The War on Drugs is Useless

Will you at least admit that lower prices don't automatically lead to more users? Because otherwise, more people would be using cocaine now than they did in the 80s.

That would depend, really. Couldn't it be a success of the continuing war on drugs?

You have to realize one thing - if something is vilified as intensely as drugs, using them becomes a taboo, not just a prohibited fruit. That causes people to think twice before they use it.
If it were sold in shops, that aspect would most certainly falter.

You're essentially claiming the only difference between 1980s and 2000s is a lower price of cocaine, which I find about as ridiculous as the rest of your arguments put together, really. If nothing else, the Hippie "culture" was only just dying down in 1980s, making your comparison utterly invalid.

If the lower price is the only effect, then usage will go up with the lower price. If there are other effects, then it can be overwhelmed by them. It is as if the war on drugs has had an impact on drug demand, wouldn't you say?

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
Of course there were other factors involved. I was just pointing out that a a drop in price does not necessarily mean an increase in use.
 
Of course there were other factors involved. I was just pointing out that a a drop in price does not necessarily mean an increase in use.

Why would a drop in price, a greater availability and an eliminated stigma lead to less use again?

McHrozni
 
Well, if they were entitled to it, the drugs would have to be paid for by the state.

It's not that I hate drugs or drug users, it's that many of the illegal drugs (not all) make a very slippery slope. First it's once a month, then once a week, then every weekend, then every day, then you discover it would be a good idea to stop, but it's far too late already. Not all occasional users go down that path, but far too many to warrant legalization, in my opinion.

I do realize, though, that someone with sufficiently different values would disagree. That can't be helped.

...

McHrozni

That's a fair enough statment at the end, but I think you've misconstrued the question somewhat. I didn't ask if those users (the vast majority) who only use occasionally for recreational purposes are entitled TO drugs, I asked if they are entitled to DO drugs when they don't harm others.

It seems to me you're making a presumption of addiction and social harm for illegal drug use. Which considering the data on use and abuse rates of most illegal drugs is a little strange.

We don't punish those who have a beer in the afternoon after work with possession of alcohol because a small percentage of people abuse alcohol. Why should we punish those who use heroin or cocaine occasionally to have some fun because a small percentage of people abuse them?

The key to any legalisation regieme would be education of drug use issues such as addiction and safe use just like we do with alcohol. We give recommendations on safe use levels in terms of drinks per day/week etc. We conduct safety campaigns against drunk driving etc. We don't have anything but "drugs r bad mmmkay" from the prohibition model, which makes people far less likely to believe the authorities in charge of the system when they tell you things which just aren't true. Such as use of drugs automatically leads to abuse, or leads to abuse in significant proportions of users.
 
And I should defend this strawman, why exactly?

Well, you were asking for a long while why cocaine use went down since 1980s, even though the price went down as well. If this is a straw man, one can only assume you weren't actually interested in the answer, which I gave. Thanks for explaining that.

McHrozni
 
That's a fair enough statment at the end, but I think you've misconstrued the question somewhat. I didn't ask if those users (the vast majority) who only use occasionally for recreational purposes are entitled TO drugs, I asked if they are entitled to DO drugs when they don't harm others.

In the case of any drug, usage will lead to harm to others. Drunken driving or stoned are both problems already. Smoking can probably be made the most safe to others.

That's why this argument can't really be made as an absolute. You can only say when the harm to others will be sufficiently minor to be the lesser of the two evils. It's that way with alcohol already, since it's quite impossible to impose a successful ban on alcohol.

We don't punish those who have a beer in the afternoon after work with possession of alcohol because a small percentage of people abuse alcohol. Why should we punish those who use heroin or cocaine occasionally to have some fun because a small percentage of people abuse them?

A couple of notes here.
1. I don't support criminalization of drug use. I've said this several times by now.
2. It's a lot easier to get addicted to heroin than to alcohol.
3. It's a lot easier for another person to discover someone has a problem with alcohol than it is to discover they have a problem with heroin.
4. It's a lot easier to treat alcohol addiction than it is to treat heroin addiction.

In other words, your question has little if any bearing on my standpoint...

The key to any legalisation regieme would be education of drug use issues such as addiction and safe use just like we do with alcohol.

This is another issue. Relatively safe use of alcohol is a lot easier than the safe use of, say, heroin. Here, an example:

We give recommendations on safe use levels in terms of drinks per day/week etc.

Violating the said rule for two weeks won't make you an alcoholic. How about violating the rule with heroin and taking it every day for a week? The safety margin for alcohol is significantly larger than with heroin.

We conduct safety campaigns against drunk driving etc. We don't have anything but "drugs r bad mmmkay" from the prohibition model, which makes people far less likely to believe the authorities in charge of the system when they tell you things which just aren't true. Such as use of drugs automatically leads to abuse, or leads to abuse in significant proportions of users.

I do believe the war on drugs should be reformed in several ways. This, I thinks, is a good candidate. It's not an all or nothing issue by any means.

McHrozni
 
Well, you were asking for a long while why cocaine use went down since 1980s, even though the price went down as well. If this is a straw man, one can only assume you weren't actually interested in the answer, which I gave. Thanks for explaining that.

McHrozni

No. Your strawman was asking me "Why would a drop in price, a greater availability and an eliminated stigma lead to less use again?", ie if it were legal. Which is a position I have never taken and thus a strawman.
 
No. Your strawman was asking me "Why would a drop in price, a greater availability and an eliminated stigma lead to less use again?", ie if it were legal. Which is a position I have never taken and thus a strawman.

Very well, then. Do you therefore agree that drug usage would increase?

McHrozni
 
In the case of any drug, usage will lead to harm to others. Drunken driving or stoned are both problems already. Smoking can probably be made the most safe to others.

That's why this argument can't really be made as an absolute. You can only say when the harm to others will be sufficiently minor to be the lesser of the two evils. It's that way with alcohol already, since it's quite impossible to impose a successful ban on alcohol.

<SNIPPED>

McHrozni


I'm not sure that you got the point. It is entirely possible to take drugs and harm no-one. I've done it. I suspect lots of people here have done it. Taken drugs, had a good time, and damaged no-one and nothing but themselves.

Why should those of us who are able to use these substances be criminalised because a small minority of people do harm others while under the influence?
 
Very well, then. Do you therefore agree that drug usage would increase?

McHrozni

Maybe. Or maybe it would stay about the same. And maybe if it did increase, less people would abuse alcohol so overall drug abuse would be the same.

And even if it did increase, I wouldn't really care that much. I don't think there is anything wrong with taking drugs. As for addiction, well I'm sure it sucks but it is entirely the fault of the addict. It's not hard to do even heroin without getting addicted. Don't start doing it everyday and you won't get addicted. I know from experience.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure that you got the point. It is entirely possible to take drugs and harm no-one. I've done it. I suspect lots of people here have done it. Taken drugs, had a good time, and damaged no-one and nothing but themselves.

Yes, that is certainly possible. However it is impossible to ensure that some of the users won't do something stupid while high - like trying to drive. That's why you can't say drugs can be absolutely safe. Smoking tobacco can come very close, but that's it.

Why should those of us who are able to use these substances be criminalised because a small minority of people do harm others while under the influence?

How many times do I need to say that I support decriminalization of drug usage? :confused:

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
Maybe. Or maybe it would stay about the same. And maybe if it did increase, less people would abuse alcohol so overall drug abuse would be the same.

Maybe. But you can't claim it would decrease, right? Furthermore, expecting an overall increase in usage (including any potential reduction of alcohol abuse) is reasonable.

And even if it did increase, I wouldn't really care that much. I don't think there is anything wrong with taking drugs. As for addiction, well I'm sure it sucks but it is entirely the fault of the addict. It's not hard to do even heroin without getting addicted. Don't start doing it everyday and you won't get addicted. I know from experience.

I disagree, but it's a matter of opinion, and impossible to debate.

McHrozni
 
DAVE, D. 2006. The effects of cocaine and heroin price on drug-related emergency department visits. Journal of Health Economics, 25, 311-33.


<snipped other references>

I haven't had a chance to look at those yet, but even if they demonstrate that lower prices lead to more usage, you've still put the cart before the horse: You are assuming prices will be lower. Why are you making that assumption?
 
Maybe. But you can't claim it would decrease, right?

It might be possible that if they weren't illegal they wouldn't be seen as the "forbidden fruit" and less people would want to try it. I find this outcome unlikely but not impossible.

Furthermore, expecting an overall increase in usage (including any potential reduction of alcohol abuse) is reasonable.

It is not an unreasonable assumption. But we can't take it for granted that it would happen.

I disagree, but it's a matter of opinion, and impossible to debate.

Fair enough.
 
I haven't had a chance to look at those yet, but even if they demonstrate that lower prices lead to more usage, you've still put the cart before the horse: You are assuming prices will be lower. Why are you making that assumption?

I'm not assuming prices will be lower. The rationale given for legalization was that it would lower the price and undercut the dealers, putting them out of business. That was the pro-legalization position offered in this thread. Wildcat said 10 bucks for a kilo of coke if it was legalized. I have no idea how much it would cost to produce given overheads, precursors and wages, but I'll take his word for it. Apparently in Australia coke is $300,000 a kilo. I'd say if coke was released in the shops at $10 a kilo tomorrow, every cokehead would go out, buy ten kilos of the stuff, binge and you'd have a bunch of OD's on the first day. We're talking about hard, highly addictive drugs here. It seems to me naive to assume that people will be responsible with it.
 
Last edited:
To be fair to Virus, unless the stuff was very heavily taxed (which would be a bad idea if you ask me), market forces would ensure that they be cheaper than now. The stuff costs very little to make.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom