The War on Drugs is Useless

The following pictures are taken from a park called Platzspitz, previously known as "Needle Park" in Switzerland. One of the pictures was taken when drug use was virtually legalized in the park. One of the was taken after the experiment was shut down. Try and guess which is which:

You do realize that these people were doing drugs before, right? The only difference is that in this picture, you can see them doing it. Do you honestly think these were all squeaky clean kids who ran out and bought heroin for the first time, when it was legalized in a park? If not, then what's the point of your post? The only point your posts makes is that drug use should perhaps not be allowed in a public park. Many parks already have such rules for legal substances, and do not allow smoking or drinking. In the Netherlands, there are many areas where you cannot smoke pot, and you can only smoke pot indoors (aside from your home of course) in designated coffeehouses.

I have mixed views on the legalization of hard drugs. I think I lean more towards making them not totally legal, but decriminalized, with users treated as opposed to prosecuted.

When it comes to softer drugs though, which have not shown themselves to be a scourge upon society and communities, then I am for total legalization. This would include weed, shrooms, ecstacy, and perhaps some others that aren't on my radar.
 
Last edited:
That is undoubtedly a factor. So perhaps more effort on the source is needed? I know much is being done already, but could more be done?

I'm sure all policies could be improved, but the question is indeed by how much.

I can't think of any ways besides maybe the US military going basically taking over the countries where these drugs are produced. They've tried destroying the crops with no real effect.



Interesting. It might be cheaper to do away with the free treatment and allow anyone to drug themselves to death if they want, though. It would depend on how much would the actual costs of procurement be, but the treatment can be so expensive as not to be worth it. It would be another money drain, in all likelihood.

That said, the cost to the society could be enormous.

Maybe.

his concern of yours strikes me as rather odd. Habitual drug users are slowly killing themselves anyway. If they kill themselves sooner, surely the damage to the society is lesser, no?

Not necessarily. Heroin isn't particularly harmful besides the dependence and high risk of overdose. A junkie can live an otherwise normal life if he has continued access to the drug a known purity rates.

And of course, not everybody that overdoses is an addict.
 
Not necessarily. Heroin isn't particularly harmful besides the dependence and high risk of overdose. A junkie can live an otherwise normal life if he has continued access to the drug a known purity rates.

That may seem so for quite a while, yes. However as it turns out, getting the fix is eventually the only goal. While it may seem to you that giving him the drug is solving the problem that really isn't the case. The addict is surviving, not living. It's a slow and relatively painless death as the person slowly abandons himself to the anticipation of the next dose.

The fact heroin doesn't significantly damage the body actually makes the whole thing worse, imho.

McHrozni
 
That may seem so for quite a while, yes. However as it turns out, getting the fix is eventually the only goal. While it may seem to you that giving him the drug is solving the problem that really isn't the case. The addict is surviving, not living. It's a slow and relatively painless death as the person slowly abandons himself to the anticipation of the next dose.

The fact heroin doesn't significantly damage the body actually makes the whole thing worse, imho.

McHrozni

Are you House?
If so,
Reference this attitude within a background model that includes the mostly pathetic lives that average people live.
Don't weigh it against the minority success story humans that don't live lives of "Quiet desperation"

(H.D. Thoreau, if I remember)
 
That may seem so for quite a while, yes. However as it turns out, getting the fix is eventually the only goal. While it may seem to you that giving him the drug is solving the problem that really isn't the case. The addict is surviving, not living.
Yeah, because it's not readily available. Users in Norway who have gotten into the Subutex distribution program and get a dose of Subutex ("replacement" drug for, among others, heroin addicts) each morning at their pharmacy are quite capable of functioning normally for the rest of the day.
 
Subutex isn't heroin. All you're doing is saying that addicts should be given treatment. Yep, I'll agree that addicts should have access to subutex.
 
Last edited:
Do you also agree that those who aren't addicts (the vast majority of users of all illegal drugs) and simply take substances for enjoyment occasionally are entitled to do so?
 
Do you not see a problem with cokeheads being able to walk into Coke-R-Us and buying a kilo for the price of a take-away?

Unfounded assumption.

Wouldn't save anything because the cost of illicit drug use to the community is greater than the cost of enforcement. More users would only increase that.

Unfounded assumption.


Tobacco use decreases with increased taxes. Happy hour increases the number of drinks people consume. Basic law of economics: Make things cheaper, more people buy them. It's just plain wishful thinking to assume otherwise.

Unfounded assumption.


You've provided no evidence that prices will go down, nor that usage will go up. Until/unless you do that, your arguments have no basis.
 
Do you also agree that those who aren't addicts (the vast majority of users of all illegal drugs) and simply take substances for enjoyment occasionally are entitled to do so?

Well, if they were entitled to it, the drugs would have to be paid for by the state.

It's not that I hate drugs or drug users, it's that many of the illegal drugs (not all) make a very slippery slope. First it's once a month, then once a week, then every weekend, then every day, then you discover it would be a good idea to stop, but it's far too late already. Not all occasional users go down that path, but far too many to warrant legalization, in my opinion.

I do realize, though, that someone with sufficiently different values would disagree. That can't be helped.

You've provided no evidence that prices will go down, nor that usage will go up.

In regards to the lower price, between the extraordinary efforts needed to get the drug to the consumer now and the fact that a portion of the shipments are seized on the way, a lower price is the only realistic possibility.

McHrozni
 
May i suggest that we all take a break in this debate; go off somewhere and smoke a joint with 2 friends; and come back with our renewed debating imagination?

Otherwise, I'm about to get bored.
Which implies, huffing plutonium, in my case.
 
The war on drugs is not useless: police departments get funds from the Feds (and the excuse) to massively militarize; police departments get the opportunity to play Rambo and violently storm the homes of non violent people who are suspected of engaging in victimless crimes (or their neighbors homes); busybodies on all sides of the political spectrum get to feel smug that they are able to control what other people do; politically ambitious DAs get something about which to grandstand for free publicity. Drug lords get substantially higher prices for their products and get free service from law enforcement officials in terms of creating barriers to entry to the market for potential competitors and elimination of their competition.

Funeral homes get more business because more people are killed each year by the war on drugs than are killed by drugs.

There are many usefull outcomes to the war on drugs.
 
You've provided no evidence that prices will go down, nor that usage will go up. Until/unless you do that, your arguments have no basis.





A 10% increase in prices can prevent 10,723 cocaine and heroin-related ED visits, with cost savings between 21 million dollars and 47 million dollars. These low magnitudes of the drug outcome-price response have implications for the cost-effectiveness of enforcement-driven price increases.
DAVE, D. 2006. The effects of cocaine and heroin price on drug-related emergency department visits. Journal of Health Economics, 25, 311-33.

CONCLUSIONS: Increasing taxes on cigarettes is a unique policy intervention that reduces smoking prevalence, generates additional tax revenue, and results in significant savings in medical care costs.
AHMAD, S. & FRANZ, G. A. 2008. Raising taxes to reduce smoking prevalence in the US: a simulation of the anticipated health and economic impacts. Public Health, 122, 3-10.

Our most consistent finding is that--contrary to some recent research--the large state tobacco tax increases of the past 15 years were associated with significant reductions in smoking participation and frequent smoking by youths. Our price elasticity estimates for smoking participation by high school youths are generally smaller than previous cross-sectional approaches but are similar to recent quasi-experimental estimates.
CARPENTER, C. & COOK, P. J. 2008. Cigarette taxes and youth smoking: new evidence from national, state, and local Youth Risk Behavior Surveys. Journal of Health Economics, 27, 287-99.

The findings suggest that the number of packs of cigarettes taxed per capita declined substantially in Massachusetts after implementation of the ballot petition.
CENTERS FOR DISEASE CONTROL & PREVENTION 1996. Cigarette smoking before and after an excise tax increase and an antismoking campaign--Massachusetts, 1990-1996. MMWR - Morbidity & Mortality Weekly Report, 45, 966-70.

Using data from the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System from 2000 to 2005, we find consistent evidence that higher taxes reduced smoking participation by older adults, especially those who are less educated and live in low-income households.
DECICCA, P. & MCLEOD, L. 2008. Cigarette taxes and older adult smoking: evidence from recent large tax increases. Journal of Health Economics, 27, 918-29.

A media campaign and $1 per pack cigarette tax increase will reduce overall smoking prevalence, significantly decrease smoking-attributable mortality, and decrease net societal costs.
FISHMAN, P. A., EBEL, B. E., GARRISON, M. M., CHRISTAKIS, D. A., WIEHE, S. E. & RIVARA, F. P. 2005. Cigarette tax increase and media campaign cost of reducing smoking-related deaths. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 29, 19-26.

Both taxation and anti-smoking media campaigns are effective means of reducing cigarette consumption. The strength of those effects, however, is influenced by the magnitude of the taxes and the amount of media campaign expenditures.
HU, T. W., SUNG, H. Y. & KEELER, T. E. 1995. Reducing cigarette consumption in California: tobacco taxes vs an anti-smoking media campaign. American Journal of Public Health, 85, 1218-22.

Young adults are sensitive to cigarette prices. Reductions in cigarette prices will lead to increased smoking initiation among this group. Tobacco taxation should be an effective strategy to reduce smoking initiation among young adults.
ZHANG, B., COHEN, J., FERRENCE, R. & REHM, J. 2006. The impact of tobacco tax cuts on smoking initiation among Canadian young adults. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 30, 474-9.
 
Hey
Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for rule 12.
why was cocaine use much higher in the 1980s when the prices were much higher than now? You ignored the question last time that I asked you. Presumably because your cognitive dissonance requires that you do.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for response to modded post.
why was cocaine use much higher in the 1980s when the prices were much higher than now? You ignored the question last time that I asked you. Presumably because your cognitive dissonance requires that you do.

Don't know.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Will you at least admit that lower prices don't automatically lead to more users? Because otherwise, more people would be using cocaine now than they did in the 80s.
 
Will you at least admit that lower prices don't automatically lead to more users? Because otherwise, more people would be using cocaine now than they did in the 80s.

I presented a bunch of studies to the contrary. I said I don't know about your specific case.
 
I presented a bunch of studies to the contrary. I said I don't know about your specific case.

You've never even read any those studies. And only one of them was about currently illegal drugs. Anyway, if lower prices automatically lead to higher use, we would see more people using cocaine than did in the 1980s. That is not happening, thus your thesis is demonstrably incorrect. Just admit your failure.
 
Last edited:
What's wrong with using legal drugs as a model? You want all drugs legalized don't you? The data from cigarette taxes indicate that higher taxes discourage use. So either you legalize drugs and tax the **** out of them to keep the number of users down, in which case the black market can still undercut you, or you undercut the dealers and get a flood of new users.
 
Why don't we use the illegal drugs themselves as a model. Why don't we see what happens when, say, cocaine becomes much cheaper. Oh wait, it's been done already. Didn't lead to more use. Actually significantly less people use.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom