There is No God (And You Know It)

Well, it depends on how the god is defined. If it is defined as "most infinitely powerful god beyond which is impossible in theory" then this is nonsense. Any god you can imagine, I can imagine an infinitely more powerful one. And more powerful than that. And so on.
There is nothing necessarily contradictory about the concept of a maximally powerful being. At the risk of being slightly reductive - since a complete, formal expression of omnipotence would be a little more complicated - a being who, at any given moment, can actualize all states of affairs that are logically able to be actualized at such moment, is maximally powerful. I would submit that you can't imagine a being more powerful than that. It would be like imagining a square circle - you might claim to have imagined one, but we'd know you really didn't. It would just be so much meaningless verbiage.
 
If God prevented all events from happening that could cause harm to others, then God would be preventing a significant amount of free will. If free will is a greater good than a world where nobody could be harmed, then an omnibenevolent God would have no reason to prevent such things from occurring. And yes, I have been paying attention.

How would preventing consequences prevent the cause ?

I'm not shifting the burden of proof, you are. The topic of the thread was that there is no God. That is a positive claim which requires its own burden of proof, just like the claim that there is a God (which I never made).

Isn't it actually a negative claim ? Or something ?
 
Would absence of evidence when evidence should be expected be evidence of absence ?

It might, except that there's no reason to assume that there would be evidence of God if God didn't want there to be. So in this case "when evidence should be expected" doesn't hold.

-Bri
 
How would preventing consequences prevent the cause ?

This has already been discussed. If God wants us to choose good over evil, he must allow us to choose evil.

Isn't it actually a negative claim ? Or something ?

No, the claim that there are no gods is a positive claim, and must be backed by evidence just like the claim that there is a God.

-Bri
 
This has already been discussed. If God wants us to choose good over evil, he must allow us to choose evil.



No, the claim that there are no gods is a positive claim, and must be backed by evidence just like the claim that there is a God.

-Bri

How about the claim that there is no quality evidence for God?
 
It might, except that there's no reason to assume that there would be evidence of God if God didn't want there to be. So in this case "when evidence should be expected" doesn't hold.

Wouldn't that be inconsistent with the belief requirement for entrance into Heaven ?
 
This has already been discussed. If God wants us to choose good over evil, he must allow us to choose evil.

Er... ok. That doesn't really answer the question. If the consequences to other people didn't occur, then we could still do anything we wanted.
 
How about the claim that there is no quality evidence for God?

The quality of evidence is subjective, but it can be just as easily be argued that there is no quality evidence that there are no gods.

-Bri
 
Wouldn't that be inconsistent with the belief requirement for entrance into Heaven ?

How so? By the way, not all religions believe in heaven and hell the same way that the Christian religion does.

-Bri
 
Er... ok. That doesn't really answer the question. If the consequences to other people didn't occur, then we could still do anything we wanted.

If shooting someone with a gun didn't kill them, the act of shooting someone with a gun would no longer be evil since it wouldn't hurt them. There would be no more evil acts if nothing you could do would hurt another person, which would preclude the ability to choose evil.

This leads us back to what ceo_esq said a few pages ago here.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
ceo_esq
The defined Christian god already breaks numerous logical rules so what’s a few more?
That's a hefty claim. If that were the case, it would be possible to disprove his existence, which so far as I am aware no one has ever satisfactorily been able to do. Which rules did you have in mind?
Since there are literally thousands of variations I’ll just list a couple.
Free willed determinism
Omnibenevolent sadist
The inscrutable law giver

It is a logical impossibility, which in my view makes it impossible to construct mentally. It's just a nonsensical combination of words. A square circle cannot exist anywhere, even as an abstraction in the mind.
Ah, remember god is beyond human understanding as is a square circle.

Bri
The mother's, of course. The mother is the one who chose to smoke crack and get pregnant.

Who would you blame for crack babies without God?
The mother, society – the typical culprits.

Without God, do you claim that being born addicted to crack is a punishment?
No.

If not, then why would you assume that it is a punishment if God exists?
Because the bible explicitly states that God punishes children to the fourth (or fifth) generation for the sins of their parents. It blatantly obvious that a new born could not have done anything to warrant such punishment. So god must be punishing it for the sins of it’s parent, grandparent, great grandparent, or great, great grandparent.

Prove that they don't. The subject of the thread is about proving that there is no God, not about proving that there is a God.
I never said they don’t. I keep saying that they are needless suffering. Sure little Timmy has to die, but does he need to be tortured for two years before that? There are much quicker ways that don’t involve a slow horrifying death.

Are you saying that Barney doesn't exist? Who's the annoying purple dinosaur I see on TV then?
That would be someone in a costume, I’m talking about the REAL BARNEY.

Ossai
 
Because the bible explicitly states that God punishes children to the fourth (or fifth) generation for the sins of their parents. It blatantly obvious that a new born could not have done anything to warrant such punishment. So god must be punishing it for the sins of it’s parent, grandparent, great grandparent, or great, great grandparent.

Oh, so now we're talking about only the Christian God. Mind you, this discussion would have no bearing on the existance of all gods and so it is somewhat off-topic.

I never said they don’t. I keep saying that they are needless suffering.

You implied that crack babies and Pontine tumors don't increase the greater good by your use of the word "needless." If they increased the greater good, the suffering wouldn't be needless.

Sure little Timmy has to die, but does he need to be tortured for two years before that? There are much quicker ways that don’t involve a slow horrifying death.

This is an appeal to emotion. Awful as it may seem, little Timmy's suffering might somehow increase the greater good.

That would be someone in a costume, I’m talking about the REAL BARNEY.

What??? Barney isn't real??? Next you're going to tell me the Tooth Fairy isn't real!

-Bri
 
Since there are literally thousands of variations I’ll just list a couple.
Free willed determinism
Omnibenevolent sadist
The inscrutable law giver

As for your first example, several solutions have been proposed to show that there is no necessary logical contradiction between divine foreknowledge and human freedom. I already gave you a link to a discussion of this.

As for your second example, it appears to be an allusion to the logical problem of evil. Yet the logical problem of evil has been shown not to exist. Even hardcore atheologians have basically discarded it, as I have mentioned elsewhere, in favor of evidential or probabilistic (rather than logical) versions of the problem of evil.

As for your third example, I'm not sure what logical contradiction you think arises from it.

Ah, remember god is beyond human understanding as is a square circle.
A square circle is beyond human understanding in a qualitatively different way than the God of classical theism is beyond human understanding. God is said to be beyond human understanding, I take it, because human faculties of reason and cognition are not sufficient to comprehend God exhaustively. If human beings were able to apply enough brainpower and information to the problem (a practical but not a logical impossibility), we could presumably understand God. Yet no amount of brainpower and information will ever enable someone to understand a square circle. Unlike the ways of the God of classical theism, a square circle is not a meaningful phenomenon so transcendent or complex that it superficially appears to be gibberish. It really is gibberish. There's no there there for anyone to figure out. Even God, if he really existed, couldn't figure out a square circle.
 
But suppose - for just a moment - that there is a 'logical shell' in which our observable universe exists within, and then that there is a 'nonlogical shell' in which such a being as a God unbound by logic exists within - perhaps this 'universe' and its logical physics and systems exists as some sort of field within a wider 'whatever'...

Oh, am I discussing multiversial or multidimensional theory?

Just something to think about.

Your post inspired mine, but haven't read the entire thread, so please forgive me if I'm repeating what others have said. This post is along the lines of thoughts I have regarding the nature/existance of a creator.

I sometimes comtemplate computer viruses. They exist and I've no doubt there are feral mutating spambots out there in the net. I imagine them evolving into sentient reproducing ...hmmm... beings? entities? ...I don't know what to call them. I don't think such exist at this time, but I think it quite possible they will someday. Viruses are out there, reproducing and mutating at a fantastic rate, so it seems a reasonable speculation to me that such creatures could evolve.

What would such creatures think of us? We live in a totally different dimensional universe than they. How could or would they concieve of lifeforms that are biologically based and live in dimensions they cannot access?

Anyway, if God or gods exist, I imagine it/they are as different from us as we are from my imaginary evolved_from_computer_viruses beings. Would they postulate a creator for their universe? It would, after all, be reasonable to do so. Their world would have been created and their original forms designed by humans. Could a theistic computer creature convince his/her athiest compatriots of the invisible unknowable beings that created their world but do not exist within it? Would the atheistic creatures compose logical arguments that sound like the ones on this forum?

In the end, I don't think we can know with certainty what, if anything, exists beyond the boundaries of our material world.
 
How so? By the way, not all religions believe in heaven and hell the same way that the Christian religion does.

True. But if your hypothesis is that there is a God that cannot be observed, does not want to be observed and serves no function whatsoever except to make your hypothesis true... do I need to tell you what that means ?
 
If shooting someone with a gun didn't kill them, the act of shooting someone with a gun would no longer be evil since it wouldn't hurt them. There would be no more evil acts if nothing you could do would hurt another person, which would preclude the ability to choose evil.

Sure. However, taking crack can result in consequences that don't have to affect the baby. In many circumstances the "evil" to others is unnecessary. Hence the term, unnecessary evil.
 
Free willed determinism
Omnibenevolent sadist
The inscrutable law giver

How does that prove that God broke the laws of logic ? What's free willed determinism ? How can you have free will if the universe is completely deterministic ?

Ah, remember god is beyond human understanding as is a square circle.

And just like the squared circle...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom