The US was NOT strongly isolationist before Pearl Harbor.

DECEMBER 17
EUROPEAN WAR

Interviewing Date 11/15-20/41
Survey #253-K Question #13

Which of these two things do you think is the more important — that this country keep out of war, or that Germany be defeated?
Keep out of war..................... 32%
Defeat Germany..................... 68
 
For those of you who have reviewed this first block of material, you can see that the construct of a "strongly isolationist" USA doesn't survive exposure to the source data.

I do suppose we'll get a few posters who will simultaneously claim the whole process is hopelessly flawed and also give examples of polls that support their own viewpoint. ;)
 
I would say you have demonstrated a transition in the level of isolationism.

Certainly, but it's clear to me, at least, that it was not from "strong isolationism". There were isolationist elements in the US from Day One to Dec. 7th, but no where near as strong as the mythology would have us believe.

Do remember that this is just the first round of material. I will present more as time presents. And if you wish, reading the material here will help get a gripe on the US attitudes of the times.
 
I think it all hinges upon how 'isolationist' is defined. If it means 'don't want to get involved in the war if at all possible' then the U.S. does seem to be rather isolationist. If instead it means, 'don't want to get involved in the war and don't care what happens to other nations, and will do little to help them' then it was not.
 
I think it all hinges upon how 'isolationist' is defined. If it means 'don't want to get involved in the war if at all possible' then the U.S. does seem to be rather isolationist. If instead it means, 'don't want to get involved in the war and don't care what happens to other nations, and will do little to help them' then it was not.

The 'don't want to get involved in the war if at all possible' is not isolationism, it's good sense.
 
DECEMBER 10
JAPAN

Interviewing Date 11/27-12/1/41
Survey #254-K Question 14

Do you think the United States will go to war against Japan sometime in the near future?
Yes................................ 52%
No................................27
No opinion.........................21

If they'd asked that a week later, I bet the results would be different.
 
Even when the opponent is the obviously unpleasant and expansionist Nazi Germany regime?

If you read the polls for the three years you'll see several instances of people saying, paraphrased, "We will be in this war sooner or later, and it's a necessary thing" AND, in the same poll, people say, again paraphrased, "I hope we don't have to." The myth of strong isolationism comes in part from "historians" cherry-picking the polls and quoting on the second part. I mentioned this to one prof and she said, "I don't know what Gallup you've been reading, but you have it wrong." She didn't even want to see the polls, she KNEW her version was right.
 
OCTOBER 19
NEUTRALITY
Interviewing Date 10/9-14/41
Survey #250-K Question #4
Should the Neutrality Act be changed to permit American ships to be armed?
Yes................................ 72%
No................................ 21
No opinion......................... 1 [7?]

. . .

Interviewing Date 10/9-14/41
Survey 1250-K Question #2
Should the Neutrality Act be changed to permit American merchant ships with American crews to carry war materials to England?
Yes................................ 46%
No................................40
No opinion......................... 14


NOVEMBER 5
NEUTRALITY

Interviewing Date 10/24-29/41
Survey #251 -K Question #4

Should the Neutrality Act be changed to permit American merchant ships to be armed?

Yes................................ 81%
No................................ 14
No opinion......................... 5

Interviewing Date 10/24-29/41
Survey #251-K Question #3

Should the Neutrality Act be changed to permit American merchant ships with American crews to carry war materials to Britain?

Yes................................ 61%
No................................ 31
No opinion......................... 8


I just wanted to point out that the USS KearnyWP was torpedoed on October 17, which would explain why Gallup decided to resurvey these questions, and the significant jump in "yes" responses.
 
If you read the polls for the three years you'll see several instances of people saying, paraphrased, "We will be in this war sooner or later, and it's a necessary thing" AND, in the same poll, people say, again paraphrased, "I hope we don't have to." The myth of strong isolationism comes in part from "historians" cherry-picking the polls and quoting on the second part. I mentioned this to one prof and she said, "I don't know what Gallup you've been reading, but you have it wrong." She didn't even want to see the polls, she KNEW her version was right.


Be that as it may, we are still left with the definitional issue I pointed out earlier. What precise meaning is being ascribed to 'isolationist'?
 
Be that as it may, we are still left with the definitional issue I pointed out earlier. What precise meaning is being ascribed to 'isolationist'?

Ask the folks who make the claim that the US was "strongly isolationist". I've tried to nail it down "precisely" and the fact of the matter is that "isolationists" were all over the map. They varied from "hard-line" Quakers to folks who wanted the Monroe Doctrine fiercely enforced. They didn't get along all that well, either. ;)
 
:th:

Also, for those unfamiliar, "HoosierWP" is a nickname (or demonym, if you want to sound all edumecated), of uncertain etymology, for a resident of Indiana.

[derail]I've never particularly liked the term, but we seem to be stuck with it :( [/rerail]

I am SO glad Purdue didn't get stuck with that for a team name. "Boilermakers" is a bit more aggressive than that, ahem, B. Knighted moniker.
 
Be that as it may, we are still left with the definitional issue I pointed out earlier. What precise meaning is being ascribed to 'isolationist'?


I'd say that a useful definition would be "someone who had to be tricked or stampeded (by FDR) into supporting America's entry into World War II, no matter how threatening the Axis countries appeared." Pearl Harbor conspiracists would have us believe that such people were a strong and growing majority in 1941. :rolleyes:
 
I'd say that a useful definition would be "someone who had to be tricked or stampeded (by FDR) into supporting America's entry into World War II, no matter how threatening the Axis countries appeared." Pearl Harbor conspiracists would have us believe that such people were a strong and growing majority in 1941. :rolleyes:

I think you mean "interventionist" there?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom