The vulnerability of the Truth Movement.

Episode IV​

AN UNCONNECTED TWOOF​

It is a
dark time
for the 9/11
Twoofers. Even
as nearly 86% of
Americans give their
unquestioning support
to sinister Inside Jobbers,
rebel forces surrounding the
Movement threaten to utterly
collapse it into its own footprint.
Harried by negative energy beams,
buffeted by savvy Hardfire Troopers
and bracketed by shocking non-release
of promised films dealing destructive doom
to the stalwart Official Theory, Twoofers are
melting into formless holograms, projected upon
structured landscapes of towering reality. Twoofer
claims of a New World Order illuminate not one block
of masonry awry in a top-down scan of the rock-solid
Evidential Pyramid. In the Movement's gloried early times,
loquacious Jonesy the Hutt held hypnotic sway over millions
as electronically amplified distortions and lies spewed from his
bulbous lips and flapping gums. Terrifyingly treacherous Change
of facts were Loosed upon a vast interconnected network by the
dreaded Three Stoogents. Horridly crude experiments revealed the
steely stubbornness of Thermiters For Twoof as, with molten temper,
they demolished all hopes of discovering fusion between flash and fact.
While the Skeptical Force at Ground Zero swirls and expands outward in
an ever-widening maelstrom of acceptance, weary but omni-vigilant JREF
Keepers are confident that a great deal of the battle has been won. From
here on out they are tempted to think that maybe the rest is Gravy. Or not...​
Reccomended opening to the SLC debunking LC:final
 
Erm, yes you are correct in one sense. Truth isn't about poll numbers which is why no one can ever have a monopoly on the "truth". "Reasoning" is subjective, whatever it is you base it on and my "peeps" understand you very well.

Take a look at these two statements. Using reasoning, we can determine that one is true and one is false, given that our terms are properly defined.

1. The cross-section of a sphere is a circle.
2. The cross-section of a sphere is a square.

Could you explain where subjectivity enters into this?
 
Many would argue that the scientific community is somewhat divided.

Reality- however- is not. Nor does the fact that "many would argue" have any relevance to reality.

This is especially true when it comes down to competing theories. Yes, scientists have been known to visciously attack one another for daring to question each other.

I wasn't talking about scientists... I was talking about "Truthers". I don't see many scientists viciously attacking each other- at least not to the degree that the conspiracists do.

So, as science currently exists, what you have described is indeed a part of the practical application science. While "a truth" will bring contention to people whose truth differs, attacking one another viciously has no association with the virtue of truth itself. So no, science is not truth. It is a process designed to find agreeable conclusions but not one that is infallible.

Agreeable to whom?

To claim that the above concept of science has any monopoly on the truth is stark raving mad.

Which is why strawmans are so silly. Your above concept of "agreeable" is ambiguous. Science is not about truth via compromise or by vote. Truth exists independent of that agreement- it exists in dependant of the observer, so to claim that it has anything to do with an individual or group is- in fact- stark raving mad.

How can you be impartial when you claim to have a monopoly on truth?

Because the two are not mutually exclusive.

How can you claim to be impartial when you claim to have a monopoly on reality?

Same as above. Although I should clarify that statement- I don't believe in a "monopoly on reality"- at least in the sense that you have taken it. As I have said, reality exists independant of the observer- so to have a monopoly on reality was really just saying that through rationality- through science we better understand reality. I was simply being climactic. I clearly do not believe that anyone "owns reality" (nor do I believe that anyone "owns truth" but you don't seem to be getting my allusion).

How, in the name of all things sacred, can you now have a monopoly on reality?

See above.

How can you have a monopoly on something without involving a commodity or having exclusive possession and control of that same commodity?

Because you are not understanding what I'm saying. Scientists (and subsequently skeptics, critical thinkers, etc) use the tools of scientific inquiry, rationality, and reason to arrive at truth. This is not religion, it's not faith or hopes or whims or luck or majority or minority or anything else- it is conscious, willful, determined effort towards understanding reality. This is exclusive to the scientific realm. Randi demonstrates this every single day. I mean... if you have a shot- there's a big reward...

The only thing you have a monopoly on is your own thoughts, it's the same with everyone else.

If everyone owns the same thing, then it's not a monopoly, really- but your point doesn't make much sense anyway.

Reality is subjective but certain things are permitted in the sense that they are agreed on to a large extent.

Absolutely, irrefutably, 100%, undeniably, unequivocally, dead wrong.

The moment you start thinking only you know the truth is the exact time when your ego breaks loose and wreaks havoc on your psyche.

Holy whopping strawman- seems to be a favorite of yours.

Please answer the following question (note: you've avoided all the other questions I've presented to you): AT WHAT POINT DID I SPECIFICALLY STATE OR EVEN IMPLY THAT ONLY I KNOW THE TRUTH?

If you can't answer- retract this time, instead of just ignoring it.

If you don't know where you stand in regards to what an opinion is worth then you have no foundation on which to make an argument.

This doesn't even make any sense.

You have a monopoly on the truth?
You have a monopoly on reality?

You seem to be doing a damn poor job of maintaining its cohesion if that's the case.

Says you, fortunately you do not decide truth. (And- according to you, truth is just subjective, anyway. So if I could get a bunch of people to disagree with you- maybe even pay them off to do so- then I would be right, and you would be wrong.)
 
Take a look at these two statements. Using reasoning, we can determine that one is true and one is false, given that our terms are properly defined.

1. The cross-section of a sphere is a circle.
2. The cross-section of a sphere is a square.

Could you explain where subjectivity enters into this?

In that case it would come down to the interpretation of language and how one observes shapes. People who have been blind since birth/early age and regain their site later in life have great difficulty recognizing shapes. The point here is that just because a majority sees the same thing, it does not mean that there's nothing more to be discovered. Which senses are being used to determine its shape are also important.

How many dimensions are we viewing these objects in?

Most likely three, in such a case (based on my perception) I would agree that the cross-section of a sphere is circular. But again, that's not entirely accurate. You are assuming that the sphere is being viewed from an angle by which a consistent two-dimensional interpretation of a circle can be drawn. A sphere is a three-dimensional object. All we're doing here, in order to obtain a cross section, is intersecting a plane. It certainly seems to be circular but we can give it more definition than something so vague as "it looks round".

Do you mean a perfect circle or a general circular shape (to the limited degree of accuracy you are able to perceive it)?

There are too many variables we take for granted regarding such things. How much information you have to verify something makes all the difference. Of equal importance is where information comes from.
 
Last edited:
Agreeable to whom?

The scientific community or the group involved.

Which is why strawmans are so silly. Your above concept of "agreeable" is ambiguous. Science is not about truth via compromise or by vote. Truth exists independent of that agreement- it exists in dependant of the observer, so to claim that it has anything to do with an individual or group is- in fact- stark raving mad.

Nay, there is much compromise in science. Some researches will make an attempt to explain something within a familiar context so as to make sense of it. In the case of Olaf Blanke, regarding out of body experiences, he attempts to bring elements of shizophrenia into his explanations so as to make them seem more understandable/plausible yet most psychologists are in general disagreement regarding his conclusions.


Because the two are not mutually exclusive.

Are you now going to say that truth involves having an impartial monopoly?

Same as above. Although I should clarify that statement- I don't believe in a "monopoly on reality"- at least in the sense that you have taken it. As I have said, reality exists independant of the observer- so to have a monopoly on reality was really just saying that through rationality- through science we better understand reality. I was simply being climactic. I clearly do not believe that anyone "owns reality" (nor do I believe that anyone "owns truth" but you don't seem to be getting my allusion).

You are hell bent on competing for a position of authority due to your belief that once you get there you will have some sort of exclusive truth by which you can justify this strange idea of having a monopoly over. What good is rational thinking when it operates within a limited understanding?

Because you are not understanding what I'm saying. Scientists (and subsequently skeptics, critical thinkers, etc) use the tools of scientific inquiry, rationality, and reason to arrive at truth.

I hate to break it to you but many religious people also have the ability to be skeptical and interpret truth via rational reasoning. You're presenting them in such a light that your notion of their psyche is all encompassing of their way of thinking. In this sense you are just being vague, generalizing to the extent that you become arrogant in your thinking.

This is not religion, it's not faith or hopes or whims or luck or majority or minority or anything else- it is conscious, willful, determined effort towards understanding reality. This is exclusive to the scientific realm. Randi demonstrates this every single day. I mean... if you have a shot- there's a big reward...

Randi's ego interferes too much with the work he does. If you are looking for a leader or someone to hail as being a hero of critical thinking then you are looking for a way by which you can surrender your own judgement. Of course its faith, people have faith in their theories be it the notion of god or superstrings. People have faith in Randi's ability to do the right thing. Faith comes into just about everything in human existence.

If everyone owns the same thing, then it's not a monopoly, really- but your point doesn't make much sense anyway.

My point is that "it's not a monopoly, really" because it doens't exist.

Absolutely, irrefutably, 100%, undeniably, unequivocally, dead wrong.

Hardly, that's the only truth there is, for me. ;)

Holy whopping strawman- seems to be a favorite of yours.

You repeat yourself just as often as I do in this case. The only difference is that you look for an opporntunity to insert the word "strawman".

Please answer the following question (note: you've avoided all the other questions I've presented to you): AT WHAT POINT DID I SPECIFICALLY STATE OR EVEN IMPLY THAT ONLY I KNOW THE TRUTH?

The moment you claimed to be one of the people who had a monopoly on it.

This doesn't even make any sense.

I think you are already aware of what claiming to have a monopoly on the truth sounds like to someone who is balanced in their thinking.

Says you, fortunately you do not decide truth. (And- according to you, truth is just subjective, anyway. So if I could get a bunch of people to disagree with you- maybe even pay them off to do so- then I would be right, and you would be wrong.)

If truth is subjective and unqiue to an individual's perception, how does paying people off to think differently from that individual affect his/her own concept of truth?

Answer: It doesn't

Now, if you're talking about propaganda, then that certainly would be capable of influencing an individual's opinion/his own truth.
 
Last edited:
In that case it would come down to the interpretation of language and how one observes shapes.

No, these things can all be clarified. "One observes shapes" as they are.

People who have been blind since birth/early age and regain their site later in life have great difficulty recognizing shapes.

Which is why it's called an abnormality.

The point here is that just because a majority sees the same thing, it does not mean that there's nothing more to be discovered. Which senses are being used to determine its shape are also important.

Actually, the point is that having an abnormality can be recognized and overcome. The fact that people who have had disabilities have trouble recognizing shapes proves that the shapes are objective.

How many dimensions are we viewing these objects in?

It doesn't matter. Your claim has been that reality is subjective. If you wish to maintain this argument, asking for clarification is self-defeating.

[cut out obfuscations]

Do you mean a perfect circle or a general circular shape (to the limited degree of accuracy you are able to perceive it)?

Do you see what you're doing here? Besides attempting to change the context, you're trying to make it seem as if it's indescribable. Since ALL of your challenges can be clarified, you've only served in defeating your own argument.

There are too many variables we take for granted regarding such things.

If there's any trouble, clarification and further focus is required. That's called context. It doesn't make it impossible to understand reality- and it certainly doesn't make it subjective.

How much information you have to verify something makes all the difference. Of equal importance is where information comes from.

As you have demonstrated- this cannot possibly be the case.
 
The scientific community or the group involved.

...

The moment you claimed to be one of the people who had a monopoly on it.

...

There's nothing for me to respond to, here- you simply dodged my questions and refused to support your position by going off on tangents (red herring) and completely avoiding the discussion.

I've chosen to instead focus on your other reply- which demonstrates quite clearly how your argument is self-defeating.
 
So on reality, The Truth Movement is extremely vulnerable and hangs on the shoulders of only a couple of people who feed the whole CT world. Without them the whole movement would shrink to a hardly noticed branch with outlandish speculations. Speculations that would not raise interest.

I've been thinking about this for close to a week now. The leaders of the Truth Movement are nothing more than salesmen, pushing a product based on lies and false accusations.

They all seemed to play nice with each other (for the most part) for quite some time. The mantra was "just asking questions"; and this mantra was combined with a generous amount of baseless speculation.

There was a lot of different flavors out there for the troofer market; ranging from the vanilla theories such as LIHOP and controlled demolition to exotic ones including death rays and holographs. There was a little something for everyone, and the salesmen knew that the best way to increase their sales was to increase the market itself. Everyone got along. Everyone cross promoted. Everyone (that mattered) got paid.

But then the market started shrinking. Why? I don't know. I would like to think that the hard work put in by the many people that frequent this board and others had something to do with it. I think a lot of it just had to do with the fact that five years is too long to sit in the "just asking questions" phase.

For people who set out to make money selling troof, the shrinking troof market was very bad. It meant that those accustomed to profiting off of lies had to increase market share just to break even. The troof peddlers had to develop a "superior" product to increase their market share. But how does one improve a product based on lies? By becoming more assertive in your statements (say goodbye to "just asking questions") and by discrediting those that are, well, telling different lies than you are. This seems like a good recipe for meltdown.

So at the end of the day, I think what we are witnessing are the salesmen of the movement attacking each others' market share; because the market has shrunk to the point where it can no longer support all of them.

Pentacon could not have picked a worse time to roll out their lies for sale.
 
No, these things can all be clarified. "One observes shapes" as they are.

Nay, one oberserves shapes as their brain is able to interpret them. It's as simple as that my friend.

Which is why it's called an abnormality.

Which implies what? (Regarding your concept of truth and statistics)

Actually, the point is that having an abnormality can be recognized and overcome. The fact that people who have had disabilities have trouble recognizing shapes proves that the shapes are objective.

It's not so simple. Again, it comes down to how we think shapes should be perceived by our limited means of perception.

Your claim has been that reality is subjective. If you wish to maintain this argument, asking for clarification is self-defeating.

The point of it being subjective is that in order to understand someone else's thoughts, as best one can, communication is required. We are not always privy to each other's thoughts.

Do you see what you're doing here? Besides attempting to change the context, you're trying to make it seem as if it's indescribable. Since ALL of your challenges can be clarified, you've only served in defeating your own argument.

It's all about context. It's certainly describable but the accuracy will vary with the context. The idea of context is in itself a means of perception.

If there's any trouble, clarification and further focus is required. That's called context. It doesn't make it impossible to understand reality- and it certainly doesn't make it subjective.

As far as you are able to perceive the the context of something, it is subjective in that sense.

You see what appears to be a circle, what is it made up of?

If you demand that something be viewed from a limited point of view then you cannot ever grasp a full understanding of it thus your idea of truth is shattered.

As you have demonstrated- this cannot possibly be the case.

Elaborate.

In regards to me avoiding discussion, hardly. I've only ever focussed on the idea of debating against the idea of "truth as a monopoly". I haven't gone off-topic at all. You seem to enjoy implying the existence of "strawmen" and "red herrings" rather than answering the simple question of how you can ever have a monopoly on the truth. You've doged that since I first replied.

There's nothing for me to respond to, here- you simply dodged my questions and refused to support your position by going off on tangents (red herring) and completely avoiding the discussion.

Nay, I answered you directly. The only way it would not apply is if you are unable to perceive what it is you claim to have a monopoly over. If you cannot know what it is, in this case truth, you cannot ever reliably believe to have a monopoly over it.

Dare you say that you reserve the truth?
 
Last edited:
Nay, one oberserves shapes as their brain is able to interpret them. It's as simple as that my friend.

Wrong! Here is the crux of your lack of understanding. Everything we know about the mind shows that you're wrong, here. The senses "observe" (if you will) the shapes (perception), the brain translates those observations into concepts: ie, circle, round, red, etc.

This is important for you to understand, because this is the reason that you continue to make the mistake of thinking that reality is subjective and contradicting yourself: reality is not made by the brain- reality is conceptualized by the brain. The degree to which we correctly make those concepts and connect them to be consistent with reality is the degree to which we find truth.

Which implies what? (Regarding your concept of truth and statistics)

Which implies that it's not normal. You try to claim that people with a disability who have a hard time (not an impossible time) recognizing shapes mean that reality is subjective. This completely contradicts itself. If they had an easy time, they wouldn't be abnormal- and if they were normal, they would recognize shapes easily... thus, reality is objective, and although some people have a harder time properly conceptualizing different truths about reality (HELLO, what forum is this?) it doesn't make reality any less consistent- only us less consistent.

It's not so simple. Again, it comes down to how we think shapes should be perceived by our limited means of perception.

A few words ago it was "just that simple..." in your words...

Anyway- what you said here again makes no sense. How can we have a should in place of a does when you claim that reality is subjective anyway? If my reality is different than yours- then how can you possibly tell me how I "should perceive" [sic] a shape? You continue to contradict yourself, here.

The truth is- how we should recognize and form concepts about that shape is how reality is. It is that simple... And you continue to talk about "perceptual limits"- but this is ambiguous and nonsensical. As we have seen with abnormalities, science is not simply a sense- it is a rigorous and tested set of observations.

The point of it being subjective is that in order to understand someone else's thoughts, as best one can, communication is required. We are not always privy to each other's thoughts.

But what does that have to do with reality? Thoughts are just as easily communicated as they are stored. Our language continues to get more and more complex to allow us to do that. I mean... we are on the mother-loving INTERNET for chrissake.

It's all about context. It's certainly describable but the accuracy will vary with the context. The idea of context is in itself a means of perception.

Let's get something straight: all knowledge comes in context to claim that certain knowledge or certain accuracy vary within the context is to state the obvious. Likewise, to claim that it is impossible to communicate these concepts because they all have context is to ignore the FACT that context allows us TO COMMUNICATE.

Want an example?

Ok, imagine a circle 10cm in diameter, completely filled red, with no border. The shape is two-dimensional.

Now- try as hard as you can to conceptualize that shape other than what I have intended without adding, subtracting, or changing what I said...

There goes your precious subjectivity.

As far as you are able to perceive the the context of something, it is subjective in that sense.

You see what appears to be a circle, what is it made up of?

Holy mother of crap.

Do you understand how quickly this statement contradicts itself? The QUESTION of "what is it made of" is solvable- do you get that? Furthermore, we can solve it and arrive at the same conclusion without ever having discussed it together. That is not subjectivity- that is objectivity... pure, unadulterated, raw, objectivity.

If you demand that something be viewed from a limited point of view then you cannot ever grasp a full understanding of it thus your idea of truth is shattered.

Who's making such demands?

Elaborate.

See above. Abnormalities, contradictions about shapes- etc.

In regards to me avoiding discussion, hardly. I've only ever focussed on the idea of debating against the idea of "truth as a monopoly".

Yet your last response failed to answer my question, and instead talked about Olaf Blanke...

I haven't gone off-topic at all.

You have avoided my rebuttal. You haven't even touched on the contradictions I have exposed in your argument.

You seem to enjoy implying the existence of "strawmen" and "red herrings" rather than answering the simple question of how you can ever have a monopoly on the truth.

You seem to enjoy claiming it's an implication, instead of an unchallenged fact. I have repeatedly answered this question- and have continued to clarify when you injected your own version of my argument.

You've doged that since I first replied.

The unedited comments of this discussion show otherwise.

Nay, I answered you directly. The only way it would not apply is if you are unable to perceive what it is you claim to have a monopoly over. If you cannot know what it is, in this case truth, you cannot ever reliably believe to have a monopoly over it.

Again, this makes no sense. Give me an example of how one cannot perceive something without directly contradicting yourself.

Dare you say that you reserve the truth?

Do you own a farm of nothing but strawmen?
 
Last edited:
Wrong! Here is the crux of your lack of understanding. Everything we know about the mind shows that you're wrong, here. The senses "observe" (if you will) the shapes (perception), the brain translates those observations into concepts: ie, circle, round, red, etc.

You're going in circles here. I already said that the brain interprets the shape (based on current understanding). You're point is non-existant and you are now talking for the sake of it. You are wasting my time and your effort. The sensory nerves take in raw information, or are you now going to try convincing me that they process more than that?

If you're trying to make a point, make it clear.

This is important for you to understand, because this is the reason that you continue to make the mistake of thinking that reality is subjective and contradicting yourself: reality is not made by the brain- reality is conceptualized by the brain. The degree to which we correctly make those concepts and connect them to be consistent with reality is the degree to which we find truth.

You seem to have trouble getting your head around the idea. Reality certainly seems to exist outside us but what we experience of it is made subjective by our own interpretation. Any reality you would be able to speak of would, in that case, be a subjective interpretation of what you are able to perceive of it (mentally or otherwise) and nothing more.


Which implies that it's not normal. You try to claim that people with a disability who have a hard time (not an impossible time) recognizing shapes mean that reality is subjective. This completely contradicts itself.

Their notion of the "reality of sight" would be very different from yours. Most of them expect to see something wonderful but in many cases they prefered being blind, something they are familiar with (and you are not). In any case, reality is certainly subjective as their personal experience is yet another part of it.

If they had an easy time, they wouldn't be abnormal- and if they were normal, they would recognize shapes easily... thus, reality is objective, and although some people have a harder time properly conceptualizing different truths about reality (HELLO, what forum is this?) it doesn't make reality any less consistent- only us less consistent.

If we are not consistent and the concept of reality is based on (or influenced by) our inconsistencies, that would make the notion anything but objective.

A few words ago it was "just that simple..." in your words...

The concept is indeed beautifully simple. Your intellectualization complicates a simple idea so as to make it suit your own ends (your "monopoly"). You're using subjective reasoning but trying to make it out to be something more.

Anyway- what you said here again makes no sense. How can we have a should in place of a does when you claim that reality is subjective anyway? If my reality is different than yours- then how can you possibly tell me how I "should perceive" [sic] a shape? You continue to contradict yourself, here.

The answer's easy, it's called standardization (the basis of comparison). Without it we'd be all over the place. That only makes it agreeable as there's really no such thing as an objective standard, just "accuracy" within a certain degree.

The truth is- how we should recognize and form concepts about that shape is how reality is. It is that simple... And you continue to talk about "perceptual limits"- but this is ambiguous and nonsensical. As we have seen with abnormalities, science is not simply a sense- it is a rigorous and tested set of observations.

Observations made using what?

But what does that have to do with reality? Thoughts are just as easily communicated as they are stored.

Rubbish, there'd be no need for diplomacy were that the case.

Our language continues to get more and more complex to allow us to do that. I mean... we are on the mother-loving INTERNET for chrissake.

Yes, we are on the internet, bbl ttyl asl? lol wtf h4x0r etc...

Let's get something straight: all knowledge comes in context to claim that certain knowledge or certain accuracy vary within the context is to state the obvious.

Yes, that's why we have words like "phenomenon" and why interpretations are made. Even if an understandable context is non-existent we tend to make something up to suit our beliefs/truths.

Likewise, to claim that it is impossible to communicate these concepts because they all have context is to ignore the FACT that context allows us TO COMMUNICATE.

It's possible to communicate information but not to override someone's thoughts. That's why anything you communicate will have to pass through another subjective thought process before it is discussed. There's no way to tell if the level of belief or understanding is precisely equal.

Want an example?

: (

Ok, imagine a circle 10cm in diameter, completely filled red, with no border. The shape is two-dimensional.

Now- try as hard as you can to conceptualize that shape other than what I have intended without adding, subtracting, or changing what I said...

There goes your precious subjectivity.

Hardly, what you said makes little sense and is based on limited thinking.

I just added a background color in order to perceive it. In my case it was white and made the red appear dull in comparison, what shade of red did you have in mind? I have nothing to compare the measurement of 10cm with so I also imagined a ruler. For the sake of making it appear as 10cm I also added an object I perceived to be roughly 1cm by the side of it. Come to mention it, it does look odd, being a 2D object in a 3D world. What am I supposed to be seeing here other than my own subjective interpretation of a red circle about 10cm accross?

Heck, you even used the word "imagine".

That's hardly objective, it's still subjective. You applied some sort of standard to it but so what, now I'm perceiving the standard in my own way.

Holy mother of crap.

: / I suppose it's better than giving me another strawman, or a fish.

Do you understand how quickly this statement contradicts itself? The QUESTION of "what is it made of" is solvable- do you get that? Furthermore, we can solve it and arrive at the same conclusion without ever having discussed it together. That is not subjectivity- that is objectivity... pure, unadulterated, raw, objectivity.

Hmm, we agreed that it was circular and formed, as best we could, a shared opinion of it in that we stated the same conclusions. As for universal objectivity, meh that's impossible to verify. You'd need to have a monopoly on truth for something like that. ;)

Who's making such demands?

I'm asking you to elaborate.

Yet your last response failed to answer my question, and instead talked about Olaf Blanke...

He was used as an example. You like to talk about strawmen and red herrings, I talk about something more interesting. : p

You have avoided my rebuttal. You haven't even touched on the contradictions I have exposed in your argument.

If you say so.

You seem to enjoy claiming it's an implication, instead of an unchallenged fact. I have repeatedly answered this question- and have continued to clarify when you injected your own version of my argument.

Summarize in less than 30 words how you can have a monopoly on the truth, let's get it over with.

Again, this makes no sense. Give me an example of how one cannot perceive something without directly contradicting yourself.

Hmm? You "do not perceive something" by giving your attention to something else. It's not a conscious process.

Do you own a farm of nothing but strawmen?

Your the one providing me with strawmen, I think you are mistaking me for one of your regular clients?

While we're at it, take this fish too (since you've decided to give them a literal interpretation instead of using them as metaphors). Now that's a waste of energy. ;)
 
Last edited:
I've been thinking about this for close to a week now. The leaders of the Truth Movement are nothing more than salesmen, pushing a product based on lies and false accusations.

That is very true. For example Dylan Avery can not have any differing views on his board. That would eat his sales. He bans people with any other view than his own in an instant.

There was a lot of different flavors out there for the troofer market; ranging from the vanilla theories such as LIHOP and controlled demolition to exotic ones including death rays and holographs. There was a little something for everyone, and the salesmen knew that the best way to increase their sales was to increase the market itself. Everyone got along. Everyone cross promoted. Everyone (that mattered) got paid.

This expansion really worked as long as their following grew.

But then the market started shrinking. Why? I don't know. I would like to think that the hard work put in by the many people that frequent this board and others had something to do with it. I think a lot of it just had to do with the fact that five years is too long to sit in the "just asking questions" phase.

I think it has to do with many things combined. Truthers have not presented anything new for a while. Older claims have been thoroughly debunked and there is more and more debunking material available. Before there was only the truther films and claims without a serious question of their reliability. Time has done it's part, interest has diminished. They have been revealed as cheaters. And so on.

For people who set out to make money selling troof, the shrinking troof market was very bad. It meant that those accustomed to profiting off of lies had to increase market share just to break even. The troof peddlers had to develop a "superior" product to increase their market share. But how does one improve a product based on lies? By becoming more assertive in your statements (say goodbye to "just asking questions") and by discrediting those that are, well, telling different lies than you are. This seems like a good recipe for meltdown.

That is their problem. Improving on anything that is based on lies brings only more and more lies. And lies don't carry you forever.

So at the end of the day, I think what we are witnessing are the salesmen of the movement attacking each others' market share; because the market has shrunk to the point where it can no longer support all of them.

This has been the trend as of late. Some are still fighting, but more and more desperately.

Pentacon could not have picked a worse time to roll out their lies for sale.

I can't wait to see this one. How many errors must that film have.
 
Last edited:
You're going in circles here. I already said that the brain interprets the shape (based on current understanding). You're point is non-existant and you are now talking for the sake of it. You are wasting my time and your effort. The sensory nerves take in raw information, or are you now going to try convincing me that they process more than that?

If you're trying to make a point, make it clear.

Have I been inconsistent? Have my statements at all contradicted each other? Have I been unclear?

Let's stipulate- for a moment- that you were not saying the opposite of what you're saying now. How- then- can your statements about a subjective reality be true?

Can you explain that? Just try.

You seem to have trouble getting your head around the idea. Reality certainly seems to exist outside us but what we experience of it is made subjective by our own interpretation. Any reality you would be able to speak of would, in that case, be a subjective interpretation of what you are able to perceive of it (mentally or otherwise) and nothing more.

What makes you think I'm the one having trouble?

Now reality does exist independent of the observer? Or it seems?

What we experience is not made subjective by our own interpretation- that is the exact opposite of what you just said above- and whined about because I was somehow "going in circles" at the same time I was pointing out what you apparently agreed with.

So which is it- is reality subjective or objective? If it's objective you cannot then turn around and say it's made by our observations. It's a direct contradiction to your previous statement.

Their notion of the "reality of sight" would be very different from yours.

And here again you contradict your first statement. This is why I emphasized just how important it was that you understood. You're now trying to slip back into a view of subjective reality at the same time you're claiming it's objective. It makes no sense... at all.

Most of them expect to see something wonderful but in many cases they prefered being blind, something they are familiar with (and you are not).

Huh? I'm familiar with not seeing. But the state of being blind- in that I have lost the ability of vision- no, I have not had that loss of ability. And what that has to do with the argument has really stumped me.

In any case, reality is certainly subjective as their personal experience is yet another part of it.

And here you directly contradict your first statement.

If we are not consistent and the concept of reality is based on (or influenced by) our inconsistencies, that would make the notion anything but objective.

Because as you stated in your first comment, reality is not subjective. Reality exists independent of our observations, wishes, whims, or desires- so how can you then turn around and say that it is after you claimed that the eyes and other senses only take sensory input from reality (which, by the way is absolutely 100% correct).

It's a direct contradiction.

The concept is indeed beautifully simple. Your intellectualization complicates a simple idea so as to make it suit your own ends (your "monopoly"). You're using subjective reasoning but trying to make it out to be something more.

Please- define "subjective reasoning", and then address your contradictions. That is the only way we will find a conclusion here: is if you stay consistent and clear in your accusations. I have done exactly that- and yet you continue to have trouble.

The answer's easy, it's called standardization (the basis of comparison). Without it we'd be all over the place. That only makes it agreeable as there's really no such thing as an objective standard, just "accuracy" within a certain degree.

Answer this: ACCURATE TO WHAT? Hmmm?

Observations made using what?

The senses. I don't know what you observe with- but senses work just fine.

Rubbish, there'd be no need for diplomacy were that the case.

Only if you believe that everyone is omniscient... Which would sort of rule out your existence in a Conspiracy Forum...

Yes, we are on the internet, bbl ttyl asl? lol wtf h4x0r etc...

And... don't forget to ignore what I said. If this is relevant to the discussion, please explain why. Otherwise you're picking out sentences for "the sake of talking" (in your words).

Yes, that's why we have words like "phenomenon" and why interpretations are made. Even if an understandable context is non-existent we tend to make something up to suit our beliefs/truths.

"Make up"- meaning being inconsistent with reality- a reality that is objective?

So when people are being inconsistent with reality, they are being irrational- making up things to suit their beliefs. How is this any different from what I've been saying- AND how is it consistent with your contradictions above? You have stated time and time again that reality is subjective. If reality is subjective, then stating that people "make up" stuff is redundant.

It's possible to communicate information but not to override someone's thoughts. That's why anything you communicate will have to pass through another subjective thought process before it is discussed. There's no way to tell if the level of belief or understanding is precisely equal.

Nor is it relevant. You aren't debating "thoughts". You aren't discussing "brain matter" (well, unless you are discussing brain matter). You are discussing your interpretation of reality- and to be correct, you have to be consistent with reality. This is the entire basis for science and understanding. Having an "equal understanding" doesn't even enter into the picture.

Hardly, what you said makes little sense and is based on limited thinking.

You did not support this claim.

I just added a background color in order to perceive it.

Which is exactly what I said you could not do. You do not need a "background color" in order to "perceive something" [sic].

In my case it was white and made the red appear dull in comparison, what shade of red did you have in mind? I have nothing to compare the measurement of 10cm with so I also imagined a ruler.

Which- again- is adding something, but the standard of measurement is further proof of objectivity. To make a measurement is to be consistent with reality.

For the sake of making it appear as 10cm I also added an object I perceived to be roughly 1cm by the side of it. Come to mention it, it does look odd, being a 2D object in a 3D world. What am I supposed to be seeing here other than my own subjective interpretation of a red circle about 10cm accross?

Besides all the stuff you added, a concept of a circle that is consistent with my communication- and thus is easy to compare to reality.

Heck, you even used the word "imagine".

Because I am asking you to conceptualize an entity which does not exist in front of you- but which is based on previous observations and concepts. It's not a perception, because it's not there.

That's hardly objective, it's still subjective. You applied some sort of standard to it but so what, now I'm perceiving the standard in my own way.

How do you perceive [sic] a standard in your own way? And if reality was subjective, how could you even have a standard?

Since you broke all the rules- take out a piece of paper. Take a ruler and draw a line 10cm long.

Now how long is that line?

I really can't make it any easier than that...

Hmm, we agreed that it was circular and formed, as best we could, a shared opinion of it in that we stated the same conclusions. As for universal objectivity, meh that's impossible to verify. You'd need to have a monopoly on truth for something like that. ;)

So yet again- you're claiming that reality is objective, but it's not?

Science is... meaningless?

I'm asking you to elaborate.

And you said: "If you demand that something be viewed from a limited point of view then you cannot ever grasp a full understanding of it thus your idea of truth is shattered."

No one has made such demands. Your argument is entirely a strawman. The "and thus your entire view of truth is shattered" should have been your first indication that you had built a man of straw.

He was used as an example. You like to talk about strawmen and red herrings, I talk about something more interesting. : p

I'm talking about your strawmans and red herrings. You continue to enter them into this discussion instead of addressing the issues. I have repeatedly pointed out inconsistencies and contradictions in your claims, and I'm left with repeating myself until you address them. You are left with attempting to defeat my claims via strawmens which you fail to elaborate on and which cannot stand up to any scrutiny.

If you say so.

The discussion thus far clearly makes my case for me. If you have any challenge to the contradictions I have pointed out in your statements- then please post it. Otherwise, this is useless. I'm simply going to continue to point out how and why you're wrong- and you're going to continue to manufacture strawmen.

Summarize in less than 30 words how you can have a monopoly on the truth, let's get it over with.

I already have. You have rebutted it with strawmen and inconsistent claims. To repeat myself will get us nowhere. If you have trouble with any portion of my argument- you can point it out and I will address it.

Hmm? You "do not perceive something" by giving your attention to something else. It's not a conscious process.

Which has absolutely nothing to do with what you were talking about. Your statement was: "The only way it would not apply is if you are unable to perceive what it is you claim to have a monopoly over. If you cannot know what it is, in this case truth, you cannot ever reliably believe to have a monopoly over it."

So I ask you again- how can one perceive something without directly contradicting yourself?

Example: "I do not see that red apple right there on the table."

What you're doing is dropping the context of the statement. Clearly- if one does not perceive something, they do not perceive it- but that's not what I was asking- because that's not what you said.

Your the one providing me with strawmen, I think you are mistaking me for one of your regular clients?

Give me one example of where my arguments have been a strawman.
 
Let's stipulate- for a moment- that you were not saying the opposite of what you're saying now. How- then- can your statements about a subjective reality be true?

Can you explain that? Just try.

Try explaining that one again. Unless subjective interpretation of meaning comes into it I'm not sure what you're saying.

What makes you think I'm the one having trouble?

Because you think that you're one of the people who "have a monopoly on the truth".

Now reality does exist independent of the observer? Or it seems?

It seems to but it's a clever illusion as whatever is there is certainly not objectively verifiable to the point of being an absolute truth.

What we experience is not made subjective by our own interpretation- that is the exact opposite of what you just said above- and whined about because I was somehow "going in circles" at the same time I was pointing out what you apparently agreed with.

Eh?

So which is it- is reality subjective or objective? If it's objective you cannot then turn around and say it's made by our observations. It's a direct contradiction to your previous statement.

Any reality you experience is made subjective by your own interpretation of it. Therefore, you could never know what it is you are experiencing in an objective sense because there is no reliable control reality. The moment you conceptualize it you go further into subjectvity.

And here again you contradict your first statement. This is why I emphasized just how important it was that you understood. You're now trying to slip back into a view of subjective reality at the same time you're claiming it's objective. It makes no sense... at all.

You misunderstand me : p

Huh? I'm familiar with not seeing. But the state of being blind- in that I have lost the ability of vision- no, I have not had that loss of ability. And what that has to do with the argument has really stumped me.

They cope with a loss, or lack, of sight in their own way and perceive what may be around them by using other means. It's subjective interpretation.

And here you directly contradict your first statement.

Hardly, emotional experience is a part of reality that is subjective in nature.

Because as you stated in your first comment, reality is not subjective. Reality exists independent of our observations, wishes, whims, or desires- so how can you then turn around and say that it is after you claimed that the eyes and other senses only take sensory input from reality (which, by the way is absolutely 100% correct).

Sensory input is not 100% correct, that's just silly. In that case we wouldn't be creating machines, based on our own interpretations of reality, to do sensing for us.


Please- define "subjective reasoning", and then address your contradictions. That is the only way we will find a conclusion here: is if you stay consistent and clear in your accusations. I have done exactly that- and yet you continue to have trouble.

Subjective reasoning is called reasoning.

Answer this: ACCURATE TO WHAT? Hmmm?

The perception of a measurement.

The senses. I don't know what you observe with- but senses work just fine.

So people are interpreting their senses subjectively, I already know this.

Only if you believe that everyone is omniscient... Which would sort of rule out your existence in a Conspiracy Forum...

Er, what?

And... don't forget to ignore what I said. If this is relevant to the discussion, please explain why. Otherwise you're picking out sentences for "the sake of talking" (in your words).

You were talking about the internet and how we use new words to describe new concepts : ) Like being away from the keyboard?

Hehe, you're going to have to be more specific than that.

"Make up"- meaning being inconsistent with reality- a reality that is objective?

Nay, a reality that is made subjective by how we interpret it. Thus, we "make up" stuff so as to avoid disastrous confusion. There are degrees of subjectivity. How absorbed one is by their own thoughts plays a large role when it comes to communication.

So when people are being inconsistent with reality, they are being irrational- making up things to suit their beliefs. How is this any different from what I've been saying- AND how is it consistent with your contradictions above? You have stated time and time again that reality is subjective. If reality is subjective, then stating that people "make up" stuff is redundant.

That's the whole point. The fact that people "make up" stuff is what makes it subjective. It's quite rational to make up stuff, like the concept of a measurement for instance.

Nor is it relevant. You aren't debating "thoughts". You aren't discussing "brain matter" (well, unless you are discussing brain matter). You are discussing your interpretation of reality- and to be correct, you have to be consistent with reality. This is the entire basis for science and understanding. Having an "equal understanding" doesn't even enter into the picture.

I can be consistent with my own interpretation of reality, certainly. As for science, it's all about coming to an agreement based on the interpretation of findings, even the reasoning itself is made from a limited understanding (based only on findings).

Which is exactly what I said you could not do. You do not need a "background color" in order to "perceive something" [sic].

Actually it depends. You really can't perceive a coloured shape without having something to compare it against, in this case a background colour.

Which- again- is adding something, but the standard of measurement is further proof of objectivity. To make a measurement is to be consistent with reality.

Measurements allow for an understanding of a perceived reality.

Besides all the stuff you added, a concept of a circle that is consistent with my communication- and thus is easy to compare to reality.

Your communication, in this sense, was not sufficient to warrant the same kind of perception on my part. That's why I had to do my own thinking and make up my own context, which is subjective.

Because I am asking you to conceptualize an entity which does not exist in front of you- but which is based on previous observations and concepts. It's not a perception, because it's not there.

Based on the previous obersvations of whom? Me? My subjective observations?

How do you perceive [sic] a standard in your own way? And if reality was subjective, how could you even have a standard?

Easy, I just created a standard to make sense of my subjectivity.

Since you broke all the rules- take out a piece of paper. Take a ruler and draw a line 10cm long.

Now how long is that line?

I really can't make it any easier than that...

No, which is why it fails. The goal is to create a line 10cm long but all that proves is that there's some sort of comparison going on. That doesn't prove an objective measurement exists, that's especially true when the theory of relativity comes into play. By my perception it would appear to be 10cm, we now have an agreement that it is roughly 10cm as measured by a particular ruler. I wouldn't agree that it is 10cm to the greatest possible accuracy there is but as far as I'm able to perceive the notion of 10cm (with the aid of a ruler) and draw a line that long, it appears to be 10cm. It's not objective in the truest sense.

Science is... meaningless?

Hardly. It looks for consistencies which we term as being "objective" but the word itself has so many degrees of accuracy that it's not actually "objective". ; p

The word "objective" is not objective because it is being understood by means of subjective interpretation through language and ideas.

And you said: "If you demand that something be viewed from a limited point of view then you cannot ever grasp a full understanding of it thus your idea of truth is shattered."

No one has made such demands. Your argument is entirely a strawman. The "and thus your entire view of truth is shattered" should have been your first indication that you had built a man of straw.

Your view of truth is not my view of truth, which is why I believe truth and reality are subjective.

I'm talking about your strawmans and red herrings. You continue to enter them into this discussion instead of addressing the issues. I have repeatedly pointed out inconsistencies and contradictions in your claims, and I'm left with repeating myself until you address them. You are left with attempting to defeat my claims via strawmens which you fail to elaborate on and which cannot stand up to any scrutiny.

You've spent more time talking about strawmen and red herrings rather than describing your monpoly.

The discussion thus far clearly makes my case for me. If you have any challenge to the contradictions I have pointed out in your statements- then please post it. Otherwise, this is useless. I'm simply going to continue to point out how and why you're wrong- and you're going to continue to manufacture strawmen.

Or rather you will continue to see them as being strawmen because that's how you subjectively interpret the context.

I already have.

You have done no such thing. : D

Which has absolutely nothing to do with what you were talking about. Your statement was: "The only way it would not apply is if you are unable to perceive what it is you claim to have a monopoly over. If you cannot know what it is, in this case truth, you cannot ever reliably believe to have a monopoly over it."

So I ask you again- how can one perceive something without directly contradicting yourself?

Ah, so if this is about context then you would have surely realised that we're talking about defining the concept of truth. Or rather you should be, by your own reasoning, but are not. Again, where is your monopoly on the truth? You don't even know what the truth is so you can't reliably claim to have a monopoly on it. I don't believe you.

Example: "I do not see that red apple right there on the table."

That's because you're not looking at it. You assume it's there though. If you were looking at it and did not see an apple then that's perfectly acceptable. What do you perceive it as being?

What you're doing is dropping the context of the statement. Clearly- if one does not perceive something, they do not perceive it- but that's not what I was asking- because that's not what you said.

I see. In that case please describe your concept of having a monopoly on the truth at least once so we can get an idea of the context.

Give me one example of where my arguments have been a strawman.

The moment you associated "monopoly" with "truth".
 
Ok, Expression_man, back to basics:

You claim that reality is subjective, correct?

Your evidence for this claim is that people disagree, correct?

Now please understand the difference between perception and conception:

Perception = the act of observation using the senses. You have gone back and forth between understanding this, and then contradicting it. Perception is not interpretation of observations- it is only an observation.

Conception = the act of taking particulars about an observation (abstraction) and forming concepts based on those particulars.

Agree, or disagree? Why or why not?

I would reply to your statement above- but you continue to go back and forth between your first statement- and then contradictions of your first statement, so we really need to clarify this before we can move on.
 
Wow. This thread is giving me better evidence than I ever expected to see for my "9/11 as Performance Art" hypothesis. Totovader and Expression_man, you might both be interested in that thread, which is here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=75003.

One relevant point from that thread, which is being amply confirmed here by Expression_man:

It makes me suspect that their [Truthers'] main cause for displeasure with skeptics is not that skeptics reach conclusions opposing the truthers', but that they spoil the game by coming to any definitive conclusion at all.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Wow. This thread is giving me better evidence than I ever expected to see for my "9/11 as Performance Art" hypothesis. Totovader and Expression_man, you might both be interested in that thread, which is here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=75003.

One relevant point from that thread, which is being amply confirmed here by Expression_man:

Respectfully,
Myriad

I would tend to agree with you, here- although I see it as slightly more offensive. I see it more as an attack on reasoning itself- as a denial of reality and logic.

I briefly touch on that in my blog (Corrected By Reality), but I will be making a series of videos on this issue within the next few days, after I collect some of my thoughts.
 
You claim that reality is subjective, correct?

I claim that what we perceive of reality is subjective. There is no way to address the concept of reality in such a way that we can speak of, with any degree of certainty, its workings and whether or not it is objective.

Your evidence for this claim is that people disagree, correct?

It's not that simple. The main evidence is that we are constantly learning and being proven wrong in our assumptions of how reality works. This is why we pursue endeavors such as the atlas experiment which, while giving the impression of being objective, is only able to detect "stuff" within the scope of its engineering and operational limitations. It only provides insight. We "see", within our means of perception, what is detectable and we try to theorize how it occurs naturally.

If evolutionary "theory" is described as being a part of reality but is debunked at some later stage, we will be forced to conclude that our notion of reality is pathetic to the extent of it being fickle. Some want to call it a "law", that's when the desperation to create a standard comes into it and people start to "make up" reality in the subjective sense via the concept of group consciousness.

Agree, or disagree? Why or why not?

The reality you are familiar with is the conception of your own perception. This makes it impossible for you to determine what an "objective reality" is made up of at its core levels. In fact, the notion of an "objective reality" is so elusive that trying to define it in words, of all things, is an exercise in futility.

I don't suppose you're going to want to talk about your little monopoly on reality now are you? ;)
 
Last edited:
I claim that what we perceive of reality is subjective.

Which makes no sense. Again, refer to the definition of perception.

There is no way to address the concept of reality in such a way that we can speak of, with any degree of certainty, its workings and whether or not it is objective.

If your statement were true, then I would be forced to not understand it. You are pointing to the apple on the table and saying "there is no way to describe that red apple".

It's not that simple. The main evidence is that we are constantly learning and being proven wrong in our assumptions of how reality works.

Here's what you have consistently avoided: if reality is subjective- then how can one be wrong or right? The closes you have come to answering this is to say there is a consensus, but a consensus based on what? You then say it's based on the perception- but this contradicts a claim that reality is subjective!

This is why we pursue endeavors such as the atlas experiment which, while giving the impression of being objective, is only able to detect "stuff" within the scope of its engineering and operational limitations. It only provides insight. We "see", within our means of perception, what is detectable and we try to theorize how it occurs naturally.

Again- theorize based on what? If your claim is that reality is subjective- and our senses are subjective- and everything is subjective... then there can be no such thing as truth. It's that simple.

You have avoided my question here. Instead, you are trying to skirt around it.

I'll ask again: You claim that reality is subjective. Your evidence for this has been that people disagree- yet you claim that truth only occurs through consensus. What you have failed to address is how consensus is reached if reality is subjective. What are they agreeing on- how, through what method?

If evolutionary "theory" is described as being a part of reality but is debunked at some later stage, we will be forced to conclude that our notion of reality is pathetic to the extent of it being fickle.

Besides that being a big if- that only shows that reality is objective.

Some want to call it a "law", that's when the desperation to create a standard comes into it and people start to "make up" reality in the subjective sense via the concept of group consciousness.

According to your definition- these laws are truth, since the vast majority of scientists agree with them.

Now you're getting into another ridiculous realm: group consciousness?

Hold on, I'm getting a message from the stones. They're telling me to read my horoscope...

The reality you are familiar with is the conception of your own perception.

But if we're at Conjunction Junction, what's your function?

Beyond the fact that this is what I have been saying repeatedly- this is the very thing you deny in your first paragraph. You seem to love to do that: start out with one statement, and then completely deny it in your following paragraphs.

This- however- does not address the fact that my perception is not flawed. My perception does not tell me that black is white- I may have an improper concept of black or white, but that's testable- because reality is objective.

So- yet again- you're defeating your own argument, here.

This makes it impossible for you to determine what an "objective reality" is made up of at its core levels.

Core levels? Whatever that means...

And, no- as a matter of fact, it does not.

True or false, A = B. Well, quite easily: false. My eyes see (perception) the points of the "A", the dash across the middle- my brain then recognizes it (conception) as the letter "A". My eyes also see the rounded breasts of the "B" (perception), and my brain then recognizes it as the letter "B" (conception). It concludes that A is not B, because A is A, and B is B. B is not A.

Not that hard to grasp.

In fact, the notion of an "objective reality" is so elusive that trying to define it in words, of all things, is an exercise in futility.

Or an exercise in science... eh, poh-tate-oh, po-toh-to.

I don't suppose you're going to want to talk about your little monopoly on reality now are you? ;)

That's all I've been doing. I've still got all my real estate- and you're losing yours. But let's stick to the topic for now before you use up all your get out of jail free cards...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom