The Official UK Election Thread! 6th May it is!

No. You have to be a member of the house to have speaking rights, and even to be allowed on to the floor. There have been instances when a lord has been allowed to address the commons: according to a bbc article I found the last time it happened was in 1814.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/blog/2008/nov/25/peter-mandelson-constitution
Thanks. So when Wellington was PM in the 1830s, he never visited the Commons. :jaw-dropp Or did he pull the same trick as Douglas-Home?

The two houses don't mix. I understand there was some unpleasantness in the mid 17 century.
Ah, I never realized the stance of the Lords during that.

Certianly a lord couldn't adress the commons without the commons agreeing to it and they would be unlikely to do so on a regular basis such as for half an hour every wednesday.
Clear. And vice versa - does every Ministry have a Peer as a junior minister to go the House of Lords, or isn't there the need to visit the House of Lords as often as the Commons?
 
In fairness the Tory-Unionist links go way back.


Oh, the "unionist" bit is actually referring to Ireland, we know that. We reserve the right to get miffed about it anyway,

Inheritance tax issue probably helps with the middle classes with houses in south east england.


See my point about piling up more votes in the seats they already won.

Torries need to pick up about 100 seats labour lose majority with less than 20.


Exactly. The probabilities lie in the middle. Though having sat up all night on 9th/10th April 1992, much of it on the phone to a friend who is a Labour activist, I'm NEVER taking anything for granted.

Richard Taylor may have a reasonable chance of holding on in Wyre Forest. Can't see UKIP or and especialy the greens picking up any seats.


Probably not, but odd things happen sometimes.

The SNP were able to buy up enough votes to pass their budget but at westminister than kind of thing could get expensive fast.


Mmmm, expensive for whom? Obviously I'm not happy about the parts of the manifesto the SNP had to ditch, but arguably the result was a consensus somewhere in the general region of the popular will. It would be an interesting experiment, anyway,

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Thanks. So when Wellington was PM in the 1830s, he never visited the Commons. :jaw-dropp Or did he pull the same trick as Douglas-Home?

No I do not think he ever sat in the commons: but that was not quite the same as itwould be now because the commons was not sovereign at that time. I was wrong that there was no legal change to prevent a PM sitting in the lords. Apparently that has been impossible since 1911: though ministers still can, as has been shown.


Clear. And vice versa - does every Ministry have a Peer as a junior minister to go the House of Lords, or isn't there the need to visit the House of Lords as often as the Commons?

There is a need to get legislation through both houses but as the lords no longer have a power of veto it is not necessary to have a peer attached to every ministry so far as I know: there are "working peers" appointed by each of the parties so that when they are in government they steer the bills, I believe. Again those more knowledgeable than I am will correct me if I am wrong on this
 
To translate the parties into US terms:

Labour-Ralph Nader could find a home here.
Tories-Outside the issue of healthcare (where he would be way too right wing) Obama could probably find a home here
Lib-dems. Errrrr I suppose some wierd fusion of the ACLU lite and the green party might be as close as you could get

SNP-there is no american equiverlent
PC (Plaid Cymru) Imagaine some kind of far left massachusetts independence movement.
UKIP-think the more secular and liberal parts of the republican party
Democratic Unionist Party- I'm not sure they even have an economic policy but socialy think southern baptists with an irish accent
Ulster Unionist Party-See the tories
Sinn Féin err cross Alaskan Independence Party with Ralph Nader might get you somewhere.
SDLP-there is no american equiverlent
Respect – The Unity Coalition- err think about the most left wing party that you can then quadrupal it. Or think George Galloway there's no practical difference.

got it,

Funny how your far right (but not completely insane) party is seen as equivalent to the liberal end of our right wing party.

I also think the description of PC would better apply to Sinn Fein since they actually have a fund raising presence in Massachusetts (heavy Irish-American constituency like say the Kennedy family). This was a big issue in the states back when the IRA was active, because Sinn Fein was typically portrayed in the media here as a political front for the IRA (not sure if that is how they were viewed there though)

And while typically short lived and completely irrelevant, there have been some California independence parities in the past, some focused on the Bay Area, so that might apply to PC more.

And I guess the BNP is your version of the teabaggers?
 
My election avatar is a mix of red and blue (which makes purple), but substantially lightened (to a pale pink). And it's a coincidence.
 
And I guess the BNP is your version of the teabaggers?

It isn't all that Conservative when it comes to its views on nationalising the banks, industry etc, but probably on immigration (Halt all immigration) and capital punishment (Fry up the peados).

It's more outrightly racist than the teabaggers, with its leader calling the gas chambers at Nazi concentration camps a 'complete lie'.
 
They both won three elections and went bad in the third term. There is a view that if there was a two term limit on a PM, leadership would be refreshed before it decayed to that point.
 
I don't agree that either of them went bad in the third term: I think they were atrocious from day one but it took a long time for folk to notice ;)

More seriously: The PM is not president. The rot set in because they started to behave as if they were and a supine parliament let them. So for me such a change would necessitate a whole lot of other changes which I would need to see spelled out before I would contemplate that
 
Not so sure, andyandy: there was an "interview random voters on the street" on the radio today in Dartmouth. The biggest issues against labour seemed to be the Iraq war and illegal immigration.

Immigration is not an issue here: but many of my friends were labour party activists and most of them are no longer. They will not work for labour and some will not even vote for them because of that war. The situation may be different elsewhere, however, and I freely grant that the " cradle" support is firm here too. But it has made some difference and that effect has not been fully discounted. Bringing Blair in is a mistake IMO

I'm surprised iraq's still playing as an issue....bringing blair back i suppose serves to remind people of how angry they were about it....like you say, probably a mistake.

i think immigration will play as an issue (though it'll be interesting to see how the parties dance around it without appearing racist...), but i was lumping that together with other domestic policies....
 
I don't agree that either of them went bad in the third term: I think they were atrocious from day one but it took a long time for folk to notice ;)

More seriously: The PM is not president. The rot set in because they started to behave as if they were and a supine parliament let them. So for me such a change would necessitate a whole lot of other changes which I would need to see spelled out before I would contemplate that

And the media help create this impression of a President - because for them it is simpler to report "Brown did this" and so so on. It is one of the reasons I am against the televised debates between the PM & the Tory and liberal party leaders.
 
And the media help create this impression of a President - because for them it is simpler to report "Brown did this" and so so on. It is one of the reasons I am against the televised debates between the PM & the Tory and liberal party leaders.

There is no doubt that hearing from the leaders on the issues is important. Yes, you may vote for your local candidate, but the UK Parliamentary system has an incredibly strong whip system. Chances are that your local candidate will be voting with the Government most of the time.

Plus, what the leadership of the governing party puts before parliament are going to be the big issues on what your local candidate will be voting on. The ideology of the Government is going to be what gives your MP the chance to vote on issues that matter to you. Private members bills hardly ever become law, and most of the time they function in order to draw attention to Government bills.

It's worth taking all the information on before casting your vote: your candidates, their leader, their shadow cabinet.
 
Last edited:
Our constituency is pretty solidly Lib Dem (42% in 2005).

That may change this time, though I'm not sure the Tories can realistically expect a 15% swing. What would be very interesting if the Tories did indeed win is that their candidate is our current MSP, and it would bring back the whole debate (locally) of whether you can realistically be an MP and an MSP

Not sure how many MSPs are in that situation - though Alex Salmond is one, which gives that side of the argument weight :)
 
It's worth taking all the information on before casting your vote: your candidates, their leader, their shadow cabinet.

This is an interesting issue - the Tories are still almost solely carried by Cameron. Osbourne's a bit of a light-weight. Then who else is there? I love politics but when it comes to naming Cameron's front bench? There's the old dogs of Hague and Clarke. And? Theresa May? I think....

and that's it.

I think this represents a pretty big failure on behalf of the tories - that they've not got many names into the public consciousness. The election on a national level is just about Cameron - the second most important person nationaly is probably Mrs Cameron.
 
got it,

Funny how your far right (but not completely insane) party is seen as equivalent to the liberal end of our right wing party.

Well parties are more national so you can't really be very right win in some areas and more moderate in the swing seats. You've also got the issue of the NHS which limits the amount of right wing drift you can have while remaining remotely viable.

I also think the description of PC would better apply to Sinn Fein since they actually have a fund raising presence in Massachusetts (heavy Irish-American constituency like say the Kennedy family).

No. Sinn Fein might actualy get NI to join Ireland one day. It seems unlikely that PC will ever get welsh independence.

This was a big issue in the states back when the IRA was active, because Sinn Fein was typically portrayed in the media here as a political front for the IRA (not sure if that is how they were viewed there though)

They were a front for the IRA. Fortunately the more moderate memebers were able to use it to get enough leverage over the IRA to get most of it to stop with the violence.

And while typically short lived and completely irrelevant, there have been some California independence parities in the past, some focused on the Bay Area, so that might apply to PC more.

PC have been around for a while.

And I guess the BNP is your version of the teabaggers?

English Democrats Party (pretty minor party no MPs a few local councillors) would be closer to the teabaggers. BNP derive from the old style far right with some very slick marketing.
 
Another question for you Brits. I have seen the phrase 'shadow cabinet' here and on other threads. From context it appears to be ministerial cabinet set up by the opposition, rather than the government. Is this correct? What other nuances am I missing as well?
 
Yes except they're obviously not ministers, but also-rans. For the third largest party they're called "The [Lib Dem's] Treasury Spokesperson" etc
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom