The War on Drugs is Useless

I sure as hell wouldn't. If some people think it is worth the risk, I fail to see the problem. It's not like they would have been getting the good stuff either way.

Maybe, maybe not. After a decade of widely available cheap medicines you might think differently, though. Attitudes change, you know.

Cheaper? Sure. More dangerous, doubtful. They want to pay as as little medical bills as possible. Forcing people to take dangerous drugs would seem counter-productive.

Many drugs that aren't permitted on the market aren't that dangerous to a large percentage of population. If the company would decide they would cut costs by 3% by paying for a cheaper drug, which would kill 1% of their insurers and drive away another 1% (reducing their revenue by that amount - 2%), they would quite likely do it, no? This is a simple example, not intended to simulate an actual drug.

Why again are you assuming that dangerous ones would be cheaper to make?

Because a large issue of the cost of drugs is the cost of their development, and a large issue of development costs is that many substances turn out to be dead ends, because of safety issues. It's a clear and obvious correlation.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
Why would a drop in price, a greater availability and an eliminated stigma lead to less use again?

McHrozni

If the population of addicts is stable (I don't know if this is true)
Then legalization leads to more openness about drug habits.
More openness may lead to better and more effective treatment for addicts.
More effective treatment may lead to fewer addicts.
Fewer addicts might lead to less overall use.

This is highly speculative, but I think it illustrates a logical series of steps in which legalization would lead to less use. Looking at statistics on drug use in the Netherlands indicates that, for whatever reason, less use as a result has a non-trivial probability of occurring.

We don't punish those who have a beer in the afternoon after work with possession of alcohol because a small percentage of people abuse alcohol. Why should we punish those who use heroin or cocaine occasionally to have some fun because a small percentage of people abuse them?

I agree that users don't need to be punished, but I do think that it is in societies best interests to maintain some control and oversight of powerful and potentially lethal drugs. I include alcohol and nicotine in that category, so age restrictions at the very least are appropriate.

Maybe. Or maybe it would stay about the same. And maybe if it did increase, less people would abuse alcohol so overall drug abuse would be the same.

And even if it did increase, I wouldn't really care that much. I don't think there is anything wrong with taking drugs. As for addiction, well I'm sure it sucks but it is entirely the fault of the addict. It's not hard to do even heroin without getting addicted. Don't start doing it everyday and you won't get addicted. I know from experience.

Even if you don't care, other people do. They don't want their loved ones to destroy their lives over an addiction to a drug. The argument about potential harm to society is a legitimate one and needs to be addressed.

You're kidding right?

Safety is a rather strong selling point. Ask Mercedes.

Better yet, ask Toyota. Or BP.
 
If the population of addicts is stable (I don't know if this is true)
Then legalization leads to more openness about drug habits.
More openness may lead to better and more effective treatment for addicts.
More effective treatment may lead to fewer addicts.
Fewer addicts might lead to less overall use.

This is highly speculative, but I think it illustrates a logical series of steps in which legalization would lead to less use. Looking at statistics on drug use in the Netherlands indicates that, for whatever reason, less use as a result has a non-trivial probability of occurring.

I've bolded a problematic point. There is no effective treatment. There are marginally effective treatments, like methadone therapy, but getting off the drug is still hell.

While I do agree that yes, it is not impossible that more would seek therapy, it is also quite possible more would need therapy in the first place. It's also possible that some addicts would consider their addiction to be fairly normal "now that's legalized" and decide they didn't need therapy anyway.

You're probably overstating the case of Netherlands. While usage of cannabis didn't increase immediately after liberalization, it increased several-fold a few years later. This is exactly what I'd expect with other drugs as well.

McHrozni
 
I've bolded a problematic point. There is no effective treatment. There are marginally effective treatments, like methadone therapy, but getting off the drug is still hell.

While I do agree that yes, it is not impossible that more would seek therapy, it is also quite possible more would need therapy in the first place. It's also possible that some addicts would consider their addiction to be fairly normal "now that's legalized" and decide they didn't need therapy anyway.

You're probably overstating the case of Netherlands. While usage of cannabis didn't increase immediately after liberalization, it increased several-fold a few years later. This is exactly what I'd expect with other drugs as well.

McHrozni
You're right, it's far better to have violent gangs shooting up the streets to control drug turf rather than letting people smoke a legal joint.
 
You're right, it's far better to have violent gangs shooting up the streets to control drug turf rather than letting people smoke a legal joint.

And I should defend this straw man, because ...?

McHrozni
 
And I should defend this straw man, because ...?

McHrozni
You can't support keeping drugs illegal, without supporting the drug gangs. These gangs could not exist were drugs not illegal. And they are causing far more problems than drug use itself.

If the government gave free hard drugs to addicts, the drug gangs would go out of business. With them out of business, there's far fewer people getting hooked on them in the first place, because only existing addicts get free drugs and there's no point in drug dealers pushing the drugs on new users because they'd just go get them for free once hooked.
 
You can't support keeping drugs illegal, without supporting the drug gangs. These gangs could not exist were drugs not illegal. And they are causing far more problems than drug use itself.

Except that organized crime predates drug prohibition. It just used to deal in extortion, protection money, kidnapping ... but those took a back seat to drug trade. They all still exist, but are, at best, secondary.

McHrozni
 
Sorry, that's rot. 25,000 people die from illicit drug use every year in the US. That's more than the annual murder rate.

http://www.annals.org/content/133/1/40.full.pdf

I thought this one were covered already.
Your link state that a majority of deaths is due to heroin, of questionably strength and purity.
Legalised heroin would be of good quality and thereby eliminate most deaths.
 
I thought this one were covered already.
Your link state that a majority of deaths is due to heroin, of questionably strength and purity.
Legalised heroin would be of good quality and thereby eliminate most deaths.

Assuming the difference isn't made up with the increase in users and the increase in AIDS, hep C and other blood-borne diseases.
 
Assuming the difference isn't made up with the increase in users and the increase in AIDS, hep C and other blood-borne diseases.

You are assuming an increase in users, and that a legalization would not involve fresh needles.
It sounds rather dumb.
 
Why's that dumb? Everyone and their dog knows that cigarettes will get you addicted, give you nasty coughs, make you smelly and then kill you but people are still taking up the habit.
 
It's not a straw man. It's reality. I suppose you haven't been to a large American city in a while, huh?

It's a straw man because I have explicitly stated that marijuana is one of the drugs I would consider legalizing, and I have repeatedly stated that I don't consider all illicit drugs to be rightfully illicit.

McHrozni
 
McHrozni,

Yeah, I can't see any good reason why marijuana is illegal.
 
McHrozni,

Yeah, I can't see any good reason why marijuana is illegal.

Well, I can see good reasons for it being legal and illegal. Did you know it has been associates with psychological problems and schizophrenia? It's not harmless as it is often portrayed.

That said, I think the harm done to society by marijuana is small enough to permit it, as long as there is a sufficient effort to warn people of the dangers it poses.

McHrozni
 
Imagine a new drug (hypothetically) that actually makes people 'better' people, yet treats no particular disease. I assume it would be illegal. Who would take it anyway?
Would it be unethical not to?
 
Imagine a new drug (hypothetically) that actually makes people 'better' people, yet treats no particular disease. I assume it would be illegal. Who would take it anyway?
Would it be unethical not to?

Define "better" people.

McHrozni
 
Sorry, that's rot. 25,000 people die from illicit drug use every year in the US. That's more than the annual murder rate.

http://www.annals.org/content/133/1/40.full.pdf
This is a complete lie. Your source cites this report which only states "More than 132,000 persons died as a consequence of alcohol and drug problems in 1992. Of these deaths, 107,400 were related to alcohol abuse and 25,500 were related to drug abuse."

"Related to"... you know what that includes? AIDS deaths if the infection was from sharing an infected needle, likewise tuberculosis and hepatitis, suicides by overdosing on either legal or illegal drugs, and other such factors.

In fact, the single greatest contributors to that number are hepatitis (8,000 to 12,000 annually) and AIDS deaths, which accounted for over 10,000 cases per year at the time of the study.

These deaths would not be happening if the drug use was legalized and regulated. Your "fact" is bogus.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom