There is No God (And You Know It)

Maybe, but in this world we are limited from doing anything we want as well.

Many theists believe that God wants us to choose good over evil of our own free will. If we weren't able to commit evil, then we couldn't make that choice.

-Bri
 
Sure, but not having free will with respect to decisions about harming other people cuts out a disproportionate number of morally significant options, doesn't it? Maybe you need to have certain kinds of physical possibilities at least theoretically available to you in a given universe in order to have free will that is morally meaningful enough to constitute the very great good that most people hold adult human free will to be. A stripped-down free will that doesn't extend to choices about harming and sparing from harm is, in my view, of vastly reduced moral significance.

Hum. I guess you're right.
 
Many theists believe that God wants us to choose good over evil of our own free will. If we weren't able to commit evil, then we couldn't make that choice.

-Bri

Unfortunately, given the evidence, it's just as likely that he wants us to choose evil over good of our own free will.
 
Belz...
That depends on whether or not we take "omnipotent" to mean "not limited to the laws of physics bu limited to the laws of logic", "not limited to the laws of logic" or "limited to the laws of physics."
No, think about it for a moment. What is the basis for logic? What if the effect came before the cause in the physical world, how would that cause logic to be redefined.

Crack babies are the direct result of human freedom of choice. Therefore, crack babies can be seen as a "greater good" if having free choice is seen as being a "greater good" than having no crack babies.
Crack babies – punishment of the innocent for the sins of the guilty.

Similarly, we cannot know for certain whether Pontine tumors or any other forms of human suffering serve some greater good.
In other words you can’t think of any reason and fall back on “God works in mysterious ways.”

If you feel that an omnibenevolent God cannot exist, then you'd have to prove that there are "evils" in the world that are not necessary for some greater good.
I already did. Go to a reputable medical site and look up Pontine tumors.

Can you prove that crack babies and Pontine tumors aren't for the greater good?
You’re still begging the question, what is the greater good?

By adding changing the definition of "square circle" to mean "kangaroo," the term would cease to be a logical impossibility.
Duh! It seem you’re finally catching on. If god can change the laws of nature making a square circle (an actual square circle – not ‘kangaroo’) would not be a problem.

Ossai
 
What is the basis for logic? What if the effect came before the cause in the physical world, how would that cause logic to be redefined.
--snip--
If god can change the laws of nature making a square circle (an actual square circle – not 'kangaroo') would not be a problem.

You seem to be under the impression that the rules of logic are merely particular laws of physics, and thus are contingent rather than necessary. That would explain why you are so quick to conflate the logically possible and the physically possible.
 
No, think about it for a moment. What is the basis for logic? What if the effect came before the cause in the physical world, how would that cause logic to be redefined.

The basis for logic is pretty simple, and it's universal. There's no reason to believe that, in other universes where physical laws are different, the laws of logic would be different. And if the cause came after the effect, then the cause would be the effect and the effect the cause, so we couldn't possibly call them that!

In other words you can’t think of any reason and fall back on “God works in mysterious ways.”

I already did. Go to a reputable medical site and look up Pontine tumors.

You’re still begging the question, what is the greater good?

Duh! It seem you’re finally catching on. If god can change the laws of nature making a square circle (an actual square circle – not ‘kangaroo’) would not be a problem.

The rest of that stuff isn't even mine!!
 
The basis for logic is pretty simple, and it's universal. There's no reason to believe that, in other universes where physical laws are different, the laws of logic would be different. And if the cause came after the effect, then the cause would be the effect and the effect the cause, so we couldn't possibly call them that!
Well put.
 
Crack babies – punishment of the innocent for the sins of the guilty.

You were responding to my comment here, not Belz. I never said that crack babies were a form of punishment at all. To the contrary, I said that perhaps crack babies are simply the result of human exercise of free will.

In other words you can’t think of any reason and fall back on “God works in mysterious ways.”

Sure, but more than that. As human beings, we cannot possibly know all the variables that would increase the amount of good in the world, so you cannot prove that bad things don't happen for a greater good.

I already did. Go to a reputable medical site and look up Pontine tumors.

Post a reference, please. I doubt any reputable medical site will mention whether or not Pontine tumors could possibly be for a greater good.

You’re still begging the question, what is the greater good?

We can't know. Only God can know.

Duh! It seem you’re finally catching on. If god can change the laws of nature making a square circle (an actual square circle – not ‘kangaroo’) would not be a problem.

What is an "actual" square circle? Give me a definition, please.

-Bri
 
You were responding to my comment here, not Belz. I never said that crack babies were a form of punishment at all. To the contrary, I said that perhaps crack babies are simply the result of human exercise of free will.

Well of course they are, in a materialistic world (determinism aside.) But if God exists and is as described, how could he allow people to suffer this way if they haven't done anything wrong themselves ? If the universe had moral objectivity, shouldn't the offender be automatically the one bearing the consequences ? Wouldn't that make sense ? That's how I would've done it.

Sure, but more than that. As human beings, we cannot possibly know all the variables that would increase the amount of good in the world, so you cannot prove that bad things don't happen for a greater good.

Of course, that's a negative. I assume you mean to say that you don't have any reason to believe your side of the argument, either.

We can't know. Only God can know.

If God exists, then I hate that insane bastard. If only God can know, then we can't possibly know good from bad.
 
Here is a snippet from the movie "Contact" which is based on the novel by one of the JREF's culture heroes Carl Sagan. The context is taken from a discussion in the movie on the existence of God. It has helped me somewhat in dealing with this proving God business:

Palmer Joss: Did you love your father?
Eleanor Arroway: Yes.
Joss: Prove it.
Arroway: (silence)
---------------------------------
If the essential nature of God is Spiritual Love, then how can love/God be proved? Love/God cannot be proved with with words, empiricism, or even deeds (deeds can be faked). Either you love someone or you don't--you either 'know it' or you don't, and there's no proving either way. This is just one way to approach the issue--certainly not the only way--but it has helped me.

I don't know what it takes to "prove" an empirical existence like this, but if overwhelming evidence to the positive is sufficient, I can easily "prove" I love my father, depending, of course, how you define love. If nothing else, I can provide a lot of evidence for it. For example, I lived with my father for 18 years, and did not leave when I was legally allowed to. That alone is not sufficient, of course (I have had other roommates, but none for as long), but it is evidence.

I included my father as a special guest at my wedding. Not as part of the wedding party, but still part of the wedding. He was one of 4 people we had in that role (all 4 parents).

I routinely invite my father to visit me, 400 miles away. And allow him to stay at my house when he is there.

I routinely drive those 400 miles back to stay at his house. I can't say that about anyone else.

Lastly, I routinely talk to my father on the phone. I don't routinely talk to anyone else on the phone, except my mom.

Now, you can try to explain these observations as random occurences, but the simplest explanation that accounts for them all, and moreover accounts for the different behavior toward others, is that I love my father in a way that I don't love them.

Foolproof? Of course not. I mean, it could apply to business partners. However, we aren't business partners, so there goes that explanation. Very good evidence? absolutely

Now, where is this "very good evidence" for god?
 
Last edited:
What is an "actual" square circle? Give me a definition, please.
That's really the key question, isn't it? I would guess that the best attempt at an answer might resemble this: "A plane rectilinear and rectangular figure with four equal sides forming a single curved line everywhere equidistant from a fixed point within." A functional equivalent, however, would be this: "Pbbthbthbt."

The problem (for our purposes) with square circles is not that the scientific laws of our universe prevent them from being instantiated in the real world, the way those laws arguably prevent magical fairies from being instantiated in the real world. Indeed, one would be justified in pointing out that even ordinary circles and squares are not, strictly speaking, instantiated in the real world, so they are not limited or determined by the natural characteristics of the actual universe.

No, the problem is that no amount of tinkering with the natural characteristics of any hypothetical universe is going to have any effect on what makes squares square and circles circular. The relationship that decrees the incompatility of these attributes is ontologically prior to questions of creation or instantiation (including, I would argue, the hypothetical instantiation of God).
 
Well of course they are, in a materialistic world (determinism aside.) But if God exists and is as described, how could he allow people to suffer this way if they haven't done anything wrong themselves ? If the universe had moral objectivity, shouldn't the offender be automatically the one bearing the consequences ? Wouldn't that make sense ? That's how I would've done it.

Again, not all theists believe that all suffering is punishment from God. In fact, I would guess that very few believe that. If humans have free will, then humans have the ability to cause suffering to other humans (and to themselves) that has nothing to do with punishment. In addition, God might very well have a reason for causing suffering that is for a greater good, which would mean that not all suffering caused by God is for the purpose of punishment either.

Of course, that's a negative. I assume you mean to say that you don't have any reason to believe your side of the argument, either.

That's correct. The subject of the thread concerns proving that there is no God, not proving that there is a God.

If God exists, then I hate that insane bastard.

If he doesn't exist, then you're wasting a lot of emotion on something that doesn't exist!

If only God can know, then we can't possibly know good from bad.

Sure we can. Atheists don't believe in God at all, yet they know good from bad.

-Bri
 
Now, where is this "very good evidence" for god?

I don't think anyone was claiming that there's "very good evidence" for God, only that there's not "very good evidence" for the belief that there is no God (as in the subject of the thread), much less enough evidence to make such a statement a fact rather than opinion.

-Bri
 
That's really the key question, isn't it? I would guess that the best attempt at an answer might resemble this: "A plane rectilinear and rectangular figure with four equal sides forming a single curved line everywhere equidistant from a fixed point within." A functional equivalent, however, would be this: "Pbbthbthbt."

Exactly. No definition will be reasonable to Ossai, because he wants the definition to hold using our logic, not some hypothetical other logic.

Using our logic, your definition is nonsense (has no meaning) because it is as semantically self-contradictory as the term it defines (essentially, you are defining a "square circle" as "something that is a square, but is also a circle"). Therefore, any statement that would contain the term "square circle" using your definition would also be nonsense.

No amount of tinkering with the laws of nature is going to make that phrase mean anything, although tinkering with the rules of logic might (as would simply changing the definition of "square circle" to "kangaroo").

-Bri
 
If humans have free will, then humans have the ability to cause suffering to other humans (and to themselves) that has nothing to do with punishment. In addition, God might very well have a reason for causing suffering that is for a greater good, which would mean that not all suffering caused by God is for the purpose of punishment either.

You seem to be a tad confused, here. Does God cause suffering in a Godful universe, or does man ? If God causes evil, then some evil is not a consequence of human free will. If man causes evil, then some evil is unnecessary (see: planecrashes) and God is either non-existent, insane or incompetent.

If he doesn't exist, then you're wasting a lot of emotion on something that doesn't exist!

I think you missed that "if" at the beginning of my sentence. If he doesn't exist then I can't hate him, therefore not wasting emotion.

How can you waste emotion, anyway ?

Sure we can. Atheists don't believe in God at all, yet they know good from bad.

That's stupid. If God doesn't exist then even he can't know the greater good, and our discussion breaks apart. You're attempting a cop out, here. IF God exists, and only he can know what is the greater good, then there's no way for us to know what we should do. Answer my point this time.
 
Exactly. No definition will be reasonable to Ossai, because he wants the definition to hold using our logic, not some hypothetical other logic.

Other logic ? I wasn't aware there were several different logics. Would you care to elaborate or extrapolate on what those different logics are or could be ?
 
Other logic ? I wasn't aware there were several different logics. Would you care to elaborate or extrapolate on what those different logics are or could be ?
I don't think Bri actually believes that there are other possible logics. Or if there are, we'll never know, because they would be completely unintelligible.
 
You seem to be a tad confused, here. Does God cause suffering in a Godful universe, or does man ? If God causes evil, then some evil is not a consequence of human free will. If man causes evil, then some evil is unnecessary (see: planecrashes) and God is either non-existent, insane or incompetent.

I was giving two possible scenarios whereas suffering might exist in a Godful universe without the suffering being for the purpose of punishment. In one scenario, man is the cause of the suffering. In the other, God causes the suffering for a greater good. Possibly both are true.

I think you missed that "if" at the beginning of my sentence. If he doesn't exist then I can't hate him, therefore not wasting emotion.

How can you waste emotion, anyway ?

I didn't miss the "if" and I was just joking.

That's stupid. If God doesn't exist then even he can't know the greater good, and our discussion breaks apart. You're attempting a cop out, here. IF God exists, and only he can know what is the greater good, then there's no way for us to know what we should do. Answer my point this time.

I'm not sure I understand your point. If we can know the difference between good and bad without God (as strong atheists believe), then we can know the difference between good and bad with God, even if we don't know for certain that he exists.

Does your point concern the fact that we can't know what the "greater good" is? Most theists believe that God doesn't expect us to know what the "greater good" is (that's his job). Our job is simply acting in a moral way, which we can undoubtedly do even if we don't know for certain that God exists and even if we can't know the greater good. Some theists even believe that God has written down for us how we should behave (i.e. the Bible) so that we know how to act even if God doesn't tell us directly.

-Bri
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom