The War on Drugs is Useless

It's a straw man because I have explicitly stated that marijuana is one of the drugs I would consider legalizing, and I have repeatedly stated that I don't consider all illicit drugs to be rightfully illicit.

McHrozni

Uh, no, that is not what I was saying. Drug gangs are a reality. Their violence is a reality. There is NOWHERE near as much easy money to be made running protection rackets. It is not a straw man to say that if you favor keeping street drugs illegal, you are in favor of keeping that level of violence unless you know another way to end it.
 
The violence is much worse in Mexico. But if the death of some Mexican means it is a little bit harder for Americans to get some cocaine, it is worth it. Right?
 
The violence is much worse in Mexico. But if the death of some Mexican means it is a little bit harder for Americans to get some cocaine, it is worth it. Right?
It's worth 100 Mexican lives if one American kid doesn't take that first line of coke.
 
And ultimately, this is what it comes down to. Is the human cost in lives, blood, treasure and money ultimately worth it for the theorised gains of a prohibtionary system of drug regulation?

I contend that all the evidence points to "No."

Oh and @ McHronzi, I would like to know what you regard as a good argument for keeping cannabis illegal, as surely the link to mental health is not it?
 
The coolest thing, for me, so far, about pot being illegal, is smoking it with cops.

It borders on performance art.

Snorting coke with cops; not so much.
 
Uh, no, that is not what I was saying. Drug gangs are a reality. Their violence is a reality. There is NOWHERE near as much easy money to be made running protection rackets. It is not a straw man to say that if you favor keeping street drugs illegal, you are in favor of keeping that level of violence unless you know another way to end it.

You explicitly mentioned smoking a joint. Was there a reason for that? At least write honestly - replace that by getting your fix at a supermarket, for example.

McHrozni
 
And ultimately, this is what it comes down to. Is the human cost in lives, blood, treasure and money ultimately worth it for the theorised gains of a prohibtionary system of drug regulation?

I contend that all the evidence points to "No."

All the evidence? How about evidence that a reduced drug market will lead to extreme violence, such as seen in Mexico? If drugs were legalized, the drug gangs wouldn't just become law-abiding citizens, you know. They would desperately seek out other means of making money. Do you know what that means?
So much for that, I suppose.

Oh and @ McHronzi, I would like to know what you regard as a good argument for keeping cannabis illegal, as surely the link to mental health is not it?

It's McHrozni and not McHronzi. Why wouldn't a dose dependent relationship with increased risk of psychosis and schizophrenia be a good reason? Because you say so, or do you have something more compelling? :)

McHrozni
(and not McHronzi)
 
These deaths would not be happening if the drug use was legalized and regulated. Your "fact" is bogus.

How do you know they wouldn't be happening? I'm quite sure that by now, just about all drug users should know of the dangers of needle sharing, right? At one seller I googled in 2 seconds, a box containing 100 needles can be bought for as little as $8. It's not that they couldn't afford to buy them, if they wanted.
But they apparently simply don't care. It's a problem with drugs and not much else.

McHrozni
 
It's worth 100 Mexican lives if one American kid doesn't take that first line of coke.

Yet despite the fact that there are already many, many, many Mexicans dying in such drug-related violence every year (and it's getting way worse), the coke still makes its way here (we haven't put a dent in it)... and American kids still are dying.

So, explain to me exactly how this Prohibition is working out?

Do you need another 40 years to see how stupid this is?
 
Last edited:
In other news, the war on drugs involved soldiers, and Mr Coke appears to remain at large. Over three dozen dead in Jamaica. Drug gang's don't care to have their turf, nor their prerogatives, messed with.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/37351793/ns/world_news-americas/

DR

Obviously, the solution is...

1. More money to the WoD
2. More soldiers to the WoD
3. Throw more people into jail (paging Joe Arpaio)
4. Put up more public ad campaigns about how drugs are eeeevvviiiiillllll!!!11! :jaw-dropp

That's sure to do the trick. It's worked so well for the last 40 years, hasn't it? ;)
 
How do you know they wouldn't be happening? I'm quite sure that by now, just about all drug users should know of the dangers of needle sharing, right? At one seller I googled in 2 seconds, a box containing 100 needles can be bought for as little as $8. It's not that they couldn't afford to buy them, if they wanted.
But they apparently simply don't care. It's a problem with drugs and not much else.

McHrozni
How many diabatics get AIDS from sharing needles?

And you do know that in most states you cannot buy needles without a prescription, don't you?
 
Obviously, the solution is...

1. More money to the WoD
2. More soldiers to the WoD
3. Throw more people into jail (paging Joe Arpaio)
4. Put up more public ad campaigns about how drugs are eeeevvviiiiillllll!!!11! :jaw-dropp

That's sure to do the trick. It's worked so well for the last 40 years, hasn't it? ;)
Why do you say that? IMO, snipers shooting at selected drug kingpins is a better remedy. Cheaper too.

DR
 
Why do you say that? IMO, snipers shooting at selected drug kingpins is a better remedy. Cheaper too.

DR

What makes you think this hasn't already been tried? And if you do take out such a kingpin, so what? Another one will simply be ready to take their place. There's just too much damn money involved in the black-market drug trade to realistically expect that by "taking out the kingpins" everything will just get better.
 
How many diabatics get AIDS from sharing needles?

Not many, I suppose. My point was that drug users simply don't care about their health, what's yours?

And you do know that in most states you cannot buy needles without a prescription, don't you?

Hm, no, actually I didn't know that. I suppose that's another aspect of the war on drugs that could (and should) be changed without legalizing anything.

That said, I fail to see why this would be a problem. Trading in heroin is a major offense in the same states, yet it can be bought with impunity, if your arguments hold true. There certainly is much more effort to crack down on illegal drug sales than there is to crack down on illegal needle sales, but you're saying that while buying illegal drugs is easy, obtaining needles illegally is a major problem?

McHrozni
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom