The Official UK Election Thread! 6th May it is!

This is why the NI row surely matters. 6 Thousand Million being pumped into public services Versus 40,000 jobs being lost in the public sector because of the Tories need to pay for dropping the NI increase is an argument worth having. I don't know how accurate that all is of course, I have been listening to Mandelson after all.
 
A debate about what the money is spent on matters. How many public sector jobs it requires is the wrong debate entirely in my view. (so is calling it a "tax on jobs" even though that is true)
 
But don't the Tories have to find an additional (12Billion or 6?) amount of cash this year alone in order to pay for their tax cut on top of the cuts Labour are already proposing?
 
Yes I think so. (Based on reading Stephanie Flanders' BBC blog and the IFS updates on their site. I have not read the manifestos)
 
Well all three of the parties whose leaders will be on the TV today are "public sector cutting".

As Fiona pointed out before, there is no available choice for a voter who wants to keep public spending unchanged as a fraction of national income.

My view is that this is because there is only negligible demand for such a policy in the country (given knowledge of what it costs).

As I said before: we need both sets of costs before you can determine what people would choose: you are not able to cost the other option and so you cannot know what the demand would be
 
Is it likely they can raise that amount this year?
Whoops, no I think that number (about £6bn) is merely the difference between the spelled-out plans of Tory minus Labour, over the whole parliament.

Since the NIC hike does not happen until 2011/12, then there is no issue with financing any roll-back of that this year. (I think)
 
As I said before: we need both sets of costs before you can determine what people would choose: you are not able to cost the other option
I don't know why you want me to cost it. That would hardly be credible. Likewise if you did.

I have shown (post 238) that according to the Institute for Fiscal Studies, the size of the structural budget deficit (revenue minus public spending, excluding the gap which can be explained fully by economic recession, and excluding spending that is counted as long term investment) is £67 billion in today's money. That assumes Labour's growth forecasts are right.

Therefore that is the cost of maintaining real spending at today's level, given the foregoing. Therefore tax rises of that magnitude are required without breaking Labour's fiscal rules, and without debt/GDP rising indefinitely.

I have also linked (same source) tax raising options (post 230) and their expected yield.

I therefore reject your statement that the other option has not been costed. It has (as well as these things can be).

and so you cannot know what the demand would be
The Green Party comes closest to raising the largest chunk of it via tax. Labour and the Lib Dems raise well under a third of it that way. The Greens have no Westminster MPs. While I can't rule out the possibility that the electorate would vote for a program that raised £67bn via tax in the next five years, I take absence of evidence (of demand for it) as evidence of absence in forming my view. I think the onus would rather be on you to show that the public want something that nobody credible is offering.
 
From the conservative Manifesto:

We will start by cutting a net £6 billion of wasteful departmental spending in the financial
year 2010/11.

And

We will make the following changes in April 2011, relative to Labour’s plans:
• raise the primary threshold for National Insurance by £24 a week and raise the Upper
Earnings Limit by £29 a week; and,
• raise the secondary threshold at which employers start paying National Insurance by £21 a week.
​


Seven out of ten working people – those earning between £7,100 and £45,400 – and
almost every employer will save up to £150 a year per person compared to under Labour.
Lower earners will get the greatest benefit as a percentage of their earnings. Nobody will be worse off as a result of these changes.

...snip... To pay for this we will take immediate action to cut a net £6 billion of wasteful departmental spending in the financial year 2010/11, with further savings in future years. This is in addition to the savings made by cutting tax credits and Child Trust Funds for betteroff families. These actions will allow us to reduce the deficit more quickly than Labour year-on-year while avoiding the most damaging part of their jobs tax. It will also lower the proportion of the reduction of the structural deficit that is accounted for by tax increases, from about one third towards one fifth. This is in line with international best practice, as well as the Treasury’s own internal analysis.

Former government advisers Sir Peter Gershon and Dr Martin Read have advised us that
savings of £12 billion across all departmental spending are possible in-year without affecting the quality of frontline services. These are over and above any savings already planned by Labour.

We will achieve this through: a freeze on major

• new Information and Communications Technologies (ICT) spending;
• immediate negotiations to achieve cost reductions from major suppliers;
• tighter control of public sector recruitment;
• reductions in discretionary spending, including travel, expenses, advertising, consultancy and office supplies; and,
• reductions in public sector property costs.​

We will match Labour’s spending plans for 2010/11 in health and overseas aid. Given our
commitment to carry out a Strategic Defence and Security Review, it would also not be
appropriate to make in-year reductions to the existing defence budget in 2010/11.

Savings in these protected areas will be channelled back into frontline services. The net £6 billion of savings will be made from the remaining departmental budgets

My translation is "Have your cake and eat it".
 
This is why the NI row surely matters. 6 Thousand Million being pumped into public services Versus 40,000 jobs being lost in the public sector because of the Tories need to pay for dropping the NI increase is an argument worth having. I don't know how accurate that all is of course, I have been listening to Mandelson after all.

An interesting article on the BBC about why the NI row doesn't actually matter in the slightest:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/election_2010/8608112.stm

Basically, the amount of tax in question is far less than the changes that have been made by every government in the past. Obviously that doesn't make it completely irrelevant, but it does show just how far out of proportion it's being blown.

In the spirit of politics, I'll change mine too.

In the spirit of politics, I'm leaving my avatar exactly as it is. In the absence of a "none of the above" option, kittening is the best I can manage. Hmm, I wonder if they'd be upset if I put a kitten in the ballot box instead of my ballot.
 
The Green manifesto:

ENVIRONMENT
• £44bn to be spent on investing in renewable energy sources, transport, insulation, housing and waste management

• An end to the use of nuclear power

• £30bn allocated to building and repairing roads will be redirected to public transport, with a ban on the construction of new roads

[snip]

EMPLOYMENT
• A "living wage" of £8.10 an hour would be introduced, compared with the current minimum wage of £5.80 an hour. This would be equivalent to 60% of net national average earnings

• An extra million jobs and training places would be created, for occupations such as carers, midwives, plumbers, builders, engineers and public transport workers

• Cuts to budgets and jobs in the public sector would be opposed, in an effort to accelerate the economic recovery

• The upper 50p rate of income tax would apply to all earnings over £100,000, rather than the current threshold of £150,000, with the extra revenue this generates going towards the creation of jobs

• A permanent tax would be introduced for all bonuses paid to bankers

• Efforts would begin to implement a 35-hour working week, to improve people's work-life balance and to help to share out jobs

• A greater emphasis on equality in the workplace, reducing the pay gap between men and women

• Periods of maternity and paternity leave for new parents would be extended


SOCIETY
• Rural post offices which have been closed would be reopened

• There would be less paperwork and fewer layers of bureaucracy for teachers

• The party would support the NUT teaching union in its efforts to scrap Sats tests

• Tuition fees in further and higher education would end

• Business would have less of a role to play in education, such as through academies

• Local health centres would be retained, rather than introducing larger polyclinics

• Hospitals would no longer be funded through PFI projects

• The replacements for Trident nuclear submarines would be cancelled, saving £80bn


HEALTH
• All plans for closures, cuts and privatisation within the NHS would be opposed, with an emphasis on ensuring people can access services locally, rather than regionally

• Prescription charges to be abolished

• All eye tests would become free

[snip]

PENSIONS
• Those eligible for the party's "citizen's pension" would receive £170 a week if single and £300 as a couple, which would not be means-tested - this would apply to about 12 million pensioners living in the UK and a further million living abroad

• The annual £110bn cost would be covered by abolishing pension credits and ending tax relief on pension contributions


HOUSING
• About 37,000 empty council homes would be renovated to help to cut waiting lists

• Another 300,000 private-sector properties which are unoccupied would be put back into use
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/election_2010/8621845.stm

I would agree with most of them as aspirations for change - only really the opposition to nuclear power as a matter of course (i think it should be used if cost effective), and the raising of the minimum wage by so much (likely to drive jobs overseas...) i would question. Re the minimum wage - they could raise a huge number of jobs from minimum wage by simply removing the middle-man employment agencies from the workplace - or at least vastly reducing their power. Other than that, looks good. Vote green - the true left wing alternative :D
 
Last edited:
Near my work in Brent:

_MediaCard_BlackBerry_pictures_IMG0.jpg


Going all out with it.

I thought Cameron said this was to be a positive campaign? Do you think, because of the tiny lettering underneath (Vote Conservative) their trying to make people actually believe that these are Labour campaign posters??
 
Last edited:
The Green Party Manifesto

Some things don't seem very well thought-through, e.g.
Decentralise healthcare responsibility to
local government
, ensure that minimum
service levels and national guidelines are
provided to prevent a postcode lottery, and
oppose further health service centralisation.

They're also still opposed to nuclear power, which I thought the green movement had finally seen reason about.
 
The Green Party Manifesto

Some things don't seem very well thought-through, e.g.


They're also still opposed to nuclear power, which I thought the green movement had finally seen reason about.

I like their policy on limiting random stop and search (Although I'd like to see it removed all together) and getting rid of Trident.

Can't agree with this though:
Terrorist attacks in the UK are linked to our invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan,

Seems naive.
 
The Green Party Manifesto

Some things don't seem very well thought-through, e.g.


They're also still opposed to nuclear power, which I thought the green movement had finally seen reason about.

yes, decentralisation of control but with centralised nationalised guidelines...looks like they just joined together two popular policy ideas "decentralise" and "end postcode "lottery" with a few random connectors :D

re nuclear power - i'm inclined to think that we shouldn't build any more - not because of the risk factor, but simply that over the entire life-cycle of the plant i don't think it's a cost effective way of producing electricity. Sellafield is still going to cost tens of billions in decommisioning and storage - and we still don't have a safe way of storing the waste for the necessary thousands of years.....
 
Last edited:
Seems naive.

seems bang on. Has our invovement in inflaming the entire Muslim world had a detrimental effect on UK muslim relations? Absolutely. Look at all the recent suicide bombers/failed suicide bombers from the UK - look at what they cite as reasons for radicalisation. Iraq really is a prominent factor. Would we have been safe from suicide bombing if we'd never set foot in either country? Of course not - after all 9-11 was a precursor. But has our involvement in Iraq made us more vulnerable to home grown terrorism? I think most security anaylists would say that it has.

There's some great books on the subject - i think i reviewed a few in the "recommended book list..." - there are basically 3 overlapping groups - think venn diagrams - for the muslim population in the UK. Group A completely peaceful and law abiding. The big majority. Group B -sympathisers to some jihadi acts either here or abroad, perhaps providers of money, more likely no direct contact and completely peaceful. Group C - activists who actively recruit and fund terrorist actions.

The Iraq war saw a shift of some people from A to B, and some from B to C. Activists found it easier to recruit angry young men who opposed the UK government because there was a wellspring of angry young men opposed to the UK government's actions in Iraq....
 
Most of these blokes who rise to become terrorists start their radicalisation with people like Maududi or Qutb, theology which is almost completely devoid of the 'they kill us, we kill them'.

If one looks at the 7/7 bombers, their radicalisation predates the Iraq war or even 9/11. Shehzad Tanweer was reported to have celebrated the 9/11 attacks at a party in his house.

Remember, the Taliban aren't the French revolution. You don't throw acid onto young schoolgirls faces because NATO invaded Afghanistan. If Mohammed Sidique Khan felt that the UK 'continually perpetrate(s) atrocities against my people all over the world.', why didn't he, or at least any of his colleagues go and fight the Taliban? It's because of religion.

I suggest reading Ed Husain's book on his descent into radicalisation.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom