The Official UK Election Thread! 6th May it is!

Ok. Why does it matter? I am not being facetious, I really don't know.

In the first source you have provided the complaint is that they ran a deficit in boom years: I accept that. I do not understand why that is a problem. The ratio of public spending to total income is a political decision and our ratio is not that high in the scheme of things. The relationship with public inome is different. Either those other countries ran a deficit too: or the income was higher.

If the income was higher that must come from tax, primarily. We can have a higher tax rate or we can have more money to tax (to put it very crudely). But it cannot be the latter if I understand this correctly: because these are ratios. So am I right in thinking it is because those countries accept higher tax?

If so the antipathy to tax may be what makes the difference: perhaps those countries with a higher public spending ratio do not do so on a deficit because tax is higher: and if that is the case there is no compelling argument for a cut in public spending. Yet we are told that is inevitable. I don't see why except as a matter of political decision.

ETA: I also don't understand what we actually owe as a percentage of national income: many people owe 3 times their income just to put a roof over their heads and this is seen as perfectly fine: if we actually owe 60% of our income we have a long way to go before that should be a problem. Certainly it is mounting at present as it would in a recession: but it looks to me as if we can take it a lot further before it should even make us uneasy. And we have been in surplus relatively recently: is there any reason to worry that will never happen again ?
 
Last edited:
So far as I can understand it, public spending is expressed as a percentage of national income. In 2008/9 the UK was 10th out of 28 countries which the OECD has figures for: and 3rd of the G7.
The IFS uses OECD data which is posted here. In 2008, general government outlays were 47.5% of GDP but the number increases to 53.4% in 2010. As you say, the size of this is influenced by the recession. You are right to point out that there are many other countries in Europe where public spending is that high; in the UK typically it has not been, and neither have the tax rates required to pay for it (been).

What matters more is the deficit (revenue minus spending). That is as bad in the UK as it is in Greece, and will--on the projections of all political parties--be larger than Greece for the next several years (data downloadable from same OECD link). Had the UK joined the euro (which was a Blairite dream back before 2005, and still is a Lib Dem objective) then Britain would be facing the level of austerity currently being self-imposed in Ireland and Greece, and required by supranational lenders (read: IMF) in Latvia and Iceland. In any case Britain unavoidably will require massive fiscal retrenchment well beyond what has been signalled to date. Thanks to its independent currency/monetary policy it may have the "relative luxury" of spreading the pain out over a longer period.

(For some colour on what Ireland is doing, I can recommend this post by Stephanie Flanders [BBC]. Ireland is avoiding a sovereign debt crisis thanks to these extremely harsh measures. Greece is teetering on the brink of one. You may know about the fate that has befallen the other two--they have both seen national income fall by more than a quarter in two years.)

Looking at the table, many of the countries which have a higher proportion of public spending are those countries which have well developed public services.
Comments on whether the UK public services are "good" inevitably call forth political preferences. Some people dislike the government providing services regardless of how well they do it. Others think the state should perform a large number of functions to the exclusion of private markets but struggle to see them done without large amounts of waste.

I keep hearing that it is not sustainable, however. I just dont understand why not and this article at least does not tie its conclusion to the data in a way that helps me.
Whatever, fiscal sustainability is ultimately determined by the path of total spending and a government's ability to generate revenue. The latter is exhaustible, and in any case the UK government has not raised revenue in line with spending since 2001 (hence the deficit--and in the case of persistent deficits, a government is at the mercy of international bond markets whether it likes it or not and whether it is right, left or centre).

In fact, running budget deficits immediately before the recession--that is, after 15 years of economic expansion--now looks like a hugely irresponsible act of deception by Gordon Brown. Had taxes risen in line with spending since 2001, it is arguably more likely that the spending plans would have had to be kept in check much earlier than now.

(see this chart out of The Economist)

The other false idea that most politicians put about is the idea that Britain's fiscal policy can be re-railed without cutting spending and by only imposing taxes on the top 2% of the population. I have seen no serious analysis that gives that idea any credence.
 
In the first source you have provided the complaint is that they ran a deficit in boom years: I accept that. I do not understand why that is a problem.

It's a problem if the people that you need to keep lending you money see it as a problem. Because either they require you to pay a higher price, or they stop lending to you.

ETA: I also don't understand what we actually owe as a percentage of national income: many people owe 3 times their income just to put a roof over their heads and this is seen as perfectly fine: if we actually owe 60% of our income we have a long way to go before that should be a problem.

Double counting is the problem. National income is made up of the income of all the people and businesses in the country. They need to use that income to pay their own debts, so if they have debts of three times their income, they are already using their cash to pay those debts. If the government also owes large amounts they need to raise taxes on those same incomes to pay their debts. The same income has to pay both debts, so it isn't a matter of comparing the size of each.
 
Ok. Why does it matter? I am not being facetious, I really don't know.

In the first source you have provided the complaint is that they ran a deficit in boom years: I accept that. I do not understand why that is a problem.

My understanding is that the deficit is the increase in overall debt (the National Debt) in one year. If you're increasing the overall debt in good years, rather than attempting to pay it off, then surely things are going to reach a point when the debt is practically unpayable? At the moment, a significant part of the deficit is simply the interest payments on existing debt.
 
If so the antipathy to tax may be what makes the difference: perhaps those countries with a higher public spending ratio do not do so on a deficit because tax is higher: and if that is the case there is no compelling argument for a cut in public spending.
You have it correct, but that assuredly is a compelling argument to cut spending in the UK. How may parties do you know getting elected on a ticket of: "We'll spend money we need, tot it all up and send you a tax bill later"?

Yet we are told that is inevitable. I don't see why except as a matter of political decision.
But raising taxes is not as simple as passing a commons vote. Political decisions like that end up being society's decisions. (And you know this, so I am not sure what you meant)

many people owe 3 times their income just to put a roof over their heads and this is seen as perfectly fine:
True but most people don't owe this, other than when they are relatively young and the "present value" of the future product of their own labour is still very high. It is hard to get a mortgage like that when you're over 50.

if we actually owe 60% of our income we have a long way to go before that should be a problem. Certainly it is mounting at present as it would in a recession: but it looks to me as if we can take it a lot further before it should even make us uneasy.
There isn't a magic number. Some countries have managed OK for more than a decade with public debt ratios above 100%. But the bottom line is that it depends on your (country's) creditworthiness with lenders, not how much it bothers you (as a nation).

And we have been in surplus relatively recently: is there any reason to worry that will never happen again ?
The fraction of years in which UK governments have run primary surpluses (= a surplus before interest payments on sovereign debt outstanding) is pretty small. Even under the conservative administration these were largely flattered by the proceeds from selling state assets like BT, BA, British Gas, (RailTrack) etc. These are not repeatable, even if one regards them as economically good decisions in the first place (and permit me to guess you do not). The Labour admin had a couple of years of surpluses at the start of the first Blair term, only because their incoming manifesto promised to stick--for three years--to prior Tory spending plans from the 1997, 6 and earlier budgets. (Without this promise, they presumably calculated that they would be less likely to win office). Pretty much as soon as that expired, and ever since, Labour has only borrowed more each year.

It is prudentTM to run surpluses and repay debt when national income is growing strongly. After 2000, Gordon Brown never did that.
 
Last edited:
just out of interest, who are people on this thread planning to vote for?

I reckon I could guess most people's affiliations....:D

I'm voting Green. Yes it's a wasted vote. Yes some of their policies are a bit dumb. But they are the only left wing party we have amongst all the right-wingers (UKIP/BNP) and neo-liberals (lab/con/lib). I couldn't possibly stomach voting labour after their abject economic and social failures. I can't stomach voting for Call Me Dave's New Tories - which will be exactly the same rich boy's network of small state privatisers as always. And lib-dems? What is their purpose? A third party neo-liberal alternative if you don't like neo-liberalism.....So, Greens it is! :)

what about you lot?
 
Last edited:
Seriously I'll have to see what the non-Tory candidates in my area say. I do know I won't be voting for my current MP (who will be re-elected) because 1) I think the Tory party as a whole are still a group of horrible people, 2) public statements he has made in his shadow cabinet position and 3) (and this is the most important one for me) since the last election I've met him and had some correspondence with him and he holds too many views that I simply do not agree with and therefore he cannot represent me in any meaningful manner.
 
Last edited:
Remember our tax rates compared to most of the other big economies in the EU tend to be less, from corporate tax to income tax to VAT. So perhaps the answer is simply to increase our taxes to say the level of France or Germany, countries that apparently the Tories think have better handled the financial crisis and subsequent recession than the UK.
 
Remember our tax rates compared to most of the other big economies in the EU tend to be less, from corporate tax to income tax to VAT. So perhaps the answer is simply to increase our taxes to say the level of France or Germany, countries that apparently the Tories think have better handled the financial crisis and subsequent recession than the UK.

but these are job-killing taxes! Do you want to kill jobs? Do you?! :D

i agree - basically we need to raise taxes across the board, VAT, income tax, NI - regardless of how loud super-rich business men squeal. We need to cut public spending - but not in the disingenous way it's being done now - we can't pretend that everything's going to be efficiancy savings and natural wastage....How about we lop £20 billion off the military budget? Let's be radical about this, if billions have to be saved I'd rather they were saved on bombs and bullets rather than on any other public service.

We should of course have fully nationalised most of the UK banking sector - and taken significant stakes in the ones that we didn't. Instead we've taken all the risk, pumped billions into the financial system and then allowed billions of private sector profit to be accrued as a result. Yes shareholders would have suffered. Yes pension funds may have been hit. Yes global financial markets wouldn't have liked it. But, i think it would have been a better alternative than what we've ended up with - which at the end of the day will be the poorest people in society taking the biggest hit....

Goodness. Maybe I should vote communist :D
 
Yet again, I have no idea - other than that it won't be Tory, BNP or UKIP.

ETA: I came out 100% Green party on that policy quiz thingy earlier in the thread.
 
http://voteforpolicies.org.uk/

Click on the green banner at the top right hand corner. They basically give you excerpts of the different policies in selected areas without telling you which party they belong to. You click on the one you agree with most.

Thanks

My results:

Issue Parties policies you chose
Economy Lib Dems
Education Green Party
Health / NHS Green Party
Welfare Green Party

The only one i actually recognised was the economy one for the greens - which goes on about renewables. And I didn't choose that.

Interesting! Looks like i am a Green :D
 
just out of interest, who are people on this thread planning to vote for?

I reckon I could guess most people's affiliations....:D

I'm voting Green. Yes it's a wasted vote. Yes some of their policies are a bit dumb. But they are the only left wing party we have amongst all the right-wingers (UKIP/BNP) and neo-liberals (lab/con/lib). I couldn't possibly stomach voting labour after their abject economic and social failures. I can't stomach voting for Call Me Dave's New Tories - which will be exactly the same rich boy's network of small state privatisers as always. And lib-dems? What is their purpose? A third party neo-liberal alternative if you don't like neo-liberalism.....So, Greens it is! :)

what about you lot?

I will be voting Lib Dem - in a relatively safe Lib Dem seat which is being heavily targeted by Labour.

I have today received a 'personal' letter from Gordon Brown's office warning me against voting Tory. Umm, I think they got 8% of the vote here last time.
 
My results:



The only one i actually recognised was the economy one for the greens - which goes on about renewables. And I didn't choose that.

Interesting! Looks like i am a Green :D
I think I chose the same four areas, and came out with 3 Labour and 1 Lib-Dem, which was only slightly surprising, as I was brought up to vote Liberal. As I'm in John Redwood's constituency, I'll be wasting my vote and not voting Tory.
 
just out of interest, who are people on this thread planning to vote for?
The constituency I live in has been Labour for as long as I am aware except for a brief period in 1982 when its MP defected to the SDP, but then lost. It has some trivia including (i) first declared gay MP (Chris Smith) and (ii) where the Blairs lived before they moved to SW1, and (iii) where the Granita pact took place (now a TexMex diner :D ). The 2005 result made it a marginal seat for Labour which they almost lost to the Lib Dems.

I think that the (national) outcome I want least at this point* is a Labour overall majority on 6 May and on that basis it is most logical that I vote for Bridget Fox (Lib Dem), whom I've met several times, and who has been deputy leader of Islington Council, and is OK. However, since it's a general election, I don't tend to associate it with local issues, or even the quality of the local candidate too much.

Incidentally the lineup of the three big parties is all women. I have seen Emily Thornberry around a bit. Never seen Antonia Cox. (There is also a Green candidate)

*FTR I voted for Smith (Labour) in '01 and Thornberry (same) in '05; I was away in New Zealand (where I come from) on holiday in May '97 and didn't vote, though it would have been for Labour then too. In '92 I was a mere slip of a thing (well, 17)
 
Last edited:
just out of interest, who are people on this thread planning to vote for?

I'll be voting for labour again, almost pointless voting here anyway - in the last 50 years or so I doubt Labour would have polled less than 65% of the total vote. The absolute safe seat.
 
http://voteforpolicies.org.uk/

Click on the green banner at the top right hand corner. They basically give you excerpts of the different policies in selected areas without telling you which party they belong to. You click on the one you agree with most.

Well, that was helpfull!

votes.jpg
 
Lib Dem.

I wouldn't vote Tory if they paid me.

Alas I'm in one of those seats where they old ladies have blue rinses and spend more on "finest" cat food than I do on my weekly shop, while complaining that they have no money because it's all going to layabouts and foreigners and what a nice young man that Mr Cameron is and his lovely wife...wonderful news isn't? The baby?......so yes your typical Tory safe seat by some massive majority.
 
Yet again, I have no idea - other than that it won't be Tory, BNP or UKIP.

ETA: I came out 100% Green party on that policy quiz thingy earlier in the thread.

Me too! I really liked the design of that test. Of course it didn't as if you were a strategic or naive voter :p .
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom