JayT
Critical Thinker
- Joined
- Feb 10, 2005
- Messages
- 319
Beliefs Should Not Outweigh The Supporting Evidence
I'm not simply rejecting the paranormal out of hand. There is an important probability factor involved in what I believe based on the thousands of years and many attempts that have failed to prove a single consistently verifiable effect of any paranormal claims.
It is not rational to adhere tenaciously to any belief without a substantial foundation to stand on to demonstrate why we should take it seriously.
The impression I get is that if there is any truth to it, paranormal influences must be very, very weak in the extreme to be so difficult to prove scientifically after all these years.
I don't say supernatural things don't exist. I only maintain that if they do, it's outside science to contend with them since natural laws don't apply and science is founded firmly upon the observed 'laws' of nature.
One definition of supernatural is:
Science is required stay within the realm of observable nature and all its theories must be founded upon natural observations - even the theories regarding things not yet proven or understood.
Science doesn't ask. "Who made the planets?", it only asks, "What are the natural laws of motion that govern their orbits?" Such things can be worked out, studied experimentally, a physical theory formulated and predictions made based on the theory. These predictions can be put to the test easily.
If something paranormal could be explained predictably in terms of the 'laws' of nature, then it wouldn't be a paranormal phenomena in the first place. It would be a scientifically verifiable fact and no reason left to doubt or wonder about it.
I'd like to see an experiment designed to test some paranormal claim and once and for all put that particular question to rest. But how does science test a claim that's not based upon any physically verifiable causes or known natural laws and is totally unpredictable?
The work of Helmut Schmidt is interesting and controversial. I have the published data from some of his experiments. The one glaring weakness in the data is that no correlation between the results and the forces he assumed caused them could be established. This means that although his results were remarkable, he hasn't proved the mind of the study subjects caused the observed results in any way. His methods gave no way to do this. No follow up experiments were ever done for some reason, so it's still an unresolved question, but worthy of further study.

I agree. But basically so what? It is not rational to disbelieve in something just because science has not vindicated it. To say the very least! A rational person looks at all the evidence and using his or her reasoning tries to judge where the truth lies.
I'm not simply rejecting the paranormal out of hand. There is an important probability factor involved in what I believe based on the thousands of years and many attempts that have failed to prove a single consistently verifiable effect of any paranormal claims.
It is not rational to adhere tenaciously to any belief without a substantial foundation to stand on to demonstrate why we should take it seriously.
I agree with that and I believe that's what I did. I couldn't find enough evidence of the paranormal to support any further belief in it and balanced that against the countless failed attempts of science to verify them too. As a result, in terms of probability, I came to favour the hypothesis that the reason we can't firmly prove such claims, is because it's most likely due to the claims being invalid more than any other single reason. For example, how many quests do we need to undertake in search of a mythical beast before we start to believe we're chasing an illusion and its time to stop, because in all probability, there really is no such animal? And should we still be arguing about their reality thousands of years later when not a single specimen has been found?A rational person looks at all the evidence and using his or her reasoning tries to judge where the truth lies.
The impression I get is that if there is any truth to it, paranormal influences must be very, very weak in the extreme to be so difficult to prove scientifically after all these years.
I don't say supernatural things don't exist. I only maintain that if they do, it's outside science to contend with them since natural laws don't apply and science is founded firmly upon the observed 'laws' of nature.
One definition of supernatural is:
Therein lies my problem.supernatural - Not existing in nature or subject to explanation according to natural laws; not physical or material.
Science is required stay within the realm of observable nature and all its theories must be founded upon natural observations - even the theories regarding things not yet proven or understood.
Science doesn't ask. "Who made the planets?", it only asks, "What are the natural laws of motion that govern their orbits?" Such things can be worked out, studied experimentally, a physical theory formulated and predictions made based on the theory. These predictions can be put to the test easily.
If something paranormal could be explained predictably in terms of the 'laws' of nature, then it wouldn't be a paranormal phenomena in the first place. It would be a scientifically verifiable fact and no reason left to doubt or wonder about it.
I'd like to see an experiment designed to test some paranormal claim and once and for all put that particular question to rest. But how does science test a claim that's not based upon any physically verifiable causes or known natural laws and is totally unpredictable?
The work of Helmut Schmidt is interesting and controversial. I have the published data from some of his experiments. The one glaring weakness in the data is that no correlation between the results and the forces he assumed caused them could be established. This means that although his results were remarkable, he hasn't proved the mind of the study subjects caused the observed results in any way. His methods gave no way to do this. No follow up experiments were ever done for some reason, so it's still an unresolved question, but worthy of further study.