The US was NOT strongly isolationist before Pearl Harbor.

Please explain, you wrote an entire thesis on American isolationism using Gallop polling for your argument and you never came across British Intelligence fakery of the polls?
 
For starters.

FEBRUARY 22 EUROPEAN WAR
Interviewing Date 2/4-9/39
Survey #147-A Question #3a
If Germany and Italy go to war against England and France, do you think we should do everything possible to help England and France win, except go to war ourselves?
Yes................................ 69%
No................................31
Six per cent expressed no opinion.


Er... did you miss the bolded bit?
 
I'm not sure if I understand this correctly. So feel free to enlighten me on the purpose of the OP.

It is an opinion poll to see if the American populace were/were not 'isolationist' (though the Government/military may not have been)? I do get the feeling that Americans are generalised into being portrayed as ignorant of world affairs (to a sense this is...true). These persons who were 'interviewed' or took part in the poll fully informed?

I think that most civilians (US/not) will prefer to not be involved in a needless war. Unless informed that it will help a group who are suppressed or some appeal to human emotions.. while at a Political level the reasons for wanting to get involved in a war may be different.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure if I understand this correctly. So feel free to enlighten me on the purpose of the OP.

It is an opinion poll to see if the American populace were/were not 'isolationist' (though the Government/military may not have been)? I do get the feeling that Americans are generalised into being portrayed as ignorant of world affairs (to a sense this is...true). These persons who were 'interviewed' or took part in the poll fully informed?

I think that most civilians (US/not) will prefer to not be involved in a needless war. Unless informed that it will help a group who are suppressed or some appeal to human emotions.. while at a Political level the reasons for wanting to get involved in a war may be different.

OP was the sample and I've urged folks to read ALL the related polls, that was the reason I pulled them out of the PDF.

However, if you want a good capsule overview of the polls, please refer to Public Opinion Quaterly, 4th Quarter, 1941. They do a good job of summing up the country's mood.
 
OCTOBER 18
If it appears that Germany is defeating England and France, should the United States declare war on Germany and send our army and navy to Europe to fight?
Yes................................ 29%
No................................ 71

What should be the policy of the United States in the present European war — Should we declare war on Germany and
send our army and navy abroad to fight or should we not send our armed forces over' seas?
Should fight......................... 5%
Should not fight..................... 95

Do you think the United States should do everything possible to help England and France win the war, except go to war ourselves?
Yes................................ 62%
No................................ 38
Are these supposed to back your original claim? ???
 
For starters.

FEBRUARY 22 EUROPEAN WAR
Interviewing Date 2/4-9/39
Survey #147-A Question #3a
If Germany and Italy go to war against England and France, do you think we should do everything possible to help England and France win, except go to war ourselves?
Are these the exact terms in which the question was put?
 
The 'don't want to get involved in the war if at all possible' is not isolationism, it's good sense.
.
At home*, I have a copy of Fortune Magazine from March 1941, which has graphs showing the existing and planned expansions in the arms industries up through 1945.





*
(at the Mall right now, beating myself up with an Android tablet)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom