Expression_Man
Even if you try an argumentum ad populum, we're still winning. That's not why we're winning though- we're winning because we have a monopoly on truth and logic.
My statement was clarified throughout the thread, which lead to your denial of reality. This is what has lead us here- so to claim I have not answered it is (much like your denial of reality) to contradict yourself.
I also provided links to where the above statement was clarified, explained, and supported.
Explained- in great detail- already:
See post #50, #103, #105, #108, #111, #114, #116, #119, #123, #126, #130, #134, #140, and #142.
I also posted it again, because you claimed it wasn't there.
AGAIN: Explained- in great detail- already:
See post #50, #103, #105, #108, #111, #114, #116, #119, #123, #126, #130, #134, #140, and #142.
In addition, throughout your argument, you have ignored the following:

Strawmen and other fallacies:
I'm afraid that your notion of what "correct reasoning" entails is also subjective, no matter how many people agree with it or how often it's used.
Well you managed to quote me in your response which implied that you were addressing my statement regarding the absurdity of having a monopoly on the truth. Such a thing is called religion.
By your thinking, the reason I am unable to understand the validity of having "a monopoly on truth and reasoning", as a concept, is because I don't take sides.
So now you have a monopoly on truth and reasoning because of the side you have taken? That is surely subjective reasoning at its best.
You think that truth and reasoning involves having some sort of faction which, incidentally, is no different from religion.
So I need to take sides in order to understand?
Truth does not belong to you, nor are you the sole proprietor of reason.
It is completely ridiculous to suppose that the truth can be owned or that it can be denied to someone.
It's always there, waiting to be discovered by those who seek it, you cannot deny people their thoughts.
I don't care about 911, I'm just addressing this strange idea that you have. It's far more disturbing than any conspiracy theory I've ever heard.
To claim that the above concept of science has any monopoly on the truth is stark raving mad.
The moment you start thinking only you know the truth is the exact time when your ego breaks loose and wreaks havoc on your psyche.
If you demand that something be viewed from a limited point of view then you cannot ever grasp a full understanding of it thus your idea of truth is shattered.
Dare you say that you reserve the truth?
No, it's much simpler than that. It's that this has gone on for a long time and I'm the only one answering questions here. This is because you are already aware that there is no foundation for the idea of having a monopoly on truth and reality.
No, it must be simple. A monopoly is not a complex idea, it does not require the over intellectualization you have applied to the concept. In less than 30 words and no more, state it now. Where is your argument?
This is because you are already aware that there is no foundation for the idea of having a monopoly on truth and reality.
48 questions Expression_Man never answered:
1) How can these two statements be true? If reasoning is subjective, then you can't possibly be right- and I can't possibly be wrong- according to you.
2) Have I not brought what I have said into the context of science?
3) What ad-hominems have I committed?
4) Care to define "bad science" without mentioning failed reasoning?
5) Failed to address any statements in regards to religion being the antithesis of reason. Instead chose to move to further strawmans.
6) What evidence do you have that there is a preponderance of emotion, here- instead of scientific inquiry, critical thinking, and truth?
7) What is wrong or questionable about the statement that:
Emotionally high-strung does not mean that people are not using the scientific method. This, again, is simply a claim you cannot support (especially if you want to continue to claim that reasoning is subjective... by your logic we shouldn't believe you).
8) What reason do you have to reject the statement that science is truth and reason applied?
9) Where have I made a statement of circular reasoning?
10) What is your response to the various statements I have pointed out that are self-defeating and contradictory? If I am wrong in that assertion, please explain why.
11) How can a cult be based on science; scientific inquiry is the exact opposite of a very definition of a cult.
12) How am I not impartial?
13) How does a belief that you are correct compromise scientific inquiry?
14) You have repeatedly made statements that science is simply a process designed to make people agreeable: How then does that agreement occur, by flipping a coin? How can it NOT be objective?
15) And, you imply that it is selective in it's "agreeability" (but apparently, not to you). How is "who knows the truth" decided?
16) At what point did I specifically state or even imply that only I know the truth?
17) Your attempt to change the definitions of the object I asked you to conceptualize shows that reality is objective. Your attempt to deny this was a direct contradiction, which was never resolved by you.
18) The fact that this statement:
Nay, one oberserves shapes as their brain is able to interpret them. It's as simple as that my friend.
is a demonstration of an objective reality (although poorly worded). This statement contradicts everything else you have said about a subjective reality. This contradiction was never resolved.
19) What does communication have to do with reality?
20) Where have I dodged the question- or more appropriately, which question has not been answered?
21) Where have my statements been inconsistent, in contradiction, or unclear?
22) How can your statements about a subjective reality be true if you are asking for clarification? (The very act of asking for clarification demands an objective reality)
23) Due to these contradictions, it is not entirely clear what you position is- although you have attempted to state that you believe in a subjective reality, your statements actually contradict this. So, which is it?
24) What is "subjective reasoning"?
25) What is "standardization" if not being accurate to a measurement- and then having that measurement being a consequence of an objective reality?
26) Is the Internet not an example of an ever-increasing detailed language and communication medium which allows people to more quickly, accurately, and broadly explain concepts?
27) How can one "make up" a context if reality is subjective?
28) Give me one example of where my argument has been a strawman.
29) Please define "perception" and "conception" and the differences between them.
30) You attempted to use the Uncertainty Principle to claim that reality is subjective- and then quickly abandoned that position without reason. Can you explain how the UP is evidence of a subjective reality, and not an objective one?
31) How does the concept of "focus"- meaning that "something else comes to our attention"- consistent with a subjective reality. By its very definition, this is evidence of an objective and consistent reality.
32) Please clarify the statement: "Truth, as you understand it, isn't involved."
33) How can agreement exist if reality is subjective?
34) Please clarify the statement: "Not if you have familiarized yourself with it to the extent that you take it for granted."
35) Is it true that nothing can be verified objectively?
36) What is confusion if not an inconsistency to reality?
37) How many realities are there?
38) And how do you know?
39) Why would an agreement require that every interpretation in existence be defined? This ignores a subjective reality and an objective reality and replaces it simply with language.
40) If something can be true for you, and not for someone else- how is it possible to communicate?
41) Please define the concept of "human reality".
42) Is it true that "human reality" is not "objective reality"?
43) What role does "luck" play in scientific study?
44) What is your basis for the claim that what is true can be true for one person, and false for another?
45) Please provide evidence for the statement: "Gravity is not objective as its laws do not apply to all perceptions of reality(ies)."
46) How can your experience define a subjective reality?
47) How have I been hypocritical?
48) Prove that reality is subjective.
