You're going in circles here. I already said that the brain interprets the shape (based on current understanding). You're point is non-existant and you are now talking for the sake of it. You are wasting my time and your effort. The sensory nerves take in raw information, or are you now going to try convincing me that they process more than that?
If you're trying to make a point, make it clear.
Have I been inconsistent? Have my statements at all contradicted each other? Have I been unclear?
Let's stipulate- for a moment- that you were not saying the opposite of what you're saying now. How- then- can your statements about a subjective reality be true?
Can you explain that? Just try.
You seem to have trouble getting your head around the idea. Reality certainly seems to exist outside us but what we experience of it is made subjective by our own interpretation. Any reality you would be able to speak of would, in that case, be a subjective interpretation of what you are able to perceive of it (mentally or otherwise) and nothing more.
What makes you think I'm the one having trouble?
Now reality
does exist independent of the observer? Or it
seems?
What we
experience is
not made subjective by our own interpretation- that is the exact opposite of what you just said above- and whined about because I was somehow "going in circles" at the same time I was pointing out what you apparently agreed with.
So which is it- is reality subjective or objective? If it's objective you cannot then turn around and say it's made by our observations. It's a direct contradiction to your previous statement.
Their notion of the "reality of sight" would be very different from yours.
And here again you contradict your first statement. This is why I emphasized just how important it was that you understood. You're now trying to slip back into a view of subjective reality at the same time you're claiming it's objective. It makes no sense... at all.
Most of them expect to see something wonderful but in many cases they prefered being blind, something they are familiar with (and you are not).
Huh? I'm familiar with not seeing. But the state of being blind- in that I have lost the ability of vision- no, I have not had that loss of ability. And what that has to do with the argument has really stumped me.
In any case, reality is certainly subjective as their personal experience is yet another part of it.
And here you
directly contradict your first statement.
If we are not consistent and the concept of reality is based on (or influenced by) our inconsistencies, that would make the notion anything but objective.
Because as you stated in
your first comment, reality is not subjective. Reality exists independent of our observations, wishes, whims, or desires- so how can you then turn around and say that it
is after you claimed that the eyes and other senses
only take sensory input from reality (which, by the way is absolutely 100% correct).
It's a direct contradiction.
The concept is indeed beautifully simple. Your intellectualization complicates a simple idea so as to make it suit your own ends (your "monopoly"). You're using subjective reasoning but trying to make it out to be something more.
Please- define "subjective reasoning", and then address your contradictions. That is the only way we will find a conclusion here: is if you stay consistent and clear in your accusations. I have done exactly that- and yet you continue to have trouble.
The answer's easy, it's called standardization (the basis of comparison). Without it we'd be all over the place. That only makes it agreeable as there's really no such thing as an objective standard, just "accuracy" within a certain degree.
Answer this:
ACCURATE TO WHAT? Hmmm?
Observations made using what?
The senses. I don't know what you observe with- but senses work just fine.
Rubbish, there'd be no need for diplomacy were that the case.
Only if you believe that everyone is
omniscient... Which would sort of rule out your existence in a
Conspiracy Forum...
Yes, we are on the internet, bbl ttyl asl? lol wtf h4x0r etc...
And... don't forget to ignore what I said. If this is relevant to the discussion, please explain why. Otherwise you're picking out sentences for "the sake of talking" (in your words).
Yes, that's why we have words like "phenomenon" and why interpretations are made. Even if an understandable context is non-existent we tend to make something up to suit our beliefs/truths.
"Make up"- meaning being inconsistent with reality- a reality that is objective?
So when people are being inconsistent with reality, they are being irrational- making up things to suit their beliefs. How is this any different from what I've been saying-
AND how is it consistent with your contradictions above? You have stated time and time again that reality is subjective. If reality is subjective, then stating that people "make up" stuff is redundant.
It's possible to communicate information but not to override someone's thoughts. That's why anything you communicate will have to pass through another subjective thought process before it is discussed. There's no way to tell if the level of belief or understanding is precisely equal.
Nor is it relevant. You aren't debating "thoughts". You aren't discussing "brain matter" (well, unless you
are discussing brain matter). You are discussing
your interpretation of reality- and to be
correct, you have to be consistent with reality. This is the entire basis for science and understanding. Having an "equal understanding" doesn't even enter into the picture.
Hardly, what you said makes little sense and is based on limited thinking.
You did not support this claim.
I just added a background color in order to perceive it.
Which is exactly what I said you could not do. You do not need a "background color" in order to "perceive something" [sic].
In my case it was white and made the red appear dull in comparison, what shade of red did you have in mind? I have nothing to compare the measurement of 10cm with so I also imagined a ruler.
Which- again- is adding something, but the standard of measurement is further proof of objectivity. To
make a measurement is to be consistent with reality.
For the sake of making it appear as 10cm I also added an object I perceived to be roughly 1cm by the side of it. Come to mention it, it does look odd, being a 2D object in a 3D world. What am I supposed to be seeing here other than my own subjective interpretation of a red circle about 10cm accross?
Besides all the stuff you added, a
concept of a circle that is consistent with my communication- and thus is easy to compare to reality.
Heck, you even used the word "imagine".
Because I am asking you to
conceptualize an entity which does not exist in front of you- but which is based on previous observations and concepts. It's not a perception, because it's not there.
That's hardly objective, it's still subjective. You applied some sort of standard to it but so what, now I'm perceiving the standard in my own way.
How do you perceive [sic] a standard in your own way? And if reality was subjective, how could you even have a standard?
Since you broke all the rules- take out a piece of paper. Take a ruler and draw a line 10cm long.
Now how long is that line?
I really can't make it any easier than that...
Hmm, we agreed that it was circular and formed, as best we could, a shared opinion of it in that we stated the same conclusions. As for universal objectivity, meh that's impossible to verify. You'd need to have a monopoly on truth for something like that.
So yet again- you're claiming that reality is objective, but it's not?
Science is... meaningless?
I'm asking you to elaborate.
And you said: "If you demand that something be viewed from a limited point of view then you cannot ever grasp a full understanding of it thus your idea of truth is shattered."
No one has made such demands. Your argument is entirely a strawman. The "and thus your entire view of truth is shattered" should have been your first indication that you had built a man of straw.
He was used as an example. You like to talk about strawmen and red herrings, I talk about something more interesting. : p
I'm talking about
your strawmans and red herrings.
You continue to enter them into this discussion instead of addressing the issues. I have repeatedly pointed out inconsistencies and contradictions in your claims, and I'm left with repeating myself until you address them.
You are left with attempting to defeat my claims via strawmens which you fail to elaborate on and which cannot stand up to any scrutiny.
The discussion thus far clearly makes my case for me. If you have any challenge to the contradictions I have pointed out in your statements- then please post it. Otherwise, this is useless. I'm simply going to continue to point out how and why you're wrong- and you're going to continue to manufacture strawmen.
Summarize in less than 30 words how you can have a monopoly on the truth, let's get it over with.
I already have. You have rebutted it with strawmen and inconsistent claims. To repeat myself will get us nowhere. If you have trouble with any portion of my argument- you can point it out and I will address it.
Hmm? You "do not perceive something" by giving your attention to something else. It's not a conscious process.
Which has absolutely nothing to do with what you were talking about. Your statement was: "The only way it would not apply is if you are unable to perceive what it is you claim to have a monopoly over. If you cannot know what it is, in this case truth, you cannot ever reliably believe to have a monopoly over it."
So I ask you again- how can one perceive something without directly contradicting yourself?
Example: "I do not see that red apple right there on the table."
What you're doing is dropping the context of the statement. Clearly- if one does not perceive something,
they do not perceive it- but that's not what I was asking- because that's not what you said.
Your the one providing me with strawmen, I think you are mistaking me for one of your regular clients?
Give me one example of where my arguments have been a strawman.