The US was NOT strongly isolationist before Pearl Harbor.

What an understatement.

The Jews in Hollywood were producing anti-Nazi films day and night to get the country into a war with Germany.

The Nye Committee tried to prove that. Nye got frustrated and adjourned the hearings in Sept. 1941. They were due to be reconvened in Jan. Didn't happen.

Racists' charges almost always fail when closely examined. This is one such case.
 
The South was mostly of British descent while people up North were more Irish and German, which answers the question, “Shall we help Great Britain?” Also I would think the limited number of newspapers read in the South would contribute the disparity compared to people living in larger urban areas of the North. Chicago and New York had their isolationist papers. Southerners only got the war propaganda from Hollywood films and radio which a lot were Roosevelt’s "fireside chats".
Roosevelt only broadcast five of his "fireside chats" between the outbreak of hostilities in Europe, and the attack on Pearl Harbor, a period of over two years. So he wasn't exactly in everyone's ears as much as you seem to think.

On the European War - Sunday, September 3, 1939
On National Defense - Sunday, May 26, 1940
On National Security - Sunday, December 29, 1940
Announcing Unlimited National Emergency - Tuesday, May 27, 1941 (the longest fireside chat)
On Maintaining Freedom of the Seas - Thursday, September 11, 1941

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fireside_chats#Chronological_list_of_Presidential_fireside_chats
 
On the Military Channel today there was a program on British Intelligence operating in the US in 1940. The program tells how British Intelligence infiltrated and rigged the outcome of public polling on the war.
So much for confidence in the Gallup Poll.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lend_Lease

Of course the USA wasn't neutral during WW2. We supplied weapons and other support for the Allies since 1940. We gave the British 50 destroyers at the end of 1940.

The only folks who were against these actions to protect and preserve Democracy, were isolationist Republicans.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lend_Lease

Of course the USA wasn't neutral during WW2. We supplied weapons and other support for the Allies since 1940. We gave the British 50 destroyers at the end of 1940.

The only folks who were against these actions to protect and preserve Democracy, were isolationist Republicans.

Actually, the isolationists and non-interventionists were quite a mixed bag. They ranged from fat cat industrialists who didn't want war interrupting their business (at last in the US, they didn't mind a little of the Cash-and-Carry business) to devout Quakers who didn't want anybody fighting anybody. The whole movement was troubled by the diversity of aims of the various factions within America First. Getting a statement out at all required negotiation and compromise, and that always frustrated one or parties.
 
You are wasting your time using the Gallup polls trying to prove America wasn’t isolationist in 1940-1941.

The polls that showed American support for violations of neutrality were rigged by British agents. "British intelligence had `penetrated' the Gallup organization.... British intelligence officer David Ogilvy later wrote about his days at Gallup: `I could not have had a better boss than Dr. Gallup. His confidence in me was such that I do not recall his ever reading any of the reports I wrote in his name'" (p. 75). By careful manipulation of the questions asked, results could be contrived to order. "In 1940 and 1941, BSC [British Security Coordination] rigged a series of polls...to project the notion that the members of prominent organizations were pro-British, avidly in favor of intervention, and intensely antagonistic toward America First"

http://mises.org/misesreview_detail.aspx?control=122
 
The USA was correct to defend freedom and democracy before our military involvement in WW2. We simply could not allow Hitler to rule Europe.

I only wish we had assisted assassination attempts against Hitler, as many folks in Germany saw how dangerous he was for Germany and the world.
 
Barnes Refutes Lindbergh

I have several thousand links, how long do you want to keep this up?

This doesn’t address the question at hand concerning British Intelligence rigging the polls. Your argument is all based upon fake Gallup polls.
If you have several thousand links, how about using just one to address the issue of British Intelligence rigging the polls?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom