Oh, you mean to imply that you’re not trying to divert attention away from answering the question of who decides what is true and how you have a monopoly on it?
Imply
nothing- I mean to specifically state- as clearly and loudly as possible- that I have already answered the question. That statement should be so unbelievable clear to you at this point that it would require you to literally be closing your eyes as you read my statements. I have linked- repeatedly- to the statements that answer your question when you first asked it.
I cannot make it any more clear for you than that- barring any challenge to my statements.
Right, let’s get down to business. You keep running away from this simple question...
So your definition of getting down to business is to continue to repeat lies?
How many times do I need to link you to the statements where I answered this question the first time?
How many times will it take?
...despite the attention I have given you and you seem to enjoy talking about fallacies. So far you’ve set yourself up in the perfect position to receive the label of "hypocrite". So, just to make you happy, I will present your argument in a fallacious way (I admit I am doing this for the single section) but it brings to light so many of your ideas.
Wrong!
Hypocrite is
not having my quotes mashed up to say something I didn't say in order for you to claim I am of the label you clearly are.
Instead of answering the questions and moving on- you've felt it necessary to take all my comments out of context in order to try and call me a hypocrite. Again, you do this in order to try and avoid the debate itself- in order to divert attention away from your own hypocrisy- your own failures. You even admit as much in this statement.
Just to make me happy you're going to take everything I say out of context- admittedly- in order to "bring light" to my ideas?
That's insane.
...
we have a monopoly on reality
I don't believe in a "monopoly on reality"
Look at how you had to take these quotes
completely out of context in order to try to make your point.
Here's the original statement:
...I should clarify that statement- I don't believe in a "monopoly on reality"- at least in the sense that you have taken it. As I have said, reality exists independant of the observer- so to have a monopoly on reality was really just saying that through rationality- through science we better understand reality. I was simply being climactic. I clearly do not believe that anyone "owns reality" (nor do I believe that anyone "owns truth" but you don't seem to be getting my allusion).
So, let's see if we can understand this. You are presenting my "
argument in a fallacious way (I admit I am doing this for the single section) but it brings to light so many of your ideas."
Does that make sense? You have to completely change what I'm saying in order to make light of my ideas?
Seems like you continue to shoot yourself in the foot. You're stumbling over your own contradictions at this point. In order to try and claim that I am incorrect or illogical, you have to change what I've said. Sort of self-defeating, don't you think?
[More statements taken out of context]
I snipped all these out because the above example is all I need to do in order to defend my character. You intentionally did not post links to those statements because you know you took them out of context- and even admitted as such. Taken in context, my statements make sense- and they do not say what you want them to. Any reader of this mess of a thread will be able to at least see that your statements admit you're a liar- and if they take the time to hunt down the quotes you were using, they will see that your efforts to impeach my character end up impeaching your own.
Ok, BS aside, I will attempt to answer your questions (again).
Let's get one thing straight: you
didn't answer these questions before, that's why I had to repost them. You certainly
responded to a large number of them, but an answer is not the same thing. In addition, all these questions sum up one undeniable fact: you have contradicted yourself on many occasions; instead of confronting that contradiction and resolving it, you've decided to try to rewind the debate. I'm not going to allow that to happen.
1) How can these two statements be true? If reasoning is subjective, then you can't possibly be right- and I can't possibly be wrong- according to you.
That being the case, it comes down to your acceptance of the idea(s).
Well, then all that matters is that I accept my own ideas. Then- according to your [failed] logic, I would have a monopoly on truth- because according to you truth is simply an acceptance of ideas.
Your answer makes no sense. Please try again.
2) Have I not brought what I have said into the context of science?
No, your idea of having a monopoly on truth and reality has nothing to do with science.
This is not an answer to the question. Please try again.
3) What ad-hominems have I committed?
Claiming that I do not understand because I do not take sides.Claiming that those who are religiously inclined are incapable of reasoning.
In addition to these
not being ad hominems, they are indeed both strawmans. I never said you don't understand [this discussion] because you don't "take sides". I clarified that in post #114:
Holy strawman. Not even close to what I said. You don't understand the validity of objective truth because you choose to believe that subjectivity is more valid, neglecting the fact that this thought requires an objective view of reality.
Apparently, we need to have a discussion on what science is. Twice, now, you've attempted to bastardize it as simply subjective and religious. That is the reason you can't comprehend a science based on objective reality.
And what was your response to this? Nothing.
I also never said that people who are religious are incapable of reason. I said that faith is the antithesis of reason. So your statement- in addition to being another strawman attempt to change my statements- is wrong.
Retract the statement, or try again!
4) Care to define "bad science" without mentioning failed reasoning?
Falsifying research data is as close as you can get, even if it’s not completely separate.
Wrong!
It's
not "completely separate", meaning your answer is invalid. I explained why it was insufficient already- it ignores the 2nd part of my rebuttal.
5) Failed to address any statements in regards to religion being the antithesis of reason. Instead chose to move to further strawmans.
I said that those of a religious inclination are fully capable of making decisions by way of reasoning. I’m not sure why this is relevant.
Quote needed!
I never said that religious people are incapable of reasoning. However, it's interesting to note that you had claimed that science was a religion- and indicated that it was therefore invalid and wrong. How does this make any sense when compared to your statement above? Yet again, you completely contradict yourself.
6) What evidence do you have that there is a preponderance of emotion, here- instead of scientific inquiry, critical thinking, and truth?
I’m not sure what you’re referring to.
You had said that the JREF forums were not made up of scientists and critical thinkers- but instead were just emotional people.
You were never able to support that statement.
Either retract the statement, or try again!
7) What is wrong or questionable about the statement that: Emotionally high-strung does not mean that people are not using the scientific method. This, again, is simply a claim you cannot support (especially if you want to continue to claim that reasoning is subjective... by your logic we shouldn't believe you).
The questionability arises due to emotion having being present in the first place. It is not a part of the scientific method and can only be a hindrance. Since humans lack the ability to become emotionless when it comes to putting an emotional investment into their work the scientific method, in practice, remains questionable.
This is not an answer to the question- and is in fact an ad hominem. Being emotional does not necessarily mean that a person is incapable of using the scientific method. You then use this failed reasoning to conclude that reasoning is therefore invalid because it's impossible to remove emotion from the human experience- again, contradicting yourself. You're reasoning that reasoning is necessarily invalid. Obviously this cannot be true.
This is not an answer to the question, try again!
8) What reason do you have to reject the statement that science is truth and reason applied?
That it is based on the belief that it is true and reasonable.
This is not an answer to the question. The belief that one is right is irrelevant to the fact of being right or wrong. This, again, is an ad hominem.
This is not an answer to the question, try again!
9) Where have I made a statement of circular reasoning?
Indecisiveness regarding whether or not you have a monopoly on truth and reality.
Not only is this a strawman- I have never been "indecisive" in my statements regarding "monopoly on truth"- but
indecisiveness is not a synonym for circular reasoning.
This is not an answer to the question, try again!
10) What is your response to the various statements I have pointed out that are self-defeating and contradictory? If I am wrong in that assertion, please explain why.
My response is that you are selfish to continue to demand answers before answering one simple question that I have continued to present to you over the course of the discussion. We can certainly go into this but it will require time to explain. I will gladly give you my opinions regarding it should you answer my single question.
Again, a strawman- and again, not an answer to the question. Even if I were "selfish"- that has nothing to do with you
repeatedly contradicting yourself. Additionally (of course) your question has been answered... repeatedly.
This is not an answer to the question, try again!
11) How can a cult be based on science; scientific inquiry is the exact opposite of a very definition of a cult.
It’s not the definition of scientific inquiry; it’s the practice of it. Groups of scientists can become dogmatic in their thinking to the point that the behaviour they exhibit is indeed cult-like.
This is not an answer to the question, try again!
This contradicts your other statements- additionally, it contradicts the original statement this question was based on.
You had said that stating you were bastardizing science (by claiming that it was subjective and religious) is
turning this place into a cult.
So how does your response above address that line of thinking? (Hint: it doesn't.)
12) How am I not impartial?
You believe that you are in a position of authority in that you are one of the people claiming to have a monopoly on truth and reality. You have also stated that skeptics and debunkers (assuming you belong to one of these groups) follow science which has proven (via practice) in many cases, to be anything but impartial. This is especially true concerning theories discussing the origin of life and how much anger the discussions provoke.
Multiple strawman- I never said I was in a position of authority- I said, as a matter of fact- much to the opposite. Additionally, following science is not an example of
not being impartial. You are committing the
guilt by association fallacy, here:
Since "science" has been wrong, all science and scientists are therefore not being impartial. Utter nonsense. Hitler was a German. Hitler was a Nazi. Therefore all Germans are Nazis...
Quit a large pile of steaming excrement, you have there.
This is not an answer to the question, try again!
13) How does a belief that you are correct compromise scientific inquiry?
It presupposes the conclusion and affects judgments.
Neglecting that you don't believe in truth- having a belief in validity does not affect judgement or scientific inquiry necessarily. That's
what the scientific method is, so you really didn't answer my question. Again, you try and stuff fallacies into your argument in order to claim that some humans are fallible some of the time, therefore humans are always fallible.
If you were correct- we again could not agree with you according to your logic. You obviously believe that you're correct and that's obviously "affecting your judgement", so you're wrong...
This is not an answer to the question, try again!
14) You have repeatedly made statements that science is simply a process designed to make people agreeable: How then does that agreement occur, by flipping a coin? How can it NOT be objective?
You asked two questions. My answers are i.) The agreement occurs through discussion based on observations.ii.) It is only objective in the sense that people are seeing things from a limited point of view. It is not true objectivity, which is impossible to attain.
1) "Discussion based on observations" according to everything you have said is impossible. Not only because discussion is impossible, but because you believe that humans are wholly incapable of making observations without controlling those observations (in addition to your contradictory statements about subjective reality- you can't seem to make up your mind).
Either way...
You're wrong! A "discussion based on observations" does not answer the question- and in fact attempts to circumvent it. How do these "discussions" occur, and are they
necessary to the discovery of truth? If so, what "discussions" did you have presupposing that you were wrong- with whom, to now conclude that you're right, in your reality (because there are multiple realities) which you cannot confirm, but somehow know, but cannot explain?
You continue to neglect the difference between
observation (perception) and
conceptualization. More on that below.
15) And, you imply that it is selective in it's "agreeability" (but apparently, not to you). How is "who knows the truth" decided?
I don’t believe anyone knows the truth. It is the same question I have asked you, multiple times, for an answer.
And if we are to believe that you're right, then you're wrong. Your statement directly contradicts itself. Allow me to phrase it a different way:
Is it true that there is no truth?
This is not an answer to the question, try again!
16) At what point did I specifically state or even imply that only I know the truth?
The moment you gave yourself the "we have a monopoly on reality" and "we have a monopoly on truth" badges. If it’s not just you, where are the other members of this club?
That question was answered already.
And this is not an answer to the question. You stated that
I implied that ONLY I KNOW THE TRUTH. Your answer does not satisfy my challenge to your statement.
Either retract the statement, or try again!
17) Your attempt to change the definitions of the object I asked you to conceptualize shows that reality is objective. Your attempt to deny this was a direct contradiction, which was never resolved by you.
I disagree with your reasoning. My response was very detailed.
This is not an answer to the question, try again!
Your response was not
an answer. I asked you to conceptualize an object based on a description I was giving in order to show that communication and objective reality were true. Part of the requirements of this test were that you did not add or subtract anything, or change my statements. In order to avoid the inevitable- that's exactly what you did. You did not give a suitable justifaction for this, and your claim that you "disagree with my reasoning" makes no sense whatsoever.
18) The fact that this statement: "Nay, one oberserves shapes as their brain is able to interpret them. It's as simple as that my friend." is a demonstration of an objective reality (although poorly worded). This statement contradicts everything else you have said about a subjective reality. This contradiction was never resolved.
I would disagree with this on the grounds of there being no way to tell how a shape is supposed to look and whether it is different for every person. A machine wouldn’t prove anything as we would still be examining the findings ourselves.
This is not an answer to the question, try again!
My example- the one where you changed everything you could- shows that this is not only possible, but it's relatively routine. You have directly avoided the fact that
observation is the act of an observer on an reality. This statement is possible only through an objective reality. Instead of addressing that- you go into "there's no way to know" regression, which was demolished long ago, and sunk in my statements above.
19) What does communication have to do with reality?
I thought you weren’t being serious. This is a detailed subject which involves not only human communication but particle physics to explain in full detail. Communication is an underlying principal of the reality we experience. This however is not relevant to the discussion. Again, I continue to ask a question of you.Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?
This is not an answer to the question, try again!
You've simply avoided the question by pretending it's far more complex than it needs to be. In order to combat that, I will rephrase the question, and you can attempt to avoid it again:
Does reality exist regardless of how we communicate about it?
You continually go back and forth between subjectivism, to relativism, to an objective reality. Each one of these views completely contradict the other- which is why you can't keep your story straight. This is a perfect example of that endless contradiction, which you are unable to resolve. You claim on the one hand that there is no such thing as truth, then you will turn around and state that truth is agreement- but you can't say how people agree because that would admit an objective view- but then you turn around and claim that reality cannot exist without communicating it.
My questions are specifically designed to point out these contradictions, and the fact that you continue to avoid them indicates that you are well aware of the contradictions, and simply cannot resolve them.
20) Where have I dodged the question- or more appropriately, which question has not been answered?
Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?
Wrong!
The answer to this question was posted and then linked to several times already. You have presented rebuttals to these statements, which I have debunked, and that has brought us to where we are. You have not addressed the undeniable fact that the answer (and subsequent followup) has already been given in the following posts: #50, #103, #105, #108, #111, #114, #116, #119, #123, #126, #130, #134, #140, and #142.
21) Where have my statements been inconsistent, in contradiction, or unclear?
Claiming that you have a monopoly on reality and then stating that you don’t believe one can have a monopoly on reality. You did this without explaining what you meant by your idea of reality or having a monopoly on it and you continue to avoid the question every time I ask it.Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?
And here we see exactly why you had to take the quote at the top of this post out of context in order to attempt to justify your accusations. I addressed this lie above. I've also addressed your accusation that I am "avoiding" your question.
How can I be avoiding it if I point to my response every single time you have asked for it?
Either retract the statement, or try again!
22) How can your statements about a subjective reality be true if you are asking for clarification? (The very act of asking for clarification demands an objective reality)
It means only that I am attempting to understand you.
Wrong!
You were trying to get clarification on
things that were already said, as well as objects and statements already made. Trying to then flip that around and say you were merely trying to understand "me"- implying that I was unclear- is to avoid the question. The very act of scientific inquiry is a
clarification it's asking the question and then finding the answer. You're committing the
amphiboly fallacy by now changing the subject of the clarification (from reality to me).
23) Due to these contradictions, it is not entirely clear what you position is- although you have attempted to state that you believe in a subjective reality, your statements actually contradict this. So, which is it?
For me to believe that reality is subjective and that no truth is immediately accessible I would have to deny myself the luxury speaking of it in terms of fact. I tend to believe that what we experience of reality is subjective and that no further claims regarding the nature of an objective reality can be made because of it.
At least you can see that your answers make no sense. I don't expect any clarification from you on this point, because it's obvious you're incapable of giving it now: you realize it would be a direct contradiction- which for some reason you consider to be a "luxury"...
Not an answer to the question, try again!
24) What is "subjective reasoning"?
All reasoning is, the idea is almost a redundancy. To avoid confusion a context might need to be given but, as I said earlier, that is unlikely to change the situation much.
Much like your statements in regards to reality, this makes no sense at all. It's obvious, however, that you're again trying an
amphiboly fallacy changing the usage of "subjective" to instead mean "personal" (which is not a proper definition). You believe that this will allow you to avoid the underlying question. Of course, I'm not going to allow that to happen.
What you are not saying here is that all reasoning is personal- it's done by humans. That doesn't mean that all reasoning is flawed, however, or that all reasoning is wrong. It does mean that
reality is objective, though. Our observations and conclusions are based on that reality- and whether we're right or wrong has no bearing on reality whatsoever (you cannot claim that humans are always wrong, and then also claim that reality is also wrong). You're trying to switch out your previous statements in regards to a subjective reality to one which is now objective but patently unknowable. There are several (thousand) contradictions that arise when you attempt to do this: the first of which is the "is it true that truth does not exist" (stolen concept fallacy) which you're well aware of, and submitted to in your response to one of the questions above.
This is not an answer to the question, try again!
25) What is "standardization" if not being accurate to a measurement- and then having that measurement being a consequence of an objective reality?
To make this easier to answer I will refute the last part of the statement by claiming that there is no way to identify an objective reality as what we experience of it is relative to ourselves. It is because of this that we cannot move further into the idea of reality being objective.
The fact that you can't deny it without contradicting yourself is just the first step, kiddo. Considering the mountain of work required here to justify your statement- I'll settle for a retraction, for now.
26) Is the Internet not an example of an ever-increasing detailed language and communication medium which allows people to more quickly, accurately, and broadly explain concepts?
I’m sorry but the reason you had for asking this question is non-existent. I believe that what you claim, in this instance, is true and that I never made an attempt to refute it. The question I implied regarding it in your original statement was of the unidentifiable relevance it had to the conversation.Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?
This is not an answer to the question, try again!
You're simply saying the question is irrelevant- neglecting of course that this is a
list of questions you never answered.
27) How can one "make up" a context if reality is subjective?
To avoid confusion of thought.
This is not an answer to the question, please try again!
Your response here is completely ambiguous- and doesn't even address the question.
28) Give me one example of where my argument has been a strawman.
I hate straw men. You love to talk about them, I don’t know what your affiliation with them is but it’s obvious, due to one reason or another, that your personal experience seems to warrant you inserting the concept at every available opportunity. To answer this I will refer to your original claim of having a monopoly on truth and reality. I believe that is the "strawest" man that ever was.
Wrong!
That answer does not fit the defitnition of a strawman. I have already given you this response. You need to look up what a strawman is and retract your accusation.
29) Please define "perception" and "conception" and the differences between them.
Go look in a dictionary.
This is not an answer to the question, please try again!
I did- and I gave you that answer, and you continue to avoid it by inventing your own definitions. I am asking for your definitions because you are using them interchangibly, and they are two- very separate- concepts.
30) You attempted to use the Uncertainty Principle to claim that reality is subjective- and then quickly abandoned that position without reason. Can you explain how the UP is evidence of a subjective reality, and not an objective one?
It is evidence of a subjective interpretation of reality.
This is not an answer to the question, please try again!
You simply avoided the question, here. (ipse dixit)
31) How does the concept of "focus"- meaning that "something else comes to our attention"- consistent with a subjective reality. By its very definition, this is evidence of an objective and consistent reality.
It depends on a single concept and question. What is our involvement with reality?
This is not an answer to the question, please try again!
You simply avoided the question, here. (red herring)
32) Please clarify the statement: "Truth, as you understand it, isn't involved."
You enjoy to throw the word "truth" about to such an extent that your portrayal of it is fickle. It is because of that that I disagree with your notion of truth.
This is not an answer to the question, please try again!
You simply avoided the question here, and replaced it with another accusation- which is far too unspecific to mean anything.(ad hominem)
33) How can agreement exist if reality is subjective?
It stops headaches.
This is not an answer to the question, please try again!
You've simply avoided the question, here. (non-sequitur)
34) Please clarify the statement: "Not if you have familiarized yourself with it to the extent that you take it for granted."
I mean that you become overly familiar with a concept to the point that you do not ever question the validity of it in detail.
This is not an answer to the question, please try again!
You simply responded by giving me a defition of the term, instead of presenting your argument. (ambiguity)
35) Is it true that nothing can be verified objectively?
Who knows?
This is not an answer to the question, please try again!
You simply avoided the question, although it's safe to assume you cannot answer it- not because the (obvious) answer escapes you, but because answering it would contradict everything you have said.
You're simply avoiding the inevitable.
36) What is confusion if not an inconsistency to reality?
Conflicting ideas of perceived reality.
Wrong!
Again, refer to that dictionary. There is no such thing as a confusion of perceived reality- in that it makes no sense. Your answer is intentionally worded to avoid the obvious evidence of objective reality.
Conflicting ideas of
conceptualized reality- or to put it more simply (considering all knowledge is contextual): conflicting ideas. The important thing to remember is that reality is objective, and the degree to which we have
truth is the degree to which we are consistent with reality.
37) How many realities are there?
I don’t know, Totovader.
This is not an answer to the question, please try again!
Considering this is a list of questions you have not answered, "I don't know" is wholly insufficient- especially since your claim was that there are multiple realities. I'm simply demanding that you justify that statement, or retract it.
You did not answer this question, please try again!
39) Why would an agreement require that every interpretation in existence be defined? This ignores a subjective reality and an objective reality and replaces it simply with language.
Anything we perceive of this argument will be based on the interpretation of language. In regards to your claim of having a monopoly on truth and reality, I would expect you to at least answer the questions of who decides what is true and how you might have a monopoly on truth and reality or else you are forced to define every truth and reality it is that you have jurisdiction over.
Your statement doesn't make any sense. Your "or" does not logically flow from your previous statement, regardless of what you
expect. Additionally, we've already established above that language is irrelevant (although you avoid the question entirely).
This is not an answer to the question, please try again!
40) If something can be true for you, and not for someone else- how is it possible to communicate?
By acknowledging the presence of two or more individuals.
You did not answer this question, please try again!
You avoided the question by defining what
more than one person is, instead of presenting an answer to the question. (Ignoratio elenchi)
41) Please define the concept of "human reality".
Perceived reality.
Followup question: why make a distinction between "reality" and "human reality/perceived reality" when you believe that "reality" itself does not exist independent of humans (and human communication)?
42) Is it true that "human reality" is not "objective reality"?
That’s a reasonable assumption.
And we end up at your core contradiction: you will claim that human reality is different than objective reality, so we can never have truth. By now, even you recognize the contradiction, here- though you cannot resolve it without submitting to an objective reality.
43) What role does "luck" play in scientific study?
Some of these questions you never actually asked but decided to claim that you did so as to give a false impression of the situation. I will answer this question if you answer mine.Who decides what is true and how do you have a monopoly on truth and reality?
You did not answer this question, please try again!
You said:
You think that luck doesn't come into science, would you dare suggest such a thing?
I would like you to justify this statement with an argument.
44) What is your basis for the claim that what is true can be true for one person, and false for another?
Personal experience.
You did not answer this question, please try again!
You have avoided the question, here. (ipse dixit)
45) Please provide evidence for the statement: "Gravity is not objective as its laws do not apply to all perceptions of reality(ies)."
Refer to the idea of a unified theory.
You did not answer this question, please try again!
You answered with an incomplete and ambiguous statement. (argument by proxy)
46) How can your experience define a subjective reality?
By experiencing it, that's the whole point.
You did not answer this question, please try again!
You have avoided the question by simply stating "it is". (ipse dixit) Furthermore, you attempt to define reality as experience (denying what it is that is being experienced) and then in the next sentence will claim that experience
defines reality. Your answer- therefore- contradicts your previous statements.
47) How have I been hypocritical?
See above section.
You did not answer this question, please try again!
48) Prove that reality is subjective.
Which reality? : p
You did not answer this question, please try again!
You avoided the question by attempting to change the meaning of the statement (and negating previous statements in reference to "multiple realities" in the process).