There is No God (And You Know It)

I'm not sure I understand your point. If we can know the difference between good and bad without God (as strong atheists believe), then we can know the difference between good and bad with God, even if we don't know for certain that he exists.

The problem is, if God exists it becomes an entirely new game. As an atheist, I don't believe in an absolute, objective moral. We all see it differently, though we can mostly agree on the basics. A hypothetical alien species could see things completely differently and still be "right" about it.

But if God exists, then it could be argued that there is an absolute, objective moral. A "true" morality, if you will. In this case, it becomes important for us to know what that moral is, without too much confusion. Otherwise we can't be held liable if we don't follow God's moral code.

Our job is simply acting in a moral way, which we can undoubtedly do even if we don't know for certain that God exists and even if we can't know the greater good. Some theists even believe that God has written down for us how we should behave (i.e. the Bible) so that we know how to act even if God doesn't tell us directly.

Unfortunately there's the crux of the problem. Which religion do we choose ? Are any of them true ? God's not helping, here. It's pretty obvious that Islam and Christianity have very different takes on morals right now. Assuming there's a God, I sure as hell would like to know what's the right path. Then, I can exercise my free will in full knowledge.
 
The problem is, if God exists it becomes an entirely new game. As an atheist, I don't believe in an absolute, objective moral. We all see it differently, though we can mostly agree on the basics. A hypothetical alien species could see things completely differently and still be "right" about it.

But if God exists, then it could be argued that there is an absolute, objective moral. A "true" morality, if you will. In this case, it becomes important for us to know what that moral is, without too much confusion. Otherwise we can't be held liable if we don't follow God's moral code.

Most religions that believe that we are held liable for not following God's moral code also believe that God provided us his moral code in some way (either we know it intuitively, or else he gave it to us in written form, such as the Bible).

Unfortunately there's the crux of the problem. Which religion do we choose ? Are any of them true ? God's not helping, here. It's pretty obvious that Islam and Christianity have very different takes on morals right now. Assuming there's a God, I sure as hell would like to know what's the right path. Then, I can exercise my free will in full knowledge.

I cannot speak for any religion, much less all of them. These are perfectly valid questions, and each religion has a different way of dealing with questions like these. I'm simply pointing out that you cannot prove that no God exists.

-Bri
 
Most religions that believe that we are held liable for not following God's moral code also believe that God provided us his moral code in some way (either we know it intuitively, or else he gave it to us in written form, such as the Bible).

Are you purposely appealing to belief instead of reason ? Who cares what they believe in ? The point is that it's obvious that God's alleged moral code is NOT self-evident.

I cannot speak for any religion, much less all of them. These are perfectly valid questions, and each religion has a different way of dealing with questions like these. I'm simply pointing out that you cannot prove that no God exists.

Depends on your definition of God. I think we're pretty safe in our assumption that a God that defies the laws of logic cannot exist. But there are a number of "gods" from other religions who are nowhere near the level of power claimed for the christian God, for example. If we use a definition of "god" that is physically possible, then you're right. So, to what god are you referring to ?

Edited: changed "laws of physics" for "laws of logic" thanks, jjramsey. Belz... sleepy.
 
Last edited:
I think we're pretty safe in our assumption that a God that defies the laws of physics cannot exist.

:jaw-dropp After all the discussion about the distinction between the logically possible and the physically possible, I find it remarkable that you think that you are "pretty safe" in that assumption.

Is it safe to assume that a God that defies the laws of logic cannot exist? Sure. But a God that merely defies the laws of physics? That may be ruled out as improbable on other grounds, such as lack of evidence for such a God, but not ruled out altogether as a logical impossibility.
 
:jaw-dropp After all the discussion about the distinction between the logically possible and the physically possible, I find it remarkable that you think that you are "pretty safe" in that assumption.

Is it safe to assume that a God that defies the laws of logic cannot exist? Sure. But a God that merely defies the laws of physics? That may be ruled out as improbable on other grounds, such as lack of evidence for such a God, but not ruled out altogether as a logical impossibility.

Oops. I meant to say "laws of logic". Guess I was dozing off!!
 
But suppose - for just a moment - that there is a 'logical shell' in which our observable universe exists within, and then that there is a 'nonlogical shell' in which such a being as a God unbound by logic exists within - perhaps this 'universe' and its logical physics and systems exists as some sort of field within a wider 'whatever'...

Oh, am I discussing multiversial or multidimensional theory?

Well, the problem that I see with such a theory is that God, having successfully created a bubble where logic must hold true, would then only be able to interact with that bubble in some consistant logical manner. In other words, having created the Universe, God would no longer be omnipotent, within that universe, and would have to find ways to interact within that universe that are consistant with the logic of that universe.

Occam's Razor, of course, tears this to shreds. But it might be worth pondering, at least in the abstract. Could explain why God is so miffed at the whole evil problem, why God seems to be such a putz in the Bible, and why God would have to 'incarnate' to teach people lessons...

Just something to think about.
 
But suppose - for just a moment - that there is a 'logical shell' in which our observable universe exists within, and then that there is a 'nonlogical shell' in which such a being as a God unbound by logic exists within - perhaps this 'universe' and its logical physics and systems exists as some sort of field within a wider 'whatever'...

Oh, am I discussing multiversial or multidimensional theory?

Well, the problem that I see with such a theory is that God, having successfully created a bubble where logic must hold true, would then only be able to interact with that bubble in some consistant logical manner. In other words, having created the Universe, God would no longer be omnipotent, within that universe, and would have to find ways to interact within that universe that are consistant with the logic of that universe.

Occam's Razor, of course, tears this to shreds. But it might be worth pondering, at least in the abstract. Could explain why God is so miffed at the whole evil problem, why God seems to be such a putz in the Bible, and why God would have to 'incarnate' to teach people lessons...

Just something to think about.

Congratulations, Zaayrdragon. My brain is bleeding ! Hehe.
 
jjramsey
You seem to be under the impression that the rules of logic are merely particular laws of physics, and thus are contingent rather than necessary. That would explain why you are so quick to conflate the logically possible and the physically possible.
No, I’m not.
The defined Christian god already breaks numerous logical rules so what’s a few more?

Bri
I never said that crack babies were a form of punishment at all. To the contrary, I said that perhaps crack babies are simply the result of human exercise of free will.
The exercise of who’s freewill? The babies or the mothers?

Sure, but more than that. As human beings, we cannot possibly know all the variables that would increase the amount of good in the world, so you cannot prove that bad things don't happen for a greater good.
I’ve already responded to this. Prove that crack babies and Pontine tumors increase the greater good.

From Pediatric Brain Tumors — Overall Review
“Children with pontine tumors often present with multiple neurological signs that are rapidly progressive, sometimes within a few weeks. They often suffer from abducens and facial palsy, dysarthria, hemi paresis and ataxia. CT scans—and more recently, MRI scans—clearly demonstrate an enlarged pons, which may often extend into the neighboring brain stem and cerebellar structures. Approximately 90% of pontine tumors are malignant astrocytomas with a rapid growth rate. Unfortunately, none of the pontine glioblastomas are surgically resectable.”

Treatments include radiation and chemotherapy together for pontine tumor, but prognosis is extremely poor with less than 20% making it a year and two year survival is only 8%. Notice survival, not cure.

What is an "actual" square circle? Give me a definition, please.
It’s an mental construct used in order to demonstrate an logical impossibility.

I don't think anyone was claiming that there's "very good evidence" for God, only that there's not "very good evidence" for the belief that there is no God (as in the subject of the thread), much less enough evidence to make such a statement a fact rather than opinion.
There is also not “very good evidence” for the nonexistence of Barney, IPU, LGM, fairies, Aquaman, FSM, GTITS, last Tuesdayism, the VW orbiting Pluto, or any of a thousand other things. However the complete lack of evidence of existence means that the logical stance to take is that god doesn’t exist.

Ossai
 
The defined Christian god already breaks numerous logical rules so what’s a few more?
That's a hefty claim. If that were the case, it would be possible to disprove his existence, which so far as I am aware no one has ever satisfactorily been able to do. Which rules did you have in mind?

It’s an mental construct used in order to demonstrate an logical impossibility.
It is a logical impossibility, which in my view makes it impossible to construct mentally. It's just a nonsensical combination of words. A square circle cannot exist anywhere, even as an abstraction in the mind.
 
Depends on your definition of God. I think we're pretty safe in our assumption that a God that defies the laws of logic cannot exist.

We would have no basis for discussing a God that defies the laws of logic, however some still believe that such a God exists. But that seems to be an unnecessary conversation, since you have yet to prove that even a God who obeys the laws of logic cannot exist.

But there are a number of "gods" from other religions who are nowhere near the level of power claimed for the christian God, for example. If we use a definition of "god" that is physically possible, then you're right. So, to what god are you referring to ?

I'm referring to the many notions of God that you cannot disprove. I think you have just confirmed what many of us have been saying all along, which is that you cannot disprove all gods.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
That's a hefty claim. If that were the case, it would be possible to disprove his existence, which so far as I am aware no one has ever satisfactorily been able to do. Which rules did you have in mind?


Well, it depends on how the god is defined. If it is defined as "most infinitely powerful god beyond which is impossible in theory" then this is nonsense. Any god you can imagine, I can imagine an infinitely more powerful one. And more powerful than that. And so on.

So such a god, if it exists, may be the top god in practice, but cannot be top in theory because there is no top in theory.
 
The exercise of who’s freewill? The babies or the mothers?

The mother's, of course. The mother is the one who chose to smoke crack and get pregnant. Who would you blame for crack babies without God? Without God, do you claim that being born addicted to crack is a punishment? If not, then why would you assume that it is a punishment if God exists?

I’ve already responded to this. Prove that crack babies and Pontine tumors increase the greater good.

Prove that they don't. The subject of the thread is about proving that there is no God, not about proving that there is a God.

There is also not “very good evidence” for the nonexistence of Barney, IPU, LGM, fairies, Aquaman, FSM, GTITS, last Tuesdayism, the VW orbiting Pluto, or any of a thousand other things. However the complete lack of evidence of existence means that the logical stance to take is that god doesn’t exist.

Are you saying that Barney doesn't exist? Who's the annoying purple dinosaur I see on TV then?

As for the rest, your argument for not believing in them is a good one. Now prove that they don't exist.

-Bri
 
Well, it depends on how the god is defined. If it is defined as "most infinitely powerful god beyond which is impossible in theory" then this is nonsense. Any god you can imagine, I can imagine an infinitely more powerful one. And more powerful than that. And so on.

So such a god, if it exists, may be the top god in practice, but cannot be top in theory because there is no top in theory.

Please define "infinitely powerful" in such a way that something else can be more powerful than the infinitely powerful.

-Bri
 
I'm referring to the many notions of God that you cannot disprove. I think you have just confirmed what many of us have been saying all along, which is that you cannot disprove all gods.

Must I disprove something in every post ? I was asking a question, here.
 
The mother's, of course. The mother is the one who chose to smoke crack and get pregnant. Who would you blame for crack babies without God? Without God, do you claim that being born addicted to crack is a punishment? If not, then why would you assume that it is a punishment if God exists?

Because there is reason to believe that an omnibenevolent God would prevent such consequences from harming those not responsible for the actions. Haven't you been paying attention ?

Prove that they don't. The subject of the thread is about proving that there is no God, not about proving that there is a God.

Shifting the burden of proof is a fallacy. I'm quite comfortable here, waiting for evidence that God does exists. I don't expect to be surprised anytime soon.
 
Must I disprove something in every post ? I was asking a question, here.

If you want to stay on-topic you do!

But to answer your question in a more appropriate manner, I'm not referring to any specific notion of God. I can name several that you cannot disprove. Start with the classic deist belief in a God that doesn't interact with the world. If you concede that the deist God might exist, but hold that all gods that interact with the world can be disproven, I'll give you an example of a God that does interact with the world but still cannot be disproved.

Bottom line, to state that no gods exist is a claim which cannot be backed up with evidence.

-Bri
 
Because there is reason to believe that an omnibenevolent God would prevent such consequences from harming those not responsible for the actions. Haven't you been paying attention ?

If God prevented all events from happening that could cause harm to others, then God would be preventing a significant amount of free will. If free will is a greater good than a world where nobody could be harmed, then an omnibenevolent God would have no reason to prevent such things from occurring. And yes, I have been paying attention.

Shifting the burden of proof is a fallacy. I'm quite comfortable here, waiting for evidence that God does exists. I don't expect to be surprised anytime soon.

I'm not shifting the burden of proof, you are. The topic of the thread was that there is no God. That is a positive claim which requires its own burden of proof, just like the claim that there is a God (which I never made).

-Bri
 
I'm not thrilled with the title of this thread--I participate somewhat because the topics inside are interesting. I wouldn't go so far as to say that I know there isn't a God, let alone what someone else knows.

But I will say that to imagine the existence of God (especially the Christian or similar) requires of me more speculation and post-hoc excuse-making than I think is reasonable.

The ultimate question is--what is the difference between this world if God exists, and if God didn't, and can we tell?
 
The ultimate question is--what is the difference between this world if God exists, and if God didn't, and can we tell?

Well, you'd be chasing your tail, because obviously we'd have to figure out if God exists or not. It's like some paradox.
 
Well, you'd be chasing your tail, because obviously we'd have to figure out if God exists or not. It's like some paradox.

Ohh, heck no... just distinguishing two hypotheticals... you don't have to know whether God exists to suppose what it would be like if God did exist.

I simply ask, for any proposed description of God, what would the world be like if it were true, compared to if it were not.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom