The vulnerability of the Truth Movement.

If your statement were true, then I would be forced to not understand it. You are pointing to the apple on the table and saying "there is no way to describe that red apple".

You can describe the apple but have no guarantee that it is thought of in the same way by someone else, even if they use the same words to describe it.

Here's what you have consistently avoided: if reality is subjective- then how can one be wrong or right? The closes you have come to answering this is to say there is a consensus, but a consensus based on what? You then say it's based on the perception- but this contradicts a claim that reality is subjective!

All it comes down to is "identifying" stuff which seems to be elusive, for whatever reason. How much more of it we're missing is anyone's guess which is especially true when things like the double slit experiment are taken into account (interfering with something we can't study objectively due to the very act of measurement having a consequence).

Again- theorize based on what? If your claim is that reality is subjective- and our senses are subjective- and everything is subjective... then there can be no such thing as truth. It's that simple.

Which is just one of the reasons why you have no monopoly on it. It's far too elusive.

I'll ask again: You claim that reality is subjective. Your evidence for this has been that people disagree- yet you claim that truth only occurs through consensus. What you have failed to address is how consensus is reached if reality is subjective. What are they agreeing on- how, through what method?

Comparisons based on the varying degrees of perceived similarities of concepts.

Besides that being a big if- that only shows that reality is objective.

It shows only that something else would have come to our attention.

According to your definition- these laws are truth, since the vast majority of scientists agree with them.

No, law is just the categorization of particular regulations certain entities are expected to follow. Truth, as you understand it, isn't involved.

Now you're getting into another ridiculous realm: group consciousness?

Hold on, I'm getting a message from the stones. They're telling me to read my horoscope...

Hmm? It's a simple concept, I suppose you can think of it in terms of "memes" if it's too much for you but that would certainly limit the idea. As for horoscopes, I don't buy into that sort of stuff but you're welcome to.

But if we're at Conjunction Junction, what's your function?

To present the contention.

Beyond the fact that this is what I have been saying repeatedly- this is the very thing you deny in your first paragraph. You seem to love to do that: start out with one statement, and then completely deny it in your following paragraphs.

Some confusion in your thinking there.

My perception does not tell me that black is white- I may have an improper concept of black or white, but that's testable- because reality is objective.

It's testable because there's an agreement as to what makes up colour based on the acceptance of a majority. There is no completely objective truth regarding it.

Core levels? Whatever that means...

The only fundamental truth, if it even exists.

True or false, A = B. Well, quite easily: false. My eyes see (perception) the points of the "A", the dash across the middle- my brain then recognizes it (conception) as the letter "A". My eyes also see the rounded breasts of the "B" (perception), and my brain then recognizes it as the letter "B" (conception). It concludes that A is not B, because A is A, and B is B. B is not A.

Based on my current understanding I would agree with you regarding your conclusion of A not being equal to B. I wouldn't say it's objective as I doubt that everyone else would see or even think same thing. We seem to be agreeing on the description of a particular set of shapes.

Not that hard to grasp.

Not if you have familiarized yourself with it to the extent that you take it for granted.

That's all I've been doing. I've still got all my real estate- and you're losing yours. But let's stick to the topic for now before you use up all your get out of jail free cards...

About this monopoly of yours, how did you come about the possession of it again?
 
You can describe the apple but have no guarantee that it is thought of in the same way by someone else, even if they use the same words to describe it.

If they are describing it accurately, I can be. Furthermore, if I turn and then look at the apple, I can be 100% sure.

All it comes down to is "identifying" stuff which seems to be elusive, for whatever reason.

It only seems to be elusive because you want to pretend that reality is subjective.

How much more of it we're missing is anyone's guess which is especially true when things like the double slit experiment are taken into account (interfering with something we can't study objectively due to the very act of measurement having a consequence).

How does the double-slit have anything to do with what we're talking about? Furthermore, the Uncertainty Principle is a fact of the consequences of observation... A FACT WE ARE AWARE OF- which only brings us back to context and the objective nature of reality.

Which is just one of the reasons why you have no monopoly on it. It's far too elusive.

But it's not elusive- you just continue to contradict yourself. You must have mistaken my pointing this out with me being confused. I am not.

Comparisons based on the varying degrees of perceived similarities of concepts.

This- for the last time- is not an answer. This is simply saying that people agree. What basis do they have to agree? If measurement is subjective, reality is subjective, concepts have no basis in reality- and truth is unattainable. How- then- do people find agreement? Out of thin air? Do they just pick random numbers and then when they match they call it reality?

No. Your claim that reality is subjective is self-defeating.

It shows only that something else would have come to our attention.

"Something" else? Of what? To you, reality is subjective... so whatever you perceive would be what you created... so... HOW COULD YOUR ASSERTION THAT "SOMETHING ELSE WOULD COME TO OUR ATTENTION" have any basis?

You continue to dodge this point. How to people agree? How is there consistency? It's not "agreement on varying degrees of similarity"- it's consistency with reality. Any attempt to deny that defeats itself- because you cannot claim that reality is subjective- and then turn around and claim that anyone who disagrees with you is wrong. "WRONG" is a judgement call based on reality. If you really believed that reality was subjective- you would have no basis for your claim that I am wrong.

No, law is just the categorization of particular regulations certain entities are expected to follow.

Bahahaha. Based on reality. You again avoided the question.

You claimed that truth is only a consensus. To then deny that axioms are not truth because people agree is to directly contradict yourself. Which- no doubt- you are fond of doing.

Truth, as you understand it, isn't involved.

This doesn't even make sense.

Hmm? It's a simple concept, I suppose you can think of it in terms of "memes" if it's too much for you but that would certainly limit the idea. As for horoscopes, I don't buy into that sort of stuff but you're welcome to.

To present the contention.

Some confusion in your thinking there.

Junk.

It's testable because there's an agreement as to what makes up colour based on the acceptance of a majority. There is no completely objective truth regarding it.

Dead wrong. First of all- how can there be agreement? If reality is subjective, no such agreement could exist. Furthermore, your regression back to the claim that the majority simply makes up reality again contradicts your earlier statement where you tried to deny laws.

And lastly- if you want to tie it all back: we have a monopoly on truth simply because we're the majority- if you believe in subjectivity.

Of course- that's total crap- but I want to see you try and back out of your own failed reasoning, here.

The only fundamental truth, if it even exists.

If you were any more ambiguous, your head would be a button.

Based on my current understanding I would agree with you regarding your conclusion of A not being equal to B. I wouldn't say it's objective as I doubt that everyone else would see or even think same thing. We seem to be agreeing on the description of a particular set of shapes.

:eek:

Not if you have familiarized yourself with it to the extent that you take it for granted.

Well this certainly makes no sense.

About this monopoly of yours, how did you come about the possession of it again?

Only after you answer my questions do you get any ice cream.
 
Ok, Expression_man, back to basics:

You claim that reality is subjective, correct?

Your evidence for this claim is that people disagree, correct?

Now please understand the difference between perception and conception:

Perception = the act of observation using the senses. You have gone back and forth between understanding this, and then contradicting it. Perception is not interpretation of observations- it is only an observation.

Conception = the act of taking particulars about an observation (abstraction) and forming concepts based on those particulars.

Agree, or disagree? Why or why not?

I would reply to your statement above- but you continue to go back and forth between your first statement- and then contradictions of your first statement, so we really need to clarify this before we can move on.

Expression_man:

You're wondering off into ambiguous mumbo jumbo again- so let's get back to this. Try and answer it again- the answer you gave before obviously got us nowhere, and you just continue to dodge my rebuttal. This really is the core of your failure, so let's get it worked out.

Quickly- please. No more parisology.
 
Expression_man:

You're wondering off into ambiguous mumbo jumbo again- so let's get back to this. Try and answer it again- the answer you gave before obviously got us nowhere, and you just continue to dodge my rebuttal. This really is the core of your failure, so let's get it worked out.

Quickly- please. No more parisology.
Oh, please. All he can do is throw up a rhetorical smoke screen to try to make it look like he has an actual point. But once you cut through all the words, you realize all he's trying to say is "you're a big mean man, trying to force your viewpoint onto others!" Typical whining, just using big words to try to hide it.
 
Oh, please. All he can do is throw up a rhetorical smoke screen to try to make it look like he has an actual point. But once you cut through all the words, you realize all he's trying to say is "you're a big mean man, trying to force your viewpoint onto others!" Typical whining, just using big words to try to hide it.

The point is that nothing can be verified objectively, it's clear that such a concept is found to be disturbing by some people. : )

We agree in order to avoid confusion, few people have ever questioned everything they believe to know.

Hehehe, these are not big words.

It's no more complex than that. Were a real truth ever observable it would be so blatant that it would most likely end up explaining itself.

-------------------------------------------------------------

Totovader

I think you understand how you can't have a monopoly on reality and truth now. Since you have refused to explain how you have a monopoly on these concepts after all this time it is obvious that you are incapable of doing so. You have played for far too much time without bringing anything to the dicussion regarding your claimed affiliation with a monopoly on truth and reality. I'm sure that you're aware of how I could go on answering your questions forever but I think that I've over-indulged you. It's also getting boring.

How can you have a monopoly on the truth and reality?

And I mean all realities and all truths. Subjective truth and objective truth. Not only that, you will also have to define how you can define an objective truth.

We might use the words "truth" and "reality" in certain contexts but when you bring in the concept of having a monopoly on them you must then address every interpretation in existence otherwise you do not have a reliable monopoly on the concepts of reality and truth.

This is not made any easier for you by your belief in perceived absolutes that are subject to change.

Good luck.
 
Last edited:
The point is that nothing can be verified objectively, it's clear that such a concept is found to be disturbing by some people. : )

Oh, good grief. So, 9/11 "Truth" is only truth once we throw out any previous definitions of truth, and adopt the imaginary definition of truth used by Expression_man.

Of course, in MY version of reality, Expression_man doesn't exist, I'm a multi-billionaire secret agent married to a beautiful supermodel, and the President of the US isn't Bush, it's Michael J. Fox. 9/11 didn't occur, it was thwarted by magical, time-travelling leprechauns...however, Osama bin Laden is still a menace to civilization, since he's an enormous, 30-foot tall demon who shoots lazers out of his eye sockets. Me and President Fox regularly battle him in a DeLorean that transforms into a giant robot.
 
The point is that nothing can be verified objectively, it's clear that such a concept is found to be disturbing by some people. : )

Quick question for you (although you may need to think about it for a while).

Is what you're saying TRUE?

*cough*...

We agree in order to avoid confusion, few people have ever questioned everything they believe to know.

So truth doesn't really exist, and consensus is just a "confusion avoider"? Tell me, what is confusion if not inconsistency in reality?

It's no more complex than that. Were a real truth ever observable it would be so blatant that it would most likely end up explaining itself.

:boggled: Again, is this TRUE?

Yet again- the contradiction you present here is so blatantly obvious, I'm left wondering how you can continue to try and maintain it without laughing at yourself.

:busted

Totovader

I think you understand how you can't have a monopoly on reality and truth now.

I think you're pretending to think that so you can run away and not defend your position. I have given no indication whatsoever that my position has changed.

Since you have refused to explain how you have a monopoly on these concepts after all this time it is obvious that you are incapable of doing so.

I've repeatedly explained it in several comments- you just keep demanding that I re-explain it so you can escape your contradictions. You haven't even said what was inconsistent about my explanations.

You have played for far too much time without bringing anything to the dicussion regarding your claimed affiliation with a monopoly on truth and reality. I'm sure that you're aware of how I could go on answering your questions forever but I think that I've over-indulged you. It's also getting boring.

Uh huh. I'm betting you would continue to dodge the questions- as you have.

How can you have a monopoly on the truth and reality?

Explained- in great detail- already:
See post #50, #103, #105, #108, #111, #114, #116, #119, #123, #126, #130, #134, #140, and #142.

And I mean all realities and all truths.

Realities? How many realities are there, Expression_Man?

Subjective truth and objective truth. Not only that, you will also have to define how you can define an objective truth.

"Objective truth" is your word, but I would simply define it as that which is consistent with reality.

We might use the words "truth" and "reality" in certain contexts but when you bring in the concept of having a monopoly on them you must then address every interpretation in existence otherwise you do not have a reliable monopoly on the concepts of reality and truth.

I don't see why that would be a requirement.

This is not made any easier for you by your belief in perceived absolutes that are subject to change.

This also makes no sense.

Good luck.

You can have luck- I'll stick with science.
 
This thread is making my brain hurt. I'm going to go have some Coca-Cola (after all, IT'S THE REAL THING) liberally mixed with Jack Daniels' Old No. 7 REAL Sippin' Whiskey.
I hear ya. Once "objective truth" (a redundancy) crept into the thread, I leapt for the cocoon of comfort that can only be found within the contents of a crystal container of cognac.
 
Never knew this would develope into something like this. I have no booze here. Maybe a glass of juice. Mmgh. I hate a flu.
 
Quick question for you (although you may need to think about it for a while).

Is what you're saying TRUE?

*cough*...

For me : )

So truth doesn't really exist, and consensus is just a "confusion avoider"? Tell me, what is confusion if not inconsistency in reality?



:boggled: Again, is this TRUE?

Why do you think the world is in confusion?

Too many perceived realities with no way of knowing which is worth more in terms of what there is to gain, subjectively. It's very confusing : p

Yet again- the contradiction you present here is so blatantly obvious, I'm left wondering how you can continue to try and maintain it without laughing at yourself.

:busted

You're not thinking simply enough.

The only way anything could ever be true is if it could explain itself without requiring interpretation on our part. That's not something we're capable of perceiving and so you're still a long way off here.


I think you're pretending to think that so you can run away and not defend your position. I have given no indication whatsoever that my position has changed.

No, it's much simpler than that. It's that this has gone on for a long time and I'm the only one answering questions here. This is because you are already aware that there is no foundation for the idea of having a monopoly on truth and reality.

I've repeatedly explained it in several comments- you just keep demanding that I re-explain it so you can escape your contradictions. You haven't even said what was inconsistent about my explanations.

You haven't explained it even once. :p

Uh huh. I'm betting you would continue to dodge the questions- as you have.

Come on, put or shutup.

Where's this monopoly?
Who is in posession of it?

Explained- in great detail- already:
See post #50, #103, #105, #108, #111, #114, #116, #119, #123, #126, #130, #134, #140, and #142.

No, it must be simple. A monopoly is not a complex idea, it does not require the over intellectualization you have applied to the concept. In less than 30 words and no more, state it now. Where is your argument?

Realities? How many realities are there, Expression_Man?

Beyond the generalized human perception of reality? I'd have no way of knowing.

"Objective truth" is your word, but I would simply define it as that which is consistent with reality.

Which reality? Human reality is not objective reality : p

I don't see why that would be a requirement.

So now you're saying that the concept of all truth doesn't come into the idea of having a monopoly on it?

This also makes no sense.

Laws are broken at different stages in there realization until they are no longer laws and the realization of it not being one has come about. Gravity is not objective as its laws do not apply to all perceptions of reality(ies). It is not a law of all reality.

You can have luck- I'll stick with science.

You think that luck doesn't come into science, would you dare suggest such a thing? : p

-------------------------------------------

Axiom Blade

Of course, in MY version of reality, Expression_man doesn't exist, I'm a multi-billionaire secret agent married to a beautiful supermodel, and the President of the US isn't Bush, it's Michael J. Fox. 9/11 didn't occur, it was thwarted by magical, time-travelling leprechauns...however, Osama bin Laden is still a menace to civilization, since he's an enormous, 30-foot tall demon who shoots lazers out of his eye sockets. Me and President Fox regularly battle him in a DeLorean that transforms into a giant robot.

But if Expression_Man doesn't exist in your reality, be it as your perceived version of objectvity or as a perceived idea (those 2 concepts being intertwined), why would you reference him?
 
Last edited:
For me : )

Based on what...

Why do you think the world is in confusion?

This isn't an answer to my question.

Too many perceived realities with no way of knowing which is worth more in terms of what there is to gain, subjectively. It's very confusing : p

Only because you choose to make it confusing, and refuse to answer my questions.

You're not thinking simply enough.

I couldn't make it any easier for you. If you're saying it's TRUE that nothing can be verified objectively- you're directly contradicting yourself. It's a fallacy known as the stolen concept. In order for something to have TRUTH, it must be verifiable. So if you're claiming that it's true that truth doesn't exist- you're mocking yourself, and according to you we shouldn't believe you.

The only way anything could ever be true is if it could explain itself without requiring interpretation on our part. That's not something we're capable of perceiving and so you're still a long way off here.

So here again you're referring to an objective reality- that truth exists independent of our observations. Then, you turn around and claim that none of our observations can be true, simple because we are observing.

Again- if this is your claim- we can't believe you based on what you've said. You debunk yourself.

No, it's much simpler than that. It's that this has gone on for a long time and I'm the only one answering questions here.

Wrong. You have avoided every question I have presented. I have repeatedly clarified, corrected, and directly answered yours. The history of this very thread shows you to be inconsistent in your statements.

This is because you are already aware that there is no foundation for the idea of having a monopoly on truth and reality.

You should know by now not to make my statements for me- because you're dead wrong.

You haven't explained it even once. :p

I linked you to several posts where I did. Cupping your ears and screaming "NO NO NO NO" is not a valid debate technique.

Come on, put or shutup.

Where's this monopoly?
Who is in posession of it?

These questions have already been answered- you know because we only got this far because of my answers.

No, it must be simple. A monopoly is not a complex idea, it does not require the over intellectualization you have applied to the concept.

Wrong. This is an ad hominem (style over substance fallacy). There is no rational basis to claim it must be "easy". "Complex" is a completely ambiguous term as you have applied it, and you're simply trying to get me to fetch further quotes for you from statements I've already made and linked to. You've done this in order to avoid the consequences of the discussion that's already taken place. We are arguing about your nonsensical definition of reality because of the misunderstanding you have on the statements I have made in regards to belonging to the group of individuals who have a monopoly on truth. The statements I have made have been painfully clear, and are readily available- I even cataloged them for you.

You're demanding that I repost it as a red herring.

In less than 30 words and no more, state it now. Where is your argument?

AGAIN: Explained- in great detail- already:
See post #50, #103, #105, #108, #111, #114, #116, #119, #123, #126, #130, #134, #140, and #142.

Beyond the generalized human perception of reality? I'd have no way of knowing.

You indicated there were multiple realities. I would like for you to provide evidence of this claim, or at the very least understand that it demands to be retracted (and since it is obviously the basis for the majority of your thinking- you will need to rethink your entire position).

If you have no way of knowing a statement you just made- perhaps you shouldn't make it?

Which reality? Human reality is not objective reality : p

Again... Is that true? *COUGH*

So now you're saying that the concept of all truth doesn't come into the idea of having a monopoly on it?

That has absolutely nothing to do with what you're saying. You said I must address every interpretation of "monopoly" in order to make my case. I said- as a matter-of-fact, no I do not. Now you're confusing yourself- by taking my statements one sentence at a time and refusing to answer my questions, you can't even remember what you were saying.

Laws are broken at different stages in there realization until they are no longer laws and the realization of it not being one has come about. Gravity is not objective as its laws do not apply to all perceptions of reality(ies). It is not a law of all reality.

:jaw-dropp

Provide evidence for your statement.

You think that luck doesn't come into science, would you dare suggest such a thing? : p

Holy mother of all strawmen. Look again at what I said, nincompoop.
 
Based on what...

Experience.

This isn't an answer to my question.

Right, then the answer's yes. Truth doesn't really exist (in fact I can't even say that as there's no way of knowing for sure), and consensus is just a "confusion avoider". Confusion comes about due to being unable to understand things at a desired level of detail. You can be confused by any number of concepts but that's all they are. It's incredibly cool that we can perceive the notion of existence at all.

Only because you choose to make it confusing, and refuse to answer my questions.

Hehe, the idea is to find a concept simple enough to explain everything. Unfortunately, the moment you concentrate exclusively on materialist perception you limit yourself to a single point of view. Trying to understand everything form that perspective is confusing.

I couldn't make it any easier for you. If you're saying it's TRUE that nothing can be verified objectively- you're directly contradicting yourself. It's a fallacy known as the stolen concept. In order for something to have TRUTH, it must be verifiable. So if you're claiming that it's true that truth doesn't exist- you're mocking yourself, and according to you we shouldn't believe you.

But you're missing the point that truth is just an idea that we, as humans, made up. Again, we're trying to understand an all-encompassing concept from an extremely limited point of view. The ideas of "objectivity" and "truth" mock themselves. That's why we invented ideas like agreement so as to avoid addressing the problems they present. It's not even condensed, it's just generalized.


So here again you're referring to an objective reality- that truth exists independent of our observations. Then, you turn around and claim that none of our observations can be true, simple because we are observing.

It may or it may not. It may even exist as part of our observations. That's extremely hard to grasp though as, were that the case, there would be no way of knowing for sure. Even if it did exist as a part of our observations that wouldn't make it objective as it brings in an entirely new concept. It would mean that reality comes about due to being imagined, not observed objectively, by consciousness. Since we don't know what consciousness entails we're left in the dark, again. If consciousness were a major factor then we'd have to consider the idea of group consciousness and determining whether that in itself can be made out to be a single entity with it's own subjective interpretations being shared throughout the other entities comprising it. It's a simple concept which scales upwards and can seem very confusing at first but is beautifully simple at its core.


Again- if this is your claim- we can't believe you based on what you've said. You debunk yourself.

Or rather, we debunk ourselves.

Wrong. You have avoided every question I have presented. I have repeatedly clarified, corrected, and directly answered yours. The history of this very thread shows you to be inconsistent in your statements.

Nay, you just don't understand the beautiful simplicity because of your over-inellectualization.

You should know by now not to make my statements for me- because you're dead wrong.

Or rather, it's because you won't make any statements regarding your idea of having a monopoly on reality. Is it so fickle that you won't talk about it now?

I linked you to several posts where I did. Cupping your ears and screaming "NO NO NO NO" is not a valid debate technique.

I agree, I don't know why you do it. : p

These questions have already been answered- you know because we only got this far because of my answers.

Hahahaha! I'm the one answering questions here. That's what has fuelled this entire conversation. It's horribly unbalanced as far as being a debate goes.

Wrong. This is an ad hominem (style over substance fallacy). There is no rational basis to claim it must be "easy". "Complex" is a completely ambiguous term as you have applied it, and you're simply trying to get me to fetch further quotes for you from statements I've already made and linked to. You've done this in order to avoid the consequences of the discussion that's already taken place. We are arguing about your nonsensical definition of reality because of the misunderstanding you have on the statements I have made in regards to belonging to the group of individuals who have a monopoly on truth. The statements I have made have been painfully clear, and are readily available- I even cataloged them for you.

A monopoly is not a complex idea. You are doing your best to make it seem as though it is so as to avoid addressing your claim directly.

You're demanding that I repost it as a red herring.

You mean that you would rather not talk about it. ; p

You indicated there were multiple realities. I would like for you to provide evidence of this claim, or at the very least understand that it demands to be retracted (and since it is obviously the basis for the majority of your thinking- you will need to rethink your entire position).

Reality is something that exists independently of ideas concerning it. That in itself is a concept in need of an impossible level of verification based on other ideas I have presented here. Reality is just a concept you see, it's very definition kills itself. Now, the key point here is that you claim to have a monopoly on reality. If you take reality to be an absolute that would mean you are claiming to be some sort of omnipotent entity. If you are not, which I suspect is the case, you are obviously choosing which realities you have a monopoly over. In this case it would be you who needs to provide evidence of the claim of multiple realities.

If you have no way of knowing a statement you just made- perhaps you shouldn't make it?

But then we'd get nowhere. ; p

All knowing is at the end of the day is just a very high level of belief.

Again... Is that true? *COUGH*

I think this has been addressed multiple times.

That has absolutely nothing to do with what you're saying. You said I must address every interpretation of "monopoly" in order to make my case. I said- as a matter-of-fact, no I do not. Now you're confusing yourself- by taking my statements one sentence at a time and refusing to answer my questions, you can't even remember what you were saying.

Not quite, you must define which truth and which reality you claim to have a monopoly over otherwise you would be claiming to be god.


Provide evidence for your statement.

Think in terms of "quantum reality".


Holy mother of all strawmen. Look again at what I said, nincompoop.

You suggested that they have no relation and that by siding with one you would theoretically remove the other. : p

It's also evident, from your remark here, that the mental torment is kicking in.
 
Expression_Man

Your intent is obvious. At this point you're unable to support your statements, and have had to regress into murky vagueness and various unclear statements. You've repeatedly dodged my questions- and you refuse to respond to the contradictions in your claims.

I've pointed out quite clearly that the statement that "Truth does not exist" is a self-defeating statement: it's contradictory- known as a fallacy of the stolen concept.

You haven't answered to this- you haven't responded to the contradictions in your claims. You are instead picking apart sentences at a time in order to go "nah uh" and avoid the discussion. It's also clear that you would rather cause "mental torment" than be clear and concise in your argument. Such is the way for people who think like you do- because if you were to be clear, your contradictions would become more obvious- and indeed every time you've been forced to explain yourself better, that's exactly what's happened.

Unless you have some response or rebuttal to the fact that your statements are contradictory- there's not much more I can say to you, and anything I do say gets ignored or replaced with a strawman, anyway.

I never claimed to be God, I never claimed to be the only one who knows truth, I never claimed to have omniscience, I never claimed that I "now understand you're right", I never claimed science is defined as "being in agreement", I never claimed that impartiality means you cannot assert that you're right, and many other things you've tried to insert into the discussion in order to avoid what I'm actually saying- because you cannot deny it.

And then we arrive at why thinking like you do is so utterly ridiculous. If we are to believe you that it is true that truth does not exist then we are not to believe you. These statements are of no use to the scientific community- and they serve no other purpose but to make you feel inculpable for failed thinking and poor investigative skills. Wherever you claim to sit on the fence of "9/11 Truth"- you aren't an ally to the scientific movement, that much is clear.

Your posts have demonstrated quite clearly what I was talking about- why those in the scientific/skeptic/debunking community have a monopoly on truth. You have proven my point for me quite effectively- if only people didn't have to drudge through all your useless parsimony to get to it.
 
You've repeatedly dodged my questions

I have answered you repeatedly. You continue to dodge the only question I have asked of you since the discussion started. : )

and you refuse to respond to the contradictions in your claims.

If you say so. ; )

I've pointed out quite clearly that the statement that "Truth does not exist" is a self-defeating statement: it's contradictory- known as a fallacy of the stolen concept.

You fail to understand what is meant by "truth". Your idea of having a monopoly over it defeats itself. Your argument goes something like "nonono, you can't argue with me because I own it and that means I'm correct".

You haven't answered to this

This is meaningless superfluous repetition on your part.

you haven't responded to the contradictions in your claims.

Yet another redundancy from you. I can only respond to them in so many ways before you have nowhere left to hide.

You are instead picking apart sentences at a time in order to go "nah uh" and avoid the discussion.

Hypocritical.

It's also clear that you would rather cause "mental torment" than be clear and concise in your argument.

Hahahaha! I only mentioned "mental torment" once in the entire thread. Clearly it's the only point you seem able to relate to.

Such is the way for people who think like you do- because if you were to be clear, your contradictions would become more obvious- and indeed every time you've been forced to explain yourself better, that's exactly what's happened.

You are unable to comprehend your own argument. Again, try to prove me wrong if you like, where is this monopoly on reality and truth?

Unless you have some response or rebuttal to the fact that your statements are contradictory- there's not much more I can say to you, and anything I do say gets ignored or replaced with a strawman, anyway.

The only question I ask of you continues to be left unanswered by your attempts to discuss strawmen.

I never claimed to be God, I never claimed to be the only one who knows truth, I never claimed to have omniscience, I never claimed that I "now understand you're right", I never claimed science is defined as "being in agreement", I never claimed that impartiality means you cannot assert that you're right, and many other things you've tried to insert into the discussion in order to avoid what I'm actually saying- because you cannot deny it.

Where is your monopoly on truth and reality mortal. ; p

And then we arrive at why thinking like you do is so utterly ridiculous. If we are to believe you that it is true that truth does not exist then we are not to believe you.

Proving me right. : )

These statements are of no use to the scientific community- and they serve no other purpose but to make you feel inculpable for failed thinking and poor investigative skills.

You use your failed attempts to address your original claim in any meaningful way to make you feel inculpable for failed thinking and poor investigative skills.

Wherever you claim to sit on the fence of "9/11 Truth"- you aren't an ally to the scientific movement, that much is clear.

Bias.

Your posts have demonstrated quite clearly what I was talking about- why those in the scientific/skeptic/debunking community have a monopoly on truth. You have proven my point for me quite effectively- if only people didn't have to drudge through all your useless parsimony to get to it.

Your posts have demonstrated quite clearly what I was talking about- why those in the scientific/skeptic/debunking community have no monopoly on truth. You have proven my point for me quite effectively- if only people didn't have to drudge through all your useless parsimony to get to it.

;)
 
Last edited:
How do you expect me to respond to this? It's just more of you cupping your ears and screaming "nah uh"...
 
You could always answer the question.

Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?

If you stick by your original claim then you should define what you mean by it.

If you were to say...

"I am part of the majority of people who believe they are correct"

...then that would be different. That would contradict your original statement of your notion of truth not involving statistics though. So what do you mean by your claim to having a monopoly on truth and reality?
 
Oh. Well, I'm in the minority that tries to use consistent, reproducible evidence to decide what things make up reality.
 
You could always answer the question.

Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?

If you stick by your original claim then you should define what you mean by it.

If you were to say...

"I am part of the majority of people who believe they are correct"

...then that would be different. That would contradict your original statement of your notion of truth not involving statistics though. So what do you mean by your claim to having a monopoly on truth and reality?

I see- so you avoided all the questions and the contradictions- and completely ignored my repeated explanations and clarifications- just so you could end up here and repeat the question?

No way. You have your answer already- it's been repeated to you far too many times. You refused to answer my questions, so I am not going to repost it for you. If you have any challenges to anything I said, then you can certainly respond to those aspects of my statements- but I am not going to repeat myself just so you can avoid your own contradictions. I've linked to my responses, and you were present back when that was the discussion, so unless you need clarification on specific statements I have made- there's no reason for me to repeat myself (except to allow you an escape from your contradictions, which I am not going to do).
 
Well this has been a very informative thread. I'd like to ask Expression Man if he can prove that truth is subjective.(I'm guessing that might be impossible)

I'm kind of convinced by Totovader's position regarding the objective nature of reality. Mostly because I'm not arrogant enough to think that the world will end when I die, nor do I believe that the universe didn't exist before I was born.

I also think that if there was no objective reality, I'd just be talking to myself right now and what would be the point of that? Especially seeing as how I would be disagreeing with myself about whether or not I exist.

Sorry I appear to have confused myself. Carry on...or not...umm whatever.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom