There is No God (And You Know It)

I sometimes comtemplate computer viruses. They exist and I've no doubt there are feral mutating spambots out there in the net. I imagine them evolving into sentient reproducing ...hmmm... beings? entities? ...I don't know what to call them. I don't think such exist at this time, but I think it quite possible they will someday. Viruses are out there, reproducing and mutating at a fantastic rate, so it seems a reasonable speculation to me that such creatures could evolve.

Computer viruses cannot evolve in the same way as biological beigns. The way their code can "evolve" is set in advance. The permutations in what they can become only serve to fool detection software. The factors entering in their evolution are limited in number and capacity. Plus, viruses are programs. Programs, in and of themselves, are like memories, not brains. They aren't themselves a separate, operating entity. The computer itself would have to be intelligent, since it alone can process data.

Of course, intelligence says nothing about consciousness.
 
But if your hypothesis is that there is a God that cannot be observed, does not want to be observed and serves no function whatsoever except to make your hypothesis true... do I need to tell you what that means ?

That's not my hypothesis. My hypothesis is a God that cannot be observed because he does not want to be observed, but does serve a function.

-Bri
 
Sure. However, taking crack can result in consequences that don't have to affect the baby. In many circumstances the "evil" to others is unnecessary. Hence the term, unnecessary evil.

Huh?

-Bri
 
Which function would that be that's not going to make the hypothesis a circular one ?

God might serve many functions. He might be the creator of the universe. He might judge us after we die. He might be the catalyst for free will. He might provide consciousness. He might endow the raw materials for life with life. He might make tornados and earthquakes. Take your pick.

In any of these cases, God might not want us to know that he exists and therefore we wouldn't expect there to be evidence of him. I still don't understand how that would be "inconsistent with the belief requirement for entrance into Heaven" as you put it.

-Bri
 
Computer viruses cannot evolve in the same way as biological beigns. The way their code can "evolve" is set in advance. The permutations in what they can become only serve to fool detection software. The factors entering in their evolution are limited in number and capacity.

Well, I'm sure you are right about evolution proceeding rather differently in programs than DNA, but your argument sounds supiciously close to the argument ID proponents make regarding biological evolution and designers. :)

I'm afraid that I don't buy the idea that programs are incapable of evolving outside of preset parameters nor that they only evolve to fool detection software. Since they are reproducing themselves, sometimes random errors will occur, the majority of which would be fatal just an in biological creatures. And sometimes, such errors are a happy accident in which the resulting creature is more fit for its environment rather than less - just as sometime happens with biological creatures. Such an error would then be propagated to future offspring.

Plus, viruses are programs. Programs, in and of themselves, are like memories, not brains. They aren't themselves a separate, operating entity. The computer itself would have to be intelligent, since it alone can process data.

Well, I wouldn't agree that programs are analogous to memory, but it's a deep issue. Certainly room for reasonable people to disagree. Sorry I haven't time for an in-depth discussion of the possibilities.

Beth
 
God might serve many functions. He might be the creator of the universe. He might judge us after we die. He might be the catalyst for free will. He might provide consciousness. He might endow the raw materials for life with life. He might make tornados and earthquakes. Take your pick.

- God is not required for the universe to exist.
- Explain the "catalyst" for free will part
- What difference is there between materials for life without life and materials for life with life ?
- No, we know how tornadoes and earthquakes happen.

Your first five "functions" also assume there is another, metaphysical quality to matter and thought, which kinda comes back to my concern about it all beign circular. The last one is patently false. So, again. What function would he have ?

In any of these cases, God might not want us to know that he exists and therefore we wouldn't expect there to be evidence of him. I still don't understand how that would be "inconsistent with the belief requirement for entrance into Heaven" as you put it.

Unless one considers the God os the christian religion, Islam or Judaism, of course.
 
I'm afraid that I don't buy the idea that programs are incapable of evolving outside of preset parameters nor that they only evolve to fool detection software. Since they are reproducing themselves, sometimes random errors will occur, the majority of which would be fatal just an in biological creatures. And sometimes, such errors are a happy accident in which the resulting creature is more fit for its environment rather than less - just as sometime happens with biological creatures. Such an error would then be propagated to future offspring.

Well I don't make viruses, but I am a computer programmer, so I know a little what I'm talking about. Viruses can't add new functions to themselves. Randomization only change a virus' ID, but doesn't change the way it works. Unless it was made that way, though I can't fathom how that'd work. And there's no question of "fit" viruses. They either work or not. Computer programs with bugs simply fail when they encounter that bug. They can't adapt because the necessary processes are lacking.
 
I said, basically, that there are consequences to actions that are unnecessary. Someone taking drugs bears the consequences already. Why would the kid, for a pregnant woman, be affected as well ?

How do you know that some consequences to actions that are unnecessary?

It may very well be for the greater good for some people who choose to smoke crack and get pregnant to give birth to a baby addicted to crack.

It's no different than any other case that where someone causes suffering to another innocent human being. Having a choice between good and evil requires that a human be able to cause suffering. God may consider free will to be a greater good than a world without human suffering.

We've also already discussed Pontine tumors, which are no different than hurricanes and earthquakes -- human suffering which cannot be attributed specifically to human causes. Aside from the possibility that all of these are the result of human causes that we don't know about, these may also be for a greater good that we don't know about.

For every scenario you conjure up that you think precludes God from being omnibenevolent because of human suffering, I can give the same answer.

-Bri
 
It may very well be for the greater good for some people who choose to smoke crack and get pregnant to give birth to a baby addicted to crack.

You're beign incredibly nebulous, here. How could that be for the greater good ?

You're basically arguing that we don't know and we can't know. This is, of course, a very tiresome argument that is getting us nowhere. I see your point that absolute proof is impossible, but, beign practical, reasonable proof could be expected. It isn't there.
 
- God is not required for the universe to exist.
- Explain the "catalyst" for free will part
- What difference is there between materials for life without life and materials for life with life ?
- No, we know how tornadoes and earthquakes happen.

* You didn't ask whether God was required for the universe to exist. You asked for functions that God might serve. That said, science cannot explain what caused the big bang. Perhaps God did.

* By "catalyst for free will" I mean that God might allow us to have free will (materialism and causation do not currently account for free will and in fact suggest that we don't have free will).

* Science cannot currently account for any difference between "materials for life" and "life." In other words, science cannot fully explain why we can't simply take the raw materials from which a simple life form is comprised, throw them in a petri dish, and create life. Much less conscious, intelligent life. God's purpose might be to impart life into the raw materials that gives rise to a living being.

* We do not know what causes tornados and earthquakes. If we did, we could predict them with certainty. God may be the ultimate cause of all tornados and earthquakes.

Your first five "functions" also assume there is another, metaphysical quality to matter and thought, which kinda comes back to my concern about it all beign circular. The last one is patently false. So, again. What function would he have ?

I listed several functions that God might serve. That any of these might not be the case is irrelevent since any of them might be the case. Unless you can prove otherwise. Prove that they're all false. In fact, prove that the one you claim is "patently false" (that God causes tornados and earthquakes) is false.

Unless one considers the God os the christian religion, Islam or Judaism, of course.

All of the religions you listed hold similar belief that God doesn't wish for us to know for certain that he exists (all put emphasis on faith in God rather than knowledge of God). Each has slightly different beliefs as to the requirements for entrance into heaven. How is any of this "inconsistent with the belief requirement for entrance into Heaven" according to any of the religions you listed, must less according to all beliefs in God?

-Bri
 
You're beign incredibly nebulous, here. How could that be for the greater good ?

Of course I'm being nebulous. I can come up with examples (as I've done) for why certain cases might be for the greater good, but you'll simply come up with additional examples and ask the same question.

The burden of proof would be on you to show that an event isn't for the greater good if you're going to use that as an argument to disprove God. The fact is that it is impossible to prove that any event isn't for the greater good since it's impossible for us to know what ingredients are necessary for the greater good.

You're basically arguing that we don't know and we can't know. This is, of course, a very tiresome argument that is getting us nowhere.

If you keep making the same argument, I'll keep giving you the same answer.

I see your point that absolute proof is impossible...

Really? Awesome!

...but, beign practical, reasonable proof could be expected. It isn't there.

Oops...so close! Reasonable proof of what could be expected and why would it be expected? Is the absence of evidence that there are no gods evidence that there are gods?

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Well, I'm sure you are right about evolution proceeding rather differently in programs than DNA...

Well I don't make viruses, but I am a computer programmer, so I know a little what I'm talking about. Viruses can't add new functions to themselves. Randomization only change a virus' ID, but doesn't change the way it works...

As a programmer, Belz might be familiar with Karl Sims' work on self-modifying programs that use a process similar to evolution (random modification) to produce artificial creatures that are amazingly adept at various tasks. A video of Karl Sims' amazing "Evolving Creatures" can be found here:

http://alife.ccp14.ac.uk/ftp-mirror/alife/zooland/pub/research/ci/Alife/karl-sims/creatures-demo.mpg

His paper describing how the creatures "evolved" can be found here:

http://www.genarts.com/karl/papers/siggraph94.pdf

-Bri
 
* You didn't ask whether God was required for the universe to exist. You asked for functions that God might serve. That said, science cannot explain what caused the big bang. Perhaps God did.

Read up. Science can and does explain it.

* By "catalyst for free will" I mean that God might allow us to have free will (materialism and causation do not currently account for free will and in fact suggest that we don't have free will).

By doing what that would be different from a godless universe ?

* Science cannot currently account for any difference between "materials for life" and "life." In other words, science cannot fully explain why we can't simply take the raw materials from which a simple life form is comprised, throw them in a petri dish, and create life. Much less conscious, intelligent life. God's purpose might be to impart life into the raw materials that gives rise to a living being.

That's a common theist response. However, I don't see how you can claim that science can't explain it. We know how cells and genes work and why. What's the basis of your assertion ?

* We do not know what causes tornados and earthquakes. If we did, we could predict them with certainty. God may be the ultimate cause of all tornados and earthquakes.

We know exactly what causes them. It doesn't make the prediction any easier because knowning what the factors are and detecting those factors continuously is not the same thing.

All of the religions you listed hold similar belief that God doesn't wish for us to know for certain that he exists (all put emphasis on faith in God rather than knowledge of God.

I know that. However, I don't see how a rational beign would expect other rational beigns to believe in something without any form of evidence. Is God insane ?
 
If you keep making the same argument, I'll keep giving you the same answer.

I'm not making arguments. I'm asking questions. What part of that did you miss ?

Oops...so close! Reasonable proof of what could be expected and why would it be expected? Is the absence of evidence that there are no gods evidence that there are gods?

If and only if we could expect God to leave such evidence, which, as you've so eloquently put it, depends on which definition of God you use.
 
As a programmer, Belz might be familiar with Karl Sims' work on self-modifying programs that use a process similar to evolution (random modification) to produce artificial creatures that are amazingly adept at various tasks.

I was aware of it, yes. But a computer dedicated to running a program that is itself dedicated to simulating evolution is one thing. I didn't say computers couldn't evolve, given the right circumstances and programming. However, Viruses are completely different. They don't evolve in the biological sense. If they did they couldn't do what they're supposed to do, which is infect and damage your computer.
 
I was aware of it, yes. But a computer dedicated to running a program that is itself dedicated to simulating evolution is one thing. I didn't say computers couldn't evolve, given the right circumstances and programming. However, Viruses are completely different. They don't evolve in the biological sense. If they did they couldn't do what they're supposed to do, which is infect and damage your computer.

I wasn't arguing with you here, just posting some links to some relevent information.

-Bri
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom