The Official UK Election Thread! 6th May it is!

Tory Manifesto: First thing to make me chuckle is the complete U-turn on the Tory's position on "society", it has gone from something that didn't exist to something it is vital that we all look after since it is apparently fraying.


Full quote from Thatcher:

They're casting their problem on society. And, you know, there is no such thing as society. There are individual men and women, and there are families. And no government can do anything except through people, and people must look to themselves first. It's our duty to look after ourselves and then, also to look after our neighbour. People have got the entitlements too much in mind, without the obligations.


To just quote "there is no such thing as society" is to utterly misrepresent what was being said. Which was the existence of society but that we should all try and take responsibility for ourselves and then after that we can give help (or receive help) from our neighbours.
 
To just quote "there is no such thing as society" is to utterly misrepresent what was being said. Which was the existence of society but that we should all try and take responsibility for ourselves and then after that we can give help (or receive help) from our neighbours.
Either way, it's standard libertarian mantra which eschews "handouts" and "welfare" as a philosophy. I think most people in Britain have an accurate impression of Lady Thatcher since she ran things for 11 years and said more than just that. (My direct knowledge is a lot less since I immigrated here in 1983 and was only 8 then)
 
I disagree that it's "utterly misrepresenting" it. She said flat-out there is no such thing as society and that you have to make sure you're okay first because that's what everyone else is doing, and you can't expect any help from them or from government except as an afterthought.

If she didn't mean "There is no such thing as society" then she shouldn't have said it. And she is far too shrewd to say something like that inadvertently.
 
Full quote from Thatcher:

They're casting their problem on society. And, you know, there is no such thing as society. There are individual men and women, and there are families. And no government can do anything except through people, and people must look to themselves first. It's our duty to look after ourselves and then, also to look after our neighbour. People have got the entitlements too much in mind, without the obligations.


To just quote "there is no such thing as society" is to utterly misrepresent what was being said. Which was the existence of society but that we should all try and take responsibility for ourselves and then after that we can give help (or receive help) from our neighbours.

And where did I quote such a thing?
 
And where did I quote such a thing?

... complete U-turn on the Tory's position on "society", it has gone from something that didn't exist to something it is vital that we all look after ...
 
... complete U-turn on the Tory's position on "society", it has gone from something that didn't exist to something it is vital that we all look after ...

You said "To just quote "there is no such thing as society" is to utterly misrepresent what was being said." I think you may have been having a bit of a knee-jerk moment as quite clearly I didn't quote anything in that post.
 
Just found out that both the Labervatives and Consour are both pledging 0.7% of GDP in overseas development assistance from 2013. (a long standing UN aspiration)

ETA: 2009 numbers for various countries; chart 1
 
Last edited:
I disagree that it's "utterly misrepresenting" it. She said flat-out there is no such thing as society and that you have to make sure you're okay first because that's what everyone else is doing, and you can't expect any help from them or from government except as an afterthought.

If she didn't mean "There is no such thing as society" then she shouldn't have said it. And she is far too shrewd to say something like that inadvertently.

Seriously?

She just said that when we refer to society, we are referring to the aggregate of countless individuals rather than some single entity. She further says that while we would all be better off if we try and take as much responsibility for ourselves as possible, we DO also have a moral obligation to our neighbours.
 
She just said that when we refer to society, we are referring to the aggregate of countless individuals rather than some single entity. She further says that while we would all be better off if we try and take as much responsibility for ourselves as possible, we DO also have a moral obligation to our neighbours.
Not sure there is a need to pick apart Thatcher's words from more than 20 years back. However:

1--No, we're not. A group is a different entity than the sum of its constituents.

2--The "neighbours" part is a call to voluntary charity and a general opposition to compulsory redistribution.

You're welcome to support that of course.
 
You said "To just quote "there is no such thing as society" is to utterly misrepresent what was being said." I think you may have been having a bit of a knee-jerk moment as quite clearly I didn't quote anything in that post.

Oh seriously Darat, you said that the Conservatives had believed that Society was something that didn't exist. Was that not a reference to Thatcher's famous (mis)quotation?
 
1--No, we're not. A group is a different entity than the sum of its constituents.

.

And is a useful shorthand for them. But we should not think that it has an existence apart from them.

2--The "neighbours" part is a call to voluntary charity and a general opposition to compulsory redistribution.

.

I'm aware that she felt that compulsory redistribution should be reduced. Do you have any proof that she was against it completely (she certainly didn't go to a flat tax or anything...)
 
She was not against it completely. I doubt it ever fell to her preferred level, but don't know.

(she certainly didn't go to a flat tax or anything...)
Of course her admin did implement a poll tax for local government funding, which is one of the most regressive types of tax (WRT income) out there.
 
Last edited:
Oh seriously Darat, you said that the Conservatives had believed that Society was something that didn't exist. Was that not a reference to Thatcher's famous (mis)quotation?

Er you said that "To just quote "there is no such thing as society" is to utterly misrepresent what was being said." and as I've pointed out I clearly didn't quote anything.

I don't mind being corrected or someone disagreeing with me but when you make up something that I didn't do and criticise me for that... well there is a word for that...
 
In your opinion which political party has a set of policies which are most likely to reduce (or at least slow the rise of) inequality in the UK without seriously damaging the economy?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom