The US was NOT strongly isolationist before Pearl Harbor.

I think you mean "interventionist" there?


Are you referring to my definition, or are you contradicting what I said about conspiracists?

I said what I meant to say, but possibly it didn't come out clearly.

Are you saying that conspiracists would claim that most interventionists had already been tricked or stampeded into supporting America's entering the war even before Pearl Harbor? If so, you may have a point.

I was trying to say that conspiracists would claim that a majority of Americans would never have supported America's entering the war in the absence of a direct attack, no matter how much of a threat the Axis appeared to pose to America.
 
I was trying to say that conspiracists would claim that a majority of Americans would never have supported America's entering the war in the absence of a direct attack, no matter how much of a threat the Axis appeared to pose to America.

I think I agree with that. The America First Committee members and fans certainly tried to promote that idea after the war. It takes some work for them to appear "right all along", so they simply ignore anything that makes that seem at all unlikely.
 
Interviewing Date 8/21-26/41

Survey #245-K Question #13

Should the United States take steps now to keep Japan from becoming more powerful, even if it means risking a war with Japan?

Yes................................ 70%

No................................ 18

No opinion......................... 12
 
Well, I think the oil embargo was proof that the United States was not so isolationist as some may claim.

It cannot have escaped the US government's attention that such an embargo might lead to an armed conflict with Japan.
 
Interviewing Date 8/21-26/41

Survey #245-K Question #13

Should the United States take steps now to keep Japan from becoming more powerful, even if it means risking a war with Japan?

Yes................................ 70%

No................................ 18

No opinion......................... 12

Does the research you quote from mention how many respondents they polled or how the respondents were chosen?
 
Well, I think the oil embargo was proof that the United States was not so isolationist as some may claim.

It cannot have escaped the US government's attention that such an embargo might lead to an armed conflict with Japan.

I would say 70/30 or so there. The non-interventionists wanted to stop helping either side, so we wouldn't get dragged into a fight, and considered anything the Japanese got was "war material". The majority of people saw the Chinese as the underdogs, especially as the Dragon Lady, T.V. Soong and Wellington Kon were working tirelessly to shore up that image.

And yes, the US knew the Japanese didn't like not getting the means to expedite the subjugation of China. However, the "moral quarantine" idea was strong with nearly everybody. The risk was acceptable to most because they didn't really see Japan as being crazy enough to attack the US.
 
Interviewing Date 8/21-26/41

Survey #245-K Question #11b

If Lindbergh, Wheeler, Nye, and others start a "Keep-Out-of-War" party and enter candidates in the next congressional elections, would you vote for the candidate of this party?

Yes................................ 16%

No................................ 84
 
In the regional figures, the South seems to be more gung-ho throughout. Is there any particular reason the South would be more pro-British or anti-German, or do they just love a scrap? :)
 
From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selective_Training_and_Service_Act_of_1940

"The draft began in October 1940. By the early summer of 1941, President Franklin Roosevelt asked the U.S. Congress to extend the term of duty for the draftees beyond twelve months. On August 12, the United States House of Representatives approved the extension by a single vote. As Karl R. Bendetson said, "Mr. Rayburn banged the gavel at a critical moment and declared the Bill had passed." The Senate approved it by a wider margin, and Roosevelt signed the bill into law on August 18.

Many of the soldiers drafted in October 1940 threatened to desert once the original twelve months of their service was up. Many of these men painted the letters "O," "H," "I," and "O" (OHIO) on the walls of their barracks in protest. These letters were an acronym for "Over the hill in October," which meant that the men intended to desert upon the end of their twelve months of duty. Desertions did occur, but they were not widespread. Following the Japanese Attack on Pearl Harbor, Hawaii, on 7 December 1941, thousands of American men and women swelled the United States' military's ranks by volunteering for service, and thousands more by conscription."
 
(In case you're wondering, I'm posting these elsewhere, and wanted to get them into this thread so they'll be handy later on.)

EUROPEAN WAR

Interviewing Date 9/19-24/41

Survey #248-K Question #4a

Which of these two things do you think is the more important — that this country keep out of war or that Germany be defeated?

Keep out of war..................... 30%

Germany be defeated................. 70

++++++

Interviewing Date 10/9-14/41

Survey #250-K Question #4

Should the Neutrality Act be changed to permit American ships to be armed?

Yes................................ 72%

No................................ 21

No opinion......................... 7

(As the arms would not be used on the English, this is an very indicative poll.)
 
And a bit of a jump here.

Interviewing Date 10/24-29/41

Survey #251-K Question #4

Should the Neutrality Act be changed to permit American merchant ships to be armed?

Yes................................ 81%

No................................ 14

No opinion......................... 5
 
Well, they'd been reading about them since at least 1923, if they got the NYT. And with a war on, they were probably somewhat aware of them at the time of the poll.

What an understatement.

The Jews in Hollywood were producing anti-Nazi films day and night to get the country into a war with Germany.
 
In the regional figures, the South seems to be more gung-ho throughout. Is there any particular reason the South would be more pro-British or anti-German, or do they just love a scrap? :)

The South was mostly of British descent while people up North were more Irish and German, which answers the question, “Shall we help Great Britain?” Also I would think the limited number of newspapers read in the South would contribute the disparity compared to people living in larger urban areas of the North. Chicago and New York had their isolationist papers. Southerners only got the war propaganda from Hollywood films and radio which a lot were Roosevelt’s "fireside chats".
 
Last edited:
The comic book industry was run by Jews.


Even if that were true, that only accounts for the production of the comic. It doesn't account for the issue's popularity.


The Jews in Hollywood were producing anti-Nazi films day and night to get the country into a war with Germany.


One might get the impression that the German occupation of Austria, Czechoslovakia, Poland, Denmark, Norway, France, Belgium, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Romania, Hungary, Greece and Yugoslavia played almost no part in anyone's thinking.
 
Even if that were true, that only accounts for the production of the comic. It doesn't account for the issue's popularity.


It was popular because of Jewish mind control obviously! ;)


One might get the impression that the German occupation of Austria, Czechoslovakia, Poland, Denmark, Norway, France, Belgium, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Romania, Hungary, Greece and Yugoslavia played almost no part in anyone's thinking.

They welcomed the Third Reich until the Jewish mind control made those ungrateful countries hate their subjugation. ;)
 
R. Douglas Stuart, Jr. was skeptical of the validity of the Gallup poll findings on foreign policy questions. He was convinced the questions were "loaded" to give results favorable to the interventionist point of view. The America First Committee, therefore, provided the funds to enable a committee under Robert M. Hutchins, president of the University of Chicago, to conduct an independent public opinion poll. The results of this survey indicated that the public overwhelmingly believed Congress should be the source of any action likely to involve the United States in war. It also indicated that two-thirds of those with opinions opposed use of American armed forces in bases in Africa, the Azores, or the Cape Verde Islands. Nearly 80 per cent opposed American entry into the war as a full belligerent. But approximately two-thirds opposed any offer by the United States to mediate between England and Germany. A clear majority would have been willing to go to war if the Western Hemisphere were attacked.

America First: The Battle against Intervention 1940-1941 page 61
http://archive.org/stream/americafirsttheb000771mbp#page/n7/mode/2up
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom