The US was NOT strongly isolationist before Pearl Harbor.

While it might not have been a declared war until then, I was under the impression that the US and German navies weren't exactly on speaking terms prior to that declaration. As long as we were supplying his enemies with war material, Hitler couldn't afford to ignore us.

FDR had directed that we operate "short of war", which basically meant we'd make life miserable for the U-boots, and shoot if we have an excuse.
 
FDR had directed that we operate "short of war", which basically meant we'd make life miserable for the U-boots, and shoot if we have an excuse.

Once the trigger had been pulled with the Japanese, I don't see life getting any better for those U-boats even without Hitler declaring war.
 
A strange expression! The Japanese attacked the USA. Then Germany declared war on the USA. Thus the USA entered the war.

Trigger as in open hostilities involving bloodshed. That the Japanese started the conflict is beyond question. My point is that once the US was in the war, it could not (nor would it want to) continue with just harassing the German navy. War is war and the Germans were allies of the Japanese. After Pearl Harbor, neither side could pretend they weren't really at war.
 
Trigger as in open hostilities involving bloodshed. That the Japanese started the conflict is beyond question. My point is that once the US was in the war, it could not (nor would it want to) continue with just harassing the German navy. War is war and the Germans were allies of the Japanese. After Pearl Harbor, neither side could pretend they weren't really at war.

True. Adolf said, "Great nations declare war, they are not declared on."
 
Trigger as in open hostilities involving bloodshed. That the Japanese started the conflict is beyond question. My point is that once the US was in the war, it could not (nor would it want to) continue with just harassing the German navy. War is war and the Germans were allies of the Japanese. After Pearl Harbor, neither side could pretend they weren't really at war.

I read some historians view that it was actually a bit of a surprise that Hitler declared war on the US right after Pearl Harbor, and that Germany and Japan were not really allies, just fighting two essentially separate wars against, in part, the same enemies. The Tripartite Pact itself was only defensive in nature, it did not obligate Germany to declare war. Also relations between Japan and Germany had grown pretty cold after Japan was not given the slightest hint about Barbarossa, and therefore they didn't give Germany any info on their plans for war.
 
I read some historians view that it was actually a bit of a surprise that Hitler declared war on the US right after Pearl Harbor, and that Germany and Japan were not really allies, just fighting two essentially separate wars against, in part, the same enemies.
They really couldn't support each other, so any "alliance" was just for show.
The Tripartite Pact itself was only defensive in nature, it did not obligate Germany to declare war. Also relations between Japan and Germany had grown pretty cold after Japan was not given the slightest hint about Barbarossa, and therefore they didn't give Germany any info on their plans for war.
The Imperial Japanese Navy didn't inform their Foreign Ministry about the planned attack on Pearl Harbor, except for the Minister himself and two assistant ministers. That was probably the closest to an air tight operation I've read about.
 
No.

Oh, btw, you might want to look a the Republican Party's 1940 presidential candidate's position regarding isolationism v. interventionism. That is informative.

I did.

" ...the Republican nomination of Wendell Willkie in 1940 was the product of a dedicated campaign by British intelligence and its American friends to prevent an isolationist challenge to Roosevelt in the election."

http://www.h-net.org/reviews/showrev.php?id=2724
 
.
Here 'tis... the image is 22" x 14"... FORTUNE was a BIG magazine way back when!

This article seems a bit stupid and risky to be published when you think of all the German spies that were operating in the country. This was the type of information they were trying to obtain.
 
Senator Gerald P. Nye chaired a Congressional Committee to investigate if Hollywood was in cahoots with England to get us into the European War or if Hollywood was acting as an unregistered agent for England for purposes of propaganda. The Committee met for six weeks or so in Sept/Oct. 1941. They adjourned with plans to meet again in the next January. That was subsequently canceled for some reason.

And yes, there were several. A Yank in the R.A.F. was probably typical.

I don’t know what alternative universe you have been living in lately, but Senator Nye was closely allied with the isolationists. I suppose you think everyone here will just take you word on these topics.

http://histclo.com/essay/war/ww2/cou/us/iso/ind/ii-nye.html
 
I don’t know what alternative universe you have been living in lately, but Senator Nye was closely allied with the isolationists. I suppose you think everyone here will just take you word on these topics.

http://histclo.com/essay/war/ww2/cou/us/iso/ind/ii-nye.html

Where did I say he wasn't? He was Burton Wheeler's personal sock puppet. That's why the investigation was started, they were paranoid about SOME of the movies that came out with a positive spin for the Allies. I'm surprised I have to explain this to you.
 
Try reading the Gallup Polls. And Lynne Olson's Those Angry Days. Or anything by Wayne Cole. Or don't. You've already made up your mind.

You apparently have made up your mind when you said you will not read Desperate Deception: British Covert Operations in the United States, 1939-44

See post 164
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom