The vulnerability of the Truth Movement.

Here is the CBS video clip of the second white smoke cloud coming from the open parking area. (lower right)

http://911studies.com/911photostudies117a.htm

Just as an aside, MaGZ, thanks for directing me to the above website. It appears to be a comical spoof of CT photo-interpretation, characterised by such obvious errors (in the Pentagon photos) as the inability to understand that:
(a) Objects behind other objects can't be seen because of the objects in front of them (the "vanishing sidewalk");
(b) Objects behind the camera in one shot and in front of it in another shot can only be seen in the second shot (the mysterious second railing);
(c) Not all areas of grass are exactly the same colour, and
(d) Temporary fences aren't visible before they've been put up.
I'm sure the particular picture you refer to is genuine, although I have no information about when it was taken; but the website, overall, is hilarious.

Dave
 
The fact that you "don't take any particular side" shows why you don't understand.

Truth is not decided by poll numbers. Reason is the only way we can understand truth- and your peeps don't got it. We've got the keys, and friends don't let conspiracists drive... ever.

Erm, yes you are correct in one sense. Truth isn't about poll numbers which is why no one can ever have a monopoly on the "truth". "Reasoning" is subjective, whatever it is you base it on and my "peeps" understand you very well. You have an opinion and are trying to BS your way into having some sort of standing so as to back it.

A strawman wrapped up in an ad baculum with a taste of ad hominem- all served on a hot plate of red herring.

Gimme those damn keys before you get someone killed...
 
Last edited:
Erm, yes you are correct in one sense. Truth isn't about poll numbers which is why no one can ever have a monopoly on the "truth". "Reasoning" is subjective, whatever it is you base it on and my "peeps" understand you very well. You have an opinion and are trying to BS your way into having some sort of standing so as to back it.

Gimme those damn keys before you get someone killed...

Monopolies aren't about polls.

Correct reasoning is not subjective.

My opinion is not the issue. And science is not a BS way of supporting an opinion.

You do not deserve the keys.
 
Monopolies aren't about polls.

Why did you mention polls in the first place then?!?!?!

Correct reasoning is not subjective.

I'm afraid that your notion of what "correct reasoning" entails is also subjective, no matter how many people agree with it or how often it's used.

My opinion is not the issue.

From what I see here, all you have is your opinion.

And science is not a BS way of supporting an opinion.

Right, and you are a scientist?
If so, what are you doing on the JREF boards?
If not, why bring what you're saying into the context of science?

You do not deserve the keys.

I took them while you were eating your side order of ad-hominem...
 
Why did you mention polls in the first place then?!?!?!

Go back and read my post. We have a monopoly on truth because we are rational, logical, scientific individuals- not because we're the majority.

I'm afraid that your notion of what "correct reasoning" entails is also subjective, no matter how many people agree with it or how often it's used.

I never said that how many people agree with me matter- nor how often it's used... in fact I said the opposite.

But look at what you're saying. You're saying that correct reasoning is subjective... at the same time you're trying to tell me I'm wrong... (while injecting a strawman). How can these two statements be true? If reasoning is subjective, then you can't possibly be right- and I can't possibly be wrong- according to you.

From what I see here, all you have is your opinion.

One wouldn't expect you to see anything else. Science, however, doesn't care about what you claim to see.

Right, and you are a scientist?
If so, what are you doing on the JREF boards?
If not, why bring what you're saying into the context of science?

Have I not?

I took them while you were eating your side order of ad-hominem...

Where?
 
Right, and you are a scientist?
If so, what are you doing on the JREF boards?

What are these two questions supposed to imply, O Wise One? Only scientists are allowed to use the scientific method? If I am a scientist, I'm banned from JREF? Sound like a couple of ridiculous questions to me, but I'm just a layman, so what do I know, compared to your radiant knowledge!
 
Go back and read my post. We have a monopoly on truth because we are rational, logical, scientific individuals- not because we're the majority.

I never said that how many people agree with me matter- nor how often it's used... in fact I said the opposite.

But why bring polls into it?
I never insinuated that it had anything to do with statistics...

But look at what you're saying. You're saying that correct reasoning is subjective... at the same time you're trying to tell me I'm wrong... (while injecting a strawman). How can these two statements be true? If reasoning is subjective, then you can't possibly be right- and I can't possibly be wrong- according to you.

Correct reasoning gave credence to the idea that the Sun orbited the earth in the old days yet it is now determined to be false reasoning thanks to a bunch of other variables. I'm not saying I'm right or that you are wrong, I'm saying that I don't know!

One wouldn't expect you to see anything else. Science, however, doesn't care about what you claim to see.

Good science, yes. Bad science, no. Science, in general, is not above false reasoning however. It's just a process designed to refine it.

What are these two questions supposed to imply, O Wise One? Only scientists are allowed to use the scientific method?

Not many people are using the scientific method on the JREF forums, it's emotionally high-strung for the most part.

If I am a scientist, I'm banned from JREF?

What?

Sound like a couple of ridiculous questions to me, but I'm just a layman, so what do I know, compared to your radiant knowledge!

What?
 
But why bring polls into it?
I never insinuated that it had anything to do with statistics...

But the post I was responding to did. You then tried to say that a monopoly was about polls. It is not. I was simply correcting your statement.

Correct reasoning gave credence to the idea that the Sun orbited the earth in the old days yet it is now determined to be false reasoning thanks to a bunch of other variables. I'm not saying I'm right or that you are wrong, I'm saying that I don't know!

Saying you don't know is different than saying no one can know. And no, it was not correct reasoning that arrived at the conclusion that the Sun orbited the Earth... it was religion- which is as far away from reasoning as one can get.

Good science, yes. Bad science, no. Science, in general, is not above false reasoning however. It's just a process designed to refine it.

Care to define "bad science" without mentioning failed reasoning?

Not many people are using the scientific method on the JREF forums, it's emotionally high-strung for the most part.

Emotionally high-strung does not mean that people are not using the scientific method. This, again, is simply a claim you cannot support (especially if you want to continue to claim that reasoning is subjective... by your logic we shouldn't believe you).

What?
What?

Exactly.
 
But the post I was responding to did. You then tried to say that a monopoly was about polls. It is not. I was simply correcting your statement.

Well you managed to quote me in your response which implied that you were addressing my statement regarding the absurdity of having a monopoly on the truth. Such a thing is called religion.

Saying you don't know is different than saying no one can know. And no, it was not correct reasoning that arrived at the conclusion that the Sun orbited the Earth... it was religion- which is as far away from reasoning as one can get.

This is being subjective again, religion is based on limited reasoning. As I said, the moment other variables come into it we get a different picture.

Care to define "bad science" without mentioning failed reasoning?

Hmm, falsifying data would qualify I suppose. Not that I'm insinuating anything, just directly answering your question.

Emotionally high-strung does not mean that people are not using the scientific method. This, again, is simply a claim you cannot support (especially if you want to continue to claim that reasoning is subjective... by your logic we shouldn't believe you).

If you can't remain balanced mentally/emotionally while evaluating something then the integrity of your mental critique becomes questionable. But if reasoning is subjective why would I care what people outside my own subjective thought processes thought? : p

I'm just pointing out variables.



Damn right!
 
" thoroughly debunked" I don’t think so.

The first CNN photo shows the white cloud of smoke that appeared at 9:04 after the missile struck WTC7. The second photo taken about an hour later shows the collapse of WTC2.


Actually, I do think that you've been debunked. You just dissapeared when you were, on SLC. Proof:
http://screwloosechange.xbehome.com/index.php?showtopic=1531

And your original post there:
http://screwloosechange.xbehome.com/index.php?showtopic=1451

If you look at the following picture:
http://www.amanzafar.com/WTC/wtc40_small.JPG

You will see that the WTC7 south face is almost completely intact just as the south tower collapses. Thus, reducing your stupid theory about missiles on WTC7 to the rubble it belongs in.
 
Well you managed to quote me in your response which implied that you were addressing my statement regarding the absurdity of having a monopoly on the truth. Such a thing is called religion.

No, it's the opposite of religion- which is why it's funny to call it a monopoly.

This is being subjective again, religion is based on limited reasoning. As I said, the moment other variables come into it we get a different picture.

No, religion is the antithesis of reasoning- it's the rejection of it, not a "limited form of it". The fact that other variables "come into it" and thus it produces a different picture shows emphatically that reason is objective. The fact that religion denied (and in some places still does) the facts about the universe shows that it is not reason.

Hmm, falsifying data would qualify I suppose. Not that I'm insinuating anything, just directly answering your question.

Which would be failed reasoning. If you are falsifying data- you have a predetermined conclusion. This is a rejection of the scientific method ie reasoning.

If you can't remain balanced mentally/emotionally while evaluating something then the integrity of your mental critique becomes questionable.

If- and only if- that emotion influences your hypothesis- instead of being a reaction to it. Question it all you want- you were saying that people were being emotional instead of being rational. The two are not mutually exclusive. You have now admitted that- but only in direct contradiction to your previous statement:

Not many people are using the scientific method on the JREF forums, it's emotionally high-strung for the most part.

But if reasoning is subjective why would I care what people outside my own subjective thought processes thought? : p

And hence why you have no argument whatsoever- you have neither the position nor the power to call anyone right or wrong. To do so would contradict what you see as a subjective truth, only to then turn around and have nothing to base it on because reality is simply subjective.

It makes no sense. And it's wrong. We prove that every day with science- with technology- with getting up and brushing our teeth.

I'm just pointing out variables.

No, you're trying to claim there's a preponderance of emotion instead of scientific reasoning, here. You have no basis for this claim, and have had to reduce it to nothing more than a "variable" or "questionable". You make no mention of what is questionable about it, or why it's wrong- you just plaster on ad hominem in an attempt to sneak in a claim of argument from emotion without actually saying so. Fact is, you can't support it. Apparently, though, you don't think you need to- because truth doesn't exist?
 
Totovader, we could go on forever like the above but it's as simple as this.

By your thinking, the reason I am unable to understand the validity of having "a monopoly on truth and reasoning", as a concept, is because I don't take sides.

So now you have a monopoly on truth and reasoning because of the side you have taken?

That is surely subjective reasoning at its best. If you want to take this further I'll be back later today, and please don't come up with "it's because my side is truth and reason".
 
Two missiles were fired in an attempt to shoot down the second hijacked plane. One missile hit WTC 7 on the 14th floor and the other missile hit in the open parking area.

The Missiles at Ground Zero
http://www.nationalvanguard.org/printer.php?id=10058

From above site

ILLUSTRATION: Damage to WTC7 is evident in this official photograph taken before the "pulling" of the building.)

In addition to the missile hit, WTC 7 suffered severe damage to its southwest corner on floors 8 thru 18 from the falling debris of the North Tower (WTC 1). Being unstable, WTC 7 might have collapsed on its own without any assistance. However, the fall would have been toward its weakest point: the southwest corner. In order to prevent such a collapse and to save lives in the ongoing search and rescue efforts, a decision was made to "pull" the building.

Well that's all the debunking I need.
 
Totovader, we could go on forever like the above but it's as simple as this.

No- eventually someone has to admit that they are not paying attention.

By your thinking, the reason I am unable to understand the validity of having "a monopoly on truth and reasoning", as a concept, is because I don't take sides.

Holy strawman. Not even close to what I said. You don't understand the validity of objective truth because you choose to believe that subjectivity is more valid, neglecting the fact that this thought requires an objective view of reality.

Apparently, we need to have a discussion on what science is. Twice, now, you've attempted to bastardize it as simply subjective and religious. That is the reason you can't comprehend a science based on objective reality.

So now you have a monopoly on truth and reasoning because of the side you have taken?

No, the side I go with is the one that has a monopoly on truth and reasoning. Again, you try a strawman.

That is surely subjective reasoning at its best. If you want to take this further I'll be back later today, and please don't come up with "it's because my side is truth and reason".

Why would you reject that statement? Because you don't like it? You gave no reason to reject it- yet you knew it was coming... I wonder why that is.

What do you think science is? A vote?
 
Why would you reject that statement? Because you don't like it? You gave no reason to reject it- yet you knew it was coming... I wonder why that is.

It is because everything I have said stands and that you are utterly predictable in your thinking to the point that I knew when to break away from your circular reasoning so as to avoid further long-winded dispute.

You think that truth and reasoning involves having some sort of faction which, incidentally, is no different from religion.

You say I bastardized science?

If that's the case then you're about to turn this place into a cult.

Ok, I really am off now. BBL
 
It is because everything I have said stands

How does it stand? You haven't even explained it- let alone proved it. I've shown that your statements are contradictory- self-defeating. What has your response been to that? Nothing.

and that you are utterly predictable in your thinking to the point that I knew when to break away from your circular reasoning so as to avoid further long-winded dispute.

Circular reasoning? Back that one up, too...

Utterly predictable != wrong.

You think that truth and reasoning involves having some sort of faction which, incidentally, is no different from religion.

Yet another strawman. I do not believe it has anything to do with labels, or what "group" you belong to. I've stated the opposite. The fact that you keep comparing a group which utilizes the faculties of reason to religion shows that you're far away from any semblance of understanding.

You say I bastardized science?

If that's the case then you're about to turn this place into a cult.

Ok, I really am off now. BBL

How can a cult be based on science? No, seriously- answer that question. Scientific inquiry is the exact opposite of the very definition of a cult.

I understand your need to reject everything you see as scientific and rigid- but claiming it's a cult or a religion won't work. All we need to do is maintain the scientific position, and then your claims fall on their face. Any quick perusal of the threads will show this to be case.
 
Yet another strawman. I do not believe it has anything to do with labels, or what "group" you belong to. I've stated the opposite. The fact that you keep comparing a group which utilizes the faculties of reason to religion shows that you're far away from any semblance of understanding.

The fact that you don't take any particular side shows why you don't understand.

So I need to take sides in order to understand?

Truth is not decided by poll numbers. Reason is the only way we can understand truth- and your peeps don't got it. We've got the keys, and friends don't let conspiracists drive... ever.

Who is "we"?

How can a cult be based on science? No, seriously- answer that question. Scientific inquiry is the exact opposite of the very definition of a cult.

What you are saying has nothing to do with science. Good science is impartial, you are not. What are you representing? The truth? Yikes, there's certainly a lot of contention in regards to that...

I understand your need to reject everything you see as scientific and rigid- but claiming it's a cult or a religion won't work. All we need to do is maintain the scientific position, and then your claims fall on their face. Any quick perusal of the threads will show this to be case.

The JREF forum is not the scientific community you make it out to be. Your notion of a scientific position became compromised when you started believing you have a monopoly on the truth.

Science as a cult, yes it's possible. It's the same reason why taboos exist in the scientific community and that even things like hypnosis and electrosensitivity are laughed at due to a lack of understanding and general unwillingness to accept the research. All due to how many failures it exposes.

we have a monopoly on truth and logic

The claim I've made is that you cannot have a monopoly on the truth. The moment you think you do, your ego comes into full play. Truth does not belong to you, nor are you the sole proprietor of reason. It is completely ridiculous to suppose that the truth can be owned or that it can be denied to someone. It's always there, waiting to be discovered by those who seek it, you cannot deny people their thoughts.

I don't care about 911, I'm just addressing this strange idea that you have. It's far more disturbing than any conspiracy theory I've ever heard.

Don't get confused, the JREF forum contains a lot of over-intellectualizing and people may believe they know "the truth" about certain things but that's all it is, a belief based on a conclusion drawn from a set of variables. A fact is unlikely to be disputed to the extent that 911 has which is why I remain undecided on the subject. I am willing to suspend my disbelief so as to consider the unthinkable.

I come to the CT boards to read about the subjects in question, not to hear someone say that they have "a monopoly on the truth". That's CT material in and of itself, start a new thread.
 
Last edited:
So I need to take sides in order to understand?

Only if you take the comment out of context. Back then we were talking about the "monopoly on truth".

Who is "we"?

Scientists, skeptics, and anyone else who wants to call themselves critical thinkers.

What you are saying has nothing to do with science. Good science is impartial, you are not.

Right now- demonstrate how I am not impartial.

Do it, I dare you.

What are you representing? The truth? Yikes, there's certainly a lot of contention in regards to that...

Disagreement does not mean that truth is not found. AGAIN, polls != truth.

The JREF forum is not the scientific community you make it out to be. Your notion of a scientific position became compromised when you started believing you have a monopoly on the truth.

Says who?

Science as a cult, yes it's possible. It's the same reason why taboos exist in the scientific community and that even things like hypnosis and electrosensitivity are laughed at due to a lack of understanding and general unwillingness to accept the research. All due to how many failures it exposes.

*giggle*

The claim I've made is that you cannot have a monopoly on the truth.

And you have not spent any energy on providing evidence for such a claim.

If I make the claim that I am rational- that I am logical- that I exist in an objective reality... then why bother challenge that by saying "no you're not"- as if that doesn't demonstrate precisely what I'm talking about.

The moment you think you do, your ego comes into full play.

Only if you allow your ego to influence your research. I don't- because I'm too egotistical to subvert scientific study. That's where my ego takes me. It plays along with science nicely- because it's primary concern is becoming educated.

Truth does not belong to you, nor are you the sole proprietor of reason.

Holy strawman.

It is completely ridiculous to suppose that the truth can be owned or that it can be denied to someone.

Another strawman.

It's always there, waiting to be discovered by those who seek it, you cannot deny people their thoughts.

And still another strawman!

I am amazed.

I don't care about 911, I'm just addressing this strange idea that you have. It's far more disturbing than any conspiracy theory I've ever heard.

And a poisoning of the well.

Magnificent.

Don't get confused, the JREF forum contains a lot of over-intellectualizing and people may believe they know "the truth" about certain things but that's all it is, a belief based on a conclusion drawn from a set of variables.

*giggle*

Um, what is the truth? And, do you really think I give a crap about what people think or say? If they want to be "over-intellectual" then "they have a right to think what they want", right? If truth is truth- then all they need to do is make sure their variables are in the right order- and people like you can only resort to personal attacks in response.

A fact is unlikely to be disputed to the extent that 911 has which is why I remain undecided on the subject.

This makes no sense whatsoever.

I am willing to suspend my disbelief so as to consider the unthinkable.

Are you sure you're suspending your disbelief? It doesn't appear that this is the case... and really, that's a contradiction in terms.

I come to the CT boards to read about the subjects in question, not to hear someone say that they have "a monopoly on the truth". That's CT material in and of itself, start a new thread.

Throw some more poison in that well. If you don't come here to read it- then don't. But I don't pretend to be something I'm not.

None of us here are infallible. We all make mistakes- either by poor reasoning, or jumping to conclusions, or not having all the information, or by loyalty- whatever. And to sum it up: who really gives a crap. In the end, the skeptics/scientists/debunkers will be the ones holding the keys in their hand- and the deniers will remain where they have always been. To claim there's some sort of middle ground is ludicrous- the scientists go with the science, and the skeptics and debunkers follow. We adapt, we concede, we discover, and we move on. Deniers... they're still eating their young over whether it was a death ray from outer space or a mini-nuke, or a controlled demolition. They cut each others throats at the mere mention of the slightest possibility they could be wrong. They viciously attack each other and everyone else for daring to question what they supposedly dared to question.

That's not science- that's not truth.

So, I'm not saying we're always right. I'm not even saying we're right in everything we're saying right now. Hell, I've been wrong in the last couple days on major items- but that doesn't stop me. It doesn't even discourage me. I shrug my shoulders and submit to reality- because that's what we do. THAT is why we have a monopoly on reality.
 
They cut each others throats at the mere mention of the slightest possibility they could be wrong. They viciously attack each other and everyone else for daring to question what they supposedly dared to question.

That's not science- that's not truth.

Many would argue that the scientific community is somewhat divided. This is especially true when it comes down to competing theories. Yes, scientists have been known to visciously attack one another for daring to question each other. So, as science currently exists, what you have described is indeed a part of the practical application science. While "a truth" will bring contention to people whose truth differs, attacking one another viciously has no association with the virtue of truth itself. So no, science is not truth. It is a process designed to find agreeable conclusions but not one that is infallible.

To claim that the above concept of science has any monopoly on the truth is stark raving mad.

How can you be impartial when you claim to have a monopoly on truth?

we have a monopoly on reality

How can you claim to be impartial when you claim to have a monopoly on reality?

How, in the name of all things sacred, can you now have a monopoly on reality?

How can you have a monopoly on something without involving a commodity or having exclusive possession and control of that same commodity?

The only thing you have a monopoly on is your own thoughts, it's the same with everyone else. Reality is subjective but certain things are permitted in the sense that they are agreed on to a large extent.

The moment you start thinking only you know the truth is the exact time when your ego breaks loose and wreaks havoc on your psyche. If you don't know where you stand in regards to what an opinion is worth then you have no foundation on which to make an argument.

You have a monopoly on the truth?
You have a monopoly on reality?

You seem to be doing a damn poor job of maintaining its cohesion if that's the case.

And, do you really think I give a crap about what people think or say?

Heck no!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom