The Official UK Election Thread! 6th May it is!

.........If we hadn't had the financial crisis but still had had a recession I don't think there would have been anything like the focus there is on the deficit.

Actually had the Conservatives not chosen to be the loud voice of doom just a short while ago, how world financing would turn its back on the UK, how the pound would crash dive to lira-esque levels...how it was so so important to get the deficit sharply under control....(before suddenly changing position entirely and promising gimmicks).

I think we would have just carried on.

The Global aspect of this whole situation is one that is being deliberately ignored by the Conservatives imo.
 
Totally disagree the government was very upfront that it was borrowing heavily to try and overcome the past underfunding. If we hadn't had the financial crisis but still had had a recession I don't think there would have been anything like the focus there is on the deficit.

I agree with this.
 
I'm going to vote for Bridget Fox, just like Francesca R. I can't say I much like the look of her, and Emily Thornberry seems decent enough, but I just can't bring myself to reward Labour with my vote after the last few years. So Lib-Dems it is.
 
Actually, I have just moved from Leicester Square to Islington - this will be the first election where I vote in Islington. I'm still on the electoral roll in Westminster so I presumably could vote there as well if I wanted to, but it's a solid Conservative seat that never changes hands so it would be a bit pointless (though interestingly the Labour candidate there is the drummer from Blur so conceivably he might come and knock on my door, which would be fun).
 
To pay for services without increasing public debt, government revenue has to equal government outlays.

Not quite. Government outlays include regular spending but they also include things like the bank bail out, which was of the order of £850 billion, per "The Independent". It may be that you are positioning that as debt rather than deficit, though. Yet the interest is surely in the income and expenditure account? I presume it is. It is true that once incurred that debt must be paid and that interest must also be paid: so it seems to me that the largest part of this problem derives from that. I do not know the interest rate on that debt and I know that not all of it is direct debt: but at least 110 billion is direct debt; and I think rather more than that.

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/u...fficial-cost-of-the-bank-bailout-1833830.html

Right now, with spending at 53.3% according to the OECD (which I am using in preference to HM Treasury),

Earlier I thought you gave figures from the IFS. The IFS figure I found was for 2008/9: so that may account for the difference: but it is a very big difference to happen in one year and it is well beyond what the IFS paper predicted. I see no reason to accept your figure over that one. But it is probably a matter of choice. There is not much hard data in economics, so far as I can see.

If you use the IFS figures for 2008/9 (presumably "actual", since the paper was written in Sep 2009) spending was 43.2% of national income: and that was £618.6 billion. So the total national income was £1432 billion. If your figure for revenue is correct at 40.1% the gap is much lower than you suggest: but I see no reason to rely on that either. The tax payers alliance (not much in favour of tax I gather) gives figures for government revenue of 416.2 billion for 2008. 67.2% of government spending on these figures: so the deficit would then be of the order of 43.2 -32.8 = 10.4%.

http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q...j3PBJo&sig=AHIEtbQLmsMxTx7iac6MWoVHpW5qOC1osQ

The OECD data makes an estimate of the deficit that is non-cyclical (annex table 28), and it is -9.8% of GDP. So that's what would need to be raised to preserve structural public spending if the economy was running at potential output, and benefit transfers (among other things) were happening at some normal rate, rather than a recession rate (which is higher).

I am not sure about this. How does that fit with the IFS comparison of fiscal policy under labour and the conservatives where it says that

• The structural budget deficit has evolved in a remarkably similar way under
Labour since 1997 to the way in which it evolved over the first 11 years of
Conservative government from 1979.
o Both parties inherited large structural budget deficits from their
predecessors: 4.8% of national income in 1978–79 and 2.9% of national
income in 1996–97.
<snip>
o To summarise, both governments presided over a fiscal strengthening in
their first three years in office followed by a weakening over the
following eight. But we should note that Labour has used more of its
borrowing to finance capital investment rather than current spending
than the Conservatives did. Under the Conservatives, the structural
budget deficit continued to deteriorate until year 14 (1992–93). It
remains to be seen when it will reach its trough under Labour.

Per the IFS structural deficit was 2.7% of national income in 2007 and was projected to rise to 3.6% in 2008 (not outurn figures though: I have not been able to find those). If that is correct then the amount of structural deficit would be 51.52 billion. It will have increased this year, but we do not seem to have figures yet (or I have missed them) .

http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q...roQ1Oz&sig=AHIEtbT7XfOzShXl0Fv1aYdkuvz_IXsbxg

UK GDP measured in pounds was £1.4 trillion in 2009 (table C
[quote1
), so 9.8% of that is £137 billion. So that is the annual increase in taxation required.

Not sure how GDP compares with total national income but it is clear that the figures are the same. No idea why we should prefer one over the other. Maybe they are just different names for the same thing

Seems like you pays your money and you picks your economist :). At least the only difference here seems to be which set of figures you accept: and the numbers are very different.

<snip>

You have Jaggy Bunnet's and my estimates (which are independently very close together) that a 2.5% VAT hike would raise a maximum of 1% of GDP, or £13 billion in today's money. Since the more one raises a tax rate, the less marginal tax revenue it yields, you can get a feel for what the ball park is for your idea.

I do not know what vat has to do with this: perhaps you are directing this at Darat?

I suggest that there is no earthly way this magnitude of government revenue can be raised in the UK, short of a debt crisis. I may be wrong.

I found this interesting

http://www.historyandpolicy.org/papers/policy-paper-95.html
 
Cameron's latest attempt to recover from his gay slips is to erase from the record the crime of gay sex with over 16 year olds for those who were convicted when that was on the books.

My god, what a revolutionary :rolleyes: !
 
WOO HOO!

We actually have a real motherloving scientist standing in Hinckley and Bosworth! He's standing here specifically to unseat the drooling moron David Tredinnick. Oh happy day! The piece of filth only held on by a couple of thousand votes last time. Let's unseat the worthless little pusball and elect someone who is infinately more qualified.

Hell, a kumquat is infinately more qualified than Tredinit.
 
For those interested in some of the numbers behind the current election, the BBC's More or Less podcast may be interesting. (This is actually a compilation of a daily segment on the Today programme.)
 
Something which is puzzling me.

According to the information I found and linked above, there has been a "structural deficit" consistently since at least 1979. It has varied in amount but it seems to be nearly always there. It is argued here that we need to eliminate structural deficit one way or another: at least that is what I take from Francesca's post where she says:

To pay for services without increasing public debt, government revenue has to equal government outlays. Right now, with spending at 53.3% according to the OECD (which I am using in preference to HM Treasury), The OECD data makes an estimate of the deficit that is non-cyclical (annex table 28), and it is -9.8% of GDP. So that's what would need to be raised to preserve structural public spending if the economy was running at potential output, and benefit transfers (among other things) were happening at some normal rate, rather than a recession rate (which is higher).

If we have had a structural deficit every year for 30 years it would seem that this should have been a crisis long ago. If it is true that a balanced budget is required we do not seem to have ever achieved it. So why must we achieve it now?

I do know that there is a school of thought which claims that a balanced budget is a primary goal of policy and that this should be a guiding principle of economic policy. I know that there are those who wish to return to the gold standard as well. But they have not been in the ascendant for many years and I do not see why we should suddenly accept their arguments. What has changed?

It is possible that there is a real change: but it is also possible that a school of thought which has not made its case is using the current circumstances opportunistically. It brings us back to the level of debt and although we have tried to separate income/expenditure from net debt in the last couple of pages I don't think we can do that. It seems to me that what we need to do on deficit spending depends on a prior assumption about what the level of debt should be: and that this is implicit in Francesca's analysis. So we cannot exclude that from the conversation

The part of my question which has not so far been addressed is the comparison. I asked for an analysis of the costs of cutting public spending and of the costs of raising tax. To be honest I did not expect anyone here to give us that: my point was that both of those analyses should be put before the public and we should be able to vote on them. But Francesca appears to have taken it as a question directed to her and she has addressed only the part about raising tax. She has asserted, yet again, that the public will not stand for it.

So what we need now is an analysis of the costs of cutting public spending to match current revenue, as she argues is necessary. (I do not accept her figures because I now think they are based the idea that we must freeze or reduce national debt and I see no reason for that: but leaving that to one side). I accept that she may also believe that some tax rises will form part of the solution and that the whole deficit need not (can not?) be met through public spending cuts. But for simplicity let us compare the two extremes

Public spending in 2008 was £618.6 billion. On Francesca's figures we need to find £137 billion in savings: Jaggy Bunnet's figure is higher. That means we need to cut 22% of public expenditure.

62% of public expenditure goes on health, education, pensions and welfare. Of the remainder I think that about 26% is spent by local government. As I said above, we have made immense efforts to cut out waste and increase efficiency over 30 years: and we have not succeeded at all. I see no reason to imagine we can do it now.

One of the links I gave above shows that more of the structural deficit spending in recent years has gone on capital investement than used to be the case. It is a question of how those things are recorded in accountancy terms and it curious that such spending appears on the revenue account: but leave that aside. What I want to know is what evidence is there that we can in fact meet any significant proportion of this 137 billion sum from cutting waste? 22%? I dont think so.

So how much of those cuts are really going to exported to be met from household incomes? And how does that compare to the amount of extra tax which households would have to pay if the shortfall were met in that way instead

This is the information we need in order to make an informed choice: but I have not been able to find it
 
...snip... But Francesca appears to have taken it as a question directed to her and she has addressed only the part about raising tax. She has asserted, yet again, that the public will not stand for it.

...snip...

And I think we have empirical data that shows that this is simply not the case, this is from the "OECD Factbook 2009: Economic, Environmental and Social Statistics © OECD 2009"



Now that is only for 2007 and I assume we had some tax increases since then that are not included but it can be seen the average tax rate for the average worker in the UK is a bit below the average for the group of countries and a lot less than comparable countries and economies e.g. France and Germany. Whilst people may complain about taxation there is not any indication that France and Germany are about to socially explode because of the level of taxation.

I think there is a strong argument that since the public wants services at least at the level of countries like France and Germany than we have to increase taxation.

Doesn't alter the deficit "issue" but like I said earlier, that's only an issue this time around because of the financial crisis and the way the parties have attempted to use that for political advantage and of course because huge figures presented in a "knowing" way by the media make for the "good" headlines and scary stories that the newspapers in particular like to run.
 
I agree, Darat. Income tax has been portrayed as a monster to fear, very strongly and for a long time. The political class and the media have all bought in to this and it seems that some are truly persuaded of this: and more have a particular political agenda: and the rest do not necessarily believe it but they have become convinced that this is the public perception. Given the propaganda there is some truth in the idea that the public do not like income tax, maybe: I remain sceptical that they will not tolerate it.

It is not so long ago that the base rate was 22%: not even long since it was 25%. I do not recall any great clamour for a cut: more low level grumbling which has hardly abated. People grumble about tax, shock!.

It is argued that the tories won elections on a promise to cut tax and that this is evidence that the public really wanted those cuts and will not stand for any reversal. I do not see anything to support that conventional wisdom. Are there any polls showing that the level of taxation was the main reason behind voting decisions? People vote for a package and it is quite hard to tease out what are the decisive factors: but it suits the neo-conservatives to repeat this ad nauseam.

Have we actually cut tax since this mantra came to the fore? Well if people will not stand for high tax we must have: but I seem to remember both parties claiming that the other has in fact raised the level of taxation while saying they are not doing that: stealth tax comes to mind.

Income tax is progressive and it is transparent: but if people really cared about the level of tax as much as is claimed then less open tax would not be accepted either: the people are not stupid and they notice it in vat and on petrol and in council tax: this does not bring governments down so far as I can see

I personally would prefer the bulk of government revenue to come from income tax where I can see it and where I have some confidence that it is reasonably fairly applied. There are real problems in getting the very rich to pay it: but that applies to most forms of taxation. Tax on sales such as vat are presented as a way of getting round that: but it does not work and it is quite regressive: tax on luxury goods might work better, I don't know. Tax on property is also a way of getting round that: but the council tax is viciously regressive and so far as I can see that was the only reason for moving to that system: the poor widow in the 6 bedroom house notwithstanding.

There is room for some tax on property and luxury goods and on capital: but basic income tax is the fairest tax we have, with all its faults. And that is the one which has been demonised. I wonder if these two facts are, by any chance, related :)
 
Not quite. Government outlays include regular spending but they also include things like the bank bail out, which was of the order of £850 billion, per "The Independent". It may be that you are positioning that as debt rather than deficit, though.
Not just me, the Treasury excludes the impact of financial intervention (their term) from the budget too. Some people think the budget deficit is so large due to bailing out Lloyds/HBOS and RBS, but that it all off-budget.

And this is the correct treatment IMO as well--the £850 billion total you see (60% of UK GDP, which is synonymous with national income yes) is the gross amount of debt guarantees and Bank of England asset purchases as well as the government's purchase of RBS and Lloyds/HBOS. None of these are current expenditure in the sense of paying for goods or services. Debt guarantees are not investment either. The RBS and Lloyds/HBOS rescues are asset swaps, which are technically investments, though not the type that government usually makes, since they are investments of last resort. The Treasury maintains that the ultimate (permanent) impact of those to the public could be a profit. Up to you whether you agree.

The bottom line is that bailouts etc are not included in the Treasury's budget numbers, nor as far as I know in the OECD estimates. The IFS, by the way, adopts HM Treasury forecasts, except where it provided the comparison with the rest of the OECD in the report you linked for the number I think you quoted.

Yet the interest is surely in the income and expenditure account? I presume it is. It is true that once incurred that debt must be paid and that interest must also be paid: so it seems to me that the largest part of this problem derives from that. I do not know the interest rate on that debt and I know that not all of it is direct debt: but at least 110 billion is direct debt; and I think rather more than that.
Part of the bailout activity will have to be funded by increasing the debt. I have seen numbers similar to yours. However if the BoE buys the debt (which it has) then this is more akin to monetisation (printing money).

Per the IFS structural deficit was 2.7% of national income in 2007 and was projected to rise to 3.6% in 2008 (not outurn figures though: I have not been able to find those). If that is correct then the amount of structural deficit would be 51.52 billion. It will have increased this year, but we do not seem to have figures yet (or I have missed them)
The Treasury (and other political parties) exclude investment spending from the structural deficit, so they calculate it as cyclically-adjusted revenue minus non-investment spending. This accounts for about 4% of the difference from the OECD number I gave before. (The Treasury's pre-budget report, December 09, linked above, does also show the cyclically-adjusted deficit including investment spending, which is in Table B2, page 168, and is -9% of GDP. The smaller number is -5.5%, same table. The March 2010 budget revised this lower to about -4.6%--see the slideshow here). You can also see in the Treasury's pre-budget report that they predict economic growth will be 2% in 2010/11, and 3.25% every year thereafter. Almost all private forecasts are lower than that. And forecasting growth is a mugs' game anyway IMO. Suffice it to say that even assuming the most rapid growth the UK was able to achieve in its housing/finance boom, a huge budget tightening is required.

Seems like you pays your money and you picks your economist :). At least the only difference here seems to be which set of figures you accept: and the numbers are very different.
And yes, public finances are a data minefield, which is why politicians are often able to help themselves to numbers that flatter themselves and discredit others.
 
So at least on one set of figures the deficit (4.6%) is within the normal range seen since 1979 (though at the high end of that range: and on another it is above it at 5.5%. Which, given the proposition that this is the worst financial crisis for a very long time, one might expect to happen. I still do not see any justification for the draconian measures proposed: nor do I see how this is better dealt with by cutting public spending.
 
Which draconian measures?

Maybe you're reading something I have not said.

I said: There is no way on god's green earth that you can raise the tax take by 2% of GDP just by soaking the rich, never mind the more like 5% additional burden that the UK would need in order to continue with present spending (post recession). in post 167, using the degree of tightening that is in the budget numbers. All political parties are proposing that, over 5 years. All of them expect the bulk to come from public spending cuts.

Then there was some discussion about keeping all spending unchanged and some implicit suggestions from yourself and Darat that this could all be financed by tax increases, and I have pointed out the extra revenue that would be required to do this with no borrowing at all. (It is one of Gordon Brown's fiscal rules that borrowing to finance public investment is OK by the way, which is why the Treasury considers the structural deficit to be "only" -5%, that is really the "sustainable" deficit according to those fiscal rules.)
 
Is this a serious political party in the UK?

I believe that they are actually registered as a party, but are they serious, or is this just some form of elaborate, extended practical joke?

The MRLP are as close as we are likely to get to a "None of the above" option on the voting paper.

No politician has the guts to authorise it.
 
Nope I'm not implying that my point is that there seems to be empirical evidence that our current level of taxation could be increased and by quite a bit, without it having any severe economic or social effects.

So, for instance, the claims by business "leaders" that the small additional costs they will face with the planned increase in NI will result in something terribly negative for the economy can be dismissed, and since they are the Tory's stated reasons for saying they will not implement the planned raise if they form the next government we can also dismiss the Tory's plans as nonsensical.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom