Yes I read your previous reply if this is the one you mean
If we had a party which put forward that platform we would see. I think it is perfectly possible, because the rationale is a great deal more complex than you imply here. It is a persuasive argument: but it has not been made. And that is a failure of a different kind
Of coure it is.
Yes, they are society's decisions. I am not sure what you mean
So the country is too old? I didn't know that
Yes.
Yes that may have been the calculation they made: I think they were wrong but we will never know. I think no matter what the manifesto was they would have won in 1997. But I also think, unlike you, I would guess, that the refusal to raise tax to fund those improvements was based on a shift in the political analysis of a large part of the party. In short they are wedded to low tax as a good thing in itself. That makes them Tories (shorthand). They are also, of course, political cowards. The combintion is lethal
It is common sense to raise tax to fund better public service, if better public service is what you want. It is dishonest to encourage people to increase their personal debt as if that has no consequence, and to mirror that nonsense in the national economy as well. That is not a failure of the labour party alone: all parties are now talking as if the public sector is somehow divorced from the lives of the majority of the electorate: as if the cuts can be made and will not directly affect them.
It is folly to suggest that this argument has nothing to do with the "errors" of the banking and financial institutions and their propagandists: and to continue to listen to their prescriptions as if they had any credibility. As I said: many of the problems in the public sector are a direct result of those prescriptions in the past: yet we are supposed to act as if we arrived up the clyde on a tea biscuit yesterday. The public memory is short, and they rely on that: they may be right. We will never know so long as no alternative is offered
You have it correct, but that assuredly is a compelling argument to cut spending in the UK. How may parties do you know getting elected on a ticket of: "We'll spend money we need, tot it all up and send you a tax bill later"?
If we had a party which put forward that platform we would see. I think it is perfectly possible, because the rationale is a great deal more complex than you imply here. It is a persuasive argument: but it has not been made. And that is a failure of a different kind
But raising taxes is not as simple as passing a commons vote.
Of coure it is.
Political decisions like that end up being society's decisions. (And you know this, so I am not sure what you meant)
Yes, they are society's decisions. I am not sure what you mean
True but most people don't owe this, other than when they are relatively young and the "present value" of the future product of their own labour is still very high. It is hard to get a mortgage like that when you're over 50.
So the country is too old? I didn't know that
There isn't a magic number. Some countries have managed OK for more than a decade with public debt ratios above 100%. But the bottom line is that it depends on your (country's) creditworthiness with lenders, not how much it bothers you (as a nation).
Yes.
The fraction of years in which UK governments have run primary surpluses (= a surplus before interest payments on sovereign debt outstanding) is pretty small. Even under the conservative administration these were largely flattered by the proceeds from selling state assets like BT, BA, British Gas, (RailTrack) etc. These are not repeatable, even if one regards them as economically good decisions in the first place (and permit me to guess you do not). The Labour admin had a couple of years of surpluses at the start of the first Blair term, only because their incoming manifesto promised to stick--for three years--to prior Tory spending plans from the 1997, 6 and earlier budgets. (Without this promise, they presumably calculated that they would be less likely to win office). Pretty much as soon as that expired, and ever since, Labour has only borrowed more each year.
Yes that may have been the calculation they made: I think they were wrong but we will never know. I think no matter what the manifesto was they would have won in 1997. But I also think, unlike you, I would guess, that the refusal to raise tax to fund those improvements was based on a shift in the political analysis of a large part of the party. In short they are wedded to low tax as a good thing in itself. That makes them Tories (shorthand). They are also, of course, political cowards. The combintion is lethal
It is prudentTM to run surpluses and repay debt when national income is growing strongly. After 2000, Gordon Brown never did that.
It is common sense to raise tax to fund better public service, if better public service is what you want. It is dishonest to encourage people to increase their personal debt as if that has no consequence, and to mirror that nonsense in the national economy as well. That is not a failure of the labour party alone: all parties are now talking as if the public sector is somehow divorced from the lives of the majority of the electorate: as if the cuts can be made and will not directly affect them.
It is folly to suggest that this argument has nothing to do with the "errors" of the banking and financial institutions and their propagandists: and to continue to listen to their prescriptions as if they had any credibility. As I said: many of the problems in the public sector are a direct result of those prescriptions in the past: yet we are supposed to act as if we arrived up the clyde on a tea biscuit yesterday. The public memory is short, and they rely on that: they may be right. We will never know so long as no alternative is offered