The Official UK Election Thread! 6th May it is!

Yes except they're obviously not ministers, but also-rans. For the third largest party they're called "The [Lib Dem's] Treasury Spokesperson" etc

Do they have any official power/duties or are they appointed simply to be spokespersons on the relevent political topics for the party in question?
 
They get to bully other MPs in their party and take their lunch money and stuff, due to being more important and getting on telly a bit more.
 
They are assumed to be who would get the role in the actual cabinet should that party win power, but it's by no means a guarantee.
 
Do they have any official power/duties or are they appointed simply to be spokespersons on the relevent political topics for the party in question?

They shadow the government minister for whichever department, so if the chancellor makes a statement or policy decision, the shadow chancellor is usually the person the media will go to for the alternative viewpoint. Similarly with the other government departments.

In my opinion this is one of the reasons why we can have an official election campaign of such short duration: the public already know who the main players are. In the US (it seems) as if a politician who may not have a very large nationwide profile can be selected to run for president and so has to spend much longer getting the voters to 'know him/her' (though not in the biblical sense....or possibly....ermm...anyway..) and also, apart from VP you don't really know who he is going to appoint as major players in his cabinet (though of course in UK election those players have to win their constituency elections to even be in with a chance of going to head the dept they have shadowed, and the new PM will probably shake up the posts in any case just to keep the new cabinet on their toes) so you can't really base your decision on what the government as a whole may look like.
 
They get to bully other MPs in their party and take their lunch money and stuff, due to being more important and getting on telly a bit more.

hehe,

reminds me of what a US expat that lived in England for some time once said about one of your government's more peculiar (at least to us) practices.

He described how once a week, the PM had to go to Parlaiment to be insulted.

(This was in the context of the interruption of Obama's first State of the Union address, where a Republican interrupted and called him a liar)
 
They shadow the government minister for whichever department, so if the chancellor makes a statement or policy decision, the shadow chancellor is usually the person the media will go to for the alternative viewpoint. Similarly with the other government departments.

In my opinion this is one of the reasons why we can have an official election campaign of such short duration: the public already know who the main players are. In the US (it seems) as if a politician who may not have a very large nationwide profile can be selected to run for president and so has to spend much longer getting the voters to 'know him/her' (though not in the biblical sense....or possibly....ermm...anyway..) and also, apart from VP you don't really know who he is going to appoint as major players in his cabinet (though of course in UK election those players have to win their constituency elections to even be in with a chance of going to head the dept they have shadowed, and the new PM will probably shake up the posts in any case just to keep the new cabinet on their toes) so you can't really base your decision on what the government as a whole may look like.

Thanks, so while primarily media spokespersons for the opposition, they do serve a larger unofficial purpose as well.
 
I'm surprised iraq's still playing as an issue....bringing blair back i suppose serves to remind people of how angry they were about it....like you say, probably a mistake.

I think that while there are still British soldiers dying there, and in Afghanistan, it's still going to be an issue, though probably not a decisive one since the Tories would almost certainly have done Bush's bidding too.
 
Thanks, so while primarily media spokespersons for the opposition, they do serve a larger unofficial purpose as well.

I was under the impression that, in recent history, the Shadow Chancellor at least receives a sort of briefing from the Treasury's civil servants during this pre-election period, so that when he finally opens the safe in Number 11 and finds nothing but a sixpence covered in stale Christmas Pudding, it's not too much of a shock. I can't remember if this courtesy also extends to the other Big Two, the Home Office and the Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
 
Do they have any official power/duties or are they appointed simply to be spokespersons on the relevent political topics for the party in question?

There is an official opposition in the Westminster parliament, and it even has a very UK style title "Her Majesty's Loyal Opposition". The position of the "Leader of Her Majesty's Most Loyal Opposition" gets paid a state salary, like a cabinet minister would, gets a chauffeur driven car and most of the same perks as a member of the actual cabinet. And if I remember correctly they will be briefed by civil servants from time to time.
 
He described how once a week, the PM had to go to Parlaiment to be insulted.

(This was in the context of the interruption of Obama's first State of the Union address, where a Republican interrupted and called him a liar)

you should see how they bully Nick Clegg Over - the leader of the Lib Dems - they all start to have a chat when he tries to speak.....

our country is run by children.....:)
 
The position of the "Leader of Her Majesty's Most Loyal Opposition" ....
This is a great example of the many quirks in British Government that soooo fascinates me.

The few times I have caught coverage of Parlaiment is also a treat. I love the way UK politicians can be so full of proper ettiquette while insulting somebody.

'The esteemed and honorable member from Lower Tadfield clearly would have difficulties locating his posterior if using both hands and utilizing a map'
 
you should see how they bully Nick Clegg Over - the leader of the Lib Dems - they all start to have a chat when he tries to speak.....

our country is run by children.....:)

You mean, those few that are actually left in the chamber after the traditional charge to the bar once the 'proper' PMQs is over.
 
you should see how they bully Nick Clegg Over - the leader of the Lib Dems - they all start to have a chat when he tries to speak.....

our country is run by children.....:)

There was a snippet on Radio4 a few weeks back about how the microphones in the chamber pick up....certain sounds.

The example given was of Diane Abbott* making slurping/sucking noises** while her parliamentary colleague Keith Vaz waxed obsequiesly about a new government minister.
It was v. funny.

*I think
** Arse kissing
 
From today's Times:

"Samantha Cameron put Sarah Brown on the spot yesterday by campaigning solo for the first time in two of the Tories’ target seats.
The wife of the Conservative leader adopted a woman-of-the-people look in skinny black jeans and Converse trainers as she toured a charity project for the homeless in Leeds North East and listened to villagers’ concerns in the Lincolnshire constituency of Brigg & Goole.

Mrs Cameron, 38 and pregnant, seemed “very normal and down-to-earth”, said Andrew Percy, the Tory candidate for Brigg. Charity workers expressed admiration for her empathy and “the depth of her understanding of social issues”.

Her attempts at classlessness were slightly undermined, however, when she stopped for lunch with her father, Sir Reginald Sheffield, at his Thealby Hall estate. Sir Reginald, the hunting, shooting and fishing eighth baronet, owns 3,000 acres of Lincolnshire, is a descendant of Charles II and traces his family back to a 13th century Knight Templar"
 
I was under the impression that, in recent history, the Shadow Chancellor at least receives a sort of briefing from the Treasury's civil servants during this pre-election period, so that when he finally opens the safe in Number 11 and finds nothing but a sixpence covered in stale Christmas Pudding, it's not too much of a shock. I can't remember if this courtesy also extends to the other Big Two, the Home Office and the Foreign and Commonwealth Office.

The principal opposition party (or in the case of Scotland, parties) have access to Civil Servants in order to brief/advise on some of the key policies they are bringing forward as part of their election campaign. My understanding is that this is to prevent them completely bolloxing up and making complete tits of themselves in their first week in office.
 
How are the Tories justifying their proposal to radically raise the Inheritance tax threshold?

It seems that a party that complains consistently about unemployed people sitting around getting money for doing nothing should support a large inheritance tax.

Does it serve any purpose other than making people stinking rich?
 
Inheritance tax tends to be very unpopular with most people. It is also a relatively easy tax to avoid (shame death isn't). If it wasn't such an emotive issue with the population, people may realise that it is one of the most efficient taxes out there (but still--easy to avoid)
 
As I understand it, the threshold is about to go up to £350,000. Perhaps the Tories could get away with raising the ceiling to -say- £700,000, but they are raising it all the way to millionares.

The hypocrites, to complain about the gap between rich and poor and the deficit while wasting 1billion on a tax break for those who happen to have rich relatives. And as everyone knows, working for your grandparents/aunties love is the easiest work you will have to do.
 
Read this in today's Independent:

http://www.independent.co.uk/opinio...-war-just-read-camerons-policies-1939666.html

...snip...

He will give a £1.2bn inheritance tax cut to the richest 2 per cent in Britain – with most going to the 3,000 wealthiest estates (including his wife's). Then he promises to end the 50p top rate of tax, giving another £2.4bn to the richest 1 per cent. Then he has pledged to cut taxes on the pensions of the richest, handing another £3.2bn to the same 1 per cent. Then his marriage tax relief policies will give 13 times more to the rich than the poor. To pay for this, he will slash programmes for the middle and the skint, like the Child Trust Fund, SureStart and state schools.

...snip...
 
Any sources for it in the Tories' stuff? I haven't looked but don't recall a promise to remove the 50% rate (probably an aspiration, but then it might well be Labour's aspiration too . . . if they'd always wanted to tax the rich at 50% they would have done it before now)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom