The Official UK Election Thread! 6th May it is!

Yes I read your previous reply if this is the one you mean

You have it correct, but that assuredly is a compelling argument to cut spending in the UK. How may parties do you know getting elected on a ticket of: "We'll spend money we need, tot it all up and send you a tax bill later"?

If we had a party which put forward that platform we would see. I think it is perfectly possible, because the rationale is a great deal more complex than you imply here. It is a persuasive argument: but it has not been made. And that is a failure of a different kind


But raising taxes is not as simple as passing a commons vote.

Of coure it is.

Political decisions like that end up being society's decisions. (And you know this, so I am not sure what you meant)

Yes, they are society's decisions. I am not sure what you mean

True but most people don't owe this, other than when they are relatively young and the "present value" of the future product of their own labour is still very high. It is hard to get a mortgage like that when you're over 50.

So the country is too old? I didn't know that

There isn't a magic number. Some countries have managed OK for more than a decade with public debt ratios above 100%. But the bottom line is that it depends on your (country's) creditworthiness with lenders, not how much it bothers you (as a nation).

Yes.

The fraction of years in which UK governments have run primary surpluses (= a surplus before interest payments on sovereign debt outstanding) is pretty small. Even under the conservative administration these were largely flattered by the proceeds from selling state assets like BT, BA, British Gas, (RailTrack) etc. These are not repeatable, even if one regards them as economically good decisions in the first place (and permit me to guess you do not). The Labour admin had a couple of years of surpluses at the start of the first Blair term, only because their incoming manifesto promised to stick--for three years--to prior Tory spending plans from the 1997, 6 and earlier budgets. (Without this promise, they presumably calculated that they would be less likely to win office). Pretty much as soon as that expired, and ever since, Labour has only borrowed more each year.

Yes that may have been the calculation they made: I think they were wrong but we will never know. I think no matter what the manifesto was they would have won in 1997. But I also think, unlike you, I would guess, that the refusal to raise tax to fund those improvements was based on a shift in the political analysis of a large part of the party. In short they are wedded to low tax as a good thing in itself. That makes them Tories (shorthand). They are also, of course, political cowards. The combintion is lethal

It is prudentTM to run surpluses and repay debt when national income is growing strongly. After 2000, Gordon Brown never did that.

It is common sense to raise tax to fund better public service, if better public service is what you want. It is dishonest to encourage people to increase their personal debt as if that has no consequence, and to mirror that nonsense in the national economy as well. That is not a failure of the labour party alone: all parties are now talking as if the public sector is somehow divorced from the lives of the majority of the electorate: as if the cuts can be made and will not directly affect them.

It is folly to suggest that this argument has nothing to do with the "errors" of the banking and financial institutions and their propagandists: and to continue to listen to their prescriptions as if they had any credibility. As I said: many of the problems in the public sector are a direct result of those prescriptions in the past: yet we are supposed to act as if we arrived up the clyde on a tea biscuit yesterday. The public memory is short, and they rely on that: they may be right. We will never know so long as no alternative is offered
 
Productivity means output per hour, or per person, or per unit of some other factor. And output typically has a monetary unit, though it could be some non-monetary outcome. If one is concerned with productivity gains or losses, then it doesn't matter if the output measure is monetary or not as long as it is internally consistent.

I would always tend to regard efficiency savings touted by politicians to mean increases in output per person, or reductions in people per unit output--hence it typically should mean less hiring or staff cuts. That they don't say this outright is spin/dishonesty, and is playing to a largely irrational popular belief that it is a bad thing to cut out wasteful employment.

So productivity is completely divorced from wages? I did not know that. It is also completely divorced from staffing levels? The output per person (whatever that means for a nurse) goes up if there are fewer nurses, is the way I understand it. So it makes sense to have ony one nurse in a hospital that used to have 100? Course the patients will die: but the experiment will be a success :)

It is more complex than that, and you know this. First you have to decide what you are trying to achieve. Then you have to recognise that there is a level of staffing required to achieve it. Those are not uncontroversial calculations: it was announced today on radio 4 that the NHS has improved in terms of medicicine in the last few years: that is what the loss of "productivity" has done. So it is a question of what you want as a society.
 
So productivity is completely divorced from wages? I did not know that. It is also completely divorced from staffing levels?
Quite the contrary.

The output per person (whatever that means for a nurse) goes up if there are fewer nurses, is the way I understand it.
I don't know what it means for a nurse, but it would probably go up if fewer nurses delivered the same measured output.

it was announced today on radio 4 that the NHS has improved in terms of medicicine in the last few years: that is what the loss of "productivity" has done.
Of course the aggregate health outcome / medical benefit delivered (and I don't know how those are measured) can certainly improve while productivity and efficiency simultaneously fall.
 
It is common sense to raise tax to fund better public service, if better public service is what you want.
And yet, this has not been done. The better service was financed by borrowing. And the public has not been shown what magnitude of tax increase is required to keep it going, which is why many people still think that it can be done by taxing the rich. And because the UK has had almost a decade of public spending splurge without the associated tax hikes, what it would have to pay up now in tax hikes would include a decade of back-pay for services already consumed and paid for with debt that is owed.

It is highly likely that given full knowledge of what it costs, UK society would actually decide "No we don't want public service that expensive". And that is a decision that society should make. And it is asking the wrong question to say "Do you want it?" without saying what it costs.
 
Quite the contrary.

Indeed

I don't know what it means for a nurse, but it would probably go up if fewer nurses delivered the same measured output.

Sure would. But it does not go up if fewer nurses produce less "measured output". And it goes down if more nurses produce more "unmeasured output".
So if you don't know what it means for a nurse you cannot make an informed decision.

And that is the problem. Who decides on the measures? How important are they? We saw this with the tendering process: first it was focussed on "cheapest" and we got a whole new tier of admin people to run the tendering. I presume they were factored into the equation but I do not know that for certain: I do know that the capital expenditure is in a separate budget from the running costs so I don't know how that is factored in.

We see the legacy of that in my local hospital. The food comes from Newcastle. It is inedible, and a lot of people do what they do in Calcutta: they take in food for their relatives. Shame about the people who don't have any relatives, but hey ho. The productivity and efficiency has gone up because they sacked all the in house catering people. And there is a meal for every patient, so the measured output is the same. Course when the consultant said my mum had to be on a special diet she didn't get it 3 days out of five because there was a lack of flexibility in the system: and that might be a "measured outcome". The number of meals that go in the bin is not a "measured outcome" though: and the export of the balance of the cost to relatives is not a "measured outcome" either. One of the hidden costs of "efficiency", I reckon

To be fair, in some areas these problems were recognised: so we moved from "cheapest" to "best value". That meant a whole new set of administrative arrangements: and a new batch of paper/computer work to implement them. Didnt make any obvious difference. "Best value" depends on measuring the outcomes too: and they measure what is easy to measure (like number of meals) and not the things that are hard to measure (like who eats them and how much the cost is stuck on the relatives)

Of course the aggregate health outcome / medical benefit delivered (and I don't know how those are measured) can certainly improve while productivity and efficiency simultaneously fall.

That is the problem: if you can say that sentence then your use of the words "productivity and efficiency" is a term of art rather than what most people mean by it. That ambiguity is rife in this debate
 
And yet, this has not been done. The better service was financed by borrowing. And the public has not been shown what magnitude of tax increase is required to keep it going, which is why many people still think that it can be done by taxing the rich. And because the UK has had almost a decade of public spending splurge without the associated tax hikes, what it would have to pay up now in tax hikes would include a decade of back-pay for services already consumed and paid for with debt that is owed.

It is highly likely that given full knowledge of what it costs, UK society would actually decide "No we don't want public service that expensive". And that is a decision that society should make. And it is asking the wrong question to say "Do you want it?" without saying what it costs.

Give us the true cost of either option and the choice, and we will see.
 
if you can say that sentence then your use of the words "productivity and efficiency" is a term of art rather than what most people mean by it. That ambiguity is rife in this debate
No, my use of the term was to define it for you, since you asked. And it is quite deterministic.
 
Ah I see how that misunderstanding arose: when I said there is a whole debate to be had about it that was not a question: it was a statement of fact. If you are using it in a specialised sense that is absolutely fine: so long as we are clear that it is a term of art in your useage there is no confusion. But you do not get to tell me what the words "actually" mean because the sense in which you use them is not universal and it happens that it serves to obscure as much as it illuminates. Now that we know what you mean we can look at whether it is helpful: as I have shown, I don't think it is, very
 
Last edited:
No in fact I think I must concede the dictionary point anyway: the point is that it carries the implication that it is a good thing and if all the factors are taken into account it probably is. They usually aren't though and that is what I am trying to get it. Hurrah words are no good if you do not look at what they actually refer to
 
And yet, this has not been done. The better service was financed by borrowing. And the public has not been shown what magnitude of tax increase is required to keep it going, which is why many people still think that it can be done by taxing the rich. And because the UK has had almost a decade of public spending splurge without the associated tax hikes, what it would have to pay up now in tax hikes would include a decade of back-pay for services already consumed and paid for with debt that is owed.

It is highly likely that given full knowledge of what it costs, UK society would actually decide "No we don't want public service that expensive". And that is a decision that society should make. And it is asking the wrong question to say "Do you want it?" without saying what it costs.

Earlier you stated that "Using 2007 data there was a bit of room before Britain's total government revenue take from the economy (41.8%) got as high as Germany's (43.8%). That gap will be smaller now, or closed. "

That would seem to indicate that we have had the "associated tax hikes" to the levels of countries like Germany but now you are now saying we haven't.

To me the idea of borrowing money over the last 10 years to try and fill in the hole that had been created by previous government underspending (compared to what the public wanted) and introducing the "associated tax hikes" seems quite a sensible approach otherwise it would have taken much longer to get our government services to anything like the standards that the public wanted. (And we can conclude that all the major parties agree that this is what the public want since they are all "ring fencing" NHS spending, as an example.)
 
Give us the true cost of either option and the choice, and we will see.
To pay for services without increasing public debt, government revenue has to equal government outlays. Right now, with spending at 53.3% according to the OECD (which I am using in preference to HM Treasury), and revenue at 40.1% there is a gap of -13.3% of GDP (IE larger than the deficit as reported in national statistics). As you have already observed, some of this is due to the recession (IE cyclical) and will disappear once the economy recovers. The OECD data makes an estimate of the deficit that is non-cyclical (annex table 28), and it is -9.8% of GDP. So that's what would need to be raised to preserve structural public spending if the economy was running at potential output, and benefit transfers (among other things) were happening at some normal rate, rather than a recession rate (which is higher).

Note that this would freeze the level of outstanding public debt, it would not reduce it. But over time as the economy grew, public debt as a fraction of GDP would fall.

UK GDP measured in pounds was £1.4 trillion in 2009 (table C1), so 9.8% of that is £137 billion. So that is the annual increase in taxation required. This ignores the almost universally accepted (among economists, that is) notion that taxes produce gross income/output losses, called the excess burden of taxation or the deadweight loss. If increasing the nation's tax bill by £137 billion (every year) could be expected to reduce the potential rate of growth in GDP, then it would end up being a larger fraction of national income than 9.8%.

You have Jaggy Bunnet's and my estimates (which are independently very close together) that a 2.5% VAT hike would raise a maximum of 1% of GDP, or £13 billion in today's money. Since the more one raises a tax rate, the less marginal tax revenue it yields, you can get a feel for what the ball park is for your idea.

I suggest that there is no earthly way this magnitude of government revenue can be raised in the UK, short of a debt crisis. I may be wrong.
 
Last edited:
Earlier you stated that "Using 2007 data there was a bit of room before Britain's total government revenue take from the economy (41.8%) got as high as Germany's (43.8%). That gap will be smaller now, or closed. "

That would seem to indicate that we have had the "associated tax hikes" to the levels of countries like Germany but now you are now saying we haven't.
The gap has not changed, that was my bad.
 
Earlier you stated that "Using 2007 data there was a bit of room before Britain's total government revenue take from the economy (41.8%) got as high as Germany's (43.8%). That gap will be smaller now, or closed. "

That would seem to indicate that we have had the "associated tax hikes" to the levels of countries like Germany but now you are now saying we haven't.

Think you are connecting two separate points:

Whether or not the overall tax burden has increased to German levels; and

Whether or not that increase has been sufficient to pay for the increased spending.

It is perfectly possible to have increased the tax take and at the same time have increased spending by more, meaning that the "associated tax hikes" for that spending have not taken place.
 
To me the idea of borrowing money over the last 10 years to try and fill in the hole that had been created by previous government underspending (compared to what the public wanted) and introducing the "associated tax hikes" seems quite a sensible approach otherwise it would have taken much longer to get our government services to anything like the standards that the public wanted. (And we can conclude that all the major parties agree that this is what the public want since they are all "ring fencing" NHS spending, as an example.)
As above, the associated tax hikes have most certainly not been introduced. If you think they have you are even more optimistic than every political party, since none of them show the budget deficit disappearing in the next parliament (or even the next two of them), and you really ought to show this.

The rest of what you are saying amounts to endorsing the approach of "asking" the public to vote for public spending outcomes without telling them what these cost. No, that is deluded, and duplicitous, and bad policy.
 
just out of interest, who are people on this thread planning to vote for?

I reckon I could guess most people's affiliations....:D

I'm voting Green. Yes it's a wasted vote. Yes some of their policies are a bit dumb. But they are the only left wing party we have amongst all the right-wingers (UKIP/BNP) and neo-liberals (lab/con/lib). I couldn't possibly stomach voting labour after their abject economic and social failures. I can't stomach voting for Call Me Dave's New Tories - which will be exactly the same rich boy's network of small state privatisers as always. And lib-dems? What is their purpose? A third party neo-liberal alternative if you don't like neo-liberalism.....So, Greens it is! :)

what about you lot?

Andy, how do you feel about the fact that the Greens don't practice skepticism?

The Green Party believes that experiments on human embryos could have unforeseen outcomes harmful both to individuals and to society. We would work for an immediate international ban on all cloning and genetic manipulation of embryos, whether for research, therapeutic or reproductive purposes. We do think that the use of 'adult' (or 'mature') stem-cells has promise for both research and therapeutic purposes and does not involve the same risks and ethical issues as embryonic stem-calls. The Green Party would work to allow the use across the EU of adult stem-cells, subject to the precautionary principle.

Yes, we believe that complementary and alternative medicine has a role in public health care. The Green Party, for example, is in favour of increased funding for research on methods of integrated conventional and holistic treatments for cancer. We want the gradual inclusion of complementary therapies within NHS provision so that patients have access to all available and appropriate treatments. Complementary therapies can often prevent the situation worsening and thus save resources. We would oppose attempts to regulate complementary medicine, except by licensing and review boards made up of representatives of their respective alternative health care fields.

http://www.layscience.net/node/581
 
That's awesome.:D

ETA: Just checked their website and Alan Hope (their leader since the cat died) is at 1,000,000 to 1 to be prime minister from William Hill. Not sure I'd make that bet...
http://www.omrlp.com/


I liked this one

Due to the increasing number of children afraid of needles, I propose the destruction of the tedious, scary and often painful process of school vaccinations.
Instead, I propose that highly trained nurses should be given free reign on the playground with specially modified tranquillizer rifles which apply vaccinations as well as a tranquillizer. This would have two main benefits: It would be less scary for the children as they will not know what hit them, also it will be more fun for the nurses
 
As above, the associated tax hikes have most certainly not been introduced. If you think they have you are even more optimistic than every political party, since none of them show the budget deficit disappearing in the next parliament (or even the next two of them), and you really ought to show this.

...snip...

Er.. remember it was your mistake in claiming the gap had closed or near enough, that is what would have required the "associated tax hikes". So what we have at the moment is pretty good empirical evidence that we can ignore the "business community" complaints about things like the NI increase, next year and that there is some room to increase taxation overall to help provide additional revenue to pay down the deficit without it causing economic hardship for the country as a whole.


The rest of what you are saying amounts to endorsing the approach of "asking" the public to vote for public spending outcomes without telling them what these cost. No, that is deluded, and duplicitous, and bad policy.


Totally disagree the government was very upfront that it was borrowing heavily to try and overcome the past underfunding. If we hadn't had the financial crisis but still had had a recession I don't think there would have been anything like the focus there is on the deficit.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom