The vulnerability of the Truth Movement.

The point is that nothing can be verified objectively, it's clear that such a concept is found to be disturbing by some people. : )

We agree in order to avoid confusion, few people have ever questioned everything they believe to know.

Hehehe, these are not big words.

It's no more complex than that. Were a real truth ever observable it would be so blatant that it would most likely end up explaining itself.
oh, look, sophistry. Relativism, to be specific.

How trite.

here's a news flash, pal. Your personal disbelief in the universe has no bearing on Sept. 11th, no more than your assertion that Newton's Law of Gravitation is "unproven" makes it possible for you to walk on water.

Philosophy class is that way. Come back when you get your bearings.
 
Ah Hah.

Well, I'll give him about another 2 minutes or so to remove it, and then I'll report it. He didn't even quote my post. It's plagiarism.

ETA: Time's up, report to mods upcoming.

Was this some kind of joke? :D
 
Brainache

Well this has been a very informative thread. I'd like to ask Expression Man if he can prove that truth is subjective.(I'm guessing that might be impossible)

That's the idea, I have explained this to the best of my abilities. : )

I'm kind of convinced by Totovader's position regarding the objective nature of reality. Mostly because I'm not arrogant enough to think that the world will end when I die, nor do I believe that the universe didn't exist before I was born.

I don't believe it will cease to exist in my absence either. There's a lot to take into account. Conception via consciousness is just an idea but seems to be how human life works. As for all reality being created by consciousness, that's a fun idea to discuss. It might be something else, the engine of reality is in place but accepts input via consciousness. The mystery is "why does stuff exist?"

It seems absurd that existence is in place.

We're going to be asking "why" forever. That doesn't mean that such a process of inquiry is not without limits.

I also think that if there was no objective reality, I'd just be talking to myself right now and what would be the point of that? Especially seeing as how I would be disagreeing with myself about whether or not I exist.

Actually it would serve a huge purpose. Not to bring schizophrenia into it but one way of understanding how we think is to fragment our personalities so as to enage in conversation and discover any contention that could exist. It's a process of self-perfection or fine tuning.


Sorry I appear to have confused myself. Carry on...or not...umm whatever.

: D

----------------------------------------------------------------------
R.Mackey

How trite.

here's a news flash, pal. Your personal disbelief in the universe has no bearing on Sept. 11th, no more than your assertion that Newton's Law of Gravitation is "unproven" makes it possible for you to walk on water.

Philosophy class is that way. Come back when you get your bearings.

Hehe, are you of the mind that you can have a monopoly on the truth as well?

If so, perhaps you can continue where Toto left off. In discussing it perhaps you can bring some bearings to light. ; )

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Totovader
Only after you answer my questions do you get any ice cream.

That's your response to being asked to explain your position regarding monopolizing the truth. I answered your questions but you were upset that they didn't support your own point of view and so it shattered your original claim. You did your best to make your personalization of it objective but found out that it wasn't getting anywhere. Without your personalization of the truth your monopoly could not exist. If you did manage to succeed in it you would only have a monopoly on your own thought process(es).

Discussion end.
 
Last edited:
Totovader
That's your response to being asked to explain your position regarding monopolizing the truth.

Now you're resorting to flat out lies.

No way. You have your answer already- it's been repeated to you far too many times. You refused to answer my questions, so I am not going to repost it for you.

I was saying "no way" to you demanding that I "summarize" or repost my position for you, which is simply a stall tactic so you can avoid answering to the contradictions in your statements.

I answered your questions

No- as a matter of fact- you did not. I have clearly documented my contention, and reposted my questions to the extent that I think it's necessary. I'm not going to continue to hound you on questions you obviously aren't capable of answering, but I will continue to point out your negligence and culpability in refusing to answer them. Especially since you are demanding- without reason- that I repost my statements for you.

but you were upset that they didn't support your own point of view and so it shattered your original claim.

I don't know if I can make this any more clear: I don't give a crap if you don't support my view. The great thing about an objective reality is that it doesn't matter if you support my view. It only matters that I take the correct view, and your view will be destroyed on its face.

You did your best to make your personalization of it objective but found out that it wasn't getting anywhere. Without your personalization of the truth your monopoly could not exist. If you did manage to succeed in it you would only have a monopoly on your own thought process(es).

This statement is entirely unsupported- and really doesn't make much sense, anyway.

Discussion end.

Computation incomplete. User error. Replace user.
 
Totovader, just answer the question. ; )

It's evident that the only one answering questions here is me. Read back and look if you like. You haven't answered any questions due to your realization that the only answers you could give would demerit your precious little monopoly.

Answer at least one question, the only question you have been asked.

Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?

Let's make this exciting, your excuses are boring and meaningless given the direct answers you have received.
 
The point is that nothing can be verified objectively, it's clear that such a concept is found to be disturbing by some people. : )

We agree in order to avoid confusion, few people have ever questioned everything they believe to know.

Hehehe, these are not big words.

It's no more complex than that. Were a real truth ever observable it would be so blatant that it would most likely end up explaining itself.

When the Tesshu, a master of Zen, calligraphy and swordsmanship, was a young man he called on the Zen master Dokuon. Wishing to impress Dokuon he said, “The mind, the Buddha, and all sentient beings after all do not exist. The true nature of phenomenon is emptiness. There is no realisation, no delusion, no sagacity, no mediocrity, nothing to give and nothing to receive.

Dokuon promptly hit him with a bamboo stick. Tesshu became quite furious.

Dokuon said quietly: “If nothing exists, where did this anger come from?”
 
When the Tesshu, a master of Zen, calligraphy and swordsmanship, was a young man he called on the Zen master Dokuon. Wishing to impress Dokuon he said, “The mind, the Buddha, and all sentient beings after all do not exist. The true nature of phenomenon is emptiness. There is no realisation, no delusion, no sagacity, no mediocrity, nothing to give and nothing to receive.

Dokuon promptly hit him with a bamboo stick. Tesshu became quite furious.

Dokuon said quietly: “If nothing exists, where did this anger come from?”

Conflicting ideas is your answer. : )

He chose to be angry. If he reacted then we could argue he was emotionally unstable. One person presents a point of view and the other beats him over the head with a stick.

All that means is that there's anger and confusion present.
 
So what happens to reality when there are no people left at all? If a big comet or whatever crashes into the Earth and wipes us all out leaving no conscious minds behind, does reality go on without observers? (for the sake of argument let's leave out ETs).
 
I have previously commented on the desperation of the truth movement. Now some truther posts have gotten me considering their vulnerability.

I have read several times a line that has been stated by a truther in the LC forum. That line in a simple form goes something like "They have a leader, we need a leader as well". "They" is referring to JREF and the leader in their minds is most probably Gravy.

But I think things are quite to the contrary. It is true that JREF has been very very fortunate to have people like Gravy around, but not to take any credit away from anybody, we are standing on a very strong ground. We are not dependant on one single person to keep our story alive. We are not lead by one single person to tell us what to do and what to believe. We have all come to our own conclusions and we all share a similar view of the events in 9/11.

That means the following. If we had our three top guns retired, so that they would quit doing their important work debunking the CT, we would still be standing strong as ever. We have resources, we have evidence, we have experts, we have the laws of physics on our side, we have our own personal knowledge and most important of all, we all share the same basic agenda. That means we are not vulnerable and dependant on a couple of people.

But think about the Truth Movement. They are exactly the opposite. They claim they have no leader, but in reality they are very much lead by only a handful of people.

Unlike us, they don't have the resources, they have no evidence, they have no real experts, they don't have the laws of physics on their side and most important of all, they don't share the same basic agenda. That means they are extremely vulnerable and dependant on a very few people.

What if the Truth Movement had their three top guns retired? Let's say Dylan Avery, Alex Jones and Steven Jones quit doing their CT work.

That would mean devastation to the Truth Movement. That would kill the whole Loose Change Phenomenan. That would kill the LC board, where people are lead by Avery and expecting the world from him and his new film. That would kill a bunch of theories, kill new surprise letters from surprise witnesses and so on.

Alex Jones retiring would kill their biggest resources of everyday CT, that would end prisonplanet, infowars, the radio shows and the bullhorning.

Steven Jones retiring would kill their only guy that has had anything to do with any research. That would kill thermite. That would kill a bunch of controlled demolition theories.

So on reality, The Truth Movement is extremely vulnerable and hangs on the shoulders of only a couple of people who feed the whole CT world. Without them the whole movement would shrink to a hardly noticed branch with outlandish speculations. Speculations that would not raise interest.


Not at all. The 911 truth movement don't have any leaders. When it comes to organisation we act like a bunch of headless chickens. This must become better.

I agree with you that if Steven Jones retired it would be a serious blow. But,he is certainly not a leader in an adm. sort of way. And there are many more capable scholars like Kevin Ryan, Jim Hoffman etc.
 
Formidable Scholars

[=pagan;2384129]Not at all. The 911 truth movement don't have any leaders. When it comes to organisation we act like a bunch of headless chickens. This must become better.

I agree with you that if Steven Jones retired it would be a serious blow. But,he is certainly not a leader in an adm. sort of way. And there are many more capable scholars like Kevin Ryan, Jim Hoffman etc.

Kevin Ryan is not a scholar by any stretch of the imagination. Jim Hoffman was scheduled to appear on Hardfire. Someone tipped him off, or so I strongly suspect, that I was prepared to use Dr. Greening's paper to refute his faulty calculations. He pulled a no-show at the last minute. Another profile in courage.
 
Expression_Man
:bowl:
Even if you try an argumentum ad populum, we're still winning. That's not why we're winning though- we're winning because we have a monopoly on truth and logic.

My statement was clarified throughout the thread, which lead to your denial of reality. This is what has lead us here- so to claim I have not answered it is (much like your denial of reality) to contradict yourself.

I also provided links to where the above statement was clarified, explained, and supported.

Explained- in great detail- already:
See post #50, #103, #105, #108, #111, #114, #116, #119, #123, #126, #130, #134, #140, and #142.

I also posted it again, because you claimed it wasn't there.

AGAIN: Explained- in great detail- already:
See post #50, #103, #105, #108, #111, #114, #116, #119, #123, #126, #130, #134, #140, and #142.

In addition, throughout your argument, you have ignored the following:
:whistling
Strawmen and other fallacies:

I'm afraid that your notion of what "correct reasoning" entails is also subjective, no matter how many people agree with it or how often it's used.

Well you managed to quote me in your response which implied that you were addressing my statement regarding the absurdity of having a monopoly on the truth. Such a thing is called religion.

By your thinking, the reason I am unable to understand the validity of having "a monopoly on truth and reasoning", as a concept, is because I don't take sides.

So now you have a monopoly on truth and reasoning because of the side you have taken? That is surely subjective reasoning at its best.

You think that truth and reasoning involves having some sort of faction which, incidentally, is no different from religion.

So I need to take sides in order to understand?

Truth does not belong to you, nor are you the sole proprietor of reason.

It is completely ridiculous to suppose that the truth can be owned or that it can be denied to someone.

It's always there, waiting to be discovered by those who seek it, you cannot deny people their thoughts.

I don't care about 911, I'm just addressing this strange idea that you have. It's far more disturbing than any conspiracy theory I've ever heard.

To claim that the above concept of science has any monopoly on the truth is stark raving mad.

The moment you start thinking only you know the truth is the exact time when your ego breaks loose and wreaks havoc on your psyche.

If you demand that something be viewed from a limited point of view then you cannot ever grasp a full understanding of it thus your idea of truth is shattered.

Dare you say that you reserve the truth?

No, it's much simpler than that. It's that this has gone on for a long time and I'm the only one answering questions here. This is because you are already aware that there is no foundation for the idea of having a monopoly on truth and reality.

No, it must be simple. A monopoly is not a complex idea, it does not require the over intellectualization you have applied to the concept. In less than 30 words and no more, state it now. Where is your argument?

This is because you are already aware that there is no foundation for the idea of having a monopoly on truth and reality.

:pythonfoot:
48 questions Expression_Man never answered:

1) How can these two statements be true? If reasoning is subjective, then you can't possibly be right- and I can't possibly be wrong- according to you.

2) Have I not brought what I have said into the context of science?

3) What ad-hominems have I committed?

4) Care to define "bad science" without mentioning failed reasoning?

5) Failed to address any statements in regards to religion being the antithesis of reason. Instead chose to move to further strawmans.

6) What evidence do you have that there is a preponderance of emotion, here- instead of scientific inquiry, critical thinking, and truth?

7) What is wrong or questionable about the statement that:

Emotionally high-strung does not mean that people are not using the scientific method. This, again, is simply a claim you cannot support (especially if you want to continue to claim that reasoning is subjective... by your logic we shouldn't believe you).

8) What reason do you have to reject the statement that science is truth and reason applied?

9) Where have I made a statement of circular reasoning?

10) What is your response to the various statements I have pointed out that are self-defeating and contradictory? If I am wrong in that assertion, please explain why.

11) How can a cult be based on science; scientific inquiry is the exact opposite of a very definition of a cult.

12) How am I not impartial?

13) How does a belief that you are correct compromise scientific inquiry?

14) You have repeatedly made statements that science is simply a process designed to make people agreeable: How then does that agreement occur, by flipping a coin? How can it NOT be objective?

15) And, you imply that it is selective in it's "agreeability" (but apparently, not to you). How is "who knows the truth" decided?

16) At what point did I specifically state or even imply that only I know the truth?

17) Your attempt to change the definitions of the object I asked you to conceptualize shows that reality is objective. Your attempt to deny this was a direct contradiction, which was never resolved by you.

18) The fact that this statement:
Nay, one oberserves shapes as their brain is able to interpret them. It's as simple as that my friend.
is a demonstration of an objective reality (although poorly worded). This statement contradicts everything else you have said about a subjective reality. This contradiction was never resolved.

19) What does communication have to do with reality?

20) Where have I dodged the question- or more appropriately, which question has not been answered?

21) Where have my statements been inconsistent, in contradiction, or unclear?

22) How can your statements about a subjective reality be true if you are asking for clarification? (The very act of asking for clarification demands an objective reality)

23) Due to these contradictions, it is not entirely clear what you position is- although you have attempted to state that you believe in a subjective reality, your statements actually contradict this. So, which is it?

24) What is "subjective reasoning"?

25) What is "standardization" if not being accurate to a measurement- and then having that measurement being a consequence of an objective reality?

26) Is the Internet not an example of an ever-increasing detailed language and communication medium which allows people to more quickly, accurately, and broadly explain concepts?

27) How can one "make up" a context if reality is subjective?

28) Give me one example of where my argument has been a strawman.

29) Please define "perception" and "conception" and the differences between them.

30) You attempted to use the Uncertainty Principle to claim that reality is subjective- and then quickly abandoned that position without reason. Can you explain how the UP is evidence of a subjective reality, and not an objective one?

31) How does the concept of "focus"- meaning that "something else comes to our attention"- consistent with a subjective reality. By its very definition, this is evidence of an objective and consistent reality.

32) Please clarify the statement: "Truth, as you understand it, isn't involved."

33) How can agreement exist if reality is subjective?

34) Please clarify the statement: "Not if you have familiarized yourself with it to the extent that you take it for granted."

35) Is it true that nothing can be verified objectively?

36) What is confusion if not an inconsistency to reality?

37) How many realities are there?

38) And how do you know?

39) Why would an agreement require that every interpretation in existence be defined? This ignores a subjective reality and an objective reality and replaces it simply with language.

40) If something can be true for you, and not for someone else- how is it possible to communicate?

41) Please define the concept of "human reality".

42) Is it true that "human reality" is not "objective reality"?

43) What role does "luck" play in scientific study?

44) What is your basis for the claim that what is true can be true for one person, and false for another?

45) Please provide evidence for the statement: "Gravity is not objective as its laws do not apply to all perceptions of reality(ies)."

46) How can your experience define a subjective reality?

47) How have I been hypocritical?

48) Prove that reality is subjective.



:bricks:
 
Dr of Whatever

Not at all. The 911 truth movement don't have any leaders. When it comes to organisation we act like a bunch of headless chickens. This must become better.

I agree with you that if Steven Jones retired it would be a serious blow. But,he is certainly not a leader in an adm. sort of way. And there are many more capable scholars like Kevin Ryan, Jim Hoffman etc.

Why do you have to call yourselves scholars?

That's a title that is not usally self-selected.
 
So what happens to reality when there are no people left at all? If a big comet or whatever crashes into the Earth and wipes us all out leaving no conscious minds behind, does reality go on without observers? (for the sake of argument let's leave out ETs).

Well, it wouldn't really matter but for the sake of argument we could say that it might. Then again, we don't know what consciousness entails so it's somewhat unprovable at this point in time. The idea of creating reality via consciousness it just another idea at the end of the day.

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To Totovader

I'm surprised you're still at it to be honest. I've answered about 95% of your questions while you have answered 0% of mine.

Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?

Again Totovader, don't be afraid. If you want this to continue state your answer now. You're so desperate that you have chosen to disregard/ignore everything I've said as though it never happened.

Hehehe, it's not so simple Tot, my posts are still there and they reference your questions. I have provided you with answers despite your pathetic cynicism and name calling.


I dare you to answer the one question I have ever asked of you.

Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?

If you do not answer that then you have no argument. If you claim to have already stated your answer then get to the point and don't reference your numerous fragmented statements. Get to the point, if you can.

Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?

Answer that and then we will begin trading questions.
 
Last edited:
To Totovader

I'm surprised you're still at it to be honest. I've answered about 95% of your questions while you have answered 0% of mine.

Well, the above post actually shows just how much you're lying on both counts, here.

Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?

Clever slip of a new statement in there, eh?

I've answered both of these questions (although this is the first time you've phrased them together- as if to change the topic of discussion). You will find those answers in the thread- where I have posted them repeatedly.

You can find this claim referenced in the top portion of the previous post. That section- actually that entire post- has been ignored by you.

If you have any problems with what I've stated so far, then you can post a response quoting those statements.

Again Totovader, don't be afraid.

Ad baculum.

If you want this to continue state your answer now.

I wanted it to end- that's why I answered it a long time ago.

See previous post on where you can find that information (as if you suddenly entered the thread.)

You're so desperate that you have chosen to disregard/ignore everything I've said as though it never happened.

Prove it.

Ok, I'm having a laugh. If you try and prove it, you will be submitting to an objective reality. So, it'll be fun to watch...

If you claim that it is true that you've answered these questions (95% my aching crap hole)- then show me. And in doing so, contradict everything you have said in regards to a subjective reality.

Gotcha.

Hehehe, it's not so simple Tot, my posts are still there and they reference your questions.

He he he... You just shot yourself in the foot.

I have provided you with answers despite your pathetic cynicism and name calling.

Cynicism? Name calling?

Oh brother. I listed at least 3 times you called me something and then couldn't back it up. I think I called you a nincompoop once. If your feelings are that hurt, then you obviously believe in an objective reality- and thus your feelings shouldn't be hurt, because I'm helping you.


I dare you to answer the one question I have ever asked of you.

And what do I get for completing this dare in the past?

See previous post on where to find this information.

If you do not answer that then you have no argument.

And if I have answered it, then you are doing what- exactly?

See previous post on where to find this information.

If you claim to have already stated your answer then get to the point and don't reference your numerous fragmented statements. Get to the point, if you can.

Oh, the points already been gotten.

See previous post on where to find this information.

Answer that and then we will begin trading questions.

Already answered. See previous post regarding this information. Your turn.

And, check mate.
 
Observations made using what?

Is this the "one question you've ever asked of me"?

Or maybe it's the 30 or more you have asked?

The ones I answered- and then you responded to, and then in order to ignore my questions, simply re-asked the ones you already had answers to.

Your claim that I "haven't answered" is completely destroyed when I point EXACTLY to where I have answered it.

What you are engaging in is known as the complex question fallacy. You simply re-ask the same question in order to claim it was never answered, though you raised no specific challenge to it when it was asked. In order to avoid the contradictions in your statements- the only thing you can do is divert the attention away from your failures, and try to make it look like I'm doing the exact thing that you're doing.

Boy is this getting silly.

The fact of the matter is- you can't claim I've never answered the question without denying that we are in the point in the discussion which is a direct result of me answering that question. This answer lead you to go off about subjective reality and your silly contradictions. When you confused conception and perception it further complicated the discussion- and as a result of my answer, I've been repeatedly trying to get you to fix your errors.

Anyone can see that you're dying for an out. You need to pretend that you're not culpable- that you have an escape route. My post above doesn't let you escape cleanly. You've avoided many points- including the very obvious contradictions in your statements. And since there is no benefit to me repeating myself- I don't see any reason why me generously linking to my previous comments would not be satisfactory.

Especially since restating my position would only allow you to go off on another round and create another endless loop. It's a red herring which will cause the discussion to go nowhere (exactly where you subjectivists often have to take it).

It ends now. You either begin to answer to the contradictions above and drop the act, or you remove yourself from the discussion.

Oh, I'm just holding my breath... :rolleyes:
 
the only thing you can do is divert the attention away from your failures, and try to make it look like I'm doing the exact thing that you're doing.
Oh, you mean to imply that you’re not trying to divert attention away from answering the question of who decides what is true and how you have a monopoly on it?Right, let’s get down to business. You keep running away from this simple question despite the attention I have given you and you seem to enjoy talking about fallacies. So far you’ve set yourself up in the perfect position to receive the label of “hypocrite”. So, just to make you happy, I will present your argument in a fallacious way (I admit I am doing this for the single section) but it brings to light so many of your ideas.
We have a monopoly on truth and logic.
I'm not saying we're always right.
we have a monopoly on reality
I don't believe in a "monopoly on reality”
If you have no way of knowing a statement you just made- perhaps you shouldn't make it?
the side I go with is the one that has a monopoly on truth and reasoning
The fact that you "don't take any particular side" shows why you don't understand.
I do not believe it has anything to do with labels, or what "group" you belong to.
My opinion is not the issue.
Yet again- the contradiction you present here is so blatantly obvious, I'm left wondering how you can continue to try and maintain it without laughing at yourself.
My opinion is not the issue.
It makes no sense. And it's wrong.
You have neither the position nor the power to call anyone right or wrong.
We have a monopoly on truth because we are rational, logical, scientific individuals
Emotionally high-strung does not mean that people are not using the scientific method.
Have I been inconsistent? Have my statements at all contradicted each other? Have I been unclear?
The discussion thus far clearly makes my case for me. If you have any challenge to the contradictions I have pointed out in your statements- then please post it.
Ok, BS aside, I will attempt to answer your questions (again).
1) How can these two statements be true? If reasoning is subjective, then you can't possibly be right- and I can't possibly be wrong- according to you.
That being the case, it comes down to your acceptance of the idea(s).
2) Have I not brought what I have said into the context of science?
No, your idea of having a monopoly on truth and reality has nothing to do with science.
3) What ad-hominems have I committed?
Claiming that I do not understand because I do not take sides.Claiming that those who are religiously inclined are incapable of reasoning.
4) Care to define "bad science" without mentioning failed reasoning?
Falsifying research data is as close as you can get, even if it’s not completely separate.
5) Failed to address any statements in regards to religion being the antithesis of reason. Instead chose to move to further strawmans.
I said that those of a religious inclination are fully capable of making decisions by way of reasoning. I’m not sure why this is relevant.
6) What evidence do you have that there is a preponderance of emotion, here- instead of scientific inquiry, critical thinking, and truth?
I’m not sure what you’re referring to.
7) What is wrong or questionable about the statement that:Emotionally high-strung does not mean that people are not using the scientific method. This, again, is simply a claim you cannot support (especially if you want to continue to claim that reasoning is subjective... by your logic we shouldn't believe you).
The questionability arises due to emotion having being present in the first place. It is not a part of the scientific method and can only be a hindrance. Since humans lack the ability to become emotionless when it comes to putting an emotional investment into their work the scientific method, in practice, remains questionable.
8) What reason do you have to reject the statement that science is truth and reason applied?
That it is based on the belief that it is true and reasonable.
9) Where have I made a statement of circular reasoning?
Indecisiveness regarding whether or not you have a monopoly on truth and reality.
10) What is your response to the various statements I have pointed out that are self-defeating and contradictory? If I am wrong in that assertion, please explain why.
My response is that you are selfish to continue to demand answers before answering one simple question that I have continued to present to you over the course of the discussion. We can certainly go into this but it will require time to explain. I will gladly give you my opinions regarding it should you answer my single question.
11) How can a cult be based on science; scientific inquiry is the exact opposite of a very definition of a cult.
It’s not the definition of scientific inquiry; it’s the practice of it. Groups of scientists can become dogmatic in their thinking to the point that the behaviour they exhibit is indeed cult-like.
12) How am I not impartial?
You believe that you are in a position of authority in that you are one of the people claiming to have a monopoly on truth and reality. You have also stated that skeptics and debunkers (assuming you belong to one of these groups) follow science which has proven (via practice) in many cases, to be anything but impartial. This is especially true concerning theories discussing the origin of life and how much anger the discussions provoke.
13) How does a belief that you are correct compromise scientific inquiry?
It presupposes the conclusion and affects judgments.
14) You have repeatedly made statements that science is simply a process designed to make people agreeable: How then does that agreement occur, by flipping a coin? How can it NOT be objective?
You asked two questions. My answers are…i.) The agreement occurs through discussion based on observations.ii.) It is only objective in the sense that people are seeing things from a limited point of view. It is not true objectivity, which is impossible to attain.
15) And, you imply that it is selective in it's "agreeability" (but apparently, not to you). How is "who knows the truth" decided?
I don’t believe anyone knows the truth. It is the same question I have asked you, multiple times, for an answer.
16) At what point did I specifically state or even imply that only I know the truth?
The moment you gave yourself the “we have a monopoly on reality” and “we have a monopoly on truth” badges. If it’s not just you, where are the other members of this club?
17) Your attempt to change the definitions of the object I asked you to conceptualize shows that reality is objective. Your attempt to deny this was a direct contradiction, which was never resolved by you.
I disagree with your reasoning. My response was very detailed.
18) The fact that this statement: Quote: Nay, one oberserves shapes as their brain is able to interpret them. It's as simple as that my friend. is a demonstration of an objective reality (although poorly worded). This statement contradicts everything else you have said about a subjective reality. This contradiction was never resolved.
I would disagree with this on the grounds of there being no way to tell how a shape is supposed to look and whether it is different for every person. A machine wouldn’t prove anything as we would still be examining the findings ourselves.
19) What does communication have to do with reality?
I thought you weren’t being serious. This is a detailed subject which involves not only human communication but particle physics to explain in full detail. Communication is an underlying principal of the reality we experience. This however is not relevant to the discussion. Again, I continue to ask a question of you.Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?
20) Where have I dodged the question- or more appropriately, which question has not been answered?
Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?
21) Where have my statements been inconsistent, in contradiction, or unclear?
Claiming that you have a monopoly on reality and then stating that you don’t believe one can have a monopoly on reality. You did this without explaining what you meant by your idea of reality or having a monopoly on it and you continue to avoid the question every time I ask it.Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?
22) How can your statements about a subjective reality be true if you are asking for clarification? (The very act of asking for clarification demands an objective reality)
It means only that I am attempting to understand you.
23) Due to these contradictions, it is not entirely clear what you position is- although you have attempted to state that you believe in a subjective reality, your statements actually contradict this. So, which is it?
For me to believe that reality is subjective and that no truth is immediately accessible I would have to deny myself the luxury speaking of it in terms of fact. I tend to believe that what we experience of reality is subjective and that no further claims regarding the nature of an objective reality can be made because of it.
24) What is "subjective reasoning"?
All reasoning is, the idea is almost a redundancy. To avoid confusion a context might need to be given but, as I said earlier, that is unlikely to change the situation much.
25) What is "standardization" if not being accurate to a measurement- and then having that measurement being a consequence of an objective reality?
To make this easier to answer I will refute the last part of the statement by claiming that there is no way to identify an objective reality as what we experience of it is relative to ourselves. It is because of this that we cannot move further into the idea of reality being objective.
26) Is the Internet not an example of an ever-increasing detailed language and communication medium which allows people to more quickly, accurately, and broadly explain concepts?
I’m sorry but the reason you had for asking this question is non-existent. I believe that what you claim, in this instance, is true and that I never made an attempt to refute it. The question I implied regarding it in your original statement was of the unidentifiable relevance it had to the conversation.Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?
27) How can one "make up" a context if reality is subjective?
To avoid confusion of thought.
28) Give me one example of where my argument has been a strawman.
I hate straw men. You love to talk about them, I don’t know what your affiliation with them is but it’s obvious, due to one reason or another, that your personal experience seems to warrant you inserting the concept at every available opportunity. To answer this I will refer to your original claim of having a monopoly on truth and reality. I believe that is the “strawest” man that ever was.
29) Please define "perception" and "conception" and the differences between them.
Go look in a dictionary.
30) You attempted to use the Uncertainty Principle to claim that reality is subjective- and then quickly abandoned that position without reason. Can you explain how the UP is evidence of a subjective reality, and not an objective one?
It is evidence of a subjective interpretation of reality.
31) How does the concept of "focus"- meaning that "something else comes to our attention"- consistent with a subjective reality. By its very definition, this is evidence of an objective and consistent reality.
It depends on a single concept and question. What is our involvement with reality?
32) Please clarify the statement: "Truth, as you understand it, isn't involved."
You enjoy to throw the word “truth” about to such an extent that your portrayal of it is fickle. It is because of that that I disagree with your notion of truth.
33) How can agreement exist if reality is subjective?
It stops headaches.
34) Please clarify the statement: "Not if you have familiarized yourself with it to the extent that you take it for granted."
I mean that you become overly familiar with a concept to the point that you do not ever question the validity of it in detail.
35) Is it true that nothing can be verified objectively?
Who knows?
36) What is confusion if not an inconsistency to reality?
Conflicting ideas of perceived reality.
37) How many realities are there?
I don’t know, Totovader.
38) And how do you know?
…
39) Why would an agreement require that every interpretation in existence be defined? This ignores a subjective reality and an objective reality and replaces it simply with language.
Anything we perceive of this argument will be based on the interpretation of language. In regards to your claim of having a monopoly on truth and reality, I would expect you to at least answer the questions of who decides what is true and how you might have a monopoly on truth and reality or else you are forced to define every truth and reality it is that you have jurisdiction over.
40) If something can be true for you, and not for someone else- how is it possible to communicate?
By acknowledging the presence of two or more individuals.
41) Please define the concept of "human reality".
Perceived reality.
42) Is it true that "human reality" is not "objective reality"?
That’s a reasonable assumption.
43) What role does "luck" play in scientific study?
Some of these questions you never actually asked but decided to claim that you did so as to give a false impression of the situation. I will answer this question if you answer mine.Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?
44) What is your basis for the claim that what is true can be true for one person, and false for another?
Personal experience.
45) Please provide evidence for the statement: "Gravity is not objective as its laws do not apply to all perceptions of reality(ies)."
Refer to the idea of a unified theory.
46) How can your experience define a subjective reality?
By experiencing it, that's the whole point.
47) How have I been hypocritical?
See above section.
48) Prove that reality is subjective.
Which reality? : p

Edit: Who decides what is true and how you have a monopoly on truth and reality?
 
So, you go quote mining- admit it's fallacious, but then do it anyway?

You have to lie in order to try and make a case...

Much like you are QUOTING SECTIONS WHERE I HAVE ANSWERED YOUR QUESTION and then claim it was never answered?

Your answers to the 48 questions then become single sentence ambiguous fluffy crap. I can't say I expected anything more. I could respond to your bs answers and continue to point out your contradictions, but it obviously won't get us anywhere- you don't have a problem with making false accusations, using fallacious arguments, and ignoring statements you don't like, so I'm assuming we're done, here?
 
Who decides what is true and how you have a monopoly on truth and reality?

If you continue to avoid this question then we are done here.

It's obvious that you are in retreat now.

I have indulged you for far too long. All I ask is that you answer a single question.

Who decides what is true and how you have a monopoly on truth and reality?

Stop ignoring the questions you don't like.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom