The War on Drugs is Useless

Yes, that is certainly possible. However it is impossible to ensure that some of the users won't do something stupid while high - like trying to drive. That's why you can't say drugs can be absolutely safe. Smoking tobacco can come very close, but that's it.

But by that logic you ban baseball bats?


How many times do I need to say that I support decriminalization of drug usage? :confused:

McHrozni

Understood, but surely it's better to legalise then you can tax it?
 
I'm not assuming prices will be lower. The rationale given for legalization was that it would lower the price and undercut the dealers, putting them out of business. That was the pro-legalization position offered in this thread. Wildcat said 10 bucks for a kilo of coke if it was legalized. I have no idea how much it would cost to produce given overheads, precursors and wages, but I'll take his word for it. Apparently in Australia coke is $300,000 a kilo. I'd say if coke was released in the shops at $10 a kilo tomorrow, every cokehead would go out, buy ten kilos of the stuff, binge and you'd have a bunch of OD's on the first day. We're talking about hard, highly addictive drugs here. It seems to me naive to assume that people will be responsible with it.

So what is some cokeheads want to earn themselves a Darwin Award?

And $300,000/key? Well if that is true cokeheads in Australia are getting ripped the hell off.
 
"It's not hard to do heroin without getting addicted. Don't start doing it everyday and you won't get addicted."

The dtugg heroin warning label.
 
It might be possible that if they weren't illegal they wouldn't be seen as the "forbidden fruit" and less people would want to try it. I find this outcome unlikely but not impossible.

That would be one factor. Another directly counters it: the vilification of the drugs now makes people less likely to loose them.

It is not an unreasonable assumption. But we can't take it for granted that it would happen.

You agreed elsewhere that this is the most likely course of events in such a case, so fair enough I suppose.

McHrozni
 
But by that logic you ban baseball bats?

No, obviously. You're making a false dichotomy: either ban everything that could be dangerous or ban nothing that is. There are other legitimate possibilities available, and comparing laws regulating psychoactive substances and potential cold weapons (for the lack of a better qualification) is just too bizarre to contemplate.

Understood, but surely it's better to legalise then you can tax it?

If that was the only effect than maybe. But as I was arguing this entire time, it is not.

McHrozni
 
So what is some cokeheads want to earn themselves a Darwin Award?

Some of us consider safety regulations an important part of the modern legal system. We also don't permit some lifesaving medicines on the market because they have dangerous side effects. Do you support big pharma selling those as well?

And $300,000/key? Well if that is true cokeheads in Australia are getting ripped the hell off.

http://www.havocscope.com/price-of-cocaine-in-asia/

Wholesale price is $145,000 per kilo, a gram on the street is $285.

Not $300,000 per kilo, but not far either.

McHrozni
 
Oh great. This is going to devolve into a drug dealing thread.


Got to admit, prohibition creates more jobs than legalization could.
 
I'm not assuming prices will be lower. The rationale given for legalization was that it would lower the price and undercut the dealers, putting them out of business. That was the pro-legalization position offered in this thread. Wildcat said 10 bucks for a kilo of coke if it was legalized. I have no idea how much it would cost to produce given overheads, precursors and wages, but I'll take his word for it. Apparently in Australia coke is $300,000 a kilo. I'd say if coke was released in the shops at $10 a kilo tomorrow, every cokehead would go out, buy ten kilos of the stuff, binge and you'd have a bunch of OD's on the first day. We're talking about hard, highly addictive drugs here. It seems to me naive to assume that people will be responsible with it.

Huh. Were I in charge, I would tax it so that it was almost the same price it is now. The fact that is regulated for purity, and less dangerous to buy and use would, I think, be sufficient enticement to buy it from legal sources.
 
Some of us consider safety regulations an important part of the modern legal system. We also don't permit some lifesaving medicines on the market because they have dangerous side effects. Do you support big pharma selling those as well?

Sure. As long as they don't lie about the side effects. People should be able decide if they want to risk it.
 
Sure. As long as they don't lie about the side effects. People should be able decide if they want to risk it.

How about the ability of anyone to buy any medicine in a fairly ordinary shop?
Is that okay with you as well?

McHrozni
 
How about the ability of anyone to buy any medicine in a fairly ordinary shop?
Is that okay with you as well?

McHrozni

Fine by me. Personally, nothing would change. I see a doctor, he advices me to take me some medicine, I go get it. If morons would thin out the herd by taking these drugs out side of medical supervision, so be it.
 
Last edited:
Huh. Were I in charge, I would tax it so that it was almost the same price it is now. The fact that is regulated for purity, and less dangerous to buy and use would, I think, be sufficient enticement to buy it from legal sources.

Good point.
 
Fine by me. Personally, nothing would change. I see a doctor, he prescribes me some medicine, I go get it. If morons would thin out the herd by taking these drugs out side of medical supervision, so be it.

So ... what would be the motivation for big pharma to produce (relatively) safe medicines, if they can produce fairly dangerous ones at a fraction of the effort required?

McHrozni
 
So ... what would be the motivation for big pharma to produce (relatively) safe medicines, if they can produce fairly dangerous ones at a fraction of the effort required?

McHrozni

They could still be forced to do study the efficacy and safety of the drugs before released. I doubt very many people would be buying the dangerous ones.
 
They could still be forced to do study the efficacy and safety of the drugs before released. I doubt very many people would be buying the dangerous ones.

Not even if they were significantly cheaper and they were running a tight budget? That's again a rather unreasonable assumption on your part.
How about insurance companies? Wouldn't they request cheaper medicines where possible?

McHrozni
 
Not even if they were significantly cheaper and they were running a tight budget? That's again a rather unreasonable assumption on your part.

I sure as hell wouldn't. If some people think it is worth the risk, I fail to see the problem. It's not like they would have been getting the good stuff either way.

How about insurance companies? Wouldn't they request cheaper medicines where possible?

McHrozni

Cheaper? Sure. More dangerous, doubtful. They want to pay as as little medical bills as possible. Forcing people to take dangerous drugs would seem counter-productive.


Why again are you assuming that dangerous ones would be cheaper to make?
 
So ... what would be the motivation for big pharma to produce (relatively) safe medicines, if they can produce fairly dangerous ones at a fraction of the effort required?

McHrozni

You're kidding right?

Safety is a rather strong selling point. Ask Mercedes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom