Ok. Why does it matter? I am not being facetious, I really don't know.
In the first source you have provided the complaint is that they ran a deficit in boom years: I accept that. I do not understand why that is a problem. The ratio of public spending to total income is a political decision and our ratio is not that high in the scheme of things. The relationship with public inome is different. Either those other countries ran a deficit too: or the income was higher.
If the income was higher that must come from tax, primarily. We can have a higher tax rate or we can have more money to tax (to put it very crudely). But it cannot be the latter if I understand this correctly: because these are ratios. So am I right in thinking it is because those countries accept higher tax?
If so the antipathy to tax may be what makes the difference: perhaps those countries with a higher public spending ratio do not do so on a deficit because tax is higher: and if that is the case there is no compelling argument for a cut in public spending. Yet we are told that is inevitable. I don't see why except as a matter of political decision.
ETA: I also don't understand what we actually owe as a percentage of national income: many people owe 3 times their income just to put a roof over their heads and this is seen as perfectly fine: if we actually owe 60% of our income we have a long way to go before that should be a problem. Certainly it is mounting at present as it would in a recession: but it looks to me as if we can take it a lot further before it should even make us uneasy. And we have been in surplus relatively recently: is there any reason to worry that will never happen again ?
In the first source you have provided the complaint is that they ran a deficit in boom years: I accept that. I do not understand why that is a problem. The ratio of public spending to total income is a political decision and our ratio is not that high in the scheme of things. The relationship with public inome is different. Either those other countries ran a deficit too: or the income was higher.
If the income was higher that must come from tax, primarily. We can have a higher tax rate or we can have more money to tax (to put it very crudely). But it cannot be the latter if I understand this correctly: because these are ratios. So am I right in thinking it is because those countries accept higher tax?
If so the antipathy to tax may be what makes the difference: perhaps those countries with a higher public spending ratio do not do so on a deficit because tax is higher: and if that is the case there is no compelling argument for a cut in public spending. Yet we are told that is inevitable. I don't see why except as a matter of political decision.
ETA: I also don't understand what we actually owe as a percentage of national income: many people owe 3 times their income just to put a roof over their heads and this is seen as perfectly fine: if we actually owe 60% of our income we have a long way to go before that should be a problem. Certainly it is mounting at present as it would in a recession: but it looks to me as if we can take it a lot further before it should even make us uneasy. And we have been in surplus relatively recently: is there any reason to worry that will never happen again ?
Last edited: