Gate had members gifted enough to design websites, but gullible enough to believe that a spaceship was coming for them.) Would you die for your beliefs? Why not, if you don't believe that you really die?

Let's believe that we are not selves.

Let's believe that no-one has ever even been conscious . . . umm . . no . . .leave me out of this last one. It's possible that other people may not be conscious, but one thing that absolutely cannot be doubted by myself, and that is that I am conscious!

What? You say I have no scientific proof that I am conscious?? Let me tell you I don't give a damn about your scientific proof. Is there any so-called skeptic on here who has a smidgen of sanity?

Do you realize you derive false (and rather schizophrenic) interpretations from what people say? It reminds me of the fundies...how they must fit all their interpretations into the "truth" that the bible is the "inerrant word of god".

I'm not trying to convince anyone of anything. My intention is simply to educate people.

Well, you are doing that very well. You are a shining example of people hell bent on believing their cherished delusion.

Did you know that the 9-11 hijackers were trying to educate Americans so they wouldn't continue their "immoral" ways? What is it exactly you think we need educating about? Why don't you ever conclude that it's yourself that needs educating.

Eh? Where have I preached and assumed in that extract??

Well, your long winded diatribe suggesting that I said selves don't exist.
I was more than clear in saying that selves (consciousnes) etc. exist--IN THE BRAIN.

You really are completely clueless.

You may be the only person in the world who thinks that. However, many people on this forum have concluded exactly that about you.

QUOTE=I think you should try to convince others with your insane ravings. I think peoples' brains have been completely f***** up on here by selective "education" with this notion of a hypothetical "scientific method" and the notion that only that which has been scientifically "proved" should be accepted as existing. You all seem to be completely screwed up as far as I can ascertain. Have none of you ever tried to think for yourselves?? Study some philosophy of science for Christ sake.

Philosophy? like Dennet? He's an atheist philospher and I bet his education and I.Q. vastly outmeasure your own. That being said, philosphy isn't really about truth. It's math and science that bases conclusions on axioms and logic. The above rant sounds like the pouting christians that proselytize here.
Do you actually think there is going to be some evidence to prove god or disembodied consciousness will ever manifest? Have none of us tried to think for ourselves??!? I used to think kind of like you BEFORE I started thinking for myself...and before I got a science degree. I was naive.

I can feel the spittle from here.
It might be coming from you; you sound like someone who could have drooling problems.
 
What does hope look like?

Irrelevant.

Even if you're right here, a description is not a measurement. A measurement is quantifying by a specific number of appropriate units.

Anyway, get it through your head that I do not regard physical processes as being literally one and the same thing as mental processes. Otherwise all things would be measurable rather than nothing being so.

I already told you that I define a soul as a self which survives the destruction of the body it is "housed" in.

I have no idea what these people mean by a soul who deny that test tube babies, clones/twins have a soul. What is this additional thing called a "soul"? What would it mean to lack this additional thing?? You say in the 70's. Are you saying these people have now changed their mind? If so then why have they?

My definition of soul? All of them. Something which is not a self and therefore is not conscious eg a boulder, cannot have feelings.

Just because you have no response doesn't mean that the issue is irrelevent.
Pictures actually are measurements. The kind of stuff that you can use to establish facts in a court of law are considered "evidence". Pictures count.

We understand your concept of soul. Most people subscribe to a similar notion. Most members on this forum probably believed that way for at least some of their lives. That doesn't make it true. You dance around the term "soul", but lets agree that it's a "disembodied form of consciousness" we are talking about--dualism...something separate from the brain. It's easier to write the shorter term, soul. So your definition of soul includes orgasm? How about pain? Do you think the souls of the hijackers experience orgasms in some afterlife. Can a soul be "cold"? Can you delineate what sort of qualia (feelings/ notions, etc.) are strictly brain processes, which are soul processess, and which are part of both.

Just because there are no brain scans developed for hope yet, doesn't mean it's a feeling that exists outside a brain. We already know that anti-depressents can increase hopefulness and that low serotonin can make people feel "hopeless".

If you are frustrated, consider the possibility that it might be because you are afraid of considering the fact that you might have been investing "hope" in a delusion.

I think that you have been very rude and pedantic to those who try to get you to think; moreover, I think it's ludicrous that you would come here hoping to "teach" us something. People would first have to conclude that you had expertise or knowledge in a particular field to even be interested. So far, you have not shown even basic scientific thinking skills and logic--such things like "confirmation bias", "corollation does not mean causation", "double blind studies"--this was especially evidenct in your eagerness to consider Natash has having "special powers". etc. At one time, it was hypothesized that X-rays could be used to see inside of people--the evidence accumulated and now X-rays are routinely used to see inside of people. No humans who have made such claims have amassed enough evidence to even warrant further study. This claim relies on a notion that has not shown evidence of being true (the notion that there is a "psychic force" of some sort allowing people to do things that defy understanding...)

This site is geared towards those who have a great desire for truth--who eagerly separate truth from illusion using the best tools available--evidence, science, measurement, axioms-- Of course, most forum members are probably also interested in how people fool themselves...and you are an excellent case for study.
 
What? You miss a word out here?

You should be more careful here. Walking is not a product of legs. You say yourself it is a process of legs. In other words walking is literally movements of legs. The analogy then says consciousness is just literally physical processes in the brain.

But consciousness is not a product of the brain just as walking is not a product of legs. At least that's the reductive materialist's premise*.

Excellent analogy by the way! Did you think of it yourself? I must use it in my website if you don't mind.

*Although it seems the vast majority of so called reductive materialists on here don't understand their own alleged position. Otherwise I wouldn't have to explain it!

Yes, I thought of the analogy myself. Use it in any way you please to convince yourself or others that consciousness outside the body exist.

I find it utterly amusing that you seem to think that scientific people across the world are going to slap their forheads and say, "damn, Ian was right--there is lots of evidence for the notion that consciousness can exist outside the body--thank you so much for leading me to this deeply satisfying "truth"!

Don't worry about explaining reductive materialism to anybody. Rest assured we do know what we mean--it boils down to the obvious: without a brain there is no "self" to be aware of. Sci-fi explanations are unnecessary. It's your unsupported but rabid belief in dualism that we find puzzling--that, and the notion that you believe you has something to teach us.

Still, I admire your tenacity and fortitude--though you seem as deluded as those who claim to have been abducted by aliens and assorted schizophrenics to me. We are all eagerly awaiting your evidence. Do let us know when you have some.
 
Neo-Ptolomists. Then you add the argument that if you believe the Earth is spherical, you must agree with the geocentric universe.

Thanks--I think. What would a neo-aristotlist believe? (I get my greek scientists mixed up). Can you come up with any other "neos" which would equate with "neo darwinist". I find the term amusing but misleading. There is so much more evidence (especially with the advent of DNA mapping) that clarifies Darwin's theory--so much so, that his theory is considered fact in the world of Biology--as factual as a spherical earth or pythagoreaus' theorem.
 
Re the interesting pictures, something must be wrong with me; I felt none of the emotions portrayed. ;)

Perhaps you ARE a turing machine!

As to the current theory of evolution, yes, I do agree that some teleological aspects are not addressed, currently. Nor, imo, will they ever be by scientific methodology. The 'god-of-the-gaps' will always exist (or, as materialists prefer to address what otherwise is magic -- emergent properties). :)

I think natural selection addresses ALL teleological aspects--what parts do you feel are not addressed. Yes, the "god of the gaps" will always exist in those who need to believe. I don't think there are as many "gaps" as you imagine. In a court of law, you can confidently convict someone of a crime without knowing all the details of that crime. There may be enough evidence to convict someone of murder even if there is not enough evidence to tell exactly how that murder occured. Evolution has quite and abundance of evidence that continues to amass.

Your discussion aims to discredit one notion without providing any explanation of an alternative--no matter what fancy words you want to use or how wise you view yourself or how superior to "noobs" you think you are. GIGO
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom