The vulnerability of the Truth Movement.

The Otis fighters thing...

Some things to consider. At 0844, when NEADS decided to launch the Otis F-15s, they had not been given a position for AA11 from Boston Centre.



We can have a quick look at these coordinates to determine where they actually are.

The first (41°15’0.00”N 74°36’0.00”W) is just north of Sussex NJ, 48 miles from the WTC due NW. The second (41°15’0.00”N 73°46’0.00”W) is just south of Yorktown Heights NY, 39 miles from the WTC due NNE.

So far so good. Except of course, the fighters don't just fly there in a straight line. You can't have a couple of F-15's just barrelling their way through civilian airspace at 1000MPH+, over urban areas. So they head east, out over the Atlantic, and follow the coast, flying through the ADIZ which is military controlled airspace.

Once they reached the coast of Long Island, to pass through to the Z-Point they then have to get FAA permission. Which they weren't given. The FAA didn't want two F-15's flying smack through the middle of New York, potentially colliding with airliners in the tightly packed airspace. It was the FAA controllers that put the F-15s in a holding pattern over Long Island. That was at 0907. And then, at 0921, the phantom A11 report came in, and the Otis fighters were directed towards Washington DC.

Bear in mind, the FAA control airspace over the USA, not the military. For NORAD to take command, first the government would need to declare an Air Defense Emergency. This would activate the Security Control of Air Traffic and Air Navigation Aids (SCATANA) Plan and give NORAD total control of airspace.

-Gumboot

Boston contacted Otis directly bypassing NORAD. Boston knew Flight 11 had turned and was heading toward NYC, therefor Otis knew. In this emergency, I find it doubtful they followed the book. (Yes, my reasonable opinion)

They flew directly to NYC at supersonic speed. After their attempt to intercept the second hijack plane (9:03am) it is entirely possible they were directed to the holding pattern off Long Island. A decision had been made to land all approaching planes to NYC and clear the air space. After the inbound passenger planes landed, the fighters resumed patrol over NYC.
 
Actually, I don't think we're "winning," for the simple reason that I never considered this a contest or game. It's about countering the lies and slander and nonsense of those who proclaim themselves "truthers." It's more a moral obligation, a responsibility to 9/11 victims, their families, and ultimately the truth itself. I've never derived a scintilla of pleasure or satisfaction from dealing with you guys. It's like an unpleasant chore, something that unfortunately has to be done by someone.

The whole 9/11 CT thing has basically devolved along the lines of the UFO and Bigfoot movements. It had its brief little heyday, but now no one takes it very seriously anymore, except the hard-core few who believe because it fulfills some personal inner need. And like the UFO movement, you're sustained by the belief that you're always right on the verge of that long-awaited breakthrough, the watershed event that will finally make the rest of us see the light and proclaim you as visionary heroes. But it never comes.

I will repeat.
I don’t consider myself part of the "Truth Movement." There are only few points of agreement.
 
Sorry, I haven't read the entire thread, so this is in response to the opening post. The "Troother" movement may have its weaknesses, but it has one enourmous strength: A lot of people just want to believe in conspiracies, whatever the arguments against. "Our side", if such a side exists, can never really win, because there will always be people who say: "Well, whatever you say, I'm sure something is afoot".

Just look at our friend Einsteen. He has understood and implicitly accepted practically every argument from our side, but he hasn't budged one inch, nevertheless.

ETA: What we must remember, however, is that it is not our loss, it is theirs.

Hans
 
There. Oh, man... am I ever in trouble now!
Not at all, well said.
-heh-
You don't understand... I run a big conspiracy theory website... that rant's gonna haunt me! :p

Seriously, any "conspiracy theorist" who was involved in conspiracy theories before 9/11 wants nothing to do with Truthers... except for popular conspiracy profiteers.
 
-heh-
You don't understand... I run a big conspiracy theory website... that rant's gonna haunt me! :p

Seriously, any "conspiracy theorist" who was involved in conspiracy theories before 9/11 wants nothing to do with Truthers... except for popular conspiracy profiteers.
Yes, Alex Jones seems to be having a fine time with the truthers. 9/11 was a windfall for him.
 
What is true today may not be true tomorrow. New facts and information brings about new truth.

No, truth does not simply change upon your whim. Additionally- this is not how the "Truth Movement" operates. They ignore facts, invent their own "evidence", lie, manipulate, and otherwise create ridiculous and backwards theories to support a predetermined conclusion.

If you honestly believe that truth is decided by reality- and you'd better believe that- then your conspiracy theories will never be true. The science is in.

The conventional thinkers here in this forum (note, not critical thinkers) base their truth on authority and not reason, example the 9/11 Commission Report.

To agree with the Commission report is not the same as relying on it as the basis for truth. I don't think conspiracists understand the difference. I have never come across a single debunker who simply relies on the position that "the government said it, so it's true". Fact of the matter is- I think most skeptics could give a crap about what "the government says".

I have presented many examples which conflicts with the known truth in this forum: i.e. The Missiles at Ground Zero. Conventional thinkers find it easier to rely upon authority than reason. To reconcile conflicting information requires a person to actually think. It appears that most people here find that a bit difficult.

Yet these claims have been thoroughly debunked. The fact that you continue to hold on to them after this has been shown- indicates that you're not interested in truth, but rather fantasy. That's exactly how conspiracism works.[/QUOTE]
 
No, truth does not simply change upon your whim. Additionally- this is not how the "Truth Movement" operates. They ignore facts, invent their own "evidence", lie, manipulate, and otherwise create ridiculous and backwards theories to support a predetermined conclusion.

If you honestly believe that truth is decided by reality- and you'd better believe that- then your conspiracy theories will never be true. The science is in.



To agree with the Commission report is not the same as relying on it as the basis for truth. I don't think conspiracists understand the difference. I have never come across a single debunker who simply relies on the position that "the government said it, so it's true". Fact of the matter is- I think most skeptics could give a crap about what "the government says".



Yet these claims have been thoroughly debunked. The fact that you continue to hold on to them after this has been shown- indicates that you're not interested in truth, but rather fantasy. That's exactly how conspiracism works.
[/quote]

" thoroughly debunked" I don’t think so.

Take the white cloud exhibit.
http://911studies.com/911photostudies119.htm

In this link we see two different events. The first CNN photo shows the white cloud of smoke that appeared at 9:04 after the missile struck WTC7. The second photo taken about an hour later shows the collapse of WTC2.

The debunkers will say it is the same event. In this case they are the ones having a problem with logic and reason. (hint: the wind is blowing in opposite directions)

Jack White is wrong in his analysis suggesting the white cloud is from an explosion in WTC 6.
 
" thoroughly debunked" I don’t think so.

Take the white cloud exhibit.
http://911studies.com/911photostudies119.htm

In this link we see two different events. The first CNN photo shows the white cloud of smoke that appeared at 9:04 after the missile struck WTC7. The second photo taken about an hour later shows the collapse of WTC2.

The debunkers will say it is the same event. In this case they are the ones having a problem with logic and reason. (hint: the wind is blowing in opposite directions)

Can you produce any eye withness reprts of a cloud the zize of a 47 story building appearing at WTC7 an hour before the collapse of WTC7?

Because methinks some of the thousands of people in the vicinity ought to have noticed it.

As for the wind, plenty of footage and pictures show that the dust clouds from the collapses were able to spread against the wind for several blocks (hint: they were driven by the air expelled from the buildings and the down-draft from the collapse).

Hans
 
Take the white cloud exhibit.
http://911studies.com/911photostudies119.htm

In this link we see two different events. The first CNN photo shows the white cloud of smoke that appeared at 9:04 after the missile struck WTC7. The second photo taken about an hour later shows the collapse of WTC2.

Those alleged times in a big blue font beneath the pics - the ones uncorroborated by any similar timestamps on the actual screen captures - you're not expecting us to accept them as accurate purely on the authority of the web page author, are you?
 
Can you produce any eye withness reprts of a cloud the zize of a 47 story building appearing at WTC7 an hour before the collapse of WTC7?

Because methinks some of the thousands of people in the vicinity ought to have noticed it.

As for the wind, plenty of footage and pictures show that the dust clouds from the collapses were able to spread against the wind for several blocks (hint: they were driven by the air expelled from the buildings and the down-draft from the collapse).

Hans

If you have a copy of the Naudets 9/11 documentary you will see the white cloud.

In the film, on the corner of Church and Vesey a cameraman (not Gedeon Naudet) is filming WTC 1 on fire. He catches the second plane crashing into WTC 2 then there is an abrupt cut in the film (when the missile hit WTC 7). The unknown cameraman runs in a panic north on Church and later cowards against a tall building. He aims his camera south and you see the large white cloud from the missile explosion pass west to east along Vesey across Church.

Also in the 9/11 documentary Jules Naudet is in the lobby of WTC 1 with the firemen. The second plane hits WTC 2 and Jules aims his camera to the east side of WTC 1 catching the debris falling from WTC 2. A few seconds later we see the white cloud from the explosion at WTC 7 drift toward WTC 2.

The Missiles at Ground Zero
http://www.nationalvanguard.org/printer.php?id=10058
 
Those alleged times in a big blue font beneath the pics - the ones uncorroborated by any similar timestamps on the actual screen captures - you're not expecting us to accept them as accurate purely on the authority of the web page author, are you?

It was confirmed by CNN; the white cloud appeared at 9:04.

http://www.thepowerhour.com/911_analysis/wtc6-explosion.htm

CNN’s Public Affairs Department confirmed that the explosion shown in the footage occurred immediately after the second plane had crashed into the South Tower. When asked if the footage was taken at 9:04 a.m., the CNN archivist said “that’s correct.”

When asked if CNN could offer any explanation about what might have caused the blast that soared higher than the 47-story WTC 7 in the foreground, the archivist said: “We can’t figure it out.”
 
maGZ said:
" thoroughly debunked" I don’t think so.

Take the white cloud exhibit.
http://911studies.com/911photostudies119.htm

In this link we see two different events. The first CNN photo shows the white cloud of smoke that appeared at 9:04 after the missile struck WTC7. The second photo taken about an hour later shows the collapse of WTC2.

The debunkers will say it is the same event. In this case they are the ones having a problem with logic and reason. (hint: the wind is blowing in opposite directions)

Jack White is wrong in his analysis suggesting the white cloud is from an explosion in WTC 6.
The title of this thread is "The vulnerability of the Truth Movement." You, MaGZ, are the poster child for that concept.

Keep up the good work! You couldn't possibly make our job any easier.

p.s. You still obviously haven't watched the video I asked you to see. What seems to be the problem, M?
 
The title of this thread is "The vulnerability of the Truth Movement." You, MaGZ, are the poster child for that concept.
As a long-term student of conspiracy theory (well before 9/11), and operator of a large conspiracy-focused board... I vigorously agree with that statement.


Keep up the good work! You couldn't possibly make our job any easier.
Please stop or acquire critical thinking skills. You (and similar) couldn't possible make the jobs of those trying to find the actual conspiracies any harder.


We've seen these poorly constructed photo-montages for more than four years. That first screen-capture is clearly right after the collapse of the south tower. There's plenty of online video to confirm this.
 
For the FOURTH time, here's the video, Ma Grand Zed.

http://wtcbpc.blogspot.com/

Show us all the "white cloud" that towers above WTC 7 at 9:04. Show us all the missile strikes. Show us all the missile damage to the parking lot at West & Vesey.

Well, what are you afraid of? Show us.
 
Back to the Nazis, of course....


Which is the site of the NATIONAL ALLIANCE, which used to be the nation's leading neo-Nazi party, until its leadership started feuding amongst themselves and started splitting up. Now its boss, Kevin Strom, is going inside for downloading child pornography and witness tampering.

So this is information from a NAZI WEB SITE, which has a considerable penknife to grind.

Which tells me more about the veracity of your claims than anything else.

So what I really want to know, MaGZ, is not your silly theories about who did 9/11, I want to know what you think of Hitler, and what your "Final Solution to the Jewish Question" is. I want to know if you think the Holocaust happened, and if it did, the Jews got what they deserved. I want to know if you've actually read "Mein Kampf" cover to cover, and how you got into neo-Nazism.

But because you're an anonymous coward, you can't and won't answer.

So I'll keep asking, mostly so that everyone who reads your drivel knows that it comes straight from Dr. Goebbels' mouth.
 
" thoroughly debunked" I don’t think so.

Take the white cloud exhibit.
http://911studies.com/911photostudies119.htm

In this link we see two different events. The first CNN photo shows the white cloud of smoke that appeared at 9:04 after the missile struck WTC7. The second photo taken about an hour later shows the collapse of WTC2.

The debunkers will say it is the same event. In this case they are the ones having a problem with logic and reason. (hint: the wind is blowing in opposite directions)

Jack White is wrong in his analysis suggesting the white cloud is from an explosion in WTC 6.

In the time it's taken me to get to your response, many people have already answered it.

So, do you still consider this a "fact"? Do you still believe that the skeptic/scientific movement abandons logic- or is it you that is actually allowing bias to interfere with your investigation?
 
In the time it's taken me to get to your response, many people have already answered it.

So, do you still consider this a "fact"? Do you still believe that the skeptic/scientific movement abandons logic- or is it you that is actually allowing bias to interfere with your investigation?

These are clearly two different events.
 
For the FOURTH time, here's the video, Ma Grand Zed.

http://wtcbpc.blogspot.com/

Show us all the "white cloud" that towers above WTC 7 at 9:04. Show us all the missile strikes. Show us all the missile damage to the parking lot at West & Vesey.

Well, what are you afraid of? Show us.

Missile damage in the parking lot at West & Vesey.
http://s18.photobucket.com/albums/b108/janedoe444/ARG/Image8.jpg

The "smoking crater" where the missile hit.
http://img431.imageshack.us/my.php?image=dsc00105gh0.jpg
 
These are clearly two different events.

I am not the first to think you are a perfect example of why the truth movement is and never was built on facts.

You are the prime evidence for this Thread. You are now just an exhibit for this thread - proving this thread.
 
Last edited:
These are clearly two different events.

Ok... let's try it another way:

Do you consider the possibility that you could be wrong? I mean, it's possible, right?

If your answer is yes, you do consider it a possibility that you're wrong- then what would indicate that you're wrong? The facts that have been presented to you already show that your version of the events is not true.

So your refusal to accept that means you're answering "no" to the question above. You refuse to accept the possibility that you're wrong. In other words, you're unscientific in your research.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom