To what extent does: Science=Faith ?

Beliefs Should Not Outweigh The Supporting Evidence

I agree. But basically so what? It is not rational to disbelieve in something just because science has not vindicated it. To say the very least! A rational person looks at all the evidence and using his or her reasoning tries to judge where the truth lies.

I'm not simply rejecting the paranormal out of hand. There is an important probability factor involved in what I believe based on the thousands of years and many attempts that have failed to prove a single consistently verifiable effect of any paranormal claims.

It is not rational to adhere tenaciously to any belief without a substantial foundation to stand on to demonstrate why we should take it seriously.

A rational person looks at all the evidence and using his or her reasoning tries to judge where the truth lies.
I agree with that and I believe that's what I did. I couldn't find enough evidence of the paranormal to support any further belief in it and balanced that against the countless failed attempts of science to verify them too. As a result, in terms of probability, I came to favour the hypothesis that the reason we can't firmly prove such claims, is because it's most likely due to the claims being invalid more than any other single reason. For example, how many quests do we need to undertake in search of a mythical beast before we start to believe we're chasing an illusion and its time to stop, because in all probability, there really is no such animal? And should we still be arguing about their reality thousands of years later when not a single specimen has been found?

The impression I get is that if there is any truth to it, paranormal influences must be very, very weak in the extreme to be so difficult to prove scientifically after all these years.

I don't say supernatural things don't exist. I only maintain that if they do, it's outside science to contend with them since natural laws don't apply and science is founded firmly upon the observed 'laws' of nature.


One definition of supernatural is:

supernatural - Not existing in nature or subject to explanation according to natural laws; not physical or material.
Therein lies my problem.

Science is required stay within the realm of observable nature and all its theories must be founded upon natural observations - even the theories regarding things not yet proven or understood.

Science doesn't ask. "Who made the planets?", it only asks, "What are the natural laws of motion that govern their orbits?" Such things can be worked out, studied experimentally, a physical theory formulated and predictions made based on the theory. These predictions can be put to the test easily.

If something paranormal could be explained predictably in terms of the 'laws' of nature, then it wouldn't be a paranormal phenomena in the first place. It would be a scientifically verifiable fact and no reason left to doubt or wonder about it.

I'd like to see an experiment designed to test some paranormal claim and once and for all put that particular question to rest. But how does science test a claim that's not based upon any physically verifiable causes or known natural laws and is totally unpredictable?

The work of Helmut Schmidt is interesting and controversial. I have the published data from some of his experiments. The one glaring weakness in the data is that no correlation between the results and the forces he assumed caused them could be established. This means that although his results were remarkable, he hasn't proved the mind of the study subjects caused the observed results in any way. His methods gave no way to do this. No follow up experiments were ever done for some reason, so it's still an unresolved question, but worthy of further study.

:)
 
If the brain generates consciousness and consciousness states are wholly dictated by physical processes in the brain, then why on earth should you get a reassembled dead creature at the other end??

If you have an absolutely physically identical copy of you, then since the original generates consciousness, then necessarily the copy must do too. And the copy must be you in the fullest sense of the word.

Of course I believe you would simply get a corpse at the other end. But that's because I recognise consciousness is non-physical. Since the transporter is only duplicating that which is physical, it would not duplicate the consciousness. But anyone who subscribes to a materialist based metaphysic cannot believe you would get a corpse.
I don’t see why a materialist cannot believe you would get a corpse on the other end. You would have to make sure that every atom, every connection between neurons, every flowing electron, every chemical is in the proper receptor… and so on was exactly how it was on the first end. Sure if every thing was exactly the same in every way you should end up with a duplicate that is conscious with every memory contained in the original, but some of this just might be impossible.

Also, once neural connections are severed in the brain there doesn’t seem to be a way to replace them. Otherwise we’d be able to restore both functional abilities and memories in those that have been severely brain damaged in accidents. If we could reconnect neural connections like that we could literally revive a dead person, and then maybe we’d just have him or her answer theses questions for us. Unfortunately, the loss of neural activity seems permanent at this point. We would first have to overcome this little problem before one of your transporters could even be possible.
 
Didn't realise there had been further responses to this thread. I failed to receive any emails notifying me.



Not that this topic has anything whatsoever to do with this thread, but why do so called skeptics continually feel compelled to lie about this issue (as well as there being no evidence for paranormal phenomena). In both cases there is a huge amount of evidence.

And in response to articulett it's more of a case that there is no compelling reason to suppose that consciousness is ontological dependent on the brain. That coupled with all the evidence gives good prima facie support for the survival hypothesis.

Ian the topic of this thread was to what extent does science=faith. The talk turned to consciousness...I was trying to illuminate what properties those who believe in a consciousness outside the brain give to this consciousness.
If it's immeasurable in every way--it seem "imaginary". If it's a valid concept, we should be able to measure it or test it in some way.

Skeptics aren't lying about this issue. It's the evidence that's problematic. It contains things like "science can't explain X, so Y must be true". It draws conclusions from occurrences that are not warranted. If it rains after a rain dance--it doesn't mean that the rain dance caused the rain. Even if you saw some evidence that it happened a lot. You'd want to find out if there really was a connection and if it was a cause and effect mechanism. Perhaps hits were counted if rain happened within 3 days of a rain dance--but if rain also appeared when no rain dance had been done--that's a piece of evidence which shows that rain can occur without rain dances. You need to tease out the concepts that you are comparing and remove confirmation bias effects.
That's how we do science. That's how we know what we know. And look how good it works. Look at your computer, your t.v., your internet, x-rays, MRI's, medicine, etc. etc. Look at how much evidence we've uncovered in the last few years just on DNA that anyone and everyone (no matter what language they speak) can understand, measure, probe, question, and replicate. Darwin never even saw a chromosome.

And there are lots of reasons to believe that consciousness depends upon a brain. Examples are readily available in the brain damaged, demented, schizophrenic, epileptic, those who have brain tumors, the drugged, the blind, the deaf, the mentally retarded, the brain dead. Although we can't tell what a given person is thinking, we can see that they are thinking, feeling, fearing, remembering, confabulating...etc. Most neurologists do not believe in dualism (invisible soul which exists beyond death). If these souls exist, why don't they help out in the above mentioned scenarios. If a person's hippocampus is destroyed, s/he can't make any new memories. (side note: research Clive Wearing on the net for a truly fascinating case study--and a documentary on him called The Man With the Seven Second Memory) So if a "soul" exists--why doesn't that remember for the person? And what good is the idea of a "soul" if it has no memory. Without memory how could this invisible consciousness have any connection to what or where it had been? What attributes do you attribute to this "consciousness" Ian--does it have feelings? Feel pain? Hunger? Lust? Does it think (process knowledge)? We know that humans need brains to do this stuff--damaging the brain can alter or destroy these experiences. In what possible way could there be consciousness outside of a brain--what do you mean by consciousness??

You claim evidence where science sees anecdote, confirmation bias, shoddy testing, delusions, false conclusions, and wide-eyed naivete. Your so-called evidence is on par with conspiracy theory evidence, aliend abduction claims, and false memory syndrome. Science knows a lot about how people fool themselves. But Science has no evidence for consciousness outside the brain.

You claim that there is no evidence to prove that consciousness depends on a brain. Come on! If you go under anesthesia, you are alive but unconscious--you are not feeling or laying down memories--you are not dead because you will regain consciousness--your brain is still "plugged in". There are lots of ways people alter their consciousness, drugs, siezures, religion, electric probes, exercise, alcohol--we know that these drugs change subjective experience and that they work via the brain--What more evidence would you hope for. Saying consciousness exists outside the brain without providing one smattering of evidence is akin to saying that a flame exists it even after you blow out the candle. Sure the atoms in it exist--but not in the excitory gaseous congregation (conflagration?) we call a flame.

P.S. Welcome JayT, I enjoy your posts!
 
Last edited:
What??? We should have 2 definitions of consciousness?? I think not.

Ian--I read a quote in someone's sig that you are the one who brought in the notion of 2 consciousnesses--you said a rock rolling down a hill is conscious!
If someone is trying to eliminate this inanimate "consciousness" from the discussion, it's only because you put it there!
 
When Ian says "no compelling reason," he means "no compelling logical reason that I've ever thought of." He is not referring to neurophysiological evidence, because he has said that such evidence is irrelevant. There can be no empirical evidence that says anything about consciousness.

I predict he is completely safe, because (a) evidence is irrelevant; and (b) there is no logical argument in favor of or against the ontological status of consciousness. He's in a metaphysical Faraday cage.

~~ Paul

Thanks for the translation...
 
If you are not that consciousness, and bearing in mind that, being non-physical, consciousness cannot be perceptually perceived, then how would you obtain such evidence? By using the brain consciousness can make it's presence known when embodied. But how would it make its presence known when disembodied?

Ian, how is your "invisible consciousness" different than fairies. Maybe that will help us understand what this disembodied consciousness is. Do they hear? Care? Have emotions? Process information? Remember? Why should we give these disembodied consciousnesses more study than Scientology's thetens--or the assorted "vapors" thought to cause illness prior to modern medicine. How are these consciousnesses different than the rain god that rain dancers danced for? How is your belief about consciousness different than the belief that the earth is the center of the universe? Your arguments sound so similar to these examples, and I would like to think your beliefs are more supported than the above claims. How? Where? Why? Links? Evidence?
 
The neurophysiological evidence could not possibly be a compelling logical reason. It could only possibly aspire to a compelling empirical reason.

As far as I am aware the neurophysiological evidence merely consists in correlations between brain states and mental states. How therefore can this present compelling logical reasons to suppose that the mental has its genesis in the brain? It does not logically compel one to conclude that the brain is the genesis of consciousness. It merely provides evidence.
Incredible.

Are you familiar with embryology?...Are you aware than when a person has an extra copy of chromosome 21 there are brain differences and measurable behavioral differences? Do you know of the huge amount of data showing the various ages in which babies develop certain kinds of awareness (self awareness, awarenes that they operate their hands, memory for object hidden under a blanket, etc. Do you know that people in the throes of romantic love show a similar brain pattern (similar to eachother) when shown a picture of their beloved? A baby without a brain (anencephaly--still has brain stem) won't live more than a few days--any consiousness is at a very primative level--most can't even swallow...some can't maintain respiration...no brain=no consciousness.
 
Ian,
How is your belief about consciousness outside the body different from this statement.

1. Computer programs can run absent computers. (to me, your argument seems to be exactly that...)
 
I agree. But basically so what? It is not rational to disbelieve in something just because science has not vindicated it. To say the very least! A rational person looks at all the evidence and using his or her reasoning tries to judge where the truth lies.

It's irrational to jump to conclusions. A UFO is just an unidentified flying object--it a giant leap of credulity to claim it's a physical entity from another planet operating a "spacecraft". When UFO's become identified, the truth is far less fantastical....military experiments, weather balloons, st. elmos fire, etc.

Primitive people jumped to these sort of conclusions because they had not developed the tools of science and they were eager to understand and possibly control natural phenomena. Modern people have science--we measure, correllate, test, extrapolate, etc. to weed out belief from truth. We have tons of data regarding how people fool themselves. We employ double blind studies to tease out placebo effects and misinterpretations...That's science...it aims for the gut of truth.
 
Last edited:
Hi, Articulett

P.S. Welcome JayT, I enjoy your posts!

I like stimulating science debates, even if they do tend to stray a bit off topic sometimes, as long as they don't turn into ugly, insulting flame wars.

You seem to have your feet on the ground. That's a good quality needed for effective critical thinking.

Glad to make your acquaintance too.
:)
 
I suspect you really wouldn't be interested in what I consider to be evidence.
I'm interested in ALL evidence. Otherwise I wouldn't have inquired.

I'm not sufficiently familiar with the research and statistics to make me qualified to do that.
You are a master of the understatement!

That's like openly admitting that you are unqualified to wage an educated debate on the subject. Something that's been painfully obvious for some time now and why it's so difficult for those well learned in science to take you seriously.

You also clearly have a potent contempt for scientific opinion, knowledge and thinkers who have been trying in vain to politely point out some very severe errors in your reasoning only to be greeted with insults in return. That's not at all constructive.

Well, we tried.

You're the one who hasn't a clue as to how to conduct a well reasoned scientific debate in a mature and respectable manner. It only serves to lessen your credibility all the more and rightly so.

People who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones!


Of course you are free to believe whatever you want, but simply wanting to believe in something in spite of any logic, science or evidence to the contrary is the essence of base irrationality. Science simply doesn't work like that. Astrology does.

Nevertheless I still learned something from your interesting insights, so it wasn't a total loss.

But science is obviously not your cup of tea.




Cheers

:)
 
Last edited:
And there are lots of reasons to believe that consciousness depends upon a brain. Examples are readily available in the brain damaged, demented, schizophrenic, epileptic, those who have brain tumors, the drugged, the blind, the deaf, the mentally retarded, the brain dead. Although we can't tell what a given person is thinking, we can see that they are thinking, feeling, fearing, remembering, confabulating...etc. Most neurologists do not believe in dualism (invisible soul which exists beyond death). If these souls exist, why don't they help out in the above mentioned scenarios. If a person's hippocampus is destroyed, s/he can't make any new memories. (side note: research Clive Wearing on the net for a truly fascinating case study--and a documentary on him called The Man With the Seven Second Memory) So if a "soul" exists--why doesn't that remember for the person? And what good is the idea of a "soul" if it has no memory. Without memory how could this invisible consciousness have any connection to what or where it had been? What attributes do you attribute to this "consciousness" Ian--does it have feelings? Feel pain? Hunger? Lust? Does it think (process knowledge)? We know that humans need brains to do this stuff--damaging the brain can alter or destroy these experiences. In what possible way could there be consciousness outside of a brain--what do you mean by consciousness??

You claim evidence where science sees anecdote, confirmation bias, shoddy testing, delusions, false conclusions, and wide-eyed naivete. Your so-called evidence is on par with conspiracy theory evidence, aliend abduction claims, and false memory syndrome. Science knows a lot about how people fool themselves. But Science has no evidence for consciousness outside the brain.

You claim that there is no evidence to prove that consciousness depends on a brain. Come on! If you go under anesthesia, you are alive but unconscious--you are not feeling or laying down memories--you are not dead because you will regain consciousness--your brain is still "plugged in". There are lots of ways people alter their consciousness, drugs, siezures, religion, electric probes, exercise, alcohol--we know that these drugs change subjective experience and that they work via the brain--What more evidence would you hope for. Saying consciousness exists outside the brain without providing one smattering of evidence is akin to saying that a flame exists it even after you blow out the candle. Sure the atoms in it exist--but not in the excitory gaseous congregation (conflagration?) we call a flame.

P.S. Welcome JayT, I enjoy your posts!

First of all his posts are completely worthless. His assertions are simply contrary to reality.

Secondly I really don't have much time on the weekend. I'll respond to the more important posts on Monday. But for the time being, since you've obviously spent some time detailing the fact that mental states often can be shown to follow physical states of the brain. I just want to draw attention to the highlighted text.

This is yet another lie made by skeptics (which often gets repeated despite my continuous denials. I have said time after time that such correlations do indeed provide evidence for the hypothesis that the brain generates consciousness.

Tell you what. It seems that people don't believe me (either that or they are not reading my posts). So I will reproduce here the first section of my forthcoming website (after the introduction) where I discuss this. Perhaps people might then be convinced I understand this issue.

Reproduced below.

The apparent dependency of mind on brain and the brain as a physical mechanism


One apparently crucial criterion by which we should judge that we are essentially nothing more than biological machines is to ask ourselves whether the totality of our conscious experiences are completely generated and depend upon the brain. Now the most obvious and powerful evidence we have to support this thesis is the apparent complete dependency of our states of our minds on our brains. There is an abundance of evidence that suggests this dependency. Just to mention a couple of examples; our capacity to understand written and spoken words, or the capacity to speak, are impaired or even eliminated with injuries to certain regions of the brain. Damage to the hippocampal and thalamic areas of the brain can destroy one's ability to store new long-term memories. In addition radical personality change may be brought about by injury to the brain. The most famous example here is undoubtedly Phineas Gage(link). We can also point to the effects of drugs that have a propensity to effect our emotions, attitudes and dispositions. Indeed even alcohol and caffeine do this.

These facts regarding not only the apparent tight correlation between our states of consciousness and physical states of the brain, but, as in the examples cited, such conscious states following physical states of the brain, powerfully suggest to many people that processes in the brain generate consciousness, or, alternatively, that consciousness is simply another way of talking about brain processes – the thesis of materialism (footnote). But regardless of whether conscious states follow, or literally are brain processes, it is held that such apparent complete dependency of conscious states on the state of the brain almost certainly shows that consciousness, or more generally the mind, has its source entirely in the brain. If this is so then our mental lives simply will reflect everything that goes on in the brain. In other words it is brain processes that completely dictate our mental processes. Hence everything we have ever thought, every emotion we have ever undergone, and more generally everything we have ever experienced is completely caused or determined by the physical processes occurring in our brains.

Now there is an implicit assumption that all physical processes follow physical laws. By physical laws we are simply referring to the regularities that we observe in nature. Thus, possibly the most obvious example we could point to here is the law of gravitation that accounts for the fact that objects, near the surface of the Earth, will, when released, fall at pretty much the same acceleration. The fact that the world exhibits such regularities allows us not only to predict future events, but also allows us to exercise a degree of control over our environment. Thus modern times has witnessed a bewildering proliferation of various machines capable of carrying out all sorts of tasks. But no matter how complex such machines might be, ultimately they are simply operating according to such physical laws that we have observed, and their behaviour is just as explicable with reference to physical laws as the motion of an apple is when released.

Thus, with reference to the physical processes occurring in our brains, the crucial question that needs to be raised here is to ask ourselves if there is any reason to suppose that the physical processes occurring here should constitute an exception. At first blush it might seem reasonable to suppose that these physical processes simply follow physical laws too. If this is so then the totality of our behaviour -- which would be the direct result of such physical processes -- will be as rigidly determined as any other process in the Universe including the behaviour of man-made machines. And of course given the point already made that it seems that all mental processes simply follow physical processes occurring in the brain, all mental processes will be rigidly determed too. If all this is correct then it might seem that our initial gut rejection of the notion that we are no more than super sophiticated machines loses much of its force. Indeed, if the totality of our behaviour, including everything we ever say, or think, or experience follows physical laws, then it seems that it should, at least in principle, be eventually possible to construct a machine that operates in a similar manner to the human body, and more specifically the human brain. Given that the brain does indeed generate consciousness then presumably such a machine would be conscious too in precisely the same way.

Especially pertinent to our consideration here are those machines labelled computers. Computers can now carry out many tasks that were formerly thought to be exclusively a preserve of the human intellect. It is now possible to program a computer that can outperform the best chess players in the world. We even have computers that can carry out rudimentary conversations with people. These computers, at least for a while, might well manage to fool us into believing that we are conversing with a genuine person.

One immediate objection to all this might be to point out that we grow and also modify our behaviour as a result from input from the environment; that is to say we learn from experience. Indeed, not just human beings do this, but all organisms do. This is in contrast to man-made machines, which, once constructed, do not generally change their internal organisation. This entails that, unlike us and all other organisms, given the same input from the environment, they will always exhibit the same behaviour. Therefore how can it be maintained that we are merely machines?

But the claim here is not that human beings are at all similar to today's machines. No, in saying that human beings are essentially nothing more than biological machines, we are talking about what machines could achieve in principle. And it is clear that we can have machines that can adapt and change, and even learn according to the input from its environment. Indeed, to a limited extent, some computers can already do precisely this. In short this objection does not hold water.

It should also be pointed out here that even if one successfully argued against the notion that the brain operates on similar principles to a computer, it arguably would still operate according to physical laws. Thus the brain would still be a machine, and, at least in principle, could be created with a sufficiently advanced technology. Putting it another way, why should brains be the only type of thing in the Universe that do not operate according to physical laws? And if they do operate according to such laws, then why suppose we differ in principle from any machine? We might admittedly be very complex machines, but essentially machines nevertheless.

Let's consider this point from a different angle. Our brains consist of billions of neurons. It seems reasonable to suppose that neurons simply operate according to physical laws just as much as anything else in the Universe. What would happen if we replaced one of our neurons with an electronic circuit that carries out the exact same function as the neuron had? If it carried out the exact same function would it not be the case that we would notice no difference whatsoever? Furthermore we can imagine all our neurons getting replaced one by one until such electronic circuits had replaced every last one of our neurons. In this case we would have an electronic brain, and yet it seems we should still be conscious and indeed feel exactly the same! Of course it might be argued that no electronic circuit could ever duplicate the functioning of a neuron. But even if this is so, if in common with all other physical processes in the Universe the neuron functions according to physical laws, then, at least in principle, some type of artificial neuron is possible, even if it were to be forevermore beyond our ability to create!

To sum up: The argument that many people make is that we have no compelling reason to suppose we are different from any other object in the Universe, and thus, in common with all other objects, we are equally as susceptible to physical laws as any other object. In particular, although the brain is extremely complex in its operation, there is no cogent reason to suppose that it is qualitatively different from what a complex man-made machine could theoretically achieve. We might feel that we are different from any other object in the Universe, but the foregoing considerations might make us feel disposed to conclude that it is not a difference in kind we are talking about here, but rather merely a difference in degree. This notion is especially persuasive when we note that mental states, including our emotions, dispositions, attitudes and general personality, can all apparently be affected by injury or alteration to the brain thereby implying that the source of consciousness is within the brain. Hence this being so it might seem that a sensible position is to suppose that we are, indeed, essentially machines.

For the time being I want to defer criticising these arguments. I shall argue against the notion that our behaviour is just as susceptible to physical laws as any other physical thing or process where I discuss the free will issue in section ******. The notion that given the evidence consciousness must necessarily be produced by the brain will be challenged in section ******. For the time being though I want to explore how consciousness could conceivably be assimilated into our scientific understanding of the world. To do this we need to take a look at a philosophical position known as materialism and to explore the nature of scientific explanation.
 
Originally Posted by Interesting Ian:

"I'm not sufficiently familiar with the research and statistics to make me qualified to do that. I'm perfectly satisfied with the fact that people have been having certain experiences of a certain character throughout history and across all cultures. That makes it prima facie likely that the paranormal occurs."

My response:

Utterly and completely absurd. The day you understand why you will realize what we have explained to you all the time.

Several people report that they have been abducted, why dont you claim that abductions are real and that there are aliens on earth?

Several people report that they have been raped in satanical rites. Why we never hear from you that this proves that satan is real?

You choose the reports that suit your beliefs, and you immediately close your mind to anything else. By this logic, every religious who believe in satan will find "the evidence" they need. What does this proves?

So Ian, I will repeat. What about extra terrestrial abductions? what about the malign satan? heck, what about santa? a fairly big percentage of humanity believes in him, I guess that points to santa being real.
 
Last edited:
Reproduced below.

Clearly biased:

"nothing more than biological machines"

"the apparent tight correlation between our states of consciousness"

"in saying that human beings are essentially nothing more than biological machines"

Besides... you say nothing new, your arguments have been used by so many people so many times that now its boring to read them again.
 
Ego??? I don't know what you mean by "ego". It kinda insinuates the notion of a self cut off from others and being solely concerned with personal selfish satisfactions. I have very grave reservations that ego equates to "self".

Why don't you stop cheating and address what I was saying?????

So, you can use the words you want, with the meaning you choose, but if I do it you feel annoyed? Welcome to our world!

Forget about the "ego", im refering to the self.
 
Last edited:
Clearly biased:

"nothing more than biological machines"

"the apparent tight correlation between our states of consciousness"

"in saying that human beings are essentially nothing more than biological machines"

Besides... you say nothing new, your arguments have been used by so many people so many times that now its boring to read them again.

If you think it's biased then your brain must be seriously damaged.
 
No. Unless conscious is causally efficacious, then by definition it cannot be studied by science. How can science study something which has absolutely no effect on the world whatsoever?

But the world affects IT, however. There is a strong causal link there. There is a huge number of chemicals that, if you pump some in your body, will completely alter your perception, personality or memories. What's left outside of these ?

Your body gets destroyed and another created at a remote location. So you experience your consciousness jump from one body as it gets destroyed, to the other as it gets created. How dissimilar does the brain have to be before you wouldn't experience out of it?

Of course, the original consciousness is DESTROYED each time. Each copy believes that it is the original, but they are not. The original mind was wiped out with it.
 
If you are not that consciousness, and bearing in mind that, being non-physical, consciousness cannot be perceptually perceived, then how would you obtain such evidence? By using the brain consciousness can make it's presence known when embodied. But how would it make its presence known when disembodied?

You're assuming your conclusion, here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom