The Official UK Election Thread! 6th May it is!

This discussion on the Inheritence Tax made me curious. Does it currently even apply at all to the Queen and her heirs, or are they exempt?.

ETA
Also what is the argument that the Tories use to oppose it. In the US the most common argument against it is that it is a double tax, in that the wealth was taxed as income as it was earned already, then taxed again when the person died and passed it on to his/her heirs.

I would expect such an argument to gain even less traction in the UK than it does in the US because you have substantially more institutionalized wealth having evolved into capitalism from feudalism, whereas the US was not founded until after the rise of capitalism in the west.
 
Last edited:
This discussion on the Inheritence Tax made me curious. Does it currently even apply at all to the Queen and her heirs, or are they exempt?.

AFAIK the Queen is currently exempt; until recently she didn't pay income tax either, so I don't know whether there might be plans to change it (presumably not). There was certainly a lot of hoo-ha when her mother died, because the Queen didn't pay tax on her thumping great inheritance, but the members of staff who were given various bequests would have had to. Although it may have been an argument over a matter of principle, because it seems doubtful to me that many of them would receive bequests in excess of the £250000 threshold.

Also what is the argument that the Tories use to oppose it. In the US the most common argument against it is that it is a double tax, in that the wealth was taxed as income as it was earned already, then taxed again when the person died and passed it on to his/her heirs.
Yeah, I think that's about it.


Edit:
Monster Raving Loony Party still around?

Indeed they are; although it's worth noting that Screaming Lord Sutch's party is the Official Monster Raving Loony Party, and not to be confused with any johnny-come-lately loonies.
 
Last edited:
This discussion on the Inheritence Tax made me curious. Does it currently even apply at all to the Queen and her heirs, or are they exempt?.

http://www.parliament.uk/commons/lib/research/briefings/SNSG-00819.doc

The Queen has always been subject to Value Added Tax and other indirect taxes and she has paid local rates (Council Tax) on a voluntary basis. In 1992, however, The Queen offered to pay income tax and capital gains tax on a voluntary basis. As from 1993, her personal income has been taxable as for any taxpayer and the Privy Purse is fully taxable, subject to a deduction for official expenditure. The Civil List and the Grants-in-aid are not remuneration for The Queen and are thus disregarded for tax.

Although The Queen's estate will be subject to Inheritance Tax, bequests from Sovereign to Sovereign are exempt. This is because constitutional impartiality requires an appropriate degree of financial independence for the Sovereign and because the Sovereign is unable to generate significant new wealth through earnings or business activities. Also, the Sovereign cannot retire and so cannot mitigate Inheritance Tax by passing on assets at an early stage to his or her successor.
 
I was under the impression that, in recent history, the Shadow Chancellor at least receives a sort of briefing from the Treasury's civil servants during this pre-election period, so that when he finally opens the safe in Number 11 and finds nothing but a sixpence covered in stale Christmas Pudding, it's not too much of a shock. I can't remember if this courtesy also extends to the other Big Two, the Home Office and the Foreign and Commonwealth Office.

The principal opposition party (or in the case of Scotland, parties) have access to Civil Servants in order to brief/advise on some of the key policies they are bringing forward as part of their election campaign. My understanding is that this is to prevent them completely bolloxing up and making complete tits of themselves in their first week in office.

I don't think Civil servants provide advice or info to the Tories. I think it is the other way round. The Tories have been in the various departments outlining their plans so that they can be implemented fairly quickly should they gain power.

I would be surprised, for example, if there is not currently a team of civil servants taking an unusually keen interest in the inheritance legislation so that there is a complete report detailing the options available ready to be placed on a ministers desk on 7th April, should the Tories gain power.
 
Last edited:
Yep. Still campaigning for a 99p coin and a three-inch high wall around Britain to trip up foriegn invaders.

I believe their current leader is a cat.

Is this a serious political party in the UK?

I believe that they are actually registered as a party, but are they serious, or is this just some form of elaborate, extended practical joke?
 
I would expect such an argument to gain even less traction in the UK than it does in the US because you have substantially more institutionalized wealth having evolved into capitalism from feudalism, whereas the US was not founded until after the rise of capitalism in the west.

Just to slightly derail this thread, but give you an insight into that institutionalised wealth and feudalism, there was a drama on TV several months ago re the Viking and Norman invasions of 1066. It ended with a shocking caption stating that something like 80% (or possibly 90%) of land in Britain was still owned by direct descendants of those Norman invaders.
 
Last edited:
They are a registered political party, but they are probably more irreverent than mentally ill. They usually get about 300 votes in a constituency election.
 
Last edited:
Just to slightly derail this thread, but give you an insight into that institutionalised wealth and feudalism, there was a drama on TV several months ago re the Viking and Norman invasions of 1066. It ended with a shocking caption stating that something like 80% (or possibly 90%) of land in Britain was still owned by direct descendants of those Norman invaders.

Not that it isn't a shocking headline, but is that perhaps due to there having been so much intermarriage over the course of a thousand years that almost everyone (well 80-90% anyway) has a Norman ancestor in their family tree?

For example:

(from http://www.theatlantic.com/past/issues/2002/05/olson.htm ):

Humphrys began to notice something odd. Whenever a reliable family tree was available, almost anyone of European ancestry turned out to be descended from English royalty—even such unlikely people as Hermann Göring and Daniel Boone. Humphrys began to think that such descent was the rule rather than the exception in the Western world, even if relatively few people had the documents to demonstrate it.
…
Much of Humphrys's genealogical research now appears on his Web page Royal Descents of Famous People. Sitting in his office, I asked him to show me how it works. He clicked on the name Walt Disney. Up popped a genealogy done by Brigitte Gastel Lloyd (Humphrys links to the work of others whenever possible) showing the twenty-two generations separating Disney from Edward I. Humphrys pointed at the screen. "Here we have a sir, so this woman is the daughter of a knight. Maybe this woman will marry nobility, but there's a limited pool of nobility, so eventually someone here is going to marry someone who's just wealthy. Then one of their children could marry someone who doesn't have that much money. In ten generations you can easily get from princess to peasant."



So perhaps it should be nearer 100%! (And John Prescott may be the scion of Royalty!)
 
Also what is the argument that the Tories use to oppose it. In the US the most common argument against it is that it is a double tax, in that the wealth was taxed as income as it was earned already, then taxed again when the person died and passed it on to his/her heirs.
In my experience the most common refrain is something like people "work hard all their lives to build up savings to leave to their children, and the bloody government want to just grab it".

Not so much that the money has already been taxed (the same applies to council tax and VAT) but that it's simply immoral. The sense of injustice lessens when it's a millionaire stranger's estate of course. Similarly the situation with elderly social care (which has never been run as a universal state-funded system like the NHS) is overwhelmingly regarded as morally disgusting since it requires the elderly to use up their savings and potentially sell their home to pay for their own care if they need it in their final years. (All political parties say they want to change this yet none have. Labour got close just recently but avoided it for the last 13 years)

IMO the public becomes strikingly libertarian (if you can call it that) in its views of the assets of the elderly. In many ways this is irrational (although not in the case of the increasingly large fraction of the electorate who are elderly of course)
 
Last edited:
Not that it isn't a shocking headline, but is that perhaps due to there having been so much intermarriage over the course of a thousand years that almost everyone (well 80-90% anyway) has a Norman ancestor in their family tree?

Perhaps.

189,000 families own two-thirds of the UK’s 60 million acres, of which nearly three-quarters is owned by the top 40,000. The biggest individual landowner turned out to be the Duke of Buccleuch with 277,000 acres, and the wealthiest was the Duke of Westminster with 140,000 acres...Land owned and controlled by Britain’s Royal Family, comprising the Crown Estates, the Duchies of Cornwall and Lancaster, and private land, amounted to some 677,000 acres. Meanwhile, Britain’s 16.8 million homeowners accounted for barely 4 per cent of the land, about the same as that owned by the Forestry Commission, the top institutional landowner.

www.labourland.org/downloads/papers/WhoOwnsPaper.pdf
 
On the subject of minor parties (many of which are hilarious) always check out the big politicians declaration (and by elections) due to the higher chance of TV coverage.

The returning officer has to read the names, which is highly amusing and the TV channel used to voice over the party. Well worth staying up for.

The Monty Python Election Night Special (on you tube I believe) was probably what encouraged me to enjoy such events.

Lord Buckethead of the gremloids was always about some place, the previously mentioned and much missed Lord Sutch, Give the royal billions to schools, Elvisly Yours Elvis Presley Party, Acne Party, "Democratic Monarchist, Public Safety, White Resident" (51 votes btw) and Tory.
 
And as for the New Tories, starting off by pledging to reverse the only tax increase that labour have announced

Only tax rise? I wish that were true.

Increased National Insurance (to pretend they were not breaking a manifesto commitment not to raise income tax rates)
New 50% rate
New 60% rate
Removal of tax relief on pension contributions for high earners.
Increased Stamp Duty Land Tax rates.

There have been a great many tax increases, problem is that public spending has risen even faster. Result is a huge deficit.
 
The first casualty of the election - Stuart MacLennan, the Labour candidate for Moray, has been deselected following some ill-advised comments on Twitter.

I think this is quite interesting as a future issue - most teenagers now put all manner of personal information on the web - fast forward 10-20 years when they want to become politicians or enter the public eye? There's going to be a never ending stream of resignations for youthful indiscretions....

the only people suitable for politicians will be the Willy Hauge types who decide they want to go into politics whilst still in secondary school....and take suitable care of their online entries as a result....

Just checked the Wail to see what other "Deeply Offensive" tweets he'd made....the only one that i'd say was borderline was the fair-trade reference to slaves....maybe a joke but in bad taste. The rest? "young man uses swear words shock!" Oh well, guess he regrets it all now....

In a series of extraordinary rants, he called David Cameron and Commons Speaker John Bercow 'tw*ts', and Labour MP Diane Abbott a '******* idiot'.

Campaigning: Stuart MacLennan with Sarah Brown last year
He said of X Factor contestants Jedward: 'Oh for ****'s sake not that pair of odious little ◊◊◊◊◊.'
He also referred to the elderly as 'coffin dodgers' and 'ugly old boots', boasted of drinking heavily and called fellow train commuters 'chavs'.
The Scot even sneered about his country's whisky industry, which employs thousands in what might have been his constituency.
'Johnnie Walker Red Label is so awful they can't sell it in Scotland,' he said.
His Twitter account is followed by Downing Street, the Prime Minister's wife Sarah Brown and Cabinet ministers Ed Balls, Ben Bradshaw and John Denham - but astonishingly, none saw fit to tell him his remarks were inappropriate.
Scottish Secretary Jim Murphy even defended Mr MacLennan, who was fighting the marginal Scottish constituency of Moray, against calls for him to be sacked, insisting it was simply a 'mistake'.
But after Labour tried to defuse the outrage by ditching the Edinburgh University graduate, Mr Murphy was forced to condemn him.
Opposition politicians described the messages - which are known as 'tweets' - as 'repugnant and insulting' and suggested they were in character with Labour's ' desperate and dirty campaign'.

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/ele...foul-mouthed-rants-Twitter.html#ixzz0kdnTGbqd

If I say Cameron is a tw*t does that mean my political career is over too? ;)
 
Last edited:
@ Jaggy Bunnet
Is that really the way this works out?

I was reading this:

http://www.ifs.org.uk/bns/bn43.pdf

So far as I can understand it, public spending is expressed as a percentage of national income. In 2008/9 the UK was 10th out of 28 countries which the OECD has figures for: and 3rd of the G7.

Looking at the table, many of the countries which have a higher proportion of public spending are those countries which have well developed public services. It seems to me that there is some question as to why this is a bad thing and I have not seen this explained.

It is stated in that paper that the percentage of public spending is heavily affected by recession because income falls and social security payments rise: that is what one would expect. Aside from that, there is a political element also: so we see that in the early 80's recession many countries saw an increase in the percent of public spending. When that recession ended some of those same countries maintained the percentage: but the uk chose to let it fall. There was again a recession in the 90's and again percentages rose: in that case some of those other countries chose to let the rate fall back after the recession ended: and the uk chose instead to do what those countries did in the 80's. I may be wrong, but the reason for the different decision in those two cases seems to me to be related to the fact that in the 80's the tories were in power: and in the late 90's it was labour. There is not much difference between the parties nowadays but this does seem to be one clear distinction.

So far I am not seeing that the increase in pubic spending in the UK is out of line with other nations, long term: and I am not seeing why it is a bad thing, either. The projection is that the UK will see the biggest increase of all the nations studied between 2007 and 2010: but the actual ratio is certainly not higher than that of many other nations: the OECD table shows that in 2008 5 nations were spending 50% or more in the public sector and the projection for the UK seems to be that it will peak at 48% in 2010/11.

I do not argue that this is a good thing, in itself: clearly it depends what you are spending the money on. The last time we saw those levels was 1982/3 and it seems to me that there was both a global and a domestic (political) component at that time. In particular social security spending was very high then because the government had decided quite deliberately to "restructure" the economy and this included very high unemployment as a means to improvement. It does not really matter if you agree with that policy or not: it it still the case that this level of public spending was sustained in the UK for those years: and is sustained in other countries.

I keep hearing that it is not sustainable, however. I just dont understand why not and this article at least does not tie its conclusion to the data in a way that helps me.
 
Last edited:
It would seem the Conservatives are now offering £150 a year for couples to get/stay married.

I suspect this is going to be seen as rather a let down, given the amount of trumpeting that Cameron has been doing about it over the last month or two.

Even the Times don't like it much http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/leading_article/article7093802.ece

£3 a week! If you are going to try your hand at social engineering (something I'm sure was a criticism levelled at labour by the conservatives in the past) at least make the carrot on the end of the stick at least the value of a real carrot.

Not to mention another cost from the party who not so long ago could focus on nothing else but deficit reduction.
 
@ Jaggy Bunnet
Is that really the way this works out?

Depends what terms you are using. Typically deficit refers to the difference between govt revenues and spending.

On that basis the UK deficit for 2009 was very similar to that of Greece. And the only country with a higher deficit was Iceland.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/...s-deficit-third-worst-in-the-world-table.html

Public sector net borrowing (which is usually expressed as a percentage of GDP) was 60.3% at the end of Feb 2010.

http://www.statistics.gov.uk/cci/nugget.asp?id=206

On the government's own figures (which include some pretty optimistic looking growth figures) it will rise to 75% by the end of the next parliament.
 
It would seem the Conservatives are now offering £150 a year for couples to get/stay married.

I suspect this is going to be seen as rather a let down, given the amount of trumpeting that Cameron has been doing about it over the last month or two.

Even the Times don't like it much http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/leading_article/article7093802.ece

£3 a week! If you are going to try your hand at social engineering (something I'm sure was a criticism levelled at labour by the conservatives in the past) at least make the carrot on the end of the stick at least the value of a real carrot.

Not to mention another cost from the party who not so long ago could focus on nothing else but deficit reduction.
It is not social engineering (according to a Tory spokesmanon R4 this morning) It is about helping those low income couples where there is only one wage earner. Apparently a couple with one earner earning £20,000 a week are taxed higher than a couple where both earn £10,000.

This to me raises a couple of key questions.

Why not help unmarried couples where one earns £20,000 and the other does not work?

If the concern (as expressed in the interview) is helping low income couples and the best measure the Tories can come up with is this one it suggests they don't really understand the tax system they are taking over. There are far better and fairer ways to give tax breaks to low income couples.

Unless this is about social engineering after all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom