The Official UK Election Thread! 6th May it is!

Me too! I really liked the design of that test. Of course it didn't as if you were a strategic or naive voter :p .

I chose 6 subjects, and I came out 83% Greens, 17% Labour. I could have achieved 100% Green - I spotted their European policy easily and didn't chose it. Most of the policies of either UKIP or BNP were also easy to discern, but for the rest, I wouldn't be able to distinguish the major parties even if you held a gun to my head.

I think Tsukasa has a point: this kind of quiz is not very suited for the strategic voter. And in a district system like the UK has, I'd also vote strategically: has my preferred candidate any chance at all, or should I go for a second choice?

The election quizzes we have in Holland typically present a (long) list of yes/no questions, and in the end present how much you agree with every party; so that format would give you more handles for choosing an alternative.
 
Remember our tax rates compared to most of the other big economies in the EU tend to be less, from corporate tax to income tax to VAT. So perhaps the answer is simply to increase our taxes to say the level of France or Germany, countries that apparently the Tories think have better handled the financial crisis and subsequent recession than the UK.

Should we increase our top rate of income tax to equal that of France (40% above €70k) or Germany (45% above €250k)? In the UK our rate hits 40% earlier than either France or Germany (at around €42k) and goes higher than either at 50%.

What about corporate rates then?

Well this comparison site:

http://www.pearse-trust.ie/services.asp?id=13&cid=undefined&gclid=CNL3-5DG_KACFUNb4wodaghtAg

shows the UK corporation tax rate as being lower than only 4 European countries (Belgium, France, Spain & Malta) although this is slightly misleading as for Germany it does not include the impact of trade tax which makes the effective rate in Germany about the same or possibly slightly above the UK.

VAT we are lower than most EU countries, typically 19-21%. Don't expect this to last long as getting rid of the deficit is going to involve both tax rises and spending cuts. VAT is the one the Treasury want to increase and arguably the easiest politically (although why is not immediately apparent).

It used to be true that the UK had lower tax rates than most other economies, but over the last few years they have been cutting their rates and we have increased ours. Sorry, adjusting rates to EU levels is not going to solve the problem.
 
Should we increase our top rate of income tax to equal that of France (40% above €70k) or Germany (45% above €250k)? In the UK our rate hits 40% earlier than either France or Germany (at around €42k) and goes higher than either at 50%.

What about corporate rates then?

Well this comparison site:

http://www.pearse-trust.ie/services.asp?id=13&cid=undefined&gclid=CNL3-5DG_KACFUNb4wodaghtAg


...snip...

According to the Wikipedia (I know!) site (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_rates_of_Europe_) Germany's corporation tax is over double what your site says - can anyone confirm either lot of figures?

How much would raising VAT to 20% across the board (with the usual exempts) raise?
 
Using 2007 data there was a bit of room before Britain's total government revenue take from the economy (41.8%) got as high as Germany's (43.8%). That gap will be smaller now, or closed. Italy (46.4) takes a bit more than Germany, and France more than Italy (49.6%). Most rich countries outside Europe are some way lower. Link (may need subscription) (Numbers include tax and social welfare contributions)

There is no way on god's green earth that you can raise the tax take by 2% of GDP just by soaking the rich, never mind the more like 5% additional burden that the UK would need in order to continue with present spending (post recession).

And since you have to get the electorate to agree . . . it is not going to happen IMO. So, very large spending cuts are a racing certainty. As I said, the only relative luxury the UK has is that external forces are not requiring it all to be done in a year or two.
 
Last edited:
How much would raising VAT to 20% across the board (with the usual exempts) raise?
I think the most it can possibly raise (assuming no change to spending at all by anyone) is about 1% of GDP per year. The deficit is 11.8% now. But assuming it slows the economy and automatic stabilisers increase then it would be lower than that.
 
According to the Wikipedia (I know!) site (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_rates_of_Europe_) Germany's corporation tax is over double what your site says - can anyone confirm either lot of figures?

How much would raising VAT to 20% across the board (with the usual exempts) raise?

Which is why I noted specifically that its figure for Germany was misleading and explained why. Unfortunately that was in the bit you snipped...

The difficulty arises because while the national German rate is 15% (plus 5.5% of this as a solidarity surcharge) there is also a local trade tax to pay, the rate of which varies by locality. Taking an average trade tax rate (I think one is a deductible expense from the other, although that may have changed) you get a rate that is generally a bit below 30%. In other words, about the same or slightly above the UK rate, which is what I posted. And you cut from the quote.

Putting VAT up by 2.5% would raise around £13bn pa. Or around 7% of the current deficit level of c£170bn pa.
 
Last edited:
Which is why I noted specifically that its figure for Germany was misleading and explained why. Unfortunately that was in the bit you snipped...
...snip...

But did read - I didn't realise what you were referring to as "trade tax" was what the wikipedia article called "local corporate tax".
 
http://voteforpolicies.org.uk/

Click on the green banner at the top right hand corner. They basically give you excerpts of the different policies in selected areas without telling you which party they belong to. You click on the one you agree with most.

I was 50% Labour and 50% Green on that quiz. Interestingly I chose Labour's environmental policy over the Greens.

My constituency is currently Labour but could go Tory this time round so I will be voting Labour as an anti-Tory vote. I voted Green at the last general election and Labour at the more recent by-election. The Lib-Dems are way behind.

I probably wouldn't vote Green if there was any danger of them coming to power as I don't agree with their european policy but they are who I tend to favour in a protest vote.
 
I didn't do the quiz, because I didn't see the point. I intend to vote SNP, and SNP policies weren't included in the selection.

I went to a coffee morning in Peebles this morning, followed by a council of war with the candidate and her agent. Got handed a big bag of leaflets with the instruction that this was for my village and the surrounding area, get on with it. We're not a target seat, and it's a huge constituency - the actual election rooms and organisation and so on are an hour and a half's drive away. So if I (and the local councillor) want any help, we're going to have to recruit it ourselves.

I'm busy making a list of the streets in the village, and planning to get the low-hanging fruit first. The big detached houses, especially those on the two very steep roads, and the outlying properties and farmhouses, might not get done unless we get a few more hands on deck. I wonder if anyone will get to the surrounding hamlets?

It's tempting to jack it in and hightail off to a neighbouring constituency we're actually targeting and which will be organised like a military campaign, but no, we need to cover the country, and I'll do my little bit of it.

Rolfe.

ETA: Well, I've made my little list, about 36 streets in total, handily grouped into manageable rounds with the low-hanging fruit at the top. (This would be easier if I didn't have a stinking cold.) It occurs to me that this could be fun for the extremely nosy part of me - it's the perfect excuse to march up to these big houses in their large plots, and see just what's behind the bushes and the hedges. Let's hope it stays fine.
 
Last edited:
It's a problem if the people that you need to keep lending you money see it as a problem. Because either they require you to pay a higher price, or they stop lending to you.

Ok. Both you and Francesca seem to agree that the problem with the deficit is that the lenders will not tolerate it. And that is my views also. There does not seem to be any comelling reason for that; at least not if the thing is in any way comparable with what ordinary people have been encouraged and keen to do. But it is a political fact. And indeed I do not like debt of any kind: so that has been one of the reasons I would not touch labour with a barge pole (only one, mind). So that is fine with me.

Double counting is the problem. National income is made up of the income of all the people and businesses in the country. They need to use that income to pay their own debts, so if they have debts of three times their income, they are already using their cash to pay those debts. If the government also owes large amounts they need to raise taxes on those same incomes to pay their debts. The same income has to pay both debts, so it isn't a matter of comparing the size of each.

The reasons given for not increasing tax sufficiently to deal with this problem seem to be two: the people will not tolerate it; and they cannot afford it. I accept that the people do not like tax rises. I do not think that is very surprising because they have been told tax is a bad thing so long and so loud without any countervailing voice. But that does not make it true, and I do not think it is.

The same income does have to pay both debts: I understand that. But I do not believe there is insufficient inome in most households to do that. In fact a raise in the basic rate of tax (even by quite a lot) would not be crippling to people on the average wage.

This year if you earned £37000 a year you would pay £6105 in income tax. (20% of 37,000- 6475 personal allowance). If the rate had been higher by two percent you would pay £6716: an increase of £611 a year. You would take home £517 per week as compared with £528 now.

We are told that there is no public service which cannot find efficiency savings of this order: maybe. By the same token I can say there is no household which cannot find efficiency savings of this order. (both are not true for some depts/ people, but leave that aside: those who advocate public spending cuts do). The transfer of the money from the private to the public purse will have no effect because it will still be spent (indeed it will all be spent instead of some part of it going to savings).

So far I see no rational case for not doing it this way on the basis of the numbers. But there are other considerations. Public spending cuts will increase the deficit because more people will be claiming benefits. That is agreed by all the sources we have seen so far. Tax increases may do the same: people will not have that money to spend and there will be an effect on jobs, as well.

Public spending cuts will also have costs for households: the person without a job in public service will be your son or daughter, and so they will stay there instead of moving out: and they will not contribute, because they have no job. The gran who cannot find a place in a care home will be your gran, and you will have to look after her with less help: so you will have to give up some hours of work for that. The child care you were relying on won't be subsidised or won't be available, so you won't be able to work full time because of that, either. Your bins won't get emptied, so you will have to drive your rubbish to the dump, and that means buying more petrol. Your roads won't be mended and, while that might ease some of your frustrations, it is likely to be hard on your car. And on and on. I doubt you will get away with less than £611 a year.

Of course the cutters will say that the "savings" will not affect you: it is all "waste" that will be cut and front line staff will still be there. Problem is we have been eliminating it consistently since 1979. Either it cannot be done or it has been done

For me the public have had a party and they did not expect to pay the wine bill: that was fantasy and anyone with any brains knew it was fantasy. Now we are being asked to believe that we can clean the house without doing any work. And that is fantasy too
 
Last edited:
Problem is we have been eliminating it consistently since 1979. Either it cannot be done or it has been done

This is just wrong. Public Sector productivity has been falling since 1997:

http://publicservices.cbi.org.uk/media/press_release/00289/

whereas in the private sector it has been growing.

It is utter nonsense to suggest there is no waste to cut in the public sector, as a look at the jobs section of the Guardian should tell you.

There will be cuts in services, the size of those will depend on how willing/able whoever wins the election are to tackle the waste that does exist.

And that is before anyone starts talking about the unfunded final salary pension crisis that is building up in the public sector.
 
This is just wrong. Public Sector productivity has been falling since 1997:

http://publicservices.cbi.org.uk/media/press_release/00289/
Interesting that the first example in that article is of a "private partner."

Focusing on improving outcomes rather than meeting targets. For example, a private-sector provider running the cleaning contract at a large West Midlands hospital discovered that staff spent as much time getting around the hospital as cleaning. The service was re-designing to give staff their own zones increasing efficiency.​
There are huge amounts of private sector involvement in the civil service. In my experience these all lead to a more expensive and less efficient service.
 
Well there is a whole separate debate to be had about what "productivity" means and how it is measured. But the examples given on that site are not very persuasive at all: it is certainly true there is waste: a lot of it arises from the very "efficiency" drives which were supposed to cut costs: that is what the target culture was all about, really; it was what "privatisation" and "Tendering" were all about as well: and as you can see the article attacks the outcomes of both of those measures.

It is easy to say that there is waste: that is true in every organisation of every stripe. Getting rid of it is not so easy. And some of what is characterised as waste or inefficiency is nothing of the sort: bed occupancy in hospitals is one such example.

The attack on public sector pensions is also a very partial argument which I find unpersuasive. But whatever your views on this my point stands: there is nothing which demonstrates that cutting public service is the only way to deal with the problems we face. That there is no mainstream political party offering an alternative strategy is not evidence that there is no practical alternative: we have heard that before and it was not true then and it is not true now. There is no political alternative any more, however. And in the long run that is bad for democracy and bad for the society we live in. At least that is my perspective.
 
Yep. Still campaigning for a 99p coin and a three-inch high wall around Britain to trip up foriegn invaders.

I believe their current leader is a cat.

That's awesome.:D

ETA: Just checked their website and Alan Hope (their leader since the cat died) is at 1,000,000 to 1 to be prime minister from William Hill. Not sure I'd make that bet...
http://www.omrlp.com/
 
Last edited:
Ok. Both you and Francesca seem to agree that the problem with the deficit is that the lenders will not tolerate it. And that is my views also. There does not seem to be any comelling reason for that; at least not if the thing is in any way comparable with what ordinary people have been encouraged and keen to do.
See my previous reply about this. I find it rather odd that you would describe the collective wisdom of lenders to be uncompelling. It is what it is. Note that as of today, there is no issue whatsover with the UK government financing itself in the credit market, and FWIW it is still rated AAA. The danger is that when there is a problem, markets are rather unforgiving and swift at imposing very punitive consequences for governments (and their people)

Another difference in respect of home loans, is that the borrower pledges collateral to the lender in the form of a secured charge on the property they are buying. If that security wasn't available, you would not see institutions lending 3x salary to people (nor loan sharks BTW). Nobody who owns a gilt has any recourse to anything other than the trust in the UK government to honour its obligations.

But it is a political fact.
Rather, an economic one. The government bond market is highly non-political (and it has brought down previous UK administrations). It is concerned with earning a return on money lent, and in being extremely confident about getting the return of the money lent.

The reasons given for not increasing tax sufficiently to deal with this problem seem to be two: the people will not tolerate it; and they cannot afford it. [ . . . ] But that does not make it true, and I do not think it is.
I don't understand this. The reason why tax may not be increased seems to be that people (the electorate) may not be willing to pay it. And if that is the case, then it does make it true. One would need to have a stongly authoritarian philosophy of society to think differently, no?

Of course they may be willing to pay sharp tax rises (and/or suffer other income losses) when threatened with the consequences of sovereign default and risk of social breakdown (Greece's government, like Ireland's, still commands quite strong public support despite having had to inflict unprecedented hardship on most of the population in attempt to recover from its borrowing malaise). But it is gross failure of government to force the stakes to that level. It doesn't really matter IMO if you call it errors or deliberate deception; I suspect some of both.
 
Well there is a whole separate debate to be had about what "productivity" means and how it is measured.
Productivity means output per hour, or per person, or per unit of some other factor. And output typically has a monetary unit, though it could be some non-monetary outcome. If one is concerned with productivity gains or losses, then it doesn't matter if the output measure is monetary or not as long as it is internally consistent.

I would always tend to regard efficiency savings touted by politicians to mean increases in output per person, or reductions in people per unit output--hence it typically should mean less hiring or staff cuts. That they don't say this outright is spin/dishonesty, and is playing to a largely irrational popular belief that it is a bad thing to cut out wasteful employment.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom